Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is disgusting - GP charging for form

487 replies

FrostedFancy · 21/12/2023 13:39

GP surgery insist I must pay £40 for completion of a form from school to request online learning for my DD (14) who is suffering from MH issues due to being diagnosed with a serious health condition.

AIBU to think this is absolutely disgusting to profit from a child with medical condition and mental health issues needing access to an education?

Form literally would take 5 minutes to complete.

OP posts:
Deliria · 22/12/2023 11:46

WashItTomorrow · 22/12/2023 08:45

What’s that got to do with anything? This has nothing to do with the NHS or NHS service providers. That’s the whole point. The NHS don’t offer a form-filling service. Your local doctor will help you by doing the forms but you have to pay for it.

Working with local authorities to ensure the special educational and health needs of children are met in an integrated way is very much the (legal) responsibility of the NHS. Different professions with involvement wih SEND children have a legal obligation to work together to ensure educational and healthcare needs are met in a joined up way. That can include involvement in various administrative processes.

moomoomoo27 · 22/12/2023 11:13

Deliria · 21/12/2023 17:41

It's not as though OP is paying for it via taxation or anything, is it? Confused

Imagine contributing more to society than what you're forced to 🙄

I highly doubt the OP has actually covered the cost of her own use of the NHS through her tax contributions. Unless she's on an absolute fortune of course.

littlebopeepp234 · 22/12/2023 09:22

Deliria · 22/12/2023 08:19

It's not a theory. This country has legislation to ensure that children with special educational and health care needs are addressed. One legal aspect of this is the requirement for partnership working between local authorities and local NHS service providers to assess and meet SEND children's needs.

To compare this with school discos suggests you have not understood the context.

Also to add to my further reply, GPs generally don’t get involved in SEND needs, they tend to refer to outside services such as CAMHS. They also refer to ss if there is a safeguarding issue and may complete reports and attend safeguarding meetings. A GP alone is not qualified to get involved with SEND, they signpost so yes whilst they work together a GP isn’t the person people should be approaching regarding a child’s education. They are allowed to and do complete forms however they are allowed to charge, even if it’s for schools.

The services you mention above also liaise with the GP and send any correspondence from consultations and interactions they have with a child which is filed in a child’s medical records however every single one of these organisations get a copy of the same correspondence, that includes the school so the school shouldn’t really need a form completing anyway as they will already have the information they need with them which have been sent to them from other mental health services, CAMHS etc.

TurquoiseDress · 22/12/2023 09:00

Having skim read through this thread, I think it's overwhelming that YABU OP

If you look at another professional eg solicitors, do you think they will be filling in/signing forms "for free"?

Why should GPs be any different? And it's not just signing/2 minutes filling in a form, they are taking responsibility for the information contained.

And in any case, as mentioned previously, this is all technically private work and needs to be paid for.

WashItTomorrow · 22/12/2023 08:45

Deliria · 22/12/2023 08:19

It's not a theory. This country has legislation to ensure that children with special educational and health care needs are addressed. One legal aspect of this is the requirement for partnership working between local authorities and local NHS service providers to assess and meet SEND children's needs.

To compare this with school discos suggests you have not understood the context.

What’s that got to do with anything? This has nothing to do with the NHS or NHS service providers. That’s the whole point. The NHS don’t offer a form-filling service. Your local doctor will help you by doing the forms but you have to pay for it.

User75325426 · 22/12/2023 08:36

Totally normal and your perspective is skewed because it involves an unwell child, which is sad but it does not reflect the greed of the system. By your logic, every single person who is ill or has poor MH should be entitled to everything for free if it's somehow related to their condition because otherwise it would be "disgusting" to profit off their sickness. How would an already beleaguered health service function if that rule was applied to all?

GPs have the right to charge for all types of paperwork confirmation. Our school required a overall certificate of health and we had to make an extra (private) appointment and paid over £120 for all of it. Participating in certain sports also require certificates and a brief health check, all of which must be paid for. Doing a drivers license requires an eye test that also needs to be paid for.

littlebopeepp234 · 22/12/2023 08:23

Deliria · 22/12/2023 08:19

It's not a theory. This country has legislation to ensure that children with special educational and health care needs are addressed. One legal aspect of this is the requirement for partnership working between local authorities and local NHS service providers to assess and meet SEND children's needs.

To compare this with school discos suggests you have not understood the context.

🙄🙄🙄🙄

You don’t understand how GP practices work. GPs are entitled to charge for forms completing whether you like it or not so let’s just leave it at that!

Deliria · 22/12/2023 08:19

littlebopeepp234 · 22/12/2023 01:41

Also by that theory you might as well say that schools shouldn’t be charging parents for school trips/ after school clubs/ school discos/ dress up days/ school dinners etc just because the NHS doesn’t charge patients for appointments because they have some sort of ‘responsibility’ placed upon them to work alongside educational services!!! It’s just a pointless non argument unfortunately and makes no sense 🙄

Its ok for schools to ask parents to pay ridiculous amounts of money for the services they provide to children - which those costs over the space of a school year equate to way more than £40 but it’s not ok for a GP to charge for a service that is completely unrelated to their actual job which is treating patients - Okay!

Edited

It's not a theory. This country has legislation to ensure that children with special educational and health care needs are addressed. One legal aspect of this is the requirement for partnership working between local authorities and local NHS service providers to assess and meet SEND children's needs.

To compare this with school discos suggests you have not understood the context.

StonedRoses · 22/12/2023 06:30

Not every death occurs in hospital.

If completing a cremation form you MUST see and examine the body. So for a pt who didn’t die in hospital that’s usually the GP, and it’s often at the funeral home.

It’s been a long time since I completed a cremation form but when I was a junior doctor it certainly took a fair amount of time and I did then before or after work. The payment came from the funeral directors - never from the family.

RiderofRohan · 22/12/2023 05:37

FrostedFancy · 21/12/2023 16:28

Also, it could be the OP who's requesting the online learning, the GP just has to write something-or-other about her child's medical condition.

Exactly, all they have to write is that child seen, reported mental health issues due to health condition and how it affects them at school, awaiting referral made to CAHMs.

2-3 lines written in box on form put in front of them.

Could have been done during an appointment on NHS time but they won’t give me one.

What if every appointment was used by people trying to get out of paying for forms?

Sounds like you want to abuse the system by using NHS funds for non-NHS work to save your own pocket. Then you'll complain the next time you're ill and can't get an appointment.

The GP is not funded to do this type of work, just as the supermarket is not funded to feed your child for free. You have to pay.

cerisepanther73 · 22/12/2023 03:27

@FrostedFancy

If you were a doctor would you do the kind of request you are asking for free then?

littlebopeepp234 · 22/12/2023 02:25

LimePi · 22/12/2023 02:14

@littlebopeepp234

yes they are private businesses who have contract with NHS for NHS work only (hence are able to request payment for non NHS work). They are not NHS employees. The contract is regularly renegotiated too

Sorry I thought you meant they see patients privately via private clinics. What you have just said is basically what I said in response to your other post. They provide an NHS service, however filling in forms regarding education is nothing to do with the NHS and so yes are allowed to charge.

mantyzer · 22/12/2023 02:23

@Muffins28 I know GPs charge for cremation forms. But in the deaths I have had to deal with the GP has never visited the funeral home. Why would they?
What has always happened is the hospital Dr signs cause of death - they usually know what is the cause already. And if they dont a post mortem is organised. And a second Dr signs the form.
It is informally known as Ash Cash and an easy way to make extra money by Drs.

WandaWonder · 22/12/2023 02:18

I don't think forms know the differnce between for a child or adult, there is a fee that needs to be paid regardless of who the form it for

LimePi · 22/12/2023 02:14

@littlebopeepp234

yes they are private businesses who have contract with NHS for NHS work only (hence are able to request payment for non NHS work). They are not NHS employees. The contract is regularly renegotiated too

LimePi · 22/12/2023 02:12

@Muffins28

you forgot that GPs actually CHOSE that much paperwork per patient when renegotiated the NHS contract. They were offered a flat rate with less paperwork but they wanted to be paid more per variable rate depending on type of work / patient /illness etc. So now them complaining about oh so much admin and forms is a bit rich

littlebopeepp234 · 22/12/2023 02:09

LimePi · 22/12/2023 02:07

the fact that GPs are private businesses is ridiculous in the first place (and one of the root causes of current issues with primary care!)

GPa are NOT private businesses - they provide an NHS service by treating NHS patients. They are not private practices who charge for private consultations. However, filling out forms that are completely unrelated to the NHS (they don’t charge to fill out forms for other NHS services btw) is classed as private non NHS work for a GP therefore they are entitled to charge for that service

LimePi · 22/12/2023 02:07

the fact that GPs are private businesses is ridiculous in the first place (and one of the root causes of current issues with primary care!)

littlebopeepp234 · 22/12/2023 01:41

Deliria · 21/12/2023 23:25

Do you have much experience of SEND legislation and the responsibilities it places on the NHS?

Also by that theory you might as well say that schools shouldn’t be charging parents for school trips/ after school clubs/ school discos/ dress up days/ school dinners etc just because the NHS doesn’t charge patients for appointments because they have some sort of ‘responsibility’ placed upon them to work alongside educational services!!! It’s just a pointless non argument unfortunately and makes no sense 🙄

Its ok for schools to ask parents to pay ridiculous amounts of money for the services they provide to children - which those costs over the space of a school year equate to way more than £40 but it’s not ok for a GP to charge for a service that is completely unrelated to their actual job which is treating patients - Okay!

Fancycheese · 22/12/2023 01:35

Yes YABVU. The entitlement of some on this thread is also mind blowing.

littlebopeepp234 · 22/12/2023 01:30

TenorMachine · 21/12/2023 23:36

Yes I don’t have to fill anything like that number and it does relate to my speciality.

So that’s the difference then. You may decide not to charge for those forms just because you might have to complete one every once in a blue moon but GPs get all sorts of forms - anything between 5 and 10 a day thrown at them that are completely unrelated to the NHS or general practice therefore it isn’t really fair to say that just because you don’t charge then GPs shouldn’t either.

littlebopeepp234 · 22/12/2023 01:26

Alwaysanotherwine · 21/12/2023 22:18

you shouldn’t have to pay for diagnosis letter

dds letters from consultant to gp have all been forwarded to me as an extra copy via post

anything else in terms of opinion yes you should pay for

dds diagnosis letter was free as i just gave the copy of the consultant to gp letter in

Exactly this!!!! That is correct - the school have all the relevant information to hand. Its all about getting a signature from the GP so they can wash their hands of any legal responsibility

littlebopeepp234 · 22/12/2023 01:21

Deliria · 21/12/2023 23:25

Do you have much experience of SEND legislation and the responsibilities it places on the NHS?

What has that got to do with GP practices??? Different organisation altogether! Like I said GP practices work alongside other services not FOR them!! GPS are by LAW allowed to charge for filling in forms - that includes forms regarding education! YOU or nobody else can change that just by making up something in your head about what you think GP practices should and shouldn’t do just because they work alongside 3rd party organisations - usually for safeguarding purposes! Not for education matters! GP practices are not a hub for education resources! Maybe research the BMA recommended guidelines regarding what GPs are allowed to charge for private non NHS work which is what filling out 3rd party forms is classed as - PRIVATE non- NHS work!

TenorMachine · 21/12/2023 23:36

littlebopeepp234 · 21/12/2023 19:20

As I have pointed out in my earlier posts though, hospital consultants usually fill out forms that are specific to their area/ specialty of work, however GPs get all manner of forms thrown at them - multiple times on a daily basis. These forms can be anything ranging from passport forms to filling out a form for a patient to get a discount on their council tax. Then there are the forms that come in from
the benefits agency, solicitors requesting medical reports, the DVLA requesting medical reports, patients bringing in forms for their holiday insurance as they have had to cancel their holiday, patients wanting a reference for immigration purposes hence why GPs are more likely to charge. I imagine you yourself would only need to complete forms for a patient if that form is related to the specific area of work you deal with and I bet you don’t have to complete more than 5 of these forms on a daily basis. Being a hospital consultant is a completely different kettle of fish to being a GP

Edited

Yes I don’t have to fill anything like that number and it does relate to my speciality.

Deliria · 21/12/2023 23:27

Soontobe60 · 21/12/2023 21:48

Maybe the GP thinks that the best treatment for the child is to go to school.

But will write something different if OP pays them 40 quid? Unlikely.