Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is disgusting - GP charging for form

487 replies

FrostedFancy · 21/12/2023 13:39

GP surgery insist I must pay £40 for completion of a form from school to request online learning for my DD (14) who is suffering from MH issues due to being diagnosed with a serious health condition.

AIBU to think this is absolutely disgusting to profit from a child with medical condition and mental health issues needing access to an education?

Form literally would take 5 minutes to complete.

OP posts:
littlebopeepp234 · 26/12/2023 23:46

Deliria · 26/12/2023 23:31

It's not what I support. It's what the law requires. It's not optional. Public servants don't get to pick.

Wrong again but if it makes you feel better keep bleating all this nonsense then go ahead if it makes you happy. Nobody cares 🤣

LorlieS · 26/12/2023 23:45

GPs are within their rights to charge for such forms.

Deliria · 26/12/2023 23:31

gggonewired · 26/12/2023 22:54

I've given up arguing with Deliria luckily most people see this the same way,
One last time
@Deliria no idea what you're bringing in 'guardians of the NHS' My primary concern is not particularly the protection of GP time. It's the overwhelming bureaucracy created by other institutions to deny people the services they need. One of which is unnecessary letters from GPs. Policies and procedures are not set in stone they are created by human beings and often cumbersome in design precisely to deter other human beings from accessing resources.

If you've been through the process there is a form for every single thing, much of which doesn't require a GP sign off at all!

Not charging is just going to allow more of this nonsense. Quite frankly these BS documentation requirements should be banned.

you have no idea what 'partnership' and integration means you're just parroting it like ChatGPT. If they were truly partnering and integrated they'd pick up the phone and talk to each other not send forms back and forth ffs. Are you a management consultant by any chance...?

If you have been through the process not sure why you support all this paperwork. Even if you get it for free it still takes effort on your part

Edited

It's not what I support. It's what the law requires. It's not optional. Public servants don't get to pick.

littlebopeepp234 · 26/12/2023 23:13

Deliria · 26/12/2023 23:08

Well I imagine you were in a good position to ensure legal obligations in respect of your child were met then?

Out of interest, in what capacity were you employed?

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Deliria · 26/12/2023 23:08

littlebopeepp234 · 26/12/2023 22:59

Yes I do. And also a child with ASD. I also used to work in a GP practice for many years! And so have way more knowledge and experience of this than you do 😅

Well I imagine you were in a good position to ensure legal obligations in respect of your child were met then?

Out of interest, in what capacity were you employed?

littlebopeepp234 · 26/12/2023 22:59

Deliria · 26/12/2023 22:55

Guessing you don't have disabled child requiring agencies to join-up provision then?

Yes I do. And also a child with ASD. I also used to work in a GP practice for many years! And so have way more knowledge and experience of this than you do 😅

littlebopeepp234 · 26/12/2023 22:57

gggonewired · 26/12/2023 22:54

I've given up arguing with Deliria luckily most people see this the same way,
One last time
@Deliria no idea what you're bringing in 'guardians of the NHS' My primary concern is not particularly the protection of GP time. It's the overwhelming bureaucracy created by other institutions to deny people the services they need. One of which is unnecessary letters from GPs. Policies and procedures are not set in stone they are created by human beings and often cumbersome in design precisely to deter other human beings from accessing resources.

If you've been through the process there is a form for every single thing, much of which doesn't require a GP sign off at all!

Not charging is just going to allow more of this nonsense. Quite frankly these BS documentation requirements should be banned.

you have no idea what 'partnership' and integration means you're just parroting it like ChatGPT. If they were truly partnering and integrated they'd pick up the phone and talk to each other not send forms back and forth ffs. Are you a management consultant by any chance...?

If you have been through the process not sure why you support all this paperwork. Even if you get it for free it still takes effort on your part

Edited

Yes I think it’s best just ignore, they obviously have issues with understanding what they are being told. That poster can keep quoting the same sentence all they like, won’t change the fact GP’s are still allowed to charge for forms 😅

Deliria · 26/12/2023 22:55

littlebopeepp234 · 26/12/2023 22:51

Oh bore off 🤣

Guessing you don't have disabled child requiring agencies to join-up provision then?

gggonewired · 26/12/2023 22:54

littlebopeepp234 · 26/12/2023 22:51

Oh bore off 🤣

I've given up arguing with Deliria luckily most people see this the same way,
One last time
@Deliria no idea what you're bringing in 'guardians of the NHS' My primary concern is not particularly the protection of GP time. It's the overwhelming bureaucracy created by other institutions to deny people the services they need. One of which is unnecessary letters from GPs. Policies and procedures are not set in stone they are created by human beings and often cumbersome in design precisely to deter other human beings from accessing resources.

If you've been through the process there is a form for every single thing, much of which doesn't require a GP sign off at all!

Not charging is just going to allow more of this nonsense. Quite frankly these BS documentation requirements should be banned.

you have no idea what 'partnership' and integration means you're just parroting it like ChatGPT. If they were truly partnering and integrated they'd pick up the phone and talk to each other not send forms back and forth ffs. Are you a management consultant by any chance...?

If you have been through the process not sure why you support all this paperwork. Even if you get it for free it still takes effort on your part

littlebopeepp234 · 26/12/2023 22:51

Deliria · 26/12/2023 22:51

The NHS has a responsibility to work in partnership with the LA to meet SEND children's health and educational needs in an integrated way. This is not chargeable. This is core NHS work. Costs of this should not be passed to families.

Oh bore off 🤣

Deliria · 26/12/2023 22:51

PissOffJeffrey · 26/12/2023 22:31

You do know that the GP will read the Paeds letters then copy that on to the form? But you're fine that the Paediatrician can't do this form.

Sorry, the time used to complete this form is less time available to see NHS patients. Of course it's chargeable.

Your anger should absolutely be diverted to the school who have absolutely no legal obligation to ask for this.

The NHS has a responsibility to work in partnership with the LA to meet SEND children's health and educational needs in an integrated way. This is not chargeable. This is core NHS work. Costs of this should not be passed to families.

PissOffJeffrey · 26/12/2023 22:31

You do know that the GP will read the Paeds letters then copy that on to the form? But you're fine that the Paediatrician can't do this form.

Sorry, the time used to complete this form is less time available to see NHS patients. Of course it's chargeable.

Your anger should absolutely be diverted to the school who have absolutely no legal obligation to ask for this.

Scirocco · 26/12/2023 22:22

@Deliria yes, NHS is a relevant term here.

GPs are not (for the most part) NHS employees. They are contracted by the NHS to provide services. The NHS pays for these services so that they are free at the point of care to patients. If the contract doesn't cover certain things, the GP may still provide those things but is unlikely to do so for free. Free doesn't keep the lights on in the surgery or pay the GP's employees.

gggonewired · 26/12/2023 22:18

Deliria · 26/12/2023 22:01

Dear me.

It's another flock of those self-appointed guardians of the NHS who enjoy adamantly telling the person with the symptoms of PE they would definitely be wasting the NHS's time if they visited A&E...

One more time, the law requires the NHS and LAs to work in partnership in order to meet the education and health care needs of SEND children in an integrated way. Yes, this requires some adminstrative effort and the exchange of information. These are statutory responsibilities which no one should be charged for.

And no, these are not reasonable adjustments - that is covered by entirely seperate legislation.

Note: NHS is the key term.

Vague thinks like 'administrative effort' and 'exchange of information' is really irrelevant here as the devil is in the detail.
Refusing to share information is going against their statutory responsibilities.
Refusing to provide information in a very specific format, as required by the LA, when this information is already readily available in any other format is not.

At the end of the day the issue is the culture of 'accountability' if clinic letters etc as @littlebopeepp234 stated are available then why is this not accepted. Why do lines need to be handwritten and signed by a GP, in some specific form.

Who charges for what is not really relevant in the face of the overwhelming bureaucracy and paperwork that's required for the simplest of things.

Deliria · 26/12/2023 22:01

gggonewired · 25/12/2023 21:54

I'm not sure if posters like @Deliria (given the username) are being deliberately obtuse. They cannot distinguish between legal requirements and bureaucracy for the sake of it. GP is not obliged to support the latter for free.

Reasonable adjustments are based on the needs of a child. In fact they can (and should be provided) even before there's any medical diagnosis. They refuse to do this and are putting in as many obstacles to block access and not pay out. That's their issue and not the GP's!

A 'similar' situation I suppose would an employer asking for a fit note for short absences.
https://www.nhs.uk/common-health-questions/caring-carers-and-long-term-conditions/when-do-i-need-a-fit-note/
For less than 7 days off your employers should NOT be asking for medical evidence. They can ask you, the employee to fill in a form. But they absolutely should not charge for it.

If your workplace insists on a fit note for even a day's absence why should the GP provide it for free? It's not legally required. It's your employer who's breaking the law (or not following 'guidance').

In a similar vein all manner of places including schools ask for fit notes, GP letters etc when not required. Just to make it harder. Actually GP's making it 'free' would just make the problem worse and not address the real issue which is that the institutions asking for all this paperwork' don't want to provide what they're legally required to.

Edited

Dear me.

It's another flock of those self-appointed guardians of the NHS who enjoy adamantly telling the person with the symptoms of PE they would definitely be wasting the NHS's time if they visited A&E...

One more time, the law requires the NHS and LAs to work in partnership in order to meet the education and health care needs of SEND children in an integrated way. Yes, this requires some adminstrative effort and the exchange of information. These are statutory responsibilities which no one should be charged for.

And no, these are not reasonable adjustments - that is covered by entirely seperate legislation.

Note: NHS is the key term.

littlebopeepp234 · 25/12/2023 22:09

gggonewired · 25/12/2023 21:54

I'm not sure if posters like @Deliria (given the username) are being deliberately obtuse. They cannot distinguish between legal requirements and bureaucracy for the sake of it. GP is not obliged to support the latter for free.

Reasonable adjustments are based on the needs of a child. In fact they can (and should be provided) even before there's any medical diagnosis. They refuse to do this and are putting in as many obstacles to block access and not pay out. That's their issue and not the GP's!

A 'similar' situation I suppose would an employer asking for a fit note for short absences.
https://www.nhs.uk/common-health-questions/caring-carers-and-long-term-conditions/when-do-i-need-a-fit-note/
For less than 7 days off your employers should NOT be asking for medical evidence. They can ask you, the employee to fill in a form. But they absolutely should not charge for it.

If your workplace insists on a fit note for even a day's absence why should the GP provide it for free? It's not legally required. It's your employer who's breaking the law (or not following 'guidance').

In a similar vein all manner of places including schools ask for fit notes, GP letters etc when not required. Just to make it harder. Actually GP's making it 'free' would just make the problem worse and not address the real issue which is that the institutions asking for all this paperwork' don't want to provide what they're legally required to.

Edited

So true. The school will have had relevant clinic letters forwarded to them containing all the information they would be asking for on the form anyway. It’s just completely unnecessary.

And yes employees have to self certify for the first 7 days of sickness but there are still a small minority of employers who insist on telling employees they need a sick note before the 7 day period is over because they seem to think they are above the law

gggonewired · 25/12/2023 22:09

LorlieS · 25/12/2023 22:00

@gggonewired When you say "they", to whom are you referring?

If you're referring to my first sentence - every poster who think that GPs' should fill out forms for free. Forms that are not legally required.
Whether said form is demanded by an educational institution is not relevant.

LorlieS · 25/12/2023 22:00

@gggonewired When you say "they", to whom are you referring?

gggonewired · 25/12/2023 21:54

littlebopeepp234 · 24/12/2023 21:51

So take that up with tge department of education then? Or whoever is in charge?? I still don’t understand why you have singled me out specifically on this thread to make your comments at? My posts relate directly to GP practices as I have knowledge in that area!

I'm not sure if posters like @Deliria (given the username) are being deliberately obtuse. They cannot distinguish between legal requirements and bureaucracy for the sake of it. GP is not obliged to support the latter for free.

Reasonable adjustments are based on the needs of a child. In fact they can (and should be provided) even before there's any medical diagnosis. They refuse to do this and are putting in as many obstacles to block access and not pay out. That's their issue and not the GP's!

A 'similar' situation I suppose would an employer asking for a fit note for short absences.
https://www.nhs.uk/common-health-questions/caring-carers-and-long-term-conditions/when-do-i-need-a-fit-note/
For less than 7 days off your employers should NOT be asking for medical evidence. They can ask you, the employee to fill in a form. But they absolutely should not charge for it.

If your workplace insists on a fit note for even a day's absence why should the GP provide it for free? It's not legally required. It's your employer who's breaking the law (or not following 'guidance').

In a similar vein all manner of places including schools ask for fit notes, GP letters etc when not required. Just to make it harder. Actually GP's making it 'free' would just make the problem worse and not address the real issue which is that the institutions asking for all this paperwork' don't want to provide what they're legally required to.

howdoesyourgardengrowinmay · 24/12/2023 23:34

Standard.

LorlieS · 24/12/2023 22:28

@lucie82 Would this also annoy you as it did when the school requested a similar fee?

lucie82 · 24/12/2023 22:13

LorlieS · 24/12/2023 22:11

@lucie82 But according to posters on here a GP would also charge you for this form?

I think you have to pay for lots of things from gp. We can have one set of our records for free then if we need another we have to pay £50. I haven't read the rest of the posts tbf.

LorlieS · 24/12/2023 22:11

@lucie82 But according to posters on here a GP would also charge you for this form?

lucie82 · 24/12/2023 22:05

I paid £30 for a letter so school would provide a dairy free menu before she was diagnosed, she's now grown out of it, but I was annoyed at paying. However if I had to pay for drs visits and treatments I probably wouldn't be here

littlebopeepp234 · 24/12/2023 21:51

LorlieS · 24/12/2023 21:49

@littlebopeepp234 We are asked to fill in forms, of course we are! Example: please write a detailed letter explaining my child has (insert condition here) that we can provide as evidence for housing. Difference: we can't charge.

So take that up with tge department of education then? Or whoever is in charge?? I still don’t understand why you have singled me out specifically on this thread to make your comments at? My posts relate directly to GP practices as I have knowledge in that area!