Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is disgusting - GP charging for form

487 replies

FrostedFancy · 21/12/2023 13:39

GP surgery insist I must pay £40 for completion of a form from school to request online learning for my DD (14) who is suffering from MH issues due to being diagnosed with a serious health condition.

AIBU to think this is absolutely disgusting to profit from a child with medical condition and mental health issues needing access to an education?

Form literally would take 5 minutes to complete.

OP posts:
Morph22010 · 28/12/2023 09:19

I’ve not read the full thread so not sure if it’s already been mentioned but does your child get dla, it is to cover stuff like this. That said I think in your case it’s more a case of the local authority/ school putting up an extra barrier for your daughter to access education which isn’t the gp’s fault. Have you gone back to the school and advised them of the cost and asked if they are happy to pay for this being as it’s something they insist on to access education?

Deliria · 28/12/2023 09:02

FixTheBone · 27/12/2023 11:41

You need to stop and think.

Who has assessed the educational needs? - not the GP.

Who has determined remote learning to be preferable? - not the GP.

Who has intimate and detailed knowledge of the local education provisions? - not the GP.

Who has looked after the child in tertiary care and made the SEND diagnoses? - not the GP.

What possible reason then is there to insist on a GP signature on a piece of paper? Absolutely none, other than to put up a barrier, and to offload responsibility.

I've heard of GPs being asked for letters from British Gas to expedite boiler repairs ffs, it really isn't their job just because someone else says it is.

This is about the intersection of the health needs of SEND children with their educational needs and their is a legal duty on the NHS as well as LAs to work together to produce integrated support plans meeting health and educational needs of SEND children. The ignorance of this is alarming.

Deliria · 28/12/2023 08:58

gggonewired · 27/12/2023 19:37

Unfortunately thinking doesn't appear to be a strong point of @Deliria . Especially ironic as they have repeated what PP have already been saying.
Patients don't need to see this 'wiring'... yes, they don't need to be sent back and forth with forms when the information is already available.

They accuse other people of getting excited by 'commissioning wrangles' but it's them who insists that the GP should just fill out the form for free. Because well if the LA requests it, it MUST be absolutely necessary.

The duty is on the LA to provide and to sift through the available evidence. Not the GP. Who as you said may not even be involved with the patient in this manner! The word 'general' in their job title is really being stretched.

FWIW for all the furore r.e. Physician Assistants this is the sort of secretarial work they should actually be doing leaving GP's free to see patients. Because of the insistence on a GP's signature for some imagined arse-covering, not due to any actual need it's the other way around.

Edited

The duty to work in partnership sits between the NHS and the LA. Have a look at the Act.

soemptyinside · 28/12/2023 02:06

Wateroverwine · 27/12/2023 16:20

I think £40 is a lot but they should charge. GP should charge for people in general going in I think something little though like £5 every visit, hopefully that would stop people who like to visit for coughs, colds or a chat

Just my opinion

Those of us with chronic conditions already have to pay for our drugs to stay alive. You think we should pay for appointments now too?

Just call your pitch what it is - a tax on the disabled.

gggonewired · 27/12/2023 19:37

FixTheBone · 27/12/2023 11:41

You need to stop and think.

Who has assessed the educational needs? - not the GP.

Who has determined remote learning to be preferable? - not the GP.

Who has intimate and detailed knowledge of the local education provisions? - not the GP.

Who has looked after the child in tertiary care and made the SEND diagnoses? - not the GP.

What possible reason then is there to insist on a GP signature on a piece of paper? Absolutely none, other than to put up a barrier, and to offload responsibility.

I've heard of GPs being asked for letters from British Gas to expedite boiler repairs ffs, it really isn't their job just because someone else says it is.

Unfortunately thinking doesn't appear to be a strong point of @Deliria . Especially ironic as they have repeated what PP have already been saying.
Patients don't need to see this 'wiring'... yes, they don't need to be sent back and forth with forms when the information is already available.

They accuse other people of getting excited by 'commissioning wrangles' but it's them who insists that the GP should just fill out the form for free. Because well if the LA requests it, it MUST be absolutely necessary.

The duty is on the LA to provide and to sift through the available evidence. Not the GP. Who as you said may not even be involved with the patient in this manner! The word 'general' in their job title is really being stretched.

FWIW for all the furore r.e. Physician Assistants this is the sort of secretarial work they should actually be doing leaving GP's free to see patients. Because of the insistence on a GP's signature for some imagined arse-covering, not due to any actual need it's the other way around.

Wateroverwine · 27/12/2023 16:20

I think £40 is a lot but they should charge. GP should charge for people in general going in I think something little though like £5 every visit, hopefully that would stop people who like to visit for coughs, colds or a chat

Just my opinion

littlebopeepp234 · 27/12/2023 12:11

FixTheBone · 27/12/2023 11:41

You need to stop and think.

Who has assessed the educational needs? - not the GP.

Who has determined remote learning to be preferable? - not the GP.

Who has intimate and detailed knowledge of the local education provisions? - not the GP.

Who has looked after the child in tertiary care and made the SEND diagnoses? - not the GP.

What possible reason then is there to insist on a GP signature on a piece of paper? Absolutely none, other than to put up a barrier, and to offload responsibility.

I've heard of GPs being asked for letters from British Gas to expedite boiler repairs ffs, it really isn't their job just because someone else says it is.

This is so true, all of it.

i worked in a GP surgery years ago and yes they do get requests to write letters to expedite boiler repairs and all sorts of other shit! They have these random requests thrown at them almost on a daily basis!

KeepGoingThomas · 27/12/2023 12:04

A letter from the GP isn’t required for alternative provision. However, schools themselves are not routinely cc’d into clinic letters. (If they do in some areas they don’t in all.)

FixTheBone · 27/12/2023 11:41

Deliria · 26/12/2023 22:55

Guessing you don't have disabled child requiring agencies to join-up provision then?

You need to stop and think.

Who has assessed the educational needs? - not the GP.

Who has determined remote learning to be preferable? - not the GP.

Who has intimate and detailed knowledge of the local education provisions? - not the GP.

Who has looked after the child in tertiary care and made the SEND diagnoses? - not the GP.

What possible reason then is there to insist on a GP signature on a piece of paper? Absolutely none, other than to put up a barrier, and to offload responsibility.

I've heard of GPs being asked for letters from British Gas to expedite boiler repairs ffs, it really isn't their job just because someone else says it is.

NotInvisible · 27/12/2023 11:33

I had a 2 page form for student finance a few years ago, for disabled students allowance. It specifically asked the GP not to charge me for it because I wasn't able to claim it back from them. I still got charged £30 🤦🏾‍♀️ It was just so they could confirm my diagnosis and for them to sign.

FixTheBone · 27/12/2023 11:33

It's not core NHS work for GPs if its not in their GMS or locally negotiated primary care contracts.

marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 27/12/2023 11:32

I suppose if you were never charged then it's a casualty of the ongoing war between the NHS and and the integrated care boards, which have renegotiated contracts with GPs over all sorts of things and removed some services to pharmacies.

littlebopeepp234 · 27/12/2023 11:17

soemptyinside · 27/12/2023 11:10

I can see the OP's POV.

GPs have always been able to charge for non-standard forms.

However, in my case, I was never charged for forms in respect of my education. This also extended to my professional education when I was part of the working poor in my early 20s.

It's reasonable to charge for a non-standard letter for work or a hobby, but when it comes to someone's basic education, I don't think a charge should be applied to that person (or their guardian).

I suppose the more relevant question is, who should suffer the cost? Should the GP do this for free, or should someone else pay? The school? The NHS?

In this case, there doesn't actually seem to be a need for a form, it's an arbitrary school policy, so perhaps the GP should be able to bill the school for the letter. I mean, they won't be able to, but morally, I think they should be able to.

The point that a lot of people, including myself have pointed out though is that schools already have the information to hand. They are sent copies of clinic letters (same ones that are sent back to a GP from hospitals and various other establishments the child has been seen at) which all confirm a child’s diagnosis and all relevant information to do with the condition and treatment of the child. All a GP would be doing by filling out a form is to be writing the same information that are on this correspondence that has been ‘carbon coped’ to the school as well as it being in the child’s medical records. The difference is that the GP is signing the form and therefore makes them legally responsible to what they are signing to, therefore it allows the school to wash their hands of any legal responsibility and can then place the responsibility of all their decisions on the child’s education on the GP because they have ‘signed a document’! In most cases it is a complete waste of unnecessary time for the GP as they are only writing the same information on the form that the school has already been sent to them, hence the reason why they should charge

soemptyinside · 27/12/2023 11:10

I can see the OP's POV.

GPs have always been able to charge for non-standard forms.

However, in my case, I was never charged for forms in respect of my education. This also extended to my professional education when I was part of the working poor in my early 20s.

It's reasonable to charge for a non-standard letter for work or a hobby, but when it comes to someone's basic education, I don't think a charge should be applied to that person (or their guardian).

I suppose the more relevant question is, who should suffer the cost? Should the GP do this for free, or should someone else pay? The school? The NHS?

In this case, there doesn't actually seem to be a need for a form, it's an arbitrary school policy, so perhaps the GP should be able to bill the school for the letter. I mean, they won't be able to, but morally, I think they should be able to.

coffeeaddict77 · 27/12/2023 10:42

Deliria · 27/12/2023 10:33

That is because there is not an act of Parliament requiring them to work in partnership to meet your needs! Do you not understand the difference?

Do you not understand what what working in a partnership means? It does not mean that the LA can tell the nhs what to do and that the NHS must pay for it.

Deliria · 27/12/2023 10:33

coffeeaddict77 · 27/12/2023 10:01

The NHS doesn't have to statutory duty to provide whatever the LA tell them to particularly if they are not paid for it. There is nothing to stop the LA or school from paying the GP for the letter, if it is considered important for the child's education. When the DVLA wanted my GP to see me and write a letter they paid for it and I think other agencies do to.

That is because there is not an act of Parliament requiring them to work in partnership to meet your needs! Do you not understand the difference?

Deliria · 27/12/2023 10:32

coffeeaddict77 · 27/12/2023 10:01

The NHS doesn't have to statutory duty to provide whatever the LA tell them to particularly if they are not paid for it. There is nothing to stop the LA or school from paying the GP for the letter, if it is considered important for the child's education. When the DVLA wanted my GP to see me and write a letter they paid for it and I think other agencies do to.

Respectfully, go and read the Children and Families Act 2014, and stop making things up.

coffeeaddict77 · 27/12/2023 10:01

Deliria · 27/12/2023 08:58

I think the point is the NHS has a legal responsibility to work with the LA in order to do this. It is a matter of a statutory responsibility it is not a contract - it is not something either party can negotiate their way out of. So the NHS must make resources available to discharge this. Frankly it should hide the wiring from families of disabled children who could do without the runaround or witnessing the internicine commissioning wrangles some folks on here seem so excited by. We don't care. Sort yourselves out.

The NHS doesn't have to statutory duty to provide whatever the LA tell them to particularly if they are not paid for it. There is nothing to stop the LA or school from paying the GP for the letter, if it is considered important for the child's education. When the DVLA wanted my GP to see me and write a letter they paid for it and I think other agencies do to.

Scirocco · 27/12/2023 09:01

@Deliria sorry, I'm not one of those management people. Nor am I a GP. You'll need to pass on your sage advice to the relevant bodies in the NHS management system. PALS may be able to advise you on who to approach.

I actually agree that the commissioning contracts should ideally cover these sorts of things, but they don't. It's not a slight on you or anyone else, it's just reality.

Deliria · 27/12/2023 08:58

Scirocco · 27/12/2023 00:57

As I've previously said, if it isn't in the contract between the NHS and the GP (who is neither an NHS employee nor a public servant), then it's not being paid for by the NHS. Someone has to pay for it. If you don't agree with this, then you should take it up with the higher levels of NHS management responsible for contracting services from GPs. Until then, GPs have businesses to run and overheads to meet, so can't go around giving their professional time away for free.

I think the point is the NHS has a legal responsibility to work with the LA in order to do this. It is a matter of a statutory responsibility it is not a contract - it is not something either party can negotiate their way out of. So the NHS must make resources available to discharge this. Frankly it should hide the wiring from families of disabled children who could do without the runaround or witnessing the internicine commissioning wrangles some folks on here seem so excited by. We don't care. Sort yourselves out.

CMZ2018 · 27/12/2023 08:43

Do you do work for nothing?

littlebopeepp234 · 27/12/2023 01:01

Deliria · 27/12/2023 00:56

How odd.

👌🤣

Scirocco · 27/12/2023 00:57

Deliria · 26/12/2023 22:51

The NHS has a responsibility to work in partnership with the LA to meet SEND children's health and educational needs in an integrated way. This is not chargeable. This is core NHS work. Costs of this should not be passed to families.

As I've previously said, if it isn't in the contract between the NHS and the GP (who is neither an NHS employee nor a public servant), then it's not being paid for by the NHS. Someone has to pay for it. If you don't agree with this, then you should take it up with the higher levels of NHS management responsible for contracting services from GPs. Until then, GPs have businesses to run and overheads to meet, so can't go around giving their professional time away for free.

Deliria · 27/12/2023 00:56

littlebopeepp234 · 26/12/2023 23:46

Wrong again but if it makes you feel better keep bleating all this nonsense then go ahead if it makes you happy. Nobody cares 🤣

How odd.

NaughtybutNice77 · 27/12/2023 00:41

Do you actually need the letter? You can have access to your (daughter's) medical notes which should include all the information you require. Of course, you'll have to sift through it and highlight her diagnosis.The way her health affects her day to day should be demonstratable. If the notes don't show this you're essentially asking for a review or assessment....which isn't 5mins.

If I want a medical to say drive a crane, I have to pay. You're not requesting heslthcare, you're requesting administration.

Swipe left for the next trending thread