Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is disgusting - GP charging for form

487 replies

FrostedFancy · 21/12/2023 13:39

GP surgery insist I must pay £40 for completion of a form from school to request online learning for my DD (14) who is suffering from MH issues due to being diagnosed with a serious health condition.

AIBU to think this is absolutely disgusting to profit from a child with medical condition and mental health issues needing access to an education?

Form literally would take 5 minutes to complete.

OP posts:
kalokagathos · 21/12/2023 17:02

It's standard at all surgeries I have been registered at

margotrose · 21/12/2023 16:57

Imagine if everyone who needed a form filling in for an external reason demanded a free appointment? How do you see that working out?

ememem84 · 21/12/2023 16:56

Standard here. It’s not clinical time. But it’s the GP’s time.

ClareBlue · 21/12/2023 16:55

You are using really emotive language and it is really disrespectful. It's not disgusting or profiteering from a child's illness. It's charging for health services to enable them to be provided. As stated, completing a form is not a tick box. It has to be completed based on knowledge of the patient and their medical files. That's why there is a form in the first place. To verify medical situations. There's liability and accountability and it's not 5 minutes work to screw money out of you because of your child's illness. If you genuinely can not afford it then look for help. It's out there. But stop blaming and accusing medical professionals of being unscrupulous.

WhereIsBebèsChambre · 21/12/2023 16:55

Who has recommended the home learning? Would they not be best placed to fill the form out?

Superfans · 21/12/2023 16:53

GP’s are professionals, they don’t work for free - they do work they are paid to do in their GP contract. If they do work outside this contract they are either doing it in their own time for free or taking time from the work they are paid for to do it. If you wish GP’s to complete work that is currently non funded you can write to your MP and suggest the contract is reviewed to include this work. Alternatively you can raise money for charity to fund these requests for people.

ohdamnitjanet · 21/12/2023 16:52

Couldn’t be arsed to worry about it to be honest, unless I was on a low income / benefits and really couldn’t pay it.

WashItTomorrow · 21/12/2023 16:49

FrostedFancy · 21/12/2023 16:19

Child is entitled to free education, prescription, medical, dental and optical treatment so this should include all care surrounding that.

I don’t disagree adults should be charged at all but this is for a child.

They don’t charge for referral letters do they? Don’t see how it’s any different really.

It’s very different. Referral letters relate to health matters under the NHS. This doesn’t. GPs aren’t involved in the education of the child. It’s not their job to look after the child in every way. Proving a letter is helping the child and family, but there’s no reason why they shouldn’t be paid for it. I suppose they could refuse. Many health issues actually have to be paid for by parents. It is they who have the responsibility of the care. If your child’s feet are deformed by too-small shoes, you don’t get new shoes provided by the NHS.

Caffeineislife · 21/12/2023 16:47

Totally normal. All forms come with a charge at our GP. This is a school issue and I would be speaking to the SENCO. It's possibly all caught up in attendance and education welfare. They need an official form from the GP as evidence that DC needs online learning and isn't classed as truanting.

They may also insist on a form to stop lots of other people requesting online learning for things other than health reasons. Since COVID there are a few CF who are demanding access to online learning/ catch up packs so they can have cheap term time holidays or so they don't have to get out of bed on a Friday morning.

Andarna · 21/12/2023 16:44

A 5 min question doesn't mean that it just takes 5 minutes. First you explain what is needed and why, then the GP might have questions and fill in the form. THEN, maybe after you have left, they need to update the notes what they did and why. So your 5 minute question might actually take 15-20 minutes.

littlebopeepp234 · 21/12/2023 16:43

Menora · 21/12/2023 16:41

They will not write what you ask they are legally obliged to write facts. They will need to review the records. The reason this isn’t an appt is because you would just be sitting watching them reading a screen?

This!! Plus with the amount of forms GP’s are asked to fill out every day there would be no appointments for patients who are ill if they were all taken by people who think they should see the GP for it and as it is classed as private work then it should not be done during NHS times ie. On NHS patient appointment slots

endofthelinefinally · 21/12/2023 16:41

windywash · 21/12/2023 16:16

I work in camhs and consultants there do not charge to fill in such forms. YANBU

So the school should be asking the consultant to fill in the form. That would be much more appropriate.

Menora · 21/12/2023 16:41

They will not write what you ask they are legally obliged to write facts. They will need to review the records. The reason this isn’t an appt is because you would just be sitting watching them reading a screen?

Grimpo · 21/12/2023 16:39

It won't take 5 minutes, though, will it. The GP will have to read the form, bring up your child's notes, check that they're the right ones, and read through them, decide how to answer and do so. They may have to consider whether to ask you to bring your child in so that they can give a properly up to date opinion. The form will need to be saved to the practice's own records and sent off to the school using whatever data protection system the surgery and/or the school use, which frankly is usually an awful faff. If the doctor is doing his/her work properly and conscientiously, that is not a 5 minute job.

littlebopeepp234 · 21/12/2023 16:39

Weepingskies · 21/12/2023 16:36

How does the GP know how your DD is affected at school better than the school who have presumably seen her at school and are fully aware of her struggles there? If they write down what you tell them to write and sign it it’s really just hearsay isn’t it?

A GP won’t write down what they are told to write down just because a patient says so. They have to write down facts from a patient’s medical records, however most 3rd party services do forward consultations with a patient back to their GP so regardless of who has seen that patient whether it’s a school/ CAHMS/ mental health services, all correspondence from those consultations will usually go back to the GP. The GP would be filling in the form based on what other services have fed back to the GP and is on the patient’s medical records. Anything other than that would be classed as giving false information and could have serious consequences for a GP

Weepingskies · 21/12/2023 16:36

How does the GP know how your DD is affected at school better than the school who have presumably seen her at school and are fully aware of her struggles there? If they write down what you tell them to write and sign it it’s really just hearsay isn’t it?

MrsAvocet · 21/12/2023 16:36

FrostedFancy · 21/12/2023 16:19

Child is entitled to free education, prescription, medical, dental and optical treatment so this should include all care surrounding that.

I don’t disagree adults should be charged at all but this is for a child.

They don’t charge for referral letters do they? Don’t see how it’s any different really.

But* *those things have limits, even for children.
I have spent a bloody fortune on optical care for my DS over the years as he has a lot of issues with a complex prescription and the lenses that he really needs are very expensive. The NHS contribution goes nowhere near providing what he really needs and our optician agrees, but she's not going to pay for them herself is she? She does what she's paid for under the NHS and I pay the rest.

Finteq · 21/12/2023 16:36

FrostedFancy · 21/12/2023 16:28

Also, it could be the OP who's requesting the online learning, the GP just has to write something-or-other about her child's medical condition.

Exactly, all they have to write is that child seen, reported mental health issues due to health condition and how it affects them at school, awaiting referral made to CAHMs.

2-3 lines written in box on form put in front of them.

Could have been done during an appointment on NHS time but they won’t give me one.

All the appointments are probably filled with other people who only want a couple of lines signing off🙄

Don't complain when there isn't any appointments to get your form filled, because they're booked up with others wanting theirs filled- And don't get me started on the entitled people who think they should have an appointment for a review of a health condition.

littlebopeepp234 · 21/12/2023 16:30

FrostedFancy · 21/12/2023 16:28

Also, it could be the OP who's requesting the online learning, the GP just has to write something-or-other about her child's medical condition.

Exactly, all they have to write is that child seen, reported mental health issues due to health condition and how it affects them at school, awaiting referral made to CAHMs.

2-3 lines written in box on form put in front of them.

Could have been done during an appointment on NHS time but they won’t give me one.

You do realise that once the GP writes all this information on the form and that they have signed it then it becomes a legal document that they have put their name to and can be potentially used against them in the future! THAT is what they are signing for and THAT is why they charge you to do so!! It’s not just a few lines it is time consuming to go through your DD’s records and make sure they are giving the most accurate and truthful information they have.

edit: GP practices are also short of appointments as it is without taking one up for the umpteen amount of forms they are asked to sign every day

KeepGoingThomas · 21/12/2023 16:30

The problem is the school/LA asking for something they don't need to provide the education they are law bound to provide.

^This. The LA has a statutory duty to provide education to those unable to attend school full time. They don’t need a specific form completed for this.

Alongside pursuing section19 provision, you should request an EHCNA if you haven’t already.

Viviennemary · 21/12/2023 16:30

GP's always charge for requested letters AFAIK. I agree. Get annoyed at the school for requesting the letter.

FrostedFancy · 21/12/2023 16:28

Also, it could be the OP who's requesting the online learning, the GP just has to write something-or-other about her child's medical condition.

Exactly, all they have to write is that child seen, reported mental health issues due to health condition and how it affects them at school, awaiting referral made to CAHMs.

2-3 lines written in box on form put in front of them.

Could have been done during an appointment on NHS time but they won’t give me one.

OP posts:
TeresaCrowd · 21/12/2023 16:28

It’s one thing for GPs to charge for things that are optional/elective - eg a letter needed to carry meds or insulin needles on a holiday flight.Absolutely right that NHS time isn’t used for that and a reasonable charge is levied. This should reflect the actual time and resources needed to complete it though, and not be seen as an opportunity to rinse patients.

Except that as a T1, the letter inevitably has to be changed when they unilaterally decides to change your medication/glucose metre/brand of CGM/brand of insulin pump, and you have to repeatedly pay for letters for the same thing because nobody will just accept a copy of your prescription or a previous letter which should be more than adequate. Yes ultimately the fault is with the people who repeatedly want letters rather than the NHS, but it's kicking people with long term conditions more than those who are on short term meds/short term injured for example where they can see an end to the cost and suck it up just that once. You know that children with T1 get DLA but once you hit adulthood you aren't eligible anymore, because the stresses and challenges of T1 stop when you hit adulthood... It's not a one off £35 or whatever, its that once or twice or more a year, every year to live an average lifestyle.

Of course the solution is to accept more what people say rather than relying on the GP. Don't get me started on activities where they say you need a GP to sign you off as fit to participate. My GP definitely would barely complete a parkrun so how do they know the required fitness and control of your condition required to complete sporting challenges that you have trained and trained for over an extended period of time.

Whatever happened to personal responsibility but also believing people when they say they need/don't need/are/aren't capable of doing something. Race to the bottom of the lowest of the low chancers ruining things for average folk once again by taking the piss.

Sorry that's a bit of a rant but as a T1 it boils my piss that because I have a medical condition I'm not deemed trustworthy to know my own capabilities but the GP who sees me once a year knows all.

Mumof2NDers · 21/12/2023 16:28

MumblesParty · 21/12/2023 16:18

Is it an NHS dentist that you work for? I assume so, because otherwise you couldn’t possibly be implying that Doctors were money grabbing. Private dentistry is a licence to print money as far as I can see!

I wasn’t implying anything!! I’m sure some dentists charge too. The dentist I work with and I have been at the same practice for 30 and just wouldn’t charge a patient.
It’s a mixed practice. We do NHS and private. Depends what a patient wants

ATerrorofLeftovers · 21/12/2023 16:27

MumblesParty · 21/12/2023 16:08

@ATerrorofLeftovers hang on, you practice privately but you expect GPs to work for free?! OK so say you were a private physio. One of your patients can’t make their appointment because their car is in the garage. Would you pay for them to get a taxi? Or go and pick them up yourself? After all, the taxi would get them to their physio appointment, so it’s related to their condition, for which you are treating them.

Oh come on. I don’t expect you to work for free, but I think you know that. You do get paid to provide services for the NHS, don’t you? FWIW I agree with you when you speak about the way the NHS and GPs’ working practices have been deliberately degraded. The deterioration in the NHS is atrocious and that’s the fault of the government and those who vote them in.. I wish your working conditions were better. But I’m still surprised you don’t see prescribing treatment for a child’s medical treatment as a core service.

What do you do if a patient can’t afford £40 for a letter to ensure their child’s medical needs are met? Those patients who are earning a lot less than you?

Swipe left for the next trending thread