Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is disgusting - GP charging for form

487 replies

FrostedFancy · 21/12/2023 13:39

GP surgery insist I must pay £40 for completion of a form from school to request online learning for my DD (14) who is suffering from MH issues due to being diagnosed with a serious health condition.

AIBU to think this is absolutely disgusting to profit from a child with medical condition and mental health issues needing access to an education?

Form literally would take 5 minutes to complete.

OP posts:
JamSandle · 21/12/2023 17:58

I have to pay £100 for some forms I need filling.

littlebopeepp234 · 21/12/2023 17:58

ATerrorofLeftovers · 21/12/2023 17:53

It may be that some think like that. But some of us really do believe in the NHS being ‘free at the point of use’ - ie NOT actually free - because we pay for it out of taxation, rather than when we use the service. And that those who are fortunate enough to earn well should be taxed accordingly. Not that those who are on low incomes should be subject to indiscriminate charges to address a medical need in their child, who then has to go without if the parent can’t pay.

As has been stated many times on this thread, a GP filling out a form is classed as private work and not on the NHS so you are not actually paying for it out of taxation

StarlightLime · 21/12/2023 17:58

There’s an issue of fairness,, for example, if a partner GP earning £100k is charging a patient struggling to make ends meet in the current CoL climate
This is such a bizarre point of view.
The GP's earnings are completely irrelevant, no other professional would be expected to give their time and expertise at a vastly discounted rate because their client may earn less.

ATerrorofLeftovers · 21/12/2023 17:57

borntobequiet · 21/12/2023 17:53

It’s prescribing something that will mitigate a medical condition.

GPs do not prescribe modes of education. They are neither qualified nor contracted to do so.

There’s an issue of fairness

There are issues to do with fairness in society, but they are irrelevant in this context.

The GP informs the education provider of the limitations created by the medical condition, presumably, so that the education specialists understand the child’s needs. A bit like a referral to a medical specialist.

I don’t agree the fairness issues are irrelevant - not morally, at least. But there’s a rather old-fashioned concept, right there!

FUPAgirl · 21/12/2023 17:56

Completely unreasonable of the school to expect your GP to make this assessment - they are not experts in mental health.

Zebedee55 · 21/12/2023 17:55

GPs have charged for letters and forms, for years. Nothing new.

borntobequiet · 21/12/2023 17:53

It’s prescribing something that will mitigate a medical condition.

GPs do not prescribe modes of education. They are neither qualified nor contracted to do so.

There’s an issue of fairness

There are issues to do with fairness in society, but they are irrelevant in this context.

ATerrorofLeftovers · 21/12/2023 17:53

wronginalltherightways · 21/12/2023 17:36

Agree.

Everyone talks a good game about saving the NHS, and how it desperately needs better funding, but heaven forbid all those non-covered extras have to be paid for individually. Those are charges only 'other people' should have to pay. Righto, then. c

It may be that some think like that. But some of us really do believe in the NHS being ‘free at the point of use’ - ie NOT actually free - because we pay for it out of taxation, rather than when we use the service. And that those who are fortunate enough to earn well should be taxed accordingly. Not that those who are on low incomes should be subject to indiscriminate charges to address a medical need in their child, who then has to go without if the parent can’t pay.

Lavenderflower · 21/12/2023 17:51

This is the norm. Is your child under CAMHS? They may provide the letter for free.

HamBone · 21/12/2023 17:50

moomoomoo27 · 21/12/2023 17:21

Maybe reframe it in your mind as a donation to the NHS, which you also benefit from in a form being signed. It is the season of giving after all, and if any good establishment needs all the help it can get, it's the NHS.

You could also look at it in terms of money you've saved by being lucky enough to be in a country with an NHS. If you were in the US you'd be 100 grand down just from giving birth, let alone anything after.

@moomoomoo27 $100K? Just a slight exaggeration! $2-3K is more standard.

Not that this has anything to do with the OP.

ATerrorofLeftovers · 21/12/2023 17:47

borntobequiet · 21/12/2023 17:05

Prescribing a required set of conditions on school is no different to prescribing medication.

It’s entirely different.

Not least because many GPs will be earning salaries way higher than the patients they are gouging.

The GP’s salary is irrelevant.

I don’t think it is entirely different. It’s prescribing something that will mitigate a medical condition. Medication prescribed by a dr also mitigates a medical condition. In each case the patient wouldn’t need what’s being prescribed if it weren’t for the fact they’re suffering from a medical condition.

The GP’s salary could be relevant in some circumstances. There’s an issue of fairness,, for example, if a partner GP earning £100k is charging a patient struggling to make ends meet in the current CoL climate. I would hope there would at least be some leeway for patients struggling financially, though some will find it embarrassing to ask.

littlebopeepp234 · 21/12/2023 17:47

Deliria · 21/12/2023 17:41

It's not as though OP is paying for it via taxation or anything, is it? Confused

GPs are taxed on all private work they do, that includes filling out forms

Deliria · 21/12/2023 17:41

moomoomoo27 · 21/12/2023 17:21

Maybe reframe it in your mind as a donation to the NHS, which you also benefit from in a form being signed. It is the season of giving after all, and if any good establishment needs all the help it can get, it's the NHS.

You could also look at it in terms of money you've saved by being lucky enough to be in a country with an NHS. If you were in the US you'd be 100 grand down just from giving birth, let alone anything after.

It's not as though OP is paying for it via taxation or anything, is it? Confused

banjocat · 21/12/2023 17:40

The NHS aren't 'profiting' from it. You are paying their admin costs instead of the government. That's not 'profiting' - no one is raking in money in the NHS, it's in a pretty poor state if you haven't noticed!

It's normal for the patient to pay admin fees for letters and forms to be filled in.

Really, it seems like the school are at fault - why won't they just accept a standard diagnosis letter which doesn't cost anything? Why do they need the GP to fill in a special form?

wronginalltherightways · 21/12/2023 17:36

Tracker1234 · 21/12/2023 16:12

Most people agree NHS is on its knees. Most people think it needs better funding. However THEY dont want to pay anything more personally. That is for others to fund.

Forms have always been chargeable. I am not sure what difference it makes if the form is for a child.

Agree.

Everyone talks a good game about saving the NHS, and how it desperately needs better funding, but heaven forbid all those non-covered extras have to be paid for individually. Those are charges only 'other people' should have to pay. Righto, then. c

Zanatdy · 21/12/2023 17:36

I had to pay £50 to exclude DD from PE for health reasons and had to return the letter with my suggested amendments as it made no sense

Metallicant · 21/12/2023 17:31

This has been standard practice for years,

Usernumber3736372836373 · 21/12/2023 17:28

very common. I was charged £27 for a very brief doctors note regrading my son and his MH a couple years ago! It was being used as an application with school transport help!

Maelil01 · 21/12/2023 17:26

Scirocco · 21/12/2023 14:00

Totally standard. Any non-NHS work like this needs to be paid for.

The form may look like it would only take 5 minutes, but it would likely take longer than that. It's an important form relating to the education and health of a child registered with that GP. The GP has a responsibility to ensure it's completed accurately so that a) the people reviewing it have the most accurate information, and b) if something were to go wrong, their decision-making can be justified and defended. To do that, the GP will probably need to take a lot longer than 5 minutes to access and review your child's healthcare records, consider how the information contained within the records relates to the questions on the form, make any necessary enquiries (eg if there's any uncertainty they may want to clarify things with any treating specialist), and complete the form.

All of that is time that isn't being spent on core NHS work. The core NHS work still needs to get done, so the GP will probably need to stay later at work, too.

£40 for a report isn't much, and I would imagine it's a report you want to be as accurate and thorough as possible. It's not profit at the expense of a child. It's payment (at a pretty low rate) for a private service for the benefit of that child. There's a difference.

100%

littlebopeepp234 · 21/12/2023 17:24

MumblesParty · 21/12/2023 17:12

One of the problems is that in general there are standard charges for forms, regardless of how long they take. So if a GP completes a simple form about a patient they know very well, it can take as little as 10 minutes to do. However, other forms can take 2 hours. That may seem unfair, and you could argue that forms should be charged based on how long they take to complete. But then, inevitably, the people with multiple complex medical problems would end up paying more, as their forms would take longer, which also seems unfair.

The argument that GPs should just do it for free “because it’ll only take a few minutes” is just unrealistic. Most surgeries will have more than 2000 patients per GP. You have to see the bigger picture.

Even for patients who are well known to the GP they still have to go through the medical records to make sure they are giving the most accurate and factual information possible

wronginalltherightways · 21/12/2023 17:24

windywash · 21/12/2023 16:21

But the GP would probably fill the form out in their NHS paid for time 🤔

Probably not, actually. Their NHS paid for time is taken up by patient slots.

3luckystars · 21/12/2023 17:22

LookItsMeAgain · 21/12/2023 14:26

You wouldn't last 5 minutes in Ireland! GP's here charge for repeat prescriptions to be written, for certs to be provided to employers and on and on and on.

We pay approximately €60 per visit to our GP. We pay for prescription medication.

We pay for health insurance.

Oh this is on top of our taxes going towards our supposed 'free' health service (like the NHS but not).

Exactly what I was thinking. €65 a visit and I actually think it’s worth it. My Gp practice is amazing and the staff are excellent.

moomoomoo27 · 21/12/2023 17:21

Maybe reframe it in your mind as a donation to the NHS, which you also benefit from in a form being signed. It is the season of giving after all, and if any good establishment needs all the help it can get, it's the NHS.

You could also look at it in terms of money you've saved by being lucky enough to be in a country with an NHS. If you were in the US you'd be 100 grand down just from giving birth, let alone anything after.

MumblesParty · 21/12/2023 17:12

One of the problems is that in general there are standard charges for forms, regardless of how long they take. So if a GP completes a simple form about a patient they know very well, it can take as little as 10 minutes to do. However, other forms can take 2 hours. That may seem unfair, and you could argue that forms should be charged based on how long they take to complete. But then, inevitably, the people with multiple complex medical problems would end up paying more, as their forms would take longer, which also seems unfair.

The argument that GPs should just do it for free “because it’ll only take a few minutes” is just unrealistic. Most surgeries will have more than 2000 patients per GP. You have to see the bigger picture.

borntobequiet · 21/12/2023 17:05

ATerrorofLeftovers · 21/12/2023 15:04

It’s one thing for GPs to charge for things that are optional/elective - eg a letter needed to carry meds or insulin needles on a holiday flight.Absolutely right that NHS time isn’t used for that and a reasonable charge is levied. This should reflect the actual time and resources needed to complete it though, and not be seen as an opportunity to rinse patients.

It’s quite another thing to charge for something that is required as treatment for a child’s medical condition, as is the case here. Treating a child’s medical condition is absolutely within the scope of a GP’s work. Prescribing a required set of conditions on school is no different to prescribing medication. It’s shocking that a GP would seek to profit from a child’s medical condition like this. Not least because many GPs will be earning salaries way higher than the patients they are gouging.

Prescribing a required set of conditions on school is no different to prescribing medication.

It’s entirely different.

Not least because many GPs will be earning salaries way higher than the patients they are gouging.

The GP’s salary is irrelevant.

Swipe left for the next trending thread