Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is disgusting - GP charging for form

487 replies

FrostedFancy · 21/12/2023 13:39

GP surgery insist I must pay £40 for completion of a form from school to request online learning for my DD (14) who is suffering from MH issues due to being diagnosed with a serious health condition.

AIBU to think this is absolutely disgusting to profit from a child with medical condition and mental health issues needing access to an education?

Form literally would take 5 minutes to complete.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ATerrorofLeftovers · 28/12/2023 16:50

gggonewired · 28/12/2023 16:14

Tell whoever's asking for the paperwork what the GP WILL provide and lodge a complaint with the MP/ombudsman/standards/whatever that unnecessary paperwork is being demanded

Are you a GP?

ATerrorofLeftovers · 28/12/2023 16:49

rainingsnoring · 28/12/2023 15:19

Still not understanding your point as it doesn't seem relevant. This discussion is nothing to do with overtime.
The school already have access to paperwork from specialists and can discuss needs with the young person and her parent(s)/ guardian(s). There is no need for GPs to be involved in the great majority of these decisions when the school already has information available to them. It appears to be back covering rather than a need.

Have you not read the full thread? It wasn’t me who spoke about this as being equivalent to overtime, it was the posters justifying the charge. I was merely addressing that point that others had made.

gggonewired · 28/12/2023 16:14

ATerrorofLeftovers · 28/12/2023 13:19

What I’d be interested in is hearing from the GPs who’ve commented on the thread in defence of the charges, what they do if a patient is on a low income/in financial hardship, and would struggle to afford the charge. Do you waive it or offer a reduced fee?

Tell whoever's asking for the paperwork what the GP WILL provide and lodge a complaint with the MP/ombudsman/standards/whatever that unnecessary paperwork is being demanded

cathcath2 · 28/12/2023 15:37

Yeah, unfortunately, this has always been chargeable for children and adults alike

rainingsnoring · 28/12/2023 15:19

ATerrorofLeftovers · 28/12/2023 14:39

You must have missed my response to LadyWithLapdog. I was rather hoping posters would be able to take the spirit of the comment, rather than be totally literal, but obviously I wasn’t clear enough. Not all professionals with career type jobs not entitled to overtime will just do their set hours. In fact hardly any do. But you know that, don’t you.

Still not understanding your point as it doesn't seem relevant. This discussion is nothing to do with overtime.
The school already have access to paperwork from specialists and can discuss needs with the young person and her parent(s)/ guardian(s). There is no need for GPs to be involved in the great majority of these decisions when the school already has information available to them. It appears to be back covering rather than a need.

MrsAvocet · 28/12/2023 14:44

ATerrorofLeftovers · 28/12/2023 13:17

The firm may well do, depending on the nature of the services offered and who’s doing them, but the individual quite often won’t see that. Other comparable jobs aren’t necessarily billing clients for time. My point was that people working comparable ‘career’ type jobs generally do not clock in and out and work only their hours or get overtime paid. But you know that, I think.

But it's not "overtime" is it? That would be staying in the surgery until all the booked patients had been seen or staying late to finish your admin. I think GPs do that kind of think pretty routinely. But this is effectively a different job, being done for a different employer.
I think GPs relationship with the NHS is kind of analagous to solicitors working for a client but being paid by an insurance company. I've just been in that situation as the claimant in a personal injury case following a car crash. I made my contributions, in the shape of my insurance premiums, so my legal "treatment" was free at the point of delivery and I never saw the bill, not unlike being an NHS patient. However, I imagine there was a detailed contract between the insurers and the law firm laying out what was expected of them, what the insurers would pay for and what they wouldn't etc. Suppose I had asked my solicitor to write a letter for something that was peripherally connected to my accident but not included in the contract with my insurers - would anyone realistically expect him to have done that for nothing? I doubt it. I would have expected one of 2 things to happen. Either he would have said sorry, that's not included in our contract with your insurers but our company's rate for that type of work is £X and you can pay us directly, or I'd have got a flat no. Why would it be any different for a GP being asked to provide something non NHS funded for an NHS patient?
Whether that is the right way for GP practices to contact with the NHS is a separate issue and is indeed worthy of debate. But it is the way things are and it's a long standing model. It's not unreasonable for GPs to expect to be paid directly for work that is outside their contract any more than it would be for anyone else.

ATerrorofLeftovers · 28/12/2023 14:43

rainingsnoring · 28/12/2023 14:22

As has already been discussed by multiple posters, this is not a medical need. A medical need would need covered by the NHS. This is the school requesting further, unnecessary paperwork.

Depends on your viewpoint. To me, if a person’s medical condition leads to a need for adjustments, that’s a medical need. Because it’s a medical need that requires treatment and the person wouldn’t need it if it weren’t for the medical condition they suffer. This is undoubtedly a lay-person’s view, though, not one coloured by the bureaucratic processes and strictures of the NHS.

ATerrorofLeftovers · 28/12/2023 14:39

rainingsnoring · 28/12/2023 14:21

GPs don't clock on and off and nor do other doctors. Solicitors, etc most certainly do charge for every service, down to 5 minute tasks so not sure these comparisons are helpful.

You must have missed my response to LadyWithLapdog. I was rather hoping posters would be able to take the spirit of the comment, rather than be totally literal, but obviously I wasn’t clear enough. Not all professionals with career type jobs not entitled to overtime will just do their set hours. In fact hardly any do. But you know that, don’t you.

ATerrorofLeftovers · 28/12/2023 14:36

LadyWithLapdog · 28/12/2023 13:52

“Eagerness to charge” is a bit of a distortion, isn’t it? What makes you think it’s eagerness rather than need or necessity or covering the extra insurance they need to pay for private work?

It may not be in all cases, but I gather from friends and colleagues who are GPs that neither they nor their practices are on the breadline, so it seems to be a choice rather than a necessity. For some patients, though, charging will cause financial hardship or be simply unaffordable.

rainingsnoring · 28/12/2023 14:22

ATerrorofLeftovers · 28/12/2023 13:39

With respect, you haven’t read my post properly. I didn’t say I think GPs clock in and out, which is why I find the eagerness to charge for these a bit surprising. However, I have learned from the thread that GPs generally do, as they are not specifically contracted by the NHS to provide this, so are entitled to. I don’t think this is a satisfactory state of affairs for patients, but accept it is what it is.

I would hope there are safeguards for patients who can’t afford a charge of £40 for their child’s medical needs to be met. So I’m interested to hear what provision GPs make for those in financial hardship, even if they feel justified in charging others the full fee.

As has already been discussed by multiple posters, this is not a medical need. A medical need would need covered by the NHS. This is the school requesting further, unnecessary paperwork.

rainingsnoring · 28/12/2023 14:21

ATerrorofLeftovers · 28/12/2023 13:17

The firm may well do, depending on the nature of the services offered and who’s doing them, but the individual quite often won’t see that. Other comparable jobs aren’t necessarily billing clients for time. My point was that people working comparable ‘career’ type jobs generally do not clock in and out and work only their hours or get overtime paid. But you know that, I think.

GPs don't clock on and off and nor do other doctors. Solicitors, etc most certainly do charge for every service, down to 5 minute tasks so not sure these comparisons are helpful.

LadyWithLapdog · 28/12/2023 13:52

“Eagerness to charge” is a bit of a distortion, isn’t it? What makes you think it’s eagerness rather than need or necessity or covering the extra insurance they need to pay for private work?

ATerrorofLeftovers · 28/12/2023 13:39

LadyWithLapdog · 28/12/2023 13:20

@ATerrorofLeftovers it’s not NHS work. I think it’s disappointing you’d think GPs “clock in and out”, how did you get that idea?

With respect, you haven’t read my post properly. I didn’t say I think GPs clock in and out, which is why I find the eagerness to charge for these a bit surprising. However, I have learned from the thread that GPs generally do, as they are not specifically contracted by the NHS to provide this, so are entitled to. I don’t think this is a satisfactory state of affairs for patients, but accept it is what it is.

I would hope there are safeguards for patients who can’t afford a charge of £40 for their child’s medical needs to be met. So I’m interested to hear what provision GPs make for those in financial hardship, even if they feel justified in charging others the full fee.

LadyWithLapdog · 28/12/2023 13:27

@soemptyinside it’s getting more expensive because people live longer and with more chronic conditions. Two of my DCs have medical conditions which are treated free on the NHS, but they can’t contemplate moving to the US (DD’s dream) because of the costs.

BarkHorse · 28/12/2023 13:26

GPs don’t clock in and out on time either though do they. You literally don’t seem
to have a point. And you gave an exact example of a business where literally every minute to “clients” is charged for.

And to answer your next question (though I’m not a GP) I imagine that it’s the same as for any other private service. The charge is the charge no matter the financial circumstances- however external help to cover these costs may be available via appropriate channels (to use your law example like legal aid paying for solicitors fees).

It’s depressing that there is a thread running with a pregnant lady who’s waited what ten hours in hospital at the same time as people thinking that a GP’s appointment time should be used for filling in forms.

soemptyinside · 28/12/2023 13:21

LadyWithLapdog · 28/12/2023 13:15

Who is suggesting you pay for appointments? Literally one person upthread.

OTC meds are not hugely expensive and you’ll find it’s the NHS pushing GPs to get patients to pay for them.

You're the one who jumped in and replied to my reply to that person.

Not hugely expensive? If I look at just one of my drugs that used to be prescribed, the annual cost is £215. That's on top of the £112 prepaid prescription for my other meds (assuming I pay annually, that is - not everyone can afford to pay upfront).

And yes, I agree the pressure is from the NHS on the GPs to prescribe less.

There is this misconception that the NHS is free to use, but if you have a chronic condition... it's really not. It's cheaper than in some other countries, sure, but it isn't free, and it's getting more expensive.

LadyWithLapdog · 28/12/2023 13:20

@ATerrorofLeftovers it’s not NHS work. I think it’s disappointing you’d think GPs “clock in and out”, how did you get that idea?

ATerrorofLeftovers · 28/12/2023 13:19

What I’d be interested in is hearing from the GPs who’ve commented on the thread in defence of the charges, what they do if a patient is on a low income/in financial hardship, and would struggle to afford the charge. Do you waive it or offer a reduced fee?

ATerrorofLeftovers · 28/12/2023 13:17

BarkHorse · 28/12/2023 13:04

Lol those are two cases where their time is definitely not “free”. They literally charge billable hours.

The firm may well do, depending on the nature of the services offered and who’s doing them, but the individual quite often won’t see that. Other comparable jobs aren’t necessarily billing clients for time. My point was that people working comparable ‘career’ type jobs generally do not clock in and out and work only their hours or get overtime paid. But you know that, I think.

LadyWithLapdog · 28/12/2023 13:15

Who is suggesting you pay for appointments? Literally one person upthread.

OTC meds are not hugely expensive and you’ll find it’s the NHS pushing GPs to get patients to pay for them.

soemptyinside · 28/12/2023 13:11

LadyWithLapdog · 28/12/2023 12:30

The prepayment certificate is £30 for 3 months and all meds are then included in that.

All meds are not included in that. More and more drugs are being made OTC and when they are available OTC, GPs start refusing to prescribe them.

A GP will tell me I need certain medication but won't prescribe it all.

We're paying and more and more for our meds, and now the suggestion is we should also pay for the appointments for our standard prescription reviews, and for whenever we have a flare up of our conditions that we cannot manage with the usual drugs?

It's getting more and more expensive to have a chronic condition in the UK. And all during a cost of living crisis too...

BarkHorse · 28/12/2023 13:04

ATerrorofLeftovers · 21/12/2023 18:52

Generally professionals do work ‘overtime’ for ‘free’. Certainly solicitors, accountants etc. Those working in careers of similar standing to that of a GP. Those sort of jobs don’t involve clocking in and out for your contracted hours only. The pay and conditions reflect this.

Really, the people I feel for most with this is those who are struggling financially. I’d love to know what provision is made for people in this position. Nobody has explained that yet.

Lol those are two cases where their time is definitely not “free”. They literally charge billable hours.

LadyWithLapdog · 28/12/2023 12:30

soemptyinside · 28/12/2023 02:06

Those of us with chronic conditions already have to pay for our drugs to stay alive. You think we should pay for appointments now too?

Just call your pitch what it is - a tax on the disabled.

The prepayment certificate is £30 for 3 months and all meds are then included in that.

FixTheBone · 28/12/2023 09:56

Deliria · 28/12/2023 09:02

This is about the intersection of the health needs of SEND children with their educational needs and their is a legal duty on the NHS as well as LAs to work together to produce integrated support plans meeting health and educational needs of SEND children. The ignorance of this is alarming.

As a doctor, a parent of a child with SEN, a wife who is a GP, a parent governor, and the SEN lead - ignorance is the last thing that I have.

For the final time. GPs ARE NOT "THE NHS" They ae contracted to provide NHS services. To massively oversimplify it to 'it's an integrated partnership between "the NHS" and LEA shows massive ignorance as to what the roles of different NHS organisations actually is.

The school / LEA may as well ask the local pharmacist or dentist to sign the form, it's essentially the exact same ask....

Scirocco · 28/12/2023 09:34

@Deliria the statutory requirement to work in partnership

a) does not mean blind one-sided compliance - it means working together, not just signing a form because someone wants it signed

b) doesn't change that, if something's not in the contract, the NHS isn't paying the GP for it and someone needs to