Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Anti-gay marriage

239 replies

NotGotAClue1 · 21/12/2023 13:21

My finance and the father of my young child told me that he doesn’t agree with gay marriage, not being gay in general, just the marriage part. And that it would be better for a child to be raised by a man and a woman. I’m completely offended by this and don’t agree in the slightest. I think he is thinking like a dinosaur and needs to move with the times. He thinks we can have different views and move on. But this has actually changed the way I look at him. He isn’t religious at all which is making me even more confused at his strong views.

AIBU?

OP posts:
KylieJennersMakeUpSponge · 21/12/2023 16:10

If he doesn’t agree with gay marriage tell him not to enter in one then. But to prevent others from doing the same is incredibly cruel. And weird

gannett · 21/12/2023 16:08

RocketIceLollie · 21/12/2023 13:38

Everyone is entitled to have their own opinions on any given topic. Your opinion on any given topic is no more right or wrong than his. As long as neither of you proactively express your opinions to the extreme expecting everyone to dance with you in an echo chamber. If so then your differing values are probably going to clash when raising your children or out in public.

Edited

What a stupid post.

Of course he's "entitled" to hold bigoted views. No one is going to prosecute him for them. But it's not what the OP was asking and legality of opinion isn't the subject here. Her post was about how she now thinks worse of him. She's completely correct about that - if their child is gay, his opinions will be actively harmful to them.

And your post goes a long way to minimising that harm given that your point seems to be that actually, anti-gay views are just as legitimate as thinking gay people should be equal. Bollocks to that. My opinion on this subject is absolutely more right than yours or the OP's dick of a husband.

graceinspace999 · 21/12/2023 16:08

CurlewKate · 21/12/2023 15:08

So. No such thing as a wrong opinion. Having sex with 12 year olds is a joyful exploration of their sexuality?

This bears no comparison to gay marriage.

The abuse of children is a serious crime that destroys lives.

Abuse is an action - not an opinion.

Desecratedcoconut · 21/12/2023 15:59

I don't think that's odd. I can think of things that I'm against which I don't think I have grounds to remove the choice of others to pursue.

Swim-suit competitions, private schooling, Brexit, online gambling.

graceinspace999 · 21/12/2023 15:58

CurlewKate · 21/12/2023 14:21

@Dotjones "He is entitled to his opinion."

Is he? Are there opinions he is not entitled to?

People have opinions whether we like it or not!

An opinion is not a fact.

We cannot force opinions to change but we can force people to hide their opinions and possibly cause harm in secret.

Would it be ok for the OPs fiancé to hold that opinion if he were Muslim or Catholic or a member of a protected religious group who ban gay marriage or worse ?

2mummies1baby · 21/12/2023 15:45

Verv · 21/12/2023 15:22

Dear god this is tiresome.

Again.

I am against gay marriage. It is my personal opinion. It is an opinion held by a number of gay people.

Me being against something, does not even vaguely mean that I wish to remove choice or "rights" from others
That is both unhinged and a straw man argument.

My preference is and would be for civil partnership because it gives legal protections, without grovelling at the bloody church or apeing heteronormativity.

At the risk of repeating myself, I am also against veganism, but accept that some people want to do it and thats fine.
I dont have to agree with something, in order to accept that others do.

Has that sunk in yet?

Me being against something, does not even vaguely mean that I wish to remove choice or "rights" from others

This is the root of my confusion- to me, this is exactly what being against something means.

People who are against abortion don't believe anyone should have the right to access it; there are plenty of people who wouldn't have an abortion themselves, but who believe everyone has the right to access it, and therefore they are not against abortion.

It sounds as if this is the way you feel about gay people getting married- you, personally, don't want to get married as a gay person, but you believe other people should have the right to. If this is the case, saying you are 'against' gay marriage is misleading, as most people would take that to mean you don't believe gay people should have the right to get married.

I am against bestiality- that means I do not believe anyone should have the right to do it. I am not against eating animals or their byproducts- I don't do it myself (I am one of those vegans you disagree with), but I believe people should have the right to do it if they want to.

Eskarina1 · 21/12/2023 15:43

@ChihuahuaMummy exactly.

I want to share values with the people I am friends or in a relationship with. I can't respect someone who thinks people should be restricted just because they are gay.

And to call it a "fashionable opinion " that might change back ignores 1) the UK used to put people to death for being gay and other countries still do and 2) this is part of a range of opinions that became "fashionable " in the last 100 years including "men can't rape their wives", "black people can sit down on buses even if white people are also on the bus", "you can't fire a woman for being pregnant " and "teachers can't hit children with sharp sticks." It's not fashionable, it's knowing better and doing better.

anotherside · 21/12/2023 15:42

CurlewKate · 21/12/2023 15:31

There are people that b this thread saying that the OP would be wrong to do anything but respect his opinion. That it shouldn't matter. Why should she "respect" such an opinion?

Because when we say respect an opinion, we really mean retain respect for the person holding the opinion despite vehemently disagreeing with them on specific issues. I strongly disagree with virtually all Tory policy but I can still be friends with Tory voters. I think organised religion is idiocy but don’t consider believers idiots just for this one aspect of their identity.

And people can consider male/female parents generally preferable for reasons that essentially have nothing to do with gay people - eg, a personal belief that it’s preferable that children are created naturally (or adopted). You might not agree with it but it’s hardly an extremist or despicable view, and certainly no more wacky than, for example, following the tenants of Christian or Islamic faiths which is considered totally fine.

divinededacende · 21/12/2023 15:41

Verv · 21/12/2023 15:26

As ive said repeatedly.
I am against it.
This does not mean that I want to remove the right or choice to do it from other people.

I get what you're saying. I suppose when I read "against", it translates to "actively opposed" in my head which makes it seem like you would would rather the option doesn't exist rather than "It's not for me, I think it's a flawed concept".

ClaudiaWankleman · 21/12/2023 15:36

Verv · 21/12/2023 14:50

Oh here we fucking go.

I'm one. I am one of the gay people who doesn't simp for gay marriage.

While I believe that gay people should absolutely have the same rights as the rest of society, I don't believe that we need to ape heterosexual marriage "under the eyes of the lord" or whatever when the church and the majority of its supporters have been pushed and legislated into accepting us on the surface while still thinking that we're sinning shitbags behind our backs.

Id rather avoid the hypocrisy and stick with civil partnership.

Are you actually? I can't believe a gay person would describe the legal recognition of same-sex relationships as 'aping' marriage. To ape something is to imitate something in an absurd, unthinking or mocking way - absolutely not what someone with emotional experience of a same-sex relationship would think.

Are you sure you are you who say you are?

Kwasi · 21/12/2023 15:32

I didn't find out my husband was homophobic until after we were married. He'd never mentioned it once but now he is very vocal about it.

CurlewKate · 21/12/2023 15:31

There are people that b this thread saying that the OP would be wrong to do anything but respect his opinion. That it shouldn't matter. Why should she "respect" such an opinion?

ChihuahuaMummy · 21/12/2023 15:30

Everyone is entitled to hold their own thoughts and feelings on matters but what they aren't entitled to do is hurt other people based upon those views.

It's not our place to police what people think or the values they hold, that is their right. However it is also our right whether we want to associate with people who hold such different views to ourselves. We can only control and alter our own behaviour.

therealcookiemonster · 21/12/2023 15:28

it sounds like you two may have very different mindsets. I would explore his worldview in general and if you feel the gap is too much, it is better to quit early if you feel strongly about your views....

obv there is a baby in the mix now, which makes it more difficult

personally I have some red lines and I would never consider anyone if they fall foul of them

Verv · 21/12/2023 15:26

divinededacende · 21/12/2023 15:22

You don't have to "simp" for it but you don't believe we should have access to it? It's not about marriage itself for me, it's about people having equal choice.

Totally on board with you on the religious aspect but marriages aren't a wholly religious thing in modern society. They are massively connected historically but that's changing and there are different ways to have a marriage ceremony that don't involve God or the church. Lots of aspects of our society were interconnected with the church which is being gradually dismantled.

As ive said repeatedly.
I am against it.
This does not mean that I want to remove the right or choice to do it from other people.

divinededacende · 21/12/2023 15:26

CurlewKate · 21/12/2023 14:40

I will sh someone would say whether there are opinions people are not entitled to hold?

There are absolutely NO opinions that someone is not entitled to have.

There are plenty of opinions people are not allowed to act on and that's the difference. We can't police thought, only action. Thoughts might then impact how we punish the action but the action needs to happen first.

It doesn't stop us judging people for their opinions and choosing how we interact with them based on their views and that's because we're all entitled to our own opinions, too.

divinededacende · 21/12/2023 15:22

Verv · 21/12/2023 14:50

Oh here we fucking go.

I'm one. I am one of the gay people who doesn't simp for gay marriage.

While I believe that gay people should absolutely have the same rights as the rest of society, I don't believe that we need to ape heterosexual marriage "under the eyes of the lord" or whatever when the church and the majority of its supporters have been pushed and legislated into accepting us on the surface while still thinking that we're sinning shitbags behind our backs.

Id rather avoid the hypocrisy and stick with civil partnership.

You don't have to "simp" for it but you don't believe we should have access to it? It's not about marriage itself for me, it's about people having equal choice.

Totally on board with you on the religious aspect but marriages aren't a wholly religious thing in modern society. They are massively connected historically but that's changing and there are different ways to have a marriage ceremony that don't involve God or the church. Lots of aspects of our society were interconnected with the church which is being gradually dismantled.

Verv · 21/12/2023 15:22

2mummies1baby · 21/12/2023 15:10

So you acknowledge that, despite saying in your previous comment that you "believe that gay people should absolutely have the same rights as the rest of society", you don't believe gay people should have the right to marry, with all the legal protections that it brings? That's incredibly sad. I'm truly sorry you feel that way.

Dear god this is tiresome.

Again.

I am against gay marriage. It is my personal opinion. It is an opinion held by a number of gay people.

Me being against something, does not even vaguely mean that I wish to remove choice or "rights" from others
That is both unhinged and a straw man argument.

My preference is and would be for civil partnership because it gives legal protections, without grovelling at the bloody church or apeing heteronormativity.

At the risk of repeating myself, I am also against veganism, but accept that some people want to do it and thats fine.
I dont have to agree with something, in order to accept that others do.

Has that sunk in yet?

itsmylife7 · 21/12/2023 15:19

TriOptimim · 21/12/2023 15:12

If he has an issue with gay people getting married and having children then he has an issue with gay people.

I'd disagree, he just has an issue with "buying babies "
As for the marriage thing, that's his choice.

SevenOnTheLabel · 21/12/2023 15:19

Did you not get to know him well before getting engaged and having a child?

If he’s not religious, I see no reason at all for him to care about gay people getting married other than homophobia.

As for raising children, I don’t agree with donor sperm and eggs or surrogacy for anyone, straight or gay, but that's due to the ethics. One of my closest female friends is married to a woman and they have adopted 2 children. They’re fantastic parents because they are lovely people with all the qualities needed to be good parents. No penis required. 😉

I think your partners views can only be based in homophobia, do you really want to be with someone like that?

ManateeFair · 21/12/2023 15:17

graceinspace999 · 21/12/2023 13:27

I’m sure your opinion is the most acceptable right now.

As long as he tolerates your opinion then why not tolerate his?

I always find this a really odd argument. People are not separate from their opinions. They have chosen to hold those opinions, and their opinions are reflective of their values and the very person they are. If you find someone's opinions abhorrent, then it's perfectly correct to find the person equally abhorrent. I wouldn't have a relationship with, eg, a racist or someone who thought we should bring back fox-hunting or an anti-vaxxer. They'd be entitled to hold those views, but I'd be equally entitled to think they were a complete cunt as a result.

Yeah, you should 'tolerate' someone's opinion in the sense that you should accept they're entitled to hold it. But that doesn't mean you have to pretend it doesn't bother you, or act like it's not indicative of the person's character. It absolutely is indicative of someone's character.

If my DP announced that he didn't think same-sex marriage should be allowed, he would expressing a view that people in same-sex relationships shouldn't have equal rights to those of people in straight relationships. I would absolutely think differently about him if that was the case, just as I'd think differently about him if he announced that he believed black people shouldn't be allowed to vote or that disabled people should be sterilised.

Christingle123 · 21/12/2023 15:16

He's entitled to his opinion. Who says yours is the right one? You don't have to agree.

His argument about children better off with Mum AND Dad, he's probably right, children do miss out being brought up by just Mum/just Dad/2 Mums/2 Dads. It stands to reason that different sexes have different roles in parenting.

You could also argue, however that families with Mum and Dad aren't always perfect and could have their own problems such as abuse, etc.

It's a very tricky topic, multi faceted but I do think YABU to be so surprised and appalled.

NotGotAClue1 · 21/12/2023 15:15

MintJulia · 21/12/2023 15:07

What happens if your child is lgbt? Is your child not allowed a normal family life?

Your man's a dinosaur, as you have correctly identified. A bigot. What you do about it is your call.

I asked him this very thing because that would be a complete dealbreaker as I will always protect my son. He said that of course he wouldn’t care if our son was gay because he loves him and would want him to be happy no matter what. He said he would go to his wedding and be happy for him.

OP posts:
Catza · 21/12/2023 15:13

I once had a very similar experience with my best friend. She loudly proclaimed that is immoral for gay people to adopt, how the child would be indoctrinated and that gay people should not be parading on the streets of Berlin, blah blah blah. I reminded her that only a few days prior to that she attended a dinner party at my house and met a wonderful gay couple, enjoyed their company very much and they are planning to adopt. She was horrified and said that she never realised they were gay and though they were just friends. Well, I looked at her very differently from then on.
But a few years later she made a point of apologising to me for her outburst. Said she had since realised that her views were not acceptable and she is genuinely sorry for ever thinking and saying such nonsense. I have a huge respect for my friend and she gave me hope that people can truly change if you give them a chance and a benefit of a doubt.

TriOptimim · 21/12/2023 15:12

itsmylife7 · 21/12/2023 15:06

So he doesn't have an issue with GAY people just them getting married ?

I don't see the issue here. Now if he had an issue with gay people , completely different.

If he has an issue with gay people getting married and having children then he has an issue with gay people.

Swipe left for the next trending thread