Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Anti-gay marriage

239 replies

NotGotAClue1 · 21/12/2023 13:21

My finance and the father of my young child told me that he doesn’t agree with gay marriage, not being gay in general, just the marriage part. And that it would be better for a child to be raised by a man and a woman. I’m completely offended by this and don’t agree in the slightest. I think he is thinking like a dinosaur and needs to move with the times. He thinks we can have different views and move on. But this has actually changed the way I look at him. He isn’t religious at all which is making me even more confused at his strong views.

AIBU?

OP posts:
ChihuahuaMummy · 21/12/2023 18:03

@2mummies1baby I don't want to derail the thread to a religious one but all those things you mention come under the Mosaic law which Christ abolished with his death. The seafood laws etc no longer apply. Whereas homosexuality was still considered a sin even after Christ.

But on the other point you raise, I completely agree with you, people don't have the right to impose restrictions on other people. Everyone makes their own choices in life and lives how they want to and that is completely their right.

sprigatito · 21/12/2023 18:02

I'm sorry OP, my comment was snidey and flippant because I was annoyed by some of the other replies you've received. I do appreciate the difficult position you're in, and have huge sympathy for you. It must be awful to be finding out now that you have different values. If I were in your shoes and really didn't want to break up the family, I guess there would have to be lots of talking and trying to unpick where his views have come from, and whether he's open to having them challenged.

RadRad · 21/12/2023 18:00

The thing is OP everyone's entitled to their opinion, the important bit is that you don't allow him to "instruct" your child to think the same way but rather teach them that we are all different and that's a good thing; remind him that your little one will be having class mates with two mums/dads as it is actually very common nowadays.

ChihuahuaMummy · 21/12/2023 18:00

Zebedee55 · 21/12/2023 17:57

He’s entitled to his opinion. No right or wrong.

I agree with this and I assume it was an opinion expressed in his own home.

2mummies1baby · 21/12/2023 18:00

ChihuahuaMummy · 21/12/2023 17:53

@2mummies1baby Religion is a protected group too though and a lot of religions don't take part in same sex relationships and/or marriages due to what it says in the Bible. And that is their right to hold those views.

People have a right to practise their religion. They do not have a right to use their religion as an excuse to impose restrictions on other people.

The very same section of the bible which condemns male homosexuality (female homosexuality is never mentioned, fyi) also condemns tattoos, eating seafood and wearing clothes made from more than one type of fabric. Would religious people be excused for saying they didn't believe people should get married if they have ever eaten a prawn?

Zebedee55 · 21/12/2023 17:57

He’s entitled to his opinion. No right or wrong.

gannett · 21/12/2023 17:57

graceinspace999 · 21/12/2023 17:46

Maybe to you it’s an ‘odd argument’ but I think we’re coming close to losing our ability to tolerate.

Different things bother different people. There are many marriages where there is dishonesty.

People can have many different qualities some good some bad.

Seeking a marital echo chamber is a great way to breed lies.

These examples of opinions such as black people not being allowed to vote and disabled people should be sterilised are subject to legislation and not comparable to the subject matter.

Wrong way round; or at least, you're disingenuously hung up on the idea of "tolerance".

Bigoted views and outdated legislation that stems from them, both of which have done immeasurable harm to marginalised groups of people, are increasingly not tolerated. And nor should they be. Tolerance is not actually the end point of a decent, civilised society; that's equality and freedom from oppression.

2mummies1baby · 21/12/2023 17:55

graceinspace999 · 21/12/2023 17:46

Maybe to you it’s an ‘odd argument’ but I think we’re coming close to losing our ability to tolerate.

Different things bother different people. There are many marriages where there is dishonesty.

People can have many different qualities some good some bad.

Seeking a marital echo chamber is a great way to breed lies.

These examples of opinions such as black people not being allowed to vote and disabled people should be sterilised are subject to legislation and not comparable to the subject matter.

These examples of opinions such as black people not being allowed to vote and disabled people should be sterilised are subject to legislation and not comparable to the subject matter.

Can you explain why these are not comparable to the subject matter? They are all opinions about the rights other people should have access to, based on a perceived difference.

ChihuahuaMummy · 21/12/2023 17:53

@2mummies1baby Religion is a protected group too though and a lot of religions don't take part in same sex relationships and/or marriages due to what it says in the Bible. And that is their right to hold those views.

pointythings · 21/12/2023 17:50

These examples of opinions such as black people not being allowed to vote and disabled people should be sterilised are subject to legislation and not comparable to the subject matter.

Marriage equality is also something that is subject to legislation and is therefore absolutely comparable. Stripped down to the basics, opposing marriage equality means saying that not everyone should have the same rights and privileges to solemnise their relationship purely because of their sexual orientation. Since sexual orientation isn't a choice, this is no different from saying that black people or disabled people should have fewer rights. Holding such an opinion speaks to someone's (lack of) morals and good character.

graceinspace999 · 21/12/2023 17:46

ManateeFair · 21/12/2023 15:17

I always find this a really odd argument. People are not separate from their opinions. They have chosen to hold those opinions, and their opinions are reflective of their values and the very person they are. If you find someone's opinions abhorrent, then it's perfectly correct to find the person equally abhorrent. I wouldn't have a relationship with, eg, a racist or someone who thought we should bring back fox-hunting or an anti-vaxxer. They'd be entitled to hold those views, but I'd be equally entitled to think they were a complete cunt as a result.

Yeah, you should 'tolerate' someone's opinion in the sense that you should accept they're entitled to hold it. But that doesn't mean you have to pretend it doesn't bother you, or act like it's not indicative of the person's character. It absolutely is indicative of someone's character.

If my DP announced that he didn't think same-sex marriage should be allowed, he would expressing a view that people in same-sex relationships shouldn't have equal rights to those of people in straight relationships. I would absolutely think differently about him if that was the case, just as I'd think differently about him if he announced that he believed black people shouldn't be allowed to vote or that disabled people should be sterilised.

Maybe to you it’s an ‘odd argument’ but I think we’re coming close to losing our ability to tolerate.

Different things bother different people. There are many marriages where there is dishonesty.

People can have many different qualities some good some bad.

Seeking a marital echo chamber is a great way to breed lies.

These examples of opinions such as black people not being allowed to vote and disabled people should be sterilised are subject to legislation and not comparable to the subject matter.

NotGotAClue1 · 21/12/2023 17:03

sprigatito · 21/12/2023 17:01

Well, it depends. Do you want to marry a bigot?

No I don’t but I don’t want to break up my family either.

OP posts:
MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 21/12/2023 17:03

Personally, I think it's better for children to be raised by parents who are not bigots.

sprigatito · 21/12/2023 17:01

Well, it depends. Do you want to marry a bigot?

justteanbiscuits · 21/12/2023 17:00

There is also a difference between "I am gay and marriage isn't for me" - the same as heterosexual couples who believe marriage isn't for them - and "I don't think there should be gay marriage". The second means removing the right for everyone, not just yourself.

ChihuahuaMummy · 21/12/2023 17:00

abominablesnowman · 21/12/2023 16:45

"Everyone is entitled to their opinion" works both ways, and when someone holds an opinion that you consider offensive and unacceptable, I think it's reasonable to openly take issue with it. When someone close to me holds homophobic opinions, I'm not just going to let that lie. If it was some stranger I just wouldn't talk to them, but someone close, it would make me lose a lot of respect for them.

When you say you wouldn't let that lie, do you mean you would challenge the person you know about their beliefs and views?

justteanbiscuits · 21/12/2023 16:58

It would be a deal breaker for me, honestly. If my husband and I disagreed on something as fundamental as this, I wouldn't have been able to marry him. having similar politics is something I feel very strongly about.

I am sure I have acquaintances that believe gay people shouldn't marry, but I would never be able to close friends with someone who believed that either. That gay people don't have the right to same marriage rights as me and my husband.

Verv · 21/12/2023 16:58

2mummies1baby · 21/12/2023 15:45

Me being against something, does not even vaguely mean that I wish to remove choice or "rights" from others

This is the root of my confusion- to me, this is exactly what being against something means.

People who are against abortion don't believe anyone should have the right to access it; there are plenty of people who wouldn't have an abortion themselves, but who believe everyone has the right to access it, and therefore they are not against abortion.

It sounds as if this is the way you feel about gay people getting married- you, personally, don't want to get married as a gay person, but you believe other people should have the right to. If this is the case, saying you are 'against' gay marriage is misleading, as most people would take that to mean you don't believe gay people should have the right to get married.

I am against bestiality- that means I do not believe anyone should have the right to do it. I am not against eating animals or their byproducts- I don't do it myself (I am one of those vegans you disagree with), but I believe people should have the right to do it if they want to.

I've been as clear as I can be.
Plenty of threads on here where people are against something but recognise the rights of others to do as they wish.
Other less controversial forms include dogs on sofas and vaping.
You don't have to be for everything that others do in order to recognise their right to do it.

Verv · 21/12/2023 16:53

ClaudiaWankleman · 21/12/2023 15:36

Are you actually? I can't believe a gay person would describe the legal recognition of same-sex relationships as 'aping' marriage. To ape something is to imitate something in an absurd, unthinking or mocking way - absolutely not what someone with emotional experience of a same-sex relationship would think.

Are you sure you are you who say you are?

https://theconversation.com/gay-rebels-why-some-older-homosexual-men-dont-support-same-sex-marriage-86205

If you dont like what I think, I could always switch "aping" to emulating which is (rather coincidentally) what some older gay men have called it.
Or you could take a look at some of the stuff coming up if you search google for "gays against gay marriage". Plenty of people there rejecting the heteronormativity element.
You might be horrified to discover that a group of lesbians have named it "Being Boring for a Blender"

And, if you want to question whether I am who I say I am, go ask MN to dig through my old posts and find out how many times I've said on here that I'm a gay woman, or referenced my female partner.

In fact, you're more than welcome to fire me a DM for my Facebook ID and you can go rake it yourself if you're that concerned.

Gay rebels: why some older homosexual men don't support same-sex marriage

When it comes to same-sex marriage, there’s a big gap in support between old and young gay men. Older gay men often see marriage as conservative, and fear marriage will create a “gold standard” for gay relationships.

https://theconversation.com/gay-rebels-why-some-older-homosexual-men-dont-support-same-sex-marriage-86205

abominablesnowman · 21/12/2023 16:45

"Everyone is entitled to their opinion" works both ways, and when someone holds an opinion that you consider offensive and unacceptable, I think it's reasonable to openly take issue with it. When someone close to me holds homophobic opinions, I'm not just going to let that lie. If it was some stranger I just wouldn't talk to them, but someone close, it would make me lose a lot of respect for them.

2mummies1baby · 21/12/2023 16:29

graceinspace999 · 21/12/2023 15:58

People have opinions whether we like it or not!

An opinion is not a fact.

We cannot force opinions to change but we can force people to hide their opinions and possibly cause harm in secret.

Would it be ok for the OPs fiancé to hold that opinion if he were Muslim or Catholic or a member of a protected religious group who ban gay marriage or worse ?

Would it be ok for the OPs fiancé to hold that opinion if he were Muslim or Catholic or a member of a protected religious group who ban gay marriage or worse ?

No, I don't think religion should ever be used as an excuse for bigotry.

gannett · 21/12/2023 16:16

NotGotAClue1 · 21/12/2023 15:15

I asked him this very thing because that would be a complete dealbreaker as I will always protect my son. He said that of course he wouldn’t care if our son was gay because he loves him and would want him to be happy no matter what. He said he would go to his wedding and be happy for him.

So next you should ask him, if all that is true, why he doesn't believe in gay marriage. If he knows he should support his son, if his son is gay and wants to get married, why would he not extend that to other gay people?

And you should also ask him what other views he holds about gay people. Does he think they're real men? If he sees a gay couple on TV is he going to react with disgust, or crack a terrible joke, or witter on about the gay agenda?

Is he going to say his anti-gay marriage opinions out loud, in your son's hearing, at any point going forward?

If your son is gay the answers to all of these questions will strongly determine his happiness growing up and his relationship with you both when he's an adult.

TriOptimim · 21/12/2023 16:14

itsmylife7 · 21/12/2023 15:19

I'd disagree, he just has an issue with "buying babies "
As for the marriage thing, that's his choice.

In which of OPs posts did she say this?

CurlewKate · 21/12/2023 16:13

@graceinspace999 "Would it be ok for the OPs fiancé to hold that opinion if he were Muslim or Catholic or a member of a protected religious group who ban gay marriage or worse?"

Under those circumstances, the OP would not have been caught by surprise b his opinion and could have acted on it earlier.

CurlewKate · 21/12/2023 16:11

@graceinspace999 "Abuse is an action - not an opinion."

I only if you do it. Thinking it's OK is an opinion.