Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Anti-gay marriage

239 replies

NotGotAClue1 · 21/12/2023 13:21

My finance and the father of my young child told me that he doesn’t agree with gay marriage, not being gay in general, just the marriage part. And that it would be better for a child to be raised by a man and a woman. I’m completely offended by this and don’t agree in the slightest. I think he is thinking like a dinosaur and needs to move with the times. He thinks we can have different views and move on. But this has actually changed the way I look at him. He isn’t religious at all which is making me even more confused at his strong views.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Fancycheese · 22/12/2023 12:07

scatterolight · 21/12/2023 13:44

Your opinion is very fashionable in the modern era. But go back a few years and everyone would have agreed that the ideal situation is for a child to have a mother and father. Perhaps the wheel will turn again one day and it's you who will be the dinosaur.

Perhaps you could list the advantages of being a motherless or fatherless child compared to having both? You might be able to persuade your DP to your fashionable view.

Bizarre that you appear to think that equal rights are a passing fad.

TriOptimim · 22/12/2023 11:59

ShelleyPercy · 22/12/2023 10:46

I tend to agree with your husband because I think its not fair on children to deny them knowledge of their mother and father, and that yes it is in the childs best interests to be raised by a male and female (not that this is always possible).

I also don't support adoption or surrogacy because I think people are only entitled to have children if they can create them themselves (there are obviously exceptions like a grandparent taking over if the parents pass away etc). Gay people can not reproduce without a third party, it goes against nature and deprives the child of their biological parents.

Why do you actually disagree with him? Calling him a dinosaur is not a well reasoned argument.

So children should be denied potential adoptive parents because they can't biologically have children with each other? That's horrible! Do you think infertile couples should be banned from adopting too?

RampantIvy · 22/12/2023 11:59

As I tire of repeating, just because I am against gay marriage, doesn't mean that I wish to withhold the right to marry from anyone else.
Im unsure how many times I need to keep saying this in order for it to filter through skulls.

It's because your terminology is incorrect and odd, as has been pointed out by several posters.
You aren't against gay marriage. It just isn't for you.

If you persist in saying that you are against something they will continue to think that you want it to be banned. Being against something in common parlance means that you think it shouldn't ever happen for anyone, ever.

Simonjt · 22/12/2023 11:49

pointythings · 22/12/2023 10:57

@ShelleyPercy you don't support adoption? So a child who loses both parents for whatever reason should not be adopted by anyone? What a bizarre stance to take.

Its a surprisingly common view among fundamentalists, particularly those who are pro-life, as the anti-adoption views give them a convenient reason not to care about children who come about via forced birth. Its also an extremely common view among abusers, a ban an adoption means they can continue to abuse their children.

Simonjt · 22/12/2023 11:47

NotGotAClue1 · 22/12/2023 08:50

He said he doesn’t like the fact that the government got involved to change the law and that he wouldn’t have a problem if it were the church’s decision. But I told him he’s contradicting himself as he said it’s just a belief that he’s never going to change. He has so many political views etc. that I don’t agree with but can agree to disagree on but this is different. I can’t get past it.

What about marriage that doesn’t involve the church? Or does he think the church has some odd power over all marriage in the UK?

Verv · 22/12/2023 11:24

ClaudiaWankleman · 21/12/2023 21:08

I’m not going to go dig through your history, and I’ll take you on your word.

I will point out that emulate =/= ape, and suggest you don’t know what you’re talking about in more ways than just that.

Because of course just one or some people saying one thing doesn’t mean we can extrapolate the truth. There are some children who don’t want to go to school, but I am yet to find someone who disputes the right to education because of that.

As I tire of repeating, just because I am against gay marriage, doesn't mean that I wish to withhold the right to marry from anyone else.
Im unsure how many times I need to keep saying this in order for it to filter through skulls.

You may not like or understand why some gay people reject the concept of "marriage", and you can label it as not knowing what we're talking about, being internally homophobic, and whatever else you can think to fling in the direction but the reality is that more than a handful gay people think that marriage is utterly regressive and prefer the civil partnership route as it doesnt buy in to anything religious, conservative, or heteronormative which is how marriage is viewed by some.

AGAIN, this doesnt mean that they want to remove marriage from the table of others, so stop making up fanciful false comparisons.

pointythings · 22/12/2023 10:57

@ShelleyPercy you don't support adoption? So a child who loses both parents for whatever reason should not be adopted by anyone? What a bizarre stance to take.

RampantIvy · 22/12/2023 10:48

Brilliant @zingally

ShelleyPercy · 22/12/2023 10:46

I tend to agree with your husband because I think its not fair on children to deny them knowledge of their mother and father, and that yes it is in the childs best interests to be raised by a male and female (not that this is always possible).

I also don't support adoption or surrogacy because I think people are only entitled to have children if they can create them themselves (there are obviously exceptions like a grandparent taking over if the parents pass away etc). Gay people can not reproduce without a third party, it goes against nature and deprives the child of their biological parents.

Why do you actually disagree with him? Calling him a dinosaur is not a well reasoned argument.

pointythings · 22/12/2023 10:10

@NotGotAClue1 your comment about the two of you having many opposing beliefs rings alarm bells for me. Why would you marry someone who doesn't share your values? You don't have to be identical, but there does have to be some overlap. My late husband was much more right wing than I am, but we absolutely had key things in common (until he dove into the bottle but that's a whole other story).

zingally · 22/12/2023 09:27

"Says the man who had a child out of wedlock...?" Said with an expression of faint bemusement?

Story time:
I'm a primary school teacher, and used to teach in a small, rather "churchy" village school. I was teaching Year One at the time, and we'd been learning about weddings in RE. I said something fairly throwaway (I thought!), like "Nowadays you can marry whoever you want! Isn't that nice?" and thought no more of it.

The next day, a dad comes storming in demanding to know why I'm pushing the gay agenda on his son, in a church school?!
I gave my best withering stare and replied, "I gave him a bit of factually accurate knowledge, and I'm pretty sure the bible tells us to love our neighbour." Then I turned and walked away.
To this date, I still count this as one of my finest moments in teaching.

Justintimeee · 22/12/2023 09:15

From a developmental standpoint, a child does need a male and female influence and role models. However, role models are not limited to parents so his argument is void and frankly disgusting. So he'd let a man and woman in a potentially violent/toxic relationship get married and raise a child but not a loving, caring, dedicated gay couple?
Weird behaviour.

Malarandras · 22/12/2023 09:06

I would be much more concerned that you do not know the man with whom you have child very well. Definitely get to know him a lot better before you marry him.

basculin · 22/12/2023 08:57

NotGotAClue1 · 22/12/2023 08:50

He said he doesn’t like the fact that the government got involved to change the law and that he wouldn’t have a problem if it were the church’s decision. But I told him he’s contradicting himself as he said it’s just a belief that he’s never going to change. He has so many political views etc. that I don’t agree with but can agree to disagree on but this is different. I can’t get past it.

He thinks the church (of England presumably) should be in charge of the law rather than Parliament?

ThinWomansBrain · 22/12/2023 08:54

maybe your child would be better being brought up by a single mother, rather than a mother and bigoted father?

NotGotAClue1 · 22/12/2023 08:50

pointythings · 22/12/2023 08:33

I think you should talk to him to find out where all this is coming from. If he is willing to support a gay child, including their wedding, then his position is illogical and he should be able to recognise that and reflect on his position.

If he can't and he's only making an exception because it's his child, I wouldn't marry him. But it might be different for you. We all have different boundaries around what we can and can't live with.

He said he doesn’t like the fact that the government got involved to change the law and that he wouldn’t have a problem if it were the church’s decision. But I told him he’s contradicting himself as he said it’s just a belief that he’s never going to change. He has so many political views etc. that I don’t agree with but can agree to disagree on but this is different. I can’t get past it.

OP posts:
pointythings · 22/12/2023 08:33

I think you should talk to him to find out where all this is coming from. If he is willing to support a gay child, including their wedding, then his position is illogical and he should be able to recognise that and reflect on his position.

If he can't and he's only making an exception because it's his child, I wouldn't marry him. But it might be different for you. We all have different boundaries around what we can and can't live with.

NotGotAClue1 · 22/12/2023 07:50

What should I do?

OP posts:
2mummies1baby · 22/12/2023 06:09

Defizz · 21/12/2023 20:59

That's nice dear.

This post alone makes it clear you are one of those gay men who has very little respect for women.

KylieJennersMakeUpSponge · 22/12/2023 00:13

@Verv can I ask why you’re against gay marriage?

RampantIvy · 21/12/2023 22:32

Verv · 21/12/2023 15:22

Dear god this is tiresome.

Again.

I am against gay marriage. It is my personal opinion. It is an opinion held by a number of gay people.

Me being against something, does not even vaguely mean that I wish to remove choice or "rights" from others
That is both unhinged and a straw man argument.

My preference is and would be for civil partnership because it gives legal protections, without grovelling at the bloody church or apeing heteronormativity.

At the risk of repeating myself, I am also against veganism, but accept that some people want to do it and thats fine.
I dont have to agree with something, in order to accept that others do.

Has that sunk in yet?

As ive said repeatedly. I am against it. This does not mean that I want to remove the right or choice to do it from other people.

Your terminology is confusing and odd.

In common parlance being against something means you think it is wrong. People who are against abortion or the death penalty think they should be banned - for everyone.

I've been as clear as I can be.

No you haven't.
Being against gay marriage or veganism is a ridiculous and incorrect way to say that they aren't for you. 2mummies1baby has explained it better than I have what being against something means to the vast majority of people.

As I pointed out earlier, marriage is a legal contract and has nothing to do with religion these days unless you choose it to be.

basculin · 21/12/2023 22:23

CocoC · 21/12/2023 21:19

Don’t understand how you can act all outraged now but clearly never had a meaningful conversation before going so far into the relationship that you have a child !!
Didn’t you discuss this sort of thing in your relationship ?!
Though on the raised by 2 sex parents thing, I think most people would deep down agree - even if they support gay marriage. Doesn’t mean a gay couple can’t make great parents, but generally speaking it’s good for kids to have close role models of both sexes I think. Little girls often love looking up to mum, and many little boys love being around men.

Edited

Ah, the old "most people secretly agree with me" excuse.

basculin · 21/12/2023 22:19

CranfordScones · 21/12/2023 21:17

Taking offence is really your choice. You're the one who is unable to handle your emotional reaction to someone holding an opinion that contradicts your own. Are you like this with all contrarian views? How do you get through life?

You're talking like being offended by honophobia is a bad thing.

ClaudiaWankleman · 21/12/2023 22:13

CocoC · 21/12/2023 21:19

Don’t understand how you can act all outraged now but clearly never had a meaningful conversation before going so far into the relationship that you have a child !!
Didn’t you discuss this sort of thing in your relationship ?!
Though on the raised by 2 sex parents thing, I think most people would deep down agree - even if they support gay marriage. Doesn’t mean a gay couple can’t make great parents, but generally speaking it’s good for kids to have close role models of both sexes I think. Little girls often love looking up to mum, and many little boys love being around men.

Edited

And many girls looks up to their dads and many boys look up to them mums? So what? It doesn’t prove or support a single argument either way, just that children often love their parents and others close to them.

CocoC · 21/12/2023 21:19

Don’t understand how you can act all outraged now but clearly never had a meaningful conversation before going so far into the relationship that you have a child !!
Didn’t you discuss this sort of thing in your relationship ?!
Though on the raised by 2 sex parents thing, I think most people would deep down agree - even if they support gay marriage. Doesn’t mean a gay couple can’t make great parents, but generally speaking it’s good for kids to have close role models of both sexes I think. Little girls often love looking up to mum, and many little boys love being around men.