Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Anti-gay marriage

239 replies

NotGotAClue1 · 21/12/2023 13:21

My finance and the father of my young child told me that he doesn’t agree with gay marriage, not being gay in general, just the marriage part. And that it would be better for a child to be raised by a man and a woman. I’m completely offended by this and don’t agree in the slightest. I think he is thinking like a dinosaur and needs to move with the times. He thinks we can have different views and move on. But this has actually changed the way I look at him. He isn’t religious at all which is making me even more confused at his strong views.

AIBU?

OP posts:
SummaLuvin · 22/12/2023 18:24

gannett · 22/12/2023 18:16

Do please explain why bigotry - and potentially causing deep harm to your child - isn't a hill worth dying on. If this isn't, what is?

not to mention growing up in a household where there is conflict between parent as a result of each having such different values

Boomboom22 · 22/12/2023 18:16

Sorry I think 26 bishops are Lords, because of their Bishop position not independently.

gannett · 22/12/2023 18:16

JazbayGrapes · 22/12/2023 17:59

Haven't RTFT but is this the hill you want to die on?

Do please explain why bigotry - and potentially causing deep harm to your child - isn't a hill worth dying on. If this isn't, what is?

Boomboom22 · 22/12/2023 18:16

@2mummies1baby but we do have 25 bishops in the house of Lords, and that was the entire reason for the invention of civil partnerships. Hence the law in 2007 then years later in 2013 gay marriage was approved. Because of the church of England having power over law.

gannett · 22/12/2023 18:15

Verv · 22/12/2023 14:09

Not only do I simply "not want to get married", I think that the gay community does itself a disservice when it attempts to conform to heteronormative and traditional ideals of what relationships should look like in order to be considered valid by wider society.

It is my opinion that gay people can protect themselves financially and give themselves the same level of rights and security by using civil partnership which is a perfectly viable option that isn't rooted in ownership, conservatism, tradition, religious belief and is, in my opinion, an outdated institution no longer compatible with modern relationships, including homosexuality.

My issue with marriage is not the sex or sexual orientation of those within the union, it is with the institution of marriage itself.
I understand that there is a lot of pressure within the heterosexual community to marry because it is often linked with finances, this can be evidenced by the number of mumsnet threads about "he doesn't want to marry me, my high earning DP is avoiding talk about marriage, he doesn't want to commit even though ive washed his pants for a decade, my DH doesn't lift a finger and i'm unhappy but I cant leave because we're married, DH has been abusive and I want to leave but hes emptied our joint account behind my back and i'm scared about divorce" etc etc, and upon reading this I have no idea why gay people wish to engage with or link themselves to such an antiquated system that appears to be particularly designed to oppress women into domesticity in order to formalise their relationships.

If they just want to do it because it's their right and thats how they want to formalise their relationship, thats fine.

I have absolutely no inclination to remove the right to from ANYBODY, gay or straight, and im more than capable of understanding that it may be what other people absolutely want to do for their own reasons within their own relationships, but my thoughts on the matter run much deeper than "not wanting to do it", to the point that I am actually pretty against it.

Hope that clarifies.

Tbh I actually agree with your stance on marriage and - having been influenced, possibly inspired, by a few very close gay friends and their long-term relationships, these are the reasons I don't believe in marriage either. It's a political stance and I get it.

However in the context of the OP... the problem is that I think her husband is coming at this from the perspective of plain old homophobia, not radical queer progressiveness. In those situations I think it's necessary to argue that such an anti-gay marriage view is deeply harmful.

JazbayGrapes · 22/12/2023 17:59

Haven't RTFT but is this the hill you want to die on?

TriOptimim · 22/12/2023 17:30

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Challenging people's opinion is fascism? That's the most ridiculous thing on this thread.

VolvoFan · 22/12/2023 17:23

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

2mummies1baby · 22/12/2023 17:12

It's amazing the number of people who seem to think the Church invented/owns marriage. There is absolutely no need for marriage to be religious, so any arguments about poor Christians having to share their precious institution of marriage with the gays are irrelevant.

2mummies1baby · 22/12/2023 17:10

@Verv Would it be correct to say that you feel yourself to be "against marriage" rather than "against gay marriage"? It sounds like this is the case, and I think you would have saved yourself a lot of bother if you'd stated it this way from the very beginning.

Boomboom22 · 22/12/2023 15:54

Sounds like you have misrepresented his view. He thinks the church shouldn't be forced to accept gay marriage / uses the religious definition of marriage. He doesn't sound bigoted in his actions or like he is campaigning to change the law or would not attend a gay friends wedding.

AnonnyMouseDave · 22/12/2023 15:46

NotGotAClue1 · 21/12/2023 13:21

My finance and the father of my young child told me that he doesn’t agree with gay marriage, not being gay in general, just the marriage part. And that it would be better for a child to be raised by a man and a woman. I’m completely offended by this and don’t agree in the slightest. I think he is thinking like a dinosaur and needs to move with the times. He thinks we can have different views and move on. But this has actually changed the way I look at him. He isn’t religious at all which is making me even more confused at his strong views.

AIBU?

I support gay marriage, but -

(1) There is an argument that marriage is a (religious - religions being homophobic) thing between man and a woman and that civil partnerships are what should be available for LGB and straight couples who want legal rights, and leave marriage as a purely religious, bigoted hateful thing.

(2) IMHO men and women have different strengths, on average, therefore, on average, other things being equal, it is better to have opposite sex parents not same sex ones. Stats might contradict my gut feel, but I believe that having opp. sex parents almost inevitably gives a better balance of nurture and more masculine characteristics, which both sexes benefit from. This doesn;t mean got and singl parents shouldn;t bring up kids, and obviously they often do a fantastic job (just as it is the case that straight parents can do a dreadful job).

I think that you should consider why you are offended? Is it because you have thought the issues through and come to rational opinions, or is it because you support LGB rights and believe that your position is the most pure one?

Verv · 22/12/2023 14:51

Thank you @CurlewKate far more succinct than me!

CurlewKate · 22/12/2023 14:29

@Verv
"My issue with marriage is not the sex or sexual orientation of those within the union, it is with the institution of marriage itself."

Me too. We are in a very exclusive club on Mumsnet! While of course I support gay people's right to marry, it always seems to me to be equalling down, not up.....

pointythings · 22/12/2023 14:27

@Verv that makes perfect sense and is completely consistent. Where I'm from, everyone has the same options: formal cohabitation contract or marriage. A civil marriage ceremony is compulsory and is what makes it valid. The religious part in itself has no legal standing. Everyone has the choice, everyone is legally protected.

Verv · 22/12/2023 14:09

2mummies1baby · 22/12/2023 13:08

I have never heard anyone use 'for' and 'against' in this way. It would be much clearer, and make a lot more sense, to say, "I like marmite. I don't like coriander." Or, indeed, "I don't want to get married."

Not only do I simply "not want to get married", I think that the gay community does itself a disservice when it attempts to conform to heteronormative and traditional ideals of what relationships should look like in order to be considered valid by wider society.

It is my opinion that gay people can protect themselves financially and give themselves the same level of rights and security by using civil partnership which is a perfectly viable option that isn't rooted in ownership, conservatism, tradition, religious belief and is, in my opinion, an outdated institution no longer compatible with modern relationships, including homosexuality.

My issue with marriage is not the sex or sexual orientation of those within the union, it is with the institution of marriage itself.
I understand that there is a lot of pressure within the heterosexual community to marry because it is often linked with finances, this can be evidenced by the number of mumsnet threads about "he doesn't want to marry me, my high earning DP is avoiding talk about marriage, he doesn't want to commit even though ive washed his pants for a decade, my DH doesn't lift a finger and i'm unhappy but I cant leave because we're married, DH has been abusive and I want to leave but hes emptied our joint account behind my back and i'm scared about divorce" etc etc, and upon reading this I have no idea why gay people wish to engage with or link themselves to such an antiquated system that appears to be particularly designed to oppress women into domesticity in order to formalise their relationships.

If they just want to do it because it's their right and thats how they want to formalise their relationship, thats fine.

I have absolutely no inclination to remove the right to from ANYBODY, gay or straight, and im more than capable of understanding that it may be what other people absolutely want to do for their own reasons within their own relationships, but my thoughts on the matter run much deeper than "not wanting to do it", to the point that I am actually pretty against it.

Hope that clarifies.

Alarum · 22/12/2023 13:27

Against adoption??!!

So children who’s parents die should do what, live in care, rather than being adopted into a loving family?

Does that even extend to being brought up by family members. My Gran was brought up her grandparents following the death of her parents. They didn’t adopt her formally but they might as well have done. Should that not have happened?

You’re entitled to a view, but let’s not pretend it’s anything other than completely inhumane.

Poorlymumma · 22/12/2023 13:25

Op have you pointed out to him that weddings don't have to be in church? How does he feel about gay people getting married in a registry office?
Or straight people using a sperm donor to conceive a baby?

I'd have to give him examples like what if a gay couple wants to adopt a child who has been waiting years for a family in foster care?

You need to ask all these questions to see if he's deeply homophobic or if it's about his feelings on IVF and the government etc.. and then decide what you can live with from there.

2mummies1baby · 22/12/2023 13:08

Verv · 22/12/2023 12:13

Sigh.
I'm for marmite and against coriander.
Doesnt mean I want coriander banned.

I have never heard anyone use 'for' and 'against' in this way. It would be much clearer, and make a lot more sense, to say, "I like marmite. I don't like coriander." Or, indeed, "I don't want to get married."

2mummies1baby · 22/12/2023 13:05

ShelleyPercy · 22/12/2023 10:46

I tend to agree with your husband because I think its not fair on children to deny them knowledge of their mother and father, and that yes it is in the childs best interests to be raised by a male and female (not that this is always possible).

I also don't support adoption or surrogacy because I think people are only entitled to have children if they can create them themselves (there are obviously exceptions like a grandparent taking over if the parents pass away etc). Gay people can not reproduce without a third party, it goes against nature and deprives the child of their biological parents.

Why do you actually disagree with him? Calling him a dinosaur is not a well reasoned argument.

You're against adoption?! What on earth do you suggest we as a society do with all the children who are removed from abusive and neglectful birth parents? Keep them in a cupboard?

divinededacende · 22/12/2023 12:21

NotGotAClue1 · 22/12/2023 08:50

He said he doesn’t like the fact that the government got involved to change the law and that he wouldn’t have a problem if it were the church’s decision. But I told him he’s contradicting himself as he said it’s just a belief that he’s never going to change. He has so many political views etc. that I don’t agree with but can agree to disagree on but this is different. I can’t get past it.

@NotGotAClue1 Your husband is confused because marriage is an important pillar of most mainstream religions with their own practices and ceremonies surrounding it. The fact is, marriage is a legal joining of two people at it's core. All the other ceremonial stuff is fluff and people could always opt in or out of it. Even before same-sex marriage, plenty of people opted to marry outside of faith based ceremonies at a registry offices.

Same sex marriage legislation only made the legal act of marriage available to everyone. It didn't force religions to recognise it or perform ceremonies. The church DOES still exercise it's own choice. The COE is moving towards it and, I believe, the Catholics are still dead against.

Your husband needs to understand his own arguments better.

Also, you might remind him that governments make, alter and revoke laws. It's literally their job - or a big part of it.

I mean, you could be flogging a dead horse here if he has lots of political opinions you don't agree with. He seems like a person who just has a set world view and isn't interested in changing it. Especially if he can't even consistently articular why he thinks the way he does or alter it when he gets new information.

erinaceus · 22/12/2023 12:19

NotGotAClue1 · 22/12/2023 08:50

He said he doesn’t like the fact that the government got involved to change the law and that he wouldn’t have a problem if it were the church’s decision. But I told him he’s contradicting himself as he said it’s just a belief that he’s never going to change. He has so many political views etc. that I don’t agree with but can agree to disagree on but this is different. I can’t get past it.

It is worth putting some energy into getting him to unpack all of his feelings on the matter. His reasoning about the government and the church is back to front: it is the government who makes the law around marriage in this country, not the church. If the church had wanted to marry same-sex couples before the law allowed for it they would not have been able to if you see what I mean.

Maybe he does not know much about the history of marriage.

People can change. My ex was astoundingly homophobic when we met; over time he changed how he understood sexual orientation.

Having bigger political differences, though, might be a deal breaker especially if he is someone who steamrollers his views and does not have any flexibility or scope to grow.

Fancycheese · 22/12/2023 12:13

ShelleyPercy · 22/12/2023 10:46

I tend to agree with your husband because I think its not fair on children to deny them knowledge of their mother and father, and that yes it is in the childs best interests to be raised by a male and female (not that this is always possible).

I also don't support adoption or surrogacy because I think people are only entitled to have children if they can create them themselves (there are obviously exceptions like a grandparent taking over if the parents pass away etc). Gay people can not reproduce without a third party, it goes against nature and deprives the child of their biological parents.

Why do you actually disagree with him? Calling him a dinosaur is not a well reasoned argument.

being annoying and double posting because I’ve just registered that your against adoption! 😂😂 you truly get all sorts on here.

Verv · 22/12/2023 12:13

RampantIvy · 22/12/2023 11:59

As I tire of repeating, just because I am against gay marriage, doesn't mean that I wish to withhold the right to marry from anyone else.
Im unsure how many times I need to keep saying this in order for it to filter through skulls.

It's because your terminology is incorrect and odd, as has been pointed out by several posters.
You aren't against gay marriage. It just isn't for you.

If you persist in saying that you are against something they will continue to think that you want it to be banned. Being against something in common parlance means that you think it shouldn't ever happen for anyone, ever.

Sigh.
I'm for marmite and against coriander.
Doesnt mean I want coriander banned.

Fancycheese · 22/12/2023 12:11

ShelleyPercy · 22/12/2023 10:46

I tend to agree with your husband because I think its not fair on children to deny them knowledge of their mother and father, and that yes it is in the childs best interests to be raised by a male and female (not that this is always possible).

I also don't support adoption or surrogacy because I think people are only entitled to have children if they can create them themselves (there are obviously exceptions like a grandparent taking over if the parents pass away etc). Gay people can not reproduce without a third party, it goes against nature and deprives the child of their biological parents.

Why do you actually disagree with him? Calling him a dinosaur is not a well reasoned argument.

Why is it in the child’s best interest to be raised by a “male and female”? (Incidentally, male and female what? Bonobo?) I assume you actually mean men and woman? What research supports this?

As long as the child is loved, cherished and provided for, I fail to see how the gender of the parents or guardians matter at all.

Swipe left for the next trending thread