Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My neighbour and his flying bins

137 replies

Philthedendron · 21/12/2023 12:34

I just need a quick sense check that I’m not being unreasonable here, I’m off work sick at the moment and I’ve lost all sense of proportion. I’ve NC’d because I have an active thread running under my main user name on a health issue that’s identifiable but I’m a long term user.

So, I live at the end of a short track that branches into 2 drives: my neighbours drive and mine. We’ve had high winds for a couple of nights, so the last couple of mornings I’ve found next doors bins blocking the shared track. As you do, I’ve just moved them out of the way and popped them back on his drive on his hard standing area where he keeps his bins.

I got back from dropping the kids off this morning and noticed the bins were back on the track, blocking access to our house (I could have squeezed passed them but I’m in a big car and didn’t want to risk knocking them).

Well out marches Mr Nextdoor when he sees me getting out of the car and he shouts from his front door ‘I hope you’ve not got out to move my bin??’

I didn’t quite process what he said in time and I thought he was apologising that his bin was on the track, so I said ‘I need to get on our drive so I’ll just move it back don’t worry it’s no problem!’

I carried on and he ran over and said ‘no no leave the bin where it is this is our property!’ Confused

So I said ‘I need to put the car on the drive and don’t want to damage your bin so can you move it please if you don’t want me to?’

It went back and forth but basically, the upshot of the conversation is he thinks the shared track is owned by him, and he wants to start keeping his bins on the track so the bin men will collect them from there and he won’t have to move them.

I don’t believe the track is owned by them, I’m pretty confident it’s not owned by either of us. I didn’t want to argue on the street so I left the conversation by offering to take his bins down the track and back again to his bin store on bin day but he said they didn’t need that thank you. So I said well the bins can’t stay where they are and I’ll need to check the deeds.

I’m sympathetic to them getting older so don’t want to start a fight, but if they don’t own the track (which I’m confident they dont), are they allowed to leave their bin there under any circumstances? How do I challenge it?

OP posts:
Philthedendron · 21/12/2023 18:36

mumda · 21/12/2023 18:30

Similar here. Our track was adopted by the council a few years after we moved in. Which means they'll have to mend it when it needs it.

I’m pretty sure ours is owned by the council - there’s very little traffic up and down it, just us and the neighbour so in the 10 years we’ve been here I’ve never known it needing any work done. Someone did repoint the retaining walls though a few years ago, not sure who though.

OP posts:
Philthedendron · 21/12/2023 18:34

Findingmypurposeinlife · 21/12/2023 18:29

No new patio in the last 9 years at his place?

Grin no but this is a running joke between DH and I, as dark as that is!

OP posts:
Philthedendron · 21/12/2023 18:32

Orangewall · 21/12/2023 18:19

what a strange thing for him to get a bee in his bonnet over! Especially as you’ve said you’ve previously returned his bins for him!

We’ve also mowed his lawn(with his permission) when he was on holiday in the summer, taken in parcels for him and fed his pond fish on the odd occasion too. He usually drops a note through our door if he needs something and asks very politely if we wouldn’t mind lending a hand which we of course never do. We offered to maintain his garden for him while we was away for a month a couple of years ago and he was very pleased.

OP posts:
mumda · 21/12/2023 18:30

Similar here. Our track was adopted by the council a few years after we moved in. Which means they'll have to mend it when it needs it.

Findingmypurposeinlife · 21/12/2023 18:29

Philthedendron · 21/12/2023 18:05

Well there is a bit of mystery on that point - his children are all grown up and the last one of 4 moved out around the time we moved in, so 10(ish) years ago.

Then about a year later, his wife mentioned over the gate that she was going to stay with her daughter for a while and she’d see us after Christmas/ in the new year and she wished us a merry Christmas etc etc. A couple of days later we got a Christmas card through the door addressed from all of them, but never saw the wife again. I assume she left him. I’ve also never seen any of the kids visit him but that doesn’t mean to say they haven’t or he hasn’t visited them, but I do find it odd that none of them have been back to the family home where they grew up, and he’s continued to live in a 6 bed farm house as a single man for the last 9 years.

No new patio in the last 9 years at his place?

Philthedendron · 21/12/2023 18:24

Right, I’m going over now while DH sorts out dinner.

I plan to be matter of fact about everything, ‘you cannot store your bins in a way that obstructs access to our drive’ and see what he says.

I’ve printed both sets of title plans and I’ll keep them in my bag unless I think they’re going to help the conversation go smoothly.

I absolutely hate confrontation so I’m hoping he was just in a bad mood earlier..

OP posts:
Orangewall · 21/12/2023 18:19

what a strange thing for him to get a bee in his bonnet over! Especially as you’ve said you’ve previously returned his bins for him!

Philthedendron · 21/12/2023 18:10

FictionalCharacter · 21/12/2023 17:48

Has he actually said he finds the weight of the bin a problem? He’s only in his 60s and still working, he isn’t a frail aged person! DH is mid 60s, working, and still immensely strong. You don’t need to give people our age a pass for being “old” when they’re not even retirement age and probably perfectly fit.

I agree with your DH to point, but it isn’t OK for this man to carry on believing that he owns the lane. Who knows what he might decide to do with “his property” in the future, or stop you doing.

He’s definitely struggling with his back, he’s mentioned a couple of times while he’s been gardening in the summer that he’s considering paving his lawn because he struggles with his back when pushing the lawnmower.

OP posts:
Philthedendron · 21/12/2023 18:05

Longtimelurkerfinallyposts · 21/12/2023 17:38

Does he live alone, or with a partner?
If so, can you try talking to the partner first? They might be more reasonable, and help you deal with him.

If you're in England/Wales, you might be able to find out the status of the road from this: https://www.findmystreet.co.uk/street-list?ProviderId=

But whoever is responsible for maintaining the road, it's obvious that you have a right of way and your access shouldn't be impeded. Sometimes the local Fire Brigade can be helpful at persuading neighbours not to do anything that would block their access in case of an emergency....

Well there is a bit of mystery on that point - his children are all grown up and the last one of 4 moved out around the time we moved in, so 10(ish) years ago.

Then about a year later, his wife mentioned over the gate that she was going to stay with her daughter for a while and she’d see us after Christmas/ in the new year and she wished us a merry Christmas etc etc. A couple of days later we got a Christmas card through the door addressed from all of them, but never saw the wife again. I assume she left him. I’ve also never seen any of the kids visit him but that doesn’t mean to say they haven’t or he hasn’t visited them, but I do find it odd that none of them have been back to the family home where they grew up, and he’s continued to live in a 6 bed farm house as a single man for the last 9 years.

OP posts:
WorriedMum231 · 21/12/2023 18:00

lol you’re nicer then me. I would have put them in the road.

RandomMess · 21/12/2023 17:57

Having seen your diagram he's being very silly.

If he leaves them out again I would leave your car in the lane as you "can't get past the bins".

FictionalCharacter · 21/12/2023 17:48

Philthedendron · 21/12/2023 17:26

This is what DH said! I think it’s the weight of the bin rather than the walk that’s hard for him - he’s in his mid-60’s and still working and doesn’t struggle with walking, he’s seemingly fit and well but you never know.

We live rurally so have a bin collection every 2 weeks rather than weekly and have quite large bins to compensate.

Has he actually said he finds the weight of the bin a problem? He’s only in his 60s and still working, he isn’t a frail aged person! DH is mid 60s, working, and still immensely strong. You don’t need to give people our age a pass for being “old” when they’re not even retirement age and probably perfectly fit.

I agree with your DH to point, but it isn’t OK for this man to carry on believing that he owns the lane. Who knows what he might decide to do with “his property” in the future, or stop you doing.

Laiste · 21/12/2023 17:46

I'd go round with a printed off copy of the deeds (to leave with him) and have a chat.

I'd treat him the way he's treating you - very matter of fact and unapologetic.

You can dress it up as

How useful and informative it is for both of you to know who owns what piece of land so that confusion can now be avoided. Bins stay on his own land. Full.Stop.

Longtimelurkerfinallyposts · 21/12/2023 17:38

Does he live alone, or with a partner?
If so, can you try talking to the partner first? They might be more reasonable, and help you deal with him.

If you're in England/Wales, you might be able to find out the status of the road from this: https://www.findmystreet.co.uk/street-list?ProviderId=

But whoever is responsible for maintaining the road, it's obvious that you have a right of way and your access shouldn't be impeded. Sometimes the local Fire Brigade can be helpful at persuading neighbours not to do anything that would block their access in case of an emergency....

List of Streets from National Street Gazeteer

The National Street Gazetteer (NSG) is the definitive source of information about streets in England and Wales. FindMyStreet uses data that’s held in the most up to date version of the NSG.

https://www.findmystreet.co.uk/street-list?ProviderId=

Philthedendron · 21/12/2023 17:26

MaggieFS · 21/12/2023 17:19

I think to keep it simple, it doesn't even need to be a debate about who owns what. If him putting the bins there means you can't fit, then it is blatantly not a place for the bins to be kept.

Incidentally, surely putting the bins out is only once per week, but having to walk to put stuff in them happens more regularly? So I isn't it better to have them near the house?

This is what DH said! I think it’s the weight of the bin rather than the walk that’s hard for him - he’s in his mid-60’s and still working and doesn’t struggle with walking, he’s seemingly fit and well but you never know.

We live rurally so have a bin collection every 2 weeks rather than weekly and have quite large bins to compensate.

OP posts:
MaggieFS · 21/12/2023 17:19

I think to keep it simple, it doesn't even need to be a debate about who owns what. If him putting the bins there means you can't fit, then it is blatantly not a place for the bins to be kept.

Incidentally, surely putting the bins out is only once per week, but having to walk to put stuff in them happens more regularly? So I isn't it better to have them near the house?

Philthedendron · 21/12/2023 17:16

Also, I assume the lane is owned by the council, there’s a telephone pole half way down and on the deeds it’s just called ‘unclassified road access’ so either council or highways?

OP posts:
napody · 21/12/2023 17:15

Obviously batshit!

I'd have gone with a pleasantly bemused
'Just explain to me what it is you want to happen....?'
Then
'And when we are leaving and returning to our home......then.....?'
Just leaving it hang there!

Philthedendron · 21/12/2023 17:11

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 21/12/2023 15:22

I'm baffled. WHOMEVER owns the drive (is it the local council?), even if it were King Charles himself, nobody could ever think it reasonable to barricade you either in or out of your own driveway!

Does he think he's leaving the bins with sufficient gap for you to get in and out? This is the only thing I can grasp at, that he's misguidedly thinking that, as it's easier to leave the bins out, he's giving you 'plenty of space' to get past.

He might think he’s giving us enough space, he does leave them right on the side up against the wall but it’s far too tight for comfort in our car. The other problem is that in the wind, it blows very strong up the lane and his bins will always get blown over if he leaves them on the lane. They were knocked over the last few days which is why I assumed they’d been blown off his drive and down the lane.

OP posts:
Philthedendron · 21/12/2023 17:08

RandomMess · 21/12/2023 14:37

If you parked on the track would it only block his drive? Every time his bins are obstructing I'd do that.

Being more sensible I'd pop over with your partner and explain they only have eight of way over the track and it can't be used for bin storage.

Yes the lane is only wide enough for a single car to go up and down and when the bins are there it’s very very tight. You’d get through in a little hatchback maybe but we drive a big 4x4 so I didn’t want to risk squeezing past. It’s a high brick wall on either side as well so no flexibility to go on a pavement or anything to avoid the bins.

OP posts:
Philthedendron · 21/12/2023 17:05

A diagram as requested. The green dotted line is our boundary according to the deeds and the red is his.

DH just got home and thinks we should go round and take the deeds with us, and offer again to sort his bins for him on bin day (we often bring his back anyway because the bin men leave all the bins at the bottom of the lane). We’re going to pop round once the kids are asleep and take the monitor with us.

My neighbour and his flying bins
OP posts:
Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 21/12/2023 15:22

I'm baffled. WHOMEVER owns the drive (is it the local council?), even if it were King Charles himself, nobody could ever think it reasonable to barricade you either in or out of your own driveway!

Does he think he's leaving the bins with sufficient gap for you to get in and out? This is the only thing I can grasp at, that he's misguidedly thinking that, as it's easier to leave the bins out, he's giving you 'plenty of space' to get past.

RausageSoul · 21/12/2023 15:22

I am unable to see the diagram you've definitely 100% provided....

LakeTiticaca · 21/12/2023 15:20

He can't block access to someone's home.
Get the awkward old sod told

HarrumphryBogart · 21/12/2023 15:18

I'd ask him for his email address, so you can send a copy of your deeds. Then send him a copy. If he continues to block your drive or even sends you something that shows he owns the drive, email him asking him not to block your access. Having all this in writing will help so much.