Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My neighbour and his flying bins

137 replies

Philthedendron · 21/12/2023 12:34

I just need a quick sense check that I’m not being unreasonable here, I’m off work sick at the moment and I’ve lost all sense of proportion. I’ve NC’d because I have an active thread running under my main user name on a health issue that’s identifiable but I’m a long term user.

So, I live at the end of a short track that branches into 2 drives: my neighbours drive and mine. We’ve had high winds for a couple of nights, so the last couple of mornings I’ve found next doors bins blocking the shared track. As you do, I’ve just moved them out of the way and popped them back on his drive on his hard standing area where he keeps his bins.

I got back from dropping the kids off this morning and noticed the bins were back on the track, blocking access to our house (I could have squeezed passed them but I’m in a big car and didn’t want to risk knocking them).

Well out marches Mr Nextdoor when he sees me getting out of the car and he shouts from his front door ‘I hope you’ve not got out to move my bin??’

I didn’t quite process what he said in time and I thought he was apologising that his bin was on the track, so I said ‘I need to get on our drive so I’ll just move it back don’t worry it’s no problem!’

I carried on and he ran over and said ‘no no leave the bin where it is this is our property!’ Confused

So I said ‘I need to put the car on the drive and don’t want to damage your bin so can you move it please if you don’t want me to?’

It went back and forth but basically, the upshot of the conversation is he thinks the shared track is owned by him, and he wants to start keeping his bins on the track so the bin men will collect them from there and he won’t have to move them.

I don’t believe the track is owned by them, I’m pretty confident it’s not owned by either of us. I didn’t want to argue on the street so I left the conversation by offering to take his bins down the track and back again to his bin store on bin day but he said they didn’t need that thank you. So I said well the bins can’t stay where they are and I’ll need to check the deeds.

I’m sympathetic to them getting older so don’t want to start a fight, but if they don’t own the track (which I’m confident they dont), are they allowed to leave their bin there under any circumstances? How do I challenge it?

OP posts:
Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 30/12/2023 13:26

I think it might need a solictor's letter. One which says in very clear and concise terms that he does NOT own the land (whatever fibs he may be telling in the slightly weird hope that you will just believe him) and he is obstructing your path with his bins, which must be stored on his own property.

He may just be so used to getting his own way with half-truths and downright lies, that he believes that he's slightly superior intellectually to everyone else. He might well only listen to someone with what he would term Professional Qualifications.

Plus a solicitor's letter starts a paper trail in case things get heated.

TheWalkingDeadly · 30/12/2023 13:20

My parents have had similar issues and it did start with a extension request.
The man was older maybe 70s. Seemed to think he owned everything.
However it does seem a lot of men are reaching an age where they arent quite with it and getting 'mixed up' or younger ones are intentionally taking land and think noone will stand up to important them!
Personally it seems to corrolate where there has been an increase in expensive devices/equipment/land value. So trying to take inches of neighbours land.
(But its also been detached houses etc). People claiming fences moved - when its is in fact them doing it!
So yes i wouldnt be that surprised if there were something suspicious about the neighbour...

Op did you tell him he only has a ROW over your land?

Helar · 30/12/2023 12:17

If this is really out of character and he’s previously been polite and reasonable then I would be wondering if it’s early signs of dementia.

Silverbirchtwo · 30/12/2023 11:42

Initially did he think you maliciously moved his bins, rather than standing them up and putting them where you thought he wanted them. Perhaps try and explain that, it may all be a stupid misunderstanding.

Just keep moving the bins out of your way. Get a sign that says do not obstruct, driveway in use. Has he got a wife you could explain to?

Have all the information to hand and if he starts going on about it again. Say after our last discussion I did look up the legal position relative to the track, would you like to see it?

Jibo · 30/12/2023 11:32

Oof! Sounds like you're handling it perfectly. What a pain though!

YesThatsATurdOnTheRug · 30/12/2023 10:53

@2jacqi OP said when she first got the deeds that neighbour has a ROW over their land to access his property.

ArchetypalBusyMum · 30/12/2023 10:51

Wow.
Think you've discovered why his wife left and the kids never visit!
Is it worth writing him a letter saying you've always been good neighbors and your disappointed that he's happy to let that go for the sake of a change in his bin habits which is affecting you negatively.
Say ownership of the track or not, doesn't change the fact you need to be able to get to your property and it isn't reasonable to expect you to buy a different car so he can put his bins on the track.
If a polite friendly letter doesn't work, then I think a solicitors letter would be next.

2jacqi · 30/12/2023 10:50

@Philthedendron to be honest it looks like he does not have a right of way across your land. is he not meant to be entering and exiting his property by another route???

HarrumphryBogart · 30/12/2023 10:41

What a lunatic! Have you told him something along the lines of you'd be perfectly happy to discover he owned the driveway, it would make it easier for you to sue him for harassment and loss of amenity when he blocks your access. Your lawyer thinks you have a very good case with all the logged instances and photos you have taken.

Do keep logs btw, he's not going to suddenly become sane overnight.

GabriellaMontez · 30/12/2023 10:38

Wow. I wonder who or what triggered this belief after years of being amicable neighbours.

Philthedendron · 30/12/2023 10:35

Alas, no. The bins reappeared on Christmas Day. He said he has every right to put them there because he’s ‘spoken to the council’ and they have told him ‘in confidence’ that the title plans are wrong and he owns the lane as he owns the ‘original’ house.

Firstly, I have no idea what council employee is working over Christmas, they must be keen and secondly, it’s bollocks. I responded by saying ‘that’s unusual, as the title plans registered with the land registry are the standard point of reference so you’ll need to contact a conveyancing solicitor I imagine but in the meantime, please move your bins as you’re blocking our access’. He didn’t, so now DH is moving his bins right to the end of the lane every single time he sees them half way up. We had a knock on the door on 27th and were accused of stealing his bins, so we ignored him and reiterated that he can’t block our access, so either he keeps his bins in his bin store or we will continue to move them out of our way without trespassing on his property which means moving them to the end of the lane.

OP posts:
Jibo · 30/12/2023 09:43

Did this get sorted @Philthedendron ?

Laiste · 21/12/2023 20:59

God you've more patience than me OP.

Thing is; DH has even less! So it would be me trying to sort it same as you are.

Philthedendron · 21/12/2023 19:38

Nanny0gg · 21/12/2023 19:26

Do they show a right of way to your property?

How long have you lived there?

Asked and answered!

Are you worried about his mental capacity at all?

Edited

No, no worries about his capacity. He’s very well spoken, able to form coherent (even if batshit) arguments and he’s still working from what I can tell. He travels alone all over the world, he’s still driving, he responded to my points articulately and coherently so although you can never be sure, I just think he’s a very proud man who’s lived alone a long time and perhaps is quite used to being right.

OP posts:
Philthedendron · 21/12/2023 19:35

Nanny0gg · 21/12/2023 19:26

Do they show a right of way to your property?

How long have you lived there?

Asked and answered!

Are you worried about his mental capacity at all?

Edited

So they don’t need to - our boundary actually extends across the front of his gates and he has right of access over ‘our’ land. Reattached diagram for reference.

His house actually faces the other way, so the ‘front’ of his house is actually the other side of the building and he has a big garden to the side. There’s then a tarmaced area at the ‘back’ of his house and a gate like a rear yard (the bit on the diagram) on which he parks his car and stores his bins. So I think the reason the access is like it is is because it’s the front of our house but the back of his, so they’ve carved it up to give us access for a car to swing into our garage which was added in the 60’s.

My neighbour and his flying bins
OP posts:
Icanttellyouanything · 21/12/2023 19:34

CrotchetyQuaver · 21/12/2023 13:39

He sounds a silly old sod with not enough going on to occupy his life meaningfully. Have you got a husband you can send round for a chat? I hate the sight of bins left out all week at the gate, just looks scruffy. I'd be quite tempted to use them for target practice if a chat about who owns what doesn't do the job. Regarding your extension, if it meets local planning policy and is on the far side away from him, it's very unlikely his objection would stop it anyway...

Why does it need a man to sort it out?

Nanny0gg · 21/12/2023 19:26

Philthedendron · 21/12/2023 12:36

I’ve got our deeds but not theirs, I can get that from the land registry though can’t I?

Do they show a right of way to your property?

How long have you lived there?

Asked and answered!

Are you worried about his mental capacity at all?

Philthedendron · 21/12/2023 19:23

MaggieFS · 21/12/2023 19:20

Gosh he's hard work. Well done OP.

I just think he’s very proud and didn’t want to be seen to be wrong. That’s fine by me, I don’t need to ‘win’ I just need his bin out of the way!

Im hoping he just doesn’t put it back again.

OP posts:
MaggieFS · 21/12/2023 19:20

Gosh he's hard work. Well done OP.

Philthedendron · 21/12/2023 19:18

I’m back, we had a threshold conversation because he didn’t invite me in which was slightly awkward.

Anyway, he was initially very defiant and ‘I’ll put my bins anywhere on my own property thank you’ so I did end up producing the deeds. He was very upset I’d got the deeds and accused me of spying on his property and getting the title plans under false pretences from the land registry. I did explain you can just buy them online but he’s convinced I’ve called the council and bribed them because I’m ‘pally’ with the planning office Confused. He said this in a half joking way but I’m not sure he was actually joking - I have no idea where that comment has come from, only thing I can think is that we know many of the local labour councillors through various bits of charity and community stuff and they’ve been round a few times, but they have nothing to do with planning and don’t even control the council!

He says the deeds aren’t real because his house was originally the only property that stood at the end of the lane and the lane was owned by the original farm. As his house is the original farm house, the lane therefore belongs to him.

Our house was built on the land in the late 1800’s when the original farm and land was sold off, so there is no way this is true. I explained that the title deeds are the title deeds and there’s no room for interpretation in them, and just repeated that he can’t block access to our house with his bin.

He then said he’s going to contact ‘the courts’ to see about it because he’s lived there 30 years and ‘knows his property’ and what he’s entitled to. I said he was welcome to, but that the title deeds are the reference point for where the boundaries are.

He said he will move his bins back into his drive ‘temporarily’ while the wind is bad, but doesn’t accept he was blocking access and thinks we should get a smaller car if we want to live here because ours is too big for the road Hmm. I’ve offered again to help him on bin days but he’s refused the help which is fine.

If the bins reappear in just going to keep moving them I think.

OP posts:
CaroleSinger · 21/12/2023 19:08

Rather than going straight in with telling he he can't do this or that, I'd just be saying you printed the deeds and the drive does not belong to either of you then hand them to him and let him join the dots.

Failing that I'm here for the fallout....😀

scoobydoo1971 · 21/12/2023 18:57

The council will collect bins for elderly or disabled people from any reasonable place within their property boundary. I have this in place, and it is considered a reasonable adjustment. I would write a note to your neighbour stating that placing the bins where he wants imposes a risk of personal injury and/ or property damage to your car. Therefore, you are advising him not to do it as you would be forced to make a claim on his insurance if anything happened in the future, like his bin hit your wing mirror. For reference, I incurred life threatening injuries from a large wheelie bin during lockdown when it fell on me. This left me with nerve and vascular damage, and a paralysed arm, so strange things do happen! As for the bit of land. Assuming it is not registered and no one officially owns it, the neighbour could have his mind set on applying to the Land Registry to claim adverse possession and ownership of it. I know someone who successfully did this to an abandoned garage adjoining a freehold house they owned, where the owners of the garage freehold could not be traced. It is not easy but possible, especially with unregistered land with no apparent owner known to the Land Registry.

Orangewall · 21/12/2023 18:55

Philthedendron · 21/12/2023 18:32

We’ve also mowed his lawn(with his permission) when he was on holiday in the summer, taken in parcels for him and fed his pond fish on the odd occasion too. He usually drops a note through our door if he needs something and asks very politely if we wouldn’t mind lending a hand which we of course never do. We offered to maintain his garden for him while we was away for a month a couple of years ago and he was very pleased.

I hope you casually bring this up when you’re over there, my neighbour occasionally brings my bins in when she can and I couldn’t be more grateful! I can’t imagine being arsey about it (I do return the favour but she’s too fast for me sometimes!)

Oldtigernidster · 21/12/2023 18:52

Your solicitor should have sorted this out when you purchased the property, either your neighbour owns it, you own it or there is shared access. I would check with them, might be able to clarify it for you. I can’t imagine it wasn’t clarified at the time as it’s such a crucial point.

HappyHamsters · 21/12/2023 18:37

The council offer bin collections for people with mobility and health issues

Swipe left for the next trending thread