Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My neighbour and his flying bins

137 replies

Philthedendron · 21/12/2023 12:34

I just need a quick sense check that I’m not being unreasonable here, I’m off work sick at the moment and I’ve lost all sense of proportion. I’ve NC’d because I have an active thread running under my main user name on a health issue that’s identifiable but I’m a long term user.

So, I live at the end of a short track that branches into 2 drives: my neighbours drive and mine. We’ve had high winds for a couple of nights, so the last couple of mornings I’ve found next doors bins blocking the shared track. As you do, I’ve just moved them out of the way and popped them back on his drive on his hard standing area where he keeps his bins.

I got back from dropping the kids off this morning and noticed the bins were back on the track, blocking access to our house (I could have squeezed passed them but I’m in a big car and didn’t want to risk knocking them).

Well out marches Mr Nextdoor when he sees me getting out of the car and he shouts from his front door ‘I hope you’ve not got out to move my bin??’

I didn’t quite process what he said in time and I thought he was apologising that his bin was on the track, so I said ‘I need to get on our drive so I’ll just move it back don’t worry it’s no problem!’

I carried on and he ran over and said ‘no no leave the bin where it is this is our property!’ Confused

So I said ‘I need to put the car on the drive and don’t want to damage your bin so can you move it please if you don’t want me to?’

It went back and forth but basically, the upshot of the conversation is he thinks the shared track is owned by him, and he wants to start keeping his bins on the track so the bin men will collect them from there and he won’t have to move them.

I don’t believe the track is owned by them, I’m pretty confident it’s not owned by either of us. I didn’t want to argue on the street so I left the conversation by offering to take his bins down the track and back again to his bin store on bin day but he said they didn’t need that thank you. So I said well the bins can’t stay where they are and I’ll need to check the deeds.

I’m sympathetic to them getting older so don’t want to start a fight, but if they don’t own the track (which I’m confident they dont), are they allowed to leave their bin there under any circumstances? How do I challenge it?

OP posts:
Tinysoxxx · 01/01/2024 14:38

When you go on the land registry you can ‘drop a pin’ over the drive where his bins are and it will tell you who owns it. It will no doubt be an old landowning family. If your services pipes run underneath, their permission will be needed to access them.

porridgecrumble · 01/01/2024 14:32

Ixoral · 01/01/2024 14:29

OP has said she has already got both sets of deeds & shown them to him.

I saw that when I refreshed the page. Should have checked before posting.

porridgecrumble · 01/01/2024 14:30

Have you not got the searches in your legal documents from when you bought the property? Unless your solicitor didn't do their job all this information about who owns the track should be in there.
My parents bought a bungalow at the end of a shared track and everything had to be documented and checked. All the original conveyancing paperwork was needed when the property was sold and the buyers insisted we took out an insurance policy in case they had any problems after they bought it.

Daffodilsandtuplips · 01/01/2024 14:30

There will be a Covenant of some kind saying that it’s shared and neither of you own it. He can’t block access to your house and nor can either of you claim it. We’ve got the same set up between us and next door, our road is private and ends in a cul de sac, our house is the middle house of three and with ours it is within our boundary line but our solicitor made it clear it was shared. It’s to allow us both to use as a space to reverse into to exit the road. Don’t back down OP.
The refuse wagon doesn’t come down our road, the bins are pulled out onto the pavement on the main road road at the end of our road. It sounds like op does the same.,

Ixoral · 01/01/2024 14:29

porridgecrumble · 01/01/2024 14:15

Your solicitor would have done searches during your purchase of the property so you could check those before you go to the expense of buying his deeds.

OP has said she has already got both sets of deeds & shown them to him.

porridgecrumble · 01/01/2024 14:15

Your solicitor would have done searches during your purchase of the property so you could check those before you go to the expense of buying his deeds.

Vinculum · 01/01/2024 14:12

If a bin lorry can fit down the lane isn’t there enough room for your car and a bin?

I may have misunderstood but I took OP to mean that the bins are kept in the bin store by the house but unreasonable neighbour normally (until this recent weirdness) takes them down the (short) track to be collected on bin day. From her post:

I left the conversation by offering to take his bins down the track and back again to his bin store on bin day

So I was assuming the bin lorry itself doesn’t go up the track, the bins are collected from the street end of the track.

wronginalltherightways · 01/01/2024 14:11

I think others are right: he can't be wrong, which probably explains why his wife left him and his grown up children don't visit. And those likely truths haven't changed him: he's doubled down and lied to boot.

So you'll probably need legal advice and a cease and desist letter.

BungleandGeorge · 01/01/2024 13:52

you need to find out who the lane actually belongs to and what rights you actually have. I expect the trigger was your extension plans as it’s potentially going to cause a lot of disruption, including an increase in traffic and noise. If his back is a problem I think the council are required to help people with health conditions and disabilities to sort their bins out so you could suggest he requests the bin collection people collect the bin from his property. If a bin lorry can fit down the lane isn’t there enough room for your car and a bin? How difficult is it making your access?

Liz1tummypain · 01/01/2024 13:50

If you are planning on an extension I would walk on eggshells. Having neighbours unhappy is so much hassle. That's all I'd say

starlingsintheslipstream · 01/01/2024 13:47

I'd be wanting to find out for sure who owns the road before going any further. Though clearly he shouldn't be blocking a shared access. The telephone/telegraph pole wouldn't be a definitive indicator of it having been adopted. You need to find out if it's registered and get the register for that. A search of the index map is the first step:

www.gov.uk/government/publications/official-searches-of-the-index-map/practice-guide-10-official-search-of-the-index-map

SlightlyJaded · 01/01/2024 13:44

All the details aside, it's very strange that he has gone from being amicable and reasonable to obsessive and unreasonable. I wonder if there is something else going on and the bins/lane are just something he has fixated on? I don't necessarily mean early-onset dementia, but some sort of mental breakdown. If he had always been grumpy and pedantic, you'd know where this was coming from and that's what I thought until he started saying the 'deeds are not real' and suggesting he has been talking to someone in the council secretly.

I know you've said the family have disappeared but is there anyone else you can talk to about him?

Practically speaking, call the council in the new year. Establish that the deeds are real (which of course they are) and ask for this in writing. Take it from there.

JoyeuxNarwhal · 01/01/2024 13:35

mamacorn1 · 01/01/2024 13:26

Go round with the deeds and show him. It’s important he knows and then you can shake hands and all put to bed. He is clearly a nutter, but in the case of making an amicable solution I would go round and show him first hand.

Op has already done that and it didn't work...

Presterjohn71 · 01/01/2024 13:27

I would drop off a copy of the deeds with a friendly note saying "turns out it's shared" and then leave the ball in his court.

mamacorn1 · 01/01/2024 13:26

Go round with the deeds and show him. It’s important he knows and then you can shake hands and all put to bed. He is clearly a nutter, but in the case of making an amicable solution I would go round and show him first hand.

JoyeuxNarwhal · 01/01/2024 13:23

As a man living alone how on earth does he generate enough rubbish in 2 weeks to make his bins very heavy?! <Misses point of thread>

Also, when we had a long drive we'd hook the wheelie bin onto the towbar of the car and take it down that way, maybe suggest that to him @Philthedendron if he's struggling and not just being an arse

AlisonDonut · 01/01/2024 13:16

Even if he does own the lane, if you have right of way then he can't block it.

DeeLusional · 01/01/2024 13:16

Philthedendron · 21/12/2023 12:39

Tempting Grin

We've just applied for planning permission for an extension and I really don’t want to annoy this guy if I can help it - he’s already verbally agreed that the extension plans are fine by him (isn’t near the boundary and we wrote to them before submitting the plans) but I don’t have anything in writing..

He has no power to block your planning application if the council would otherwise grant it, councils take very little notice of neighbours' objections.

Faceache45 · 01/01/2024 12:50

Philthedendron · 30/12/2023 10:35

Alas, no. The bins reappeared on Christmas Day. He said he has every right to put them there because he’s ‘spoken to the council’ and they have told him ‘in confidence’ that the title plans are wrong and he owns the lane as he owns the ‘original’ house.

Firstly, I have no idea what council employee is working over Christmas, they must be keen and secondly, it’s bollocks. I responded by saying ‘that’s unusual, as the title plans registered with the land registry are the standard point of reference so you’ll need to contact a conveyancing solicitor I imagine but in the meantime, please move your bins as you’re blocking our access’. He didn’t, so now DH is moving his bins right to the end of the lane every single time he sees them half way up. We had a knock on the door on 27th and were accused of stealing his bins, so we ignored him and reiterated that he can’t block our access, so either he keeps his bins in his bin store or we will continue to move them out of our way without trespassing on his property which means moving them to the end of the lane.

I imagine that ti's is why he's single and his kids don't visit him. He is pigheaded and can't be wrong. What a prat.

I'd contact the council yourself.

TheBerry · 01/01/2024 12:32

Love the thread OP.

Hoping for further updates as the saga progresses.

GrannyAchingsShepherdsHut · 01/01/2024 12:30

@Philthedendron if the lane is registered with the LR - it may not be if it's not been sold since it became compulsory - then you should be able to get the parcel number from this map, and then order the deeds for the lane itself.

https://www.arcgis.com/apps/StorytellingSwipe/index.html?appid=c445c71c1d494f38b13e0dc0f4e8f584#map

It does sound like he's either backed himself into a corner and now won't admit he's wrong, or he's having some cognitive decline and it's manifesting as him believing this weird thing about the lane and he's reordering facts to suit that belief.

I know someone who got into a very expensive and protracted legal battle over land, and it was only after several years that it became apparent that the problem was dementia, his wife, the other party and both sets of solicitors were completely convinced that he genuinely believed what he was saying (he did!) and that he had some legal basis for the claims he was making about verbal contracts etc - it turned out it was all in his head once the dementia started affecting other areas of his life. It was very sad.

Story Map Swipe and Spyglass

This story map was created with the Esri Story Map Swipe and Spyglass application in ArcGIS Online.

https://www.arcgis.com/apps/StorytellingSwipe/index.html?appid=c445c71c1d494f38b13e0dc0f4e8f584#map

LauderSyme · 31/12/2023 13:23

He really doesn't like being wrong, does he? It's such a shame you are now having to deal with his arrogant idiocy. It must be causing you stress and it might have to cost you money too. What a pain.

DyslexicPoster · 31/12/2023 12:53

PuttingDownRoots · 21/12/2023 12:39

Even if h does own the track,it sounds like you have row over it... so no he cant put his bins there anyway!

This. I own a shared drive. It's on my house deeds. Normally someone has to own it. I can not block access

LookItsMeAgain · 31/12/2023 12:47

I'd contact a solicitor to see if you can get a "cease and desist" letter written up. He can use the laneway to move his bins up and down from his property on the days when there is a bin collection and apart from that, he has no permission to use the lane for the storage of his bins.

If you are the only ones who use the lane for vehicular access, you might want to see if it's worth it to get an electric gate or some of those bollards that are activated when you approach and go into the ground and then rise up again when you're passed them, though a gate would probably be easier to install.

Klcak · 30/12/2023 13:34

What a horrible petty wanker. Who is lying through his teeth about the council.