Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s going to look like I’m copying my SiL

235 replies

Purplegirly01 · 21/12/2023 12:13

I need some honest advice.

My brother & SIL got engaged a couple of years ago and married this year. I got engaged this year and my wedding is all booked and arranged for next year.

I’d jokingly said to my now fiancé that I expected a bigger engagement ring than my SIL’s - unfortunately he took it literally and got
exactly the same ring, but my centre diamond is quite visibly bigger. My DB and SIL never commented on my ring at all, however I’ve heard through mutual friends that they were both really upset by it. It was embarrassing for me having people comment on how similar they are but I didn’t want to make my fiancé feel awkward about it.

Fast forward to their wedding, and my SIL’s wedding dress is really similar to the one I had already ordered & paid for. I was honestly devastated and could barely hold it together on the day. Everyone kept asking me if I was ok but I obviously couldn’t say what the issue was.

My mum is the only person who has seen my dress and she said it’s fine, no one will remember her dress & compare but I can’t help feeling that I look like a massive copy cat especially with the rings too! I really don’t know what to do - it’s my dream dress but I’m worried I look silly with all the similarities. My SIL and I are not close at all, we are very different people and she’s not really my sort of person and I find her quite formal and uptight which is another reason why I feel so awkward about the dress being so similar.

YABU - you look like you’re copying
YANBU - no one will notice

OP posts:
PossumintheHouse · 21/12/2023 13:05

You “joked” that you wanted a bigger ring, and then made a show of yourself at her wedding by being visibly upset to her guests? Jesus Christ.

randomusername2020 · 21/12/2023 13:05

This reply has been withdrawn

Removed at poster's request due to privacy concerns.

GreatGateauxsby · 21/12/2023 13:04

It will be really weird. Especially all the drama at her wedding with you being so upset people asked about it….
You will be perceived as totally weird as there too many similarities for it to be random.

things you can and should do….

You should pick a diff colour scheme….even if it costs you some money.

The dress is (unfortunately) the dress. You can however get an evening / wedding breakfast dress (like meghan markle did)

Also make sure your flowers are very different.

I’d also just say to your DP you don’t like the ring and you’d like to reset it
then reset your ring (if there is a halo remove it, if it’s white gold recast in yellow etc) it sounds like you don’t LOVE it anyway

MercyIsEliminated · 21/12/2023 13:03

You were “devastated” because your SIL’s dress was similar to yours? And you were so upset at the wedding that people kept asking what was wrong? You must know that your reaction was absurd and your behaviour was ridiculously attention seeking.

Absolutely no one will notice any similarities between the two wedding dresses.

RoseGoldEagle · 21/12/2023 13:02

No one will remember what her dress was like (other than her), and it sounds like they’re both fairly traditional dresses with some differences anyway. To be honest if a friend bought the exact same wedding dress as me- unless she actually wore it on my wedding day- I wouldn’t care in the slightest, why would I?! Like I’d be thinking ‘oh my GOD! I thought I looked amazing- and now- SHE looks amazing and it’s not fair!’ I honestly don’t get the drama. It’s just a day, you wear what you want and go for colours you like- it doesn’t have to define your whole personality.

The ring thing is odd- it seems a shame that you haven’t got a ring you love, regardless of whether it’s similar or not, or bigger or not, than someone else’s.

Hopefully you won’t really like the same baby names OP!

PostmansKnock · 21/12/2023 13:02

Whoops....same colour scheme.

PostmansKnock · 21/12/2023 13:01

I think everyone will think you are copying her. Confused Same ring, such a similar dress that you went to pieces on her wedding day and the same dress.

Pinkdelight3 · 21/12/2023 13:01

the lead time on my dress is 10 months

Christ, reminds me why I married in Vegas. This level of wedding aggro is madness - you could build a house - or make a new human - in less time!

Between the comment about the ring and the way your acted at her wedding, you sound like this is a thing so won't be able to pull off breezily genuinely not-copying. I'd look into changing the dress or it's going to blight the year and beyond.

maras2 · 21/12/2023 13:00

I wouldn't even notice the similarities, Not the sort of thing that bothers me. BUT. There will be many who will and will probably be 'team SIL'.
Sort it now to save a lifetime of argy bargy and ill will.
Good luck.

Luckygreenduck · 21/12/2023 13:00

I would change your colour scheme and make sure your hair/ veil etc. are quite different. The same dress can look quite different depending on how it is styled.
I am not sure it matter too much but it clearly matters to you if you are so upset. I would speak to your SIL about it as well to take away the worry about her reaction on the day.

Barleysugar86 · 21/12/2023 12:59

I don't understand all the fuss at all. It never occured to me to compare my ring or dress with anyone? I can't even recall my dress all that much if I'm honest. Are you not adding a second ring to your engagement ring at the wedding? That will change the look a bit.

Honestly I'd just ignore it. Likely noone will remember the dress next year. And if SIL said anything she'd sound a bit odd herself- wedding dresses don't change much!

SisterAgatha · 21/12/2023 12:59

Gosh I wish you were my SIL. It’s nice to have someone care about this. On my 40th my SIL booked the same lunch venue (like an idiot I told her where) at the same time, brought a 40 cake along and had her friends sing happy birthday to her, on MY birthday in MY venue (it was her birthday 2 weeks before).

she won’t accept any accusations of copying.

she could literally climb in to my skin and wear me as a puppet and not get accused of copying me.

do what you like. No one will notice unless it’s in the extreme 🙂

HeckyPeck · 21/12/2023 12:59

I wouldn't notice the same colour scheme unless it's really out there or you both have a batman theme or something. I'm assuming different venues so it will look completely different anyway.

The dress sounds different enough with a different skirt and neckline that I wouldn't think anything of it.

The ring is done now and can't be helped! SIL sounds oversensitive and a bit mean to her husband to be complaining about the same rings but hers being smaller. There are only so many variations on engagement rings if you go for diamond.

Feelinadequate23 · 21/12/2023 12:58

OP if you're not close to her then does it really matter? if you're not keen on the ring then ask DF to change it to something different. Presumably the only cross-over in guests will be OH's family, so I wouldn't care about the dress unless you also have same body type and same colour hair - as then you might end up looking like a carbon copy! Maybe change the colour scheme now though, as you have time. At least of the flowers if you already have bridesmaid dresses.

museumum · 21/12/2023 12:58

I think you need to change your colour scheme. Sorry, but you can maybe get away with the dress (if your hair/accessories are very different) but not added to the same colour scheme. You'll just look weird. It's the disadvantage of doing this so close to their wedding, but you just have to suck it up.

PeppermintParty · 21/12/2023 12:56

Could you link to two similar, but not identical pictures of wedding dresses on the internet, so we can see how similar or not so similar they are?

Janieforever · 21/12/2023 12:54

Allofaflutter · 21/12/2023 12:52

Nobody remembers dresses. And 90% of wedding dresses are practically the same anyway. It’s fashion that drives that. Nobody will notice from your guests and sil wil just have to lump it.

Pretty sure her sil, her bil, and her pil will all remember, as will, many other close people, you don’t remember actively, but if you see someone in pretty much the same dress, with the same ring and the same colour scheme, you remember.

OrigamiOwl · 21/12/2023 12:54

If you were so upset that at their wedding people were asking if you were okay then you've been OTT

FriedasCarLoad · 21/12/2023 12:54

I think you need to speak to SIL or write to her.

You can apologise that you've ended up with a similar ring and explain that B your fiancé knew you thought hers was beautiful and didn't realise it would be insensitive to get the same ring. And you didn't want to hurt his feelings by asking him to change the ring.

And you can explain that you had chosen your wedding dress and colour scheme before her wedding, and maybe show her the proof of this.

And you could think about other ways in which you could make your wedding less like hers. Maybe having flowers in a contrasting colour would make the colour scheme seem less similar? Maybe your veil/hair/accessories could be very different?

I can imagine making jokey comments about a ring. And it wouldn't occur to me to delay choosing a wedding dress and bridesmaid dresses until after someone else's wedding, just in case there were similarities. I'm not sure why some PPs don't believe you.

Motnight · 21/12/2023 12:54

I really hope that you didn't make your SIL's wedding day all about you, Op...

Allofaflutter · 21/12/2023 12:52

Nobody remembers dresses. And 90% of wedding dresses are practically the same anyway. It’s fashion that drives that. Nobody will notice from your guests and sil wil just have to lump it.

Janieforever · 21/12/2023 12:52

What’s caused this op? Are you insecure in your own taste? In awe of her? Jealous of her?

BeardieWeirdie · 21/12/2023 12:51

Make sure flowers and bridesmaid dresses are different, and that if she’s gone for festival/black tie/50s/country chic/Gatsby theme that you’re not copying that too. I can’t remember what my sister’s wedding dress was like, I doubt anyone else bar your SIL will remember. You could always adapt yours - shorten the sleeves? - if you think the dresses are too similar.

And try not to announce your pregnancy the day her baby is born.

SunshineYay · 21/12/2023 12:50

Did you choose and buy the dress before your SIL did? Did you see SIL's dress before you paid for yours? Why have you chosen the same colour theme for your wedding? Sounds like you're copying your SIL.

SecondUsername4me · 21/12/2023 12:50

Ring - "hey fiance, this is identical to my brothers wife's ring which I feel a bit odd about, can we go swap it this weekend?"
Done

Dress - "mum, can you let me know if you think DB and SIL will think I've gone for the same dress as her? What do you think?"

Colourscheme - just change it.