Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s going to look like I’m copying my SiL

235 replies

Purplegirly01 · 21/12/2023 12:13

I need some honest advice.

My brother & SIL got engaged a couple of years ago and married this year. I got engaged this year and my wedding is all booked and arranged for next year.

I’d jokingly said to my now fiancé that I expected a bigger engagement ring than my SIL’s - unfortunately he took it literally and got
exactly the same ring, but my centre diamond is quite visibly bigger. My DB and SIL never commented on my ring at all, however I’ve heard through mutual friends that they were both really upset by it. It was embarrassing for me having people comment on how similar they are but I didn’t want to make my fiancé feel awkward about it.

Fast forward to their wedding, and my SIL’s wedding dress is really similar to the one I had already ordered & paid for. I was honestly devastated and could barely hold it together on the day. Everyone kept asking me if I was ok but I obviously couldn’t say what the issue was.

My mum is the only person who has seen my dress and she said it’s fine, no one will remember her dress & compare but I can’t help feeling that I look like a massive copy cat especially with the rings too! I really don’t know what to do - it’s my dream dress but I’m worried I look silly with all the similarities. My SIL and I are not close at all, we are very different people and she’s not really my sort of person and I find her quite formal and uptight which is another reason why I feel so awkward about the dress being so similar.

YABU - you look like you’re copying
YANBU - no one will notice

OP posts:
BoredofBlonde · 21/12/2023 13:21

BigBouncyBaubles · 21/12/2023 13:14

I was honestly devastated and could barely hold it together on the day. Everyone kept asking me if I was ok but I obviously couldn’t say what the issue was.

Eek. Like one of those people who posts a vague Facebook status about how 'you can't trust anyone' but refuse to elaborate in the hope of getting lots of 'u ok hunni?' style concerned replies. Yuck.

100% this.

What a drama queen you sound. I dont even know you or your SiL, and I am on her side already.

WickDittington · 21/12/2023 13:21

YABU but not because people will think you’re copying but because your whole OP is really rather snidely nasty about your SiL.

You might want to reflect on why you feel a desperate need to compete with her and why your behaviour at her wedding was all about you?

Namenamchange · 21/12/2023 13:20

Purplegirly01 · 21/12/2023 12:39

I didn’t think he was actually going to get the same ! It was just in the context of they got engaged first so as I’ve waited longer, you need to make up for it. It was a joke

I’m not sure it was a joke, not sure what’s funny about it. Sounds more like a put down.

However you are now in a situation of your own creating where you are copying her, you need to change some things up; tbh you are coming across as a little unkind.

easylikeasundaymorn · 21/12/2023 13:18

To be honest I'm surprised that you didn't think to ask your SIL what her dress was like before you settled on yours, given by this time you were already aware of the issue with the ring. Surely its a normal question to check with another family member who is getting married at a similar time to you? In fact, asking about the dress is a normal question even if you weren't getting married yourself. Did neither you, your mum or anyone show any interest in SIL's dress over the many months between her choosing it and you choosing yours?? Did she not ask you about yours? It doesn't seem like you like each other very much!

Mmmm19 · 21/12/2023 13:17

I think you are getting a hard time here. I can imagine someone making that joke in private and can also imagine some dopey unimaginative partner taking it literally (looking at you OH who goes to his sister and my mum and shop assistants to help him choose gifts and jewellery rather than listening to me). I can see how the dress could happen too- hopefully an honest conversation with your SIL will clear the air but it will depend on them as well as you approaching it tactfully

RandomButtons · 21/12/2023 13:16

Honesty OP just get over it. A lot of wedding dresses are very similar. Just make sure you do everything else different. Add a belt or cap sleeve to dress. Wear different jewlery. Do your hair down rather than up if she had hers up. Pick different colours for bridesmaids and flowers. Use a different venue. Don’t let the men wear identical suits to your brothers.

It’s very very easy to make your day different. Unless there’s more going on here? Seems very OTT to be crying at someone else’s dress choice.

BitOutOfPractice · 21/12/2023 13:16

The only thing you’ve done that would piss me off if I were the sil is being visibly upset at my wedding. WTF?!

HeckyPeck · 21/12/2023 13:15

I've also just googled long sleeved lace wedding dresses and there are so many different styles. I really doubt anyone will think anything of it as the skirt and neckline are different.

StolenCookie · 21/12/2023 13:14

Erm. I think the big mistake here is the ring. If the ring had been different then the similar dress wouldn’t have mattered. Your fiancé buying basically the same ring but with a bigger stone is really not a good look and comes across very tacky I’m sorry to say!

BigBouncyBaubles · 21/12/2023 13:14

I was honestly devastated and could barely hold it together on the day. Everyone kept asking me if I was ok but I obviously couldn’t say what the issue was.

Eek. Like one of those people who posts a vague Facebook status about how 'you can't trust anyone' but refuse to elaborate in the hope of getting lots of 'u ok hunni?' style concerned replies. Yuck.

Mary28 · 21/12/2023 13:13

I wasn't sure which vote made sense but do not let the wedding stuff get out of hand in your head. You cannot control what anyone says or does or thinks so let it go. Enjoy your dress, your ring, your wedding and your life. I know easier said than done but my point is, stop worrying about what people think and the things you can't control and have confidence in yourself and your decisions.

FastBlueHedgehog · 21/12/2023 13:12

Wait until you've been married for 25 years and you will realise how utterly irrelevant your devastation is. FFS it's one day. Literally no one will give a shit.

RandomButtons · 21/12/2023 13:11

Thementalloadisreal · 21/12/2023 12:29

Honestly, just find a different dress. The dress is for one day, she’ll be your sister in law forever.

Not that simple with wedding dresses. A lot of them are made to order and paid for up front. OP could easily have already spent £1000-3000 on the dress, that’s too much for most people to “just buy a new one”.

Janieforever · 21/12/2023 13:11

PossumintheHouse · 21/12/2023 13:05

You “joked” that you wanted a bigger ring, and then made a show of yourself at her wedding by being visibly upset to her guests? Jesus Christ.

It’s just weird. I mean to be so upset people have to check your 0k at her wedding, to make such a show of yourself, coupled with everting else, the ring joke, that her fiancé though was serious, the dress, the him having to make up for the fact the sil got engaged first, the colour scheme.

I wonder why she’s doing it though,

OhwhyOY · 21/12/2023 13:09

Couldn't you have returned and exchanged the ring? Pretty awful not to have, and for your partner to think it was OK to try to one up them.

I'd either swap the dress or if you're absolutely unwilling to do so then I'd call her up and apologise and just say you seem to have very similar tastes, but you honestly aren't trying to copy her. Expect her to be upset though. I'd also apologise for your behaviour on her wedding day and explain that you were feeling terrible about the dress situation, though again I'd expect her to be upset and agree with PPs that your reaction was very OTT. I think you need to make a real effort here to avoid coming off as a jealous copycat unfortunately.

MTdazed · 21/12/2023 13:09

To be honest, if it's already bothering you then you need to change it.

Yes, it will look like you're copying her. Maybe not to everyone, but to some people at least, and it's your wedding day, do you really want anyone cringing for you that you're maybe trying to outdo them.

It is coming across a bit like that. Especially with the comment about waiting longer for the ring than her, your ring being bigger etc. It's all coming across a little tacky and sorry I'm sure you don't actually mean it to, but if I were you I would die at the thought of ppl thinking that's what my wedding was about. So I'd change colour scheme, and do whatever I could to make them different.

RoseGoldEagle · 21/12/2023 13:09

If you genuinely were in competition with someone though- you wouldn’t copy them, would you? You’d go for something you thought better? I don’t get any of this, am amazed some posters would think ‘wow OP must be copying her SIL- how sad’- why would it even be sad if she was?! I am so glad I don’t have this kind of drama in my life (or if people are thinking things like this about me that I don’t know it at any rate!!)

Highlyflavouredgravy · 21/12/2023 13:08

I call bs in this. Surely nobody can be this insensitive?

HeckyPeck · 21/12/2023 13:07

Janieforever · 21/12/2023 13:05

Are you in a different thread? The op specially said the sil had never mentioned the ring, never mind moan about it 😂

In the OP it says "My DB and SIL never commented on my ring at all, however I’ve heard through mutual friends that they were both really upset by it" so she obviously did moan about.

Myhusbandearns150k · 21/12/2023 13:06

Of all the engagement rings in the world he picked the same one. That’s ridiculous

tattygrl · 21/12/2023 13:06

How did your STBDH know which ring to buy to get an exact same version with bigger stone? It sounds like quite a lot of effort he'd have had to go to off the back of a jokey, throwaway comment from you. Did he ask his brother which ring he'd bought SIL?

Pinkdelight3 · 21/12/2023 13:06

The better reaction at her wedding would've been to seed it in a light-hearted way - "I love your dress - the one I've ordered is quite similar - great minds!" then laughed it off and enjoyed the rest of her wedding and then your wedding. The self-absorbness and angsting has made this a bigger problem.

MaggieNextDoor · 21/12/2023 13:06

You have time to change your wedding dress and sell your engagement ring for something unique and not a bigger and better copy of your sister in law's. People are going to think you are copying her and they might judge you unfavourably because of it. Change the colour scheme of the wedding too. Imitation is the biggest form of flattery but it's also creepy and ostentatious if yours is obviously bigger, better and more expensive.

BigBouncyBaubles · 21/12/2023 13:06

I'd definitely think you were in competition with your sister in law

Janieforever · 21/12/2023 13:05

HeckyPeck · 21/12/2023 12:59

I wouldn't notice the same colour scheme unless it's really out there or you both have a batman theme or something. I'm assuming different venues so it will look completely different anyway.

The dress sounds different enough with a different skirt and neckline that I wouldn't think anything of it.

The ring is done now and can't be helped! SIL sounds oversensitive and a bit mean to her husband to be complaining about the same rings but hers being smaller. There are only so many variations on engagement rings if you go for diamond.

Are you in a different thread? The op specially said the sil had never mentioned the ring, never mind moan about it 😂