Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s going to look like I’m copying my SiL

235 replies

Purplegirly01 · 21/12/2023 12:13

I need some honest advice.

My brother & SIL got engaged a couple of years ago and married this year. I got engaged this year and my wedding is all booked and arranged for next year.

I’d jokingly said to my now fiancé that I expected a bigger engagement ring than my SIL’s - unfortunately he took it literally and got
exactly the same ring, but my centre diamond is quite visibly bigger. My DB and SIL never commented on my ring at all, however I’ve heard through mutual friends that they were both really upset by it. It was embarrassing for me having people comment on how similar they are but I didn’t want to make my fiancé feel awkward about it.

Fast forward to their wedding, and my SIL’s wedding dress is really similar to the one I had already ordered & paid for. I was honestly devastated and could barely hold it together on the day. Everyone kept asking me if I was ok but I obviously couldn’t say what the issue was.

My mum is the only person who has seen my dress and she said it’s fine, no one will remember her dress & compare but I can’t help feeling that I look like a massive copy cat especially with the rings too! I really don’t know what to do - it’s my dream dress but I’m worried I look silly with all the similarities. My SIL and I are not close at all, we are very different people and she’s not really my sort of person and I find her quite formal and uptight which is another reason why I feel so awkward about the dress being so similar.

YABU - you look like you’re copying
YANBU - no one will notice

OP posts:
AcrossthePond55 · 21/12/2023 14:07

1- Engagement ring; My ring is actually a very popular style from the days of my engagement (36+years ago). I didn't care, it was classic then and is classic now. If it 'concerns' you that much, be sure you pick a different style wedding ring from your SiL or return the ring for something different.

2-The dress; I picked out my 'dream' dress only to find out that our NDN's daughter wore the exact same dress (our weddings were 5 months apart). Since our guest lists were just about identical (small town, lots of common friends), I found another 'dream dress'. If it 'concerns' you so much, pick another dress or have yours altered or redesigned.

3- The colour scheme: I had a Christmas wedding. Obviously my colour scheme was the same as probably 80% of the Christmas weddings back in the 80s, most brides chose either red or green back then. I didn't care, I kept my beautiful shade of Christmas green. If it 'concerns' you so much, pick a different colour.

Quit making your SiL's choices all about you.

WickDittington · 21/12/2023 14:05

And to be honest, I feel a bit sorry for the op. If you’re doing this then everything isn’t right.

Yes you’re right there - I feel sorry for someone who has so little else in her life …

Look @Purplegirly01 get a hobby, or do some volunteer work, or get a better education, so that your life revolves around more worthwhile things than competing with your SiL about your respective wedding dresses.

It’s just a dress. You have a live to live - try to live it more richly than this.

FairytaleOfKent · 21/12/2023 14:04

I wouldn't worry about the dress. You've already had a sour look on your face for your SIL's wedding. It's only fair that she has a chance to attention seek at your wedding, right?

It doesn't sound like you like your SIL very much and as you only really need to be cordial with one another at family gatherings, it doesn't really matter. Just get on with your life.

Mirabai · 21/12/2023 14:03

I mean it’s a ring and a dress they’re all fairly similar. The former is DH’s fault and the latter is no-one’s fault.

If you’re worried you could always talk to her about it.

Seaweed42 · 21/12/2023 14:03

It sounds like you don't like the ring.

Get the ring changed.

If its a constant and daily reminder for you then look at getting the ring done in a different setting.

You can't live with an engagement ring that you don't like or that it reminds you of these issues.

Go to the jewellers yourself and find out what the options and explain to them what the issue is and that you'd like a modification and what do they suggest?

It's a big deal for you and that's absolutely fine.

But you need to find a voice for yourself and make your own decisions and find your own peace with those decisions.

OneCup · 21/12/2023 14:03

You need to have a chat with her rather than let misunderstandings fester.

Janieforever · 21/12/2023 13:59

People having to ask the op if she was ok, on her sil wedding day makes it clear she was looking for attention, trying to make it about her. There is no reason anyone should know otherwise.

I don’t know if she’s copying or competing. Possibly both.

But this sort of thing does happen when someone has very low self esteem, a lack of confidence, and is envious or in awe of another person, if it’s bad enough they can move to copying or competing. Although doing it for engagement ring and wedding is really grim.

I do wonder if it’s just the wedding and ring, of it the op is doing this in other areas, holidays, home furnishings, social events, normal dress style etc.

good on the sil and bil for not saying anything. I feel a bit sorry for the sil. And to be honest, I feel a bit sorry for the op. If you’re doing this then everything isn’t right. It looks like the op has realised everyone will know , and she’s now worried,

pushbaum · 21/12/2023 13:58

Purplegirly01 · 21/12/2023 12:35

Unfortunately the colour schemes are similar too - same colour but different shades

Well change your 'colour scheme' then?

lapsedrdwhoenthusiast · 21/12/2023 13:56

I was honestly devastated and could barely hold it together on the day.

It does rather sound like you found a way to make your SIL's wedding all about you.

queenofallqueens · 21/12/2023 13:56

BigBouncyBaubles · 21/12/2023 13:50

My SIL and I are not close at all, we are very different people and she’s not really my sort of person

Except when looking for wedding inspo

a lil mean but so true🙂

Baffledandalarmed · 21/12/2023 13:55

I’d jokingly said to my now fiancé that I expected a bigger engagement ring than my SIL’s - unfortunately he took it literally and got
exactly the same ring, but my centre diamond is quite visibly bigger.

Why would anyone say this as a joke? It's a pretty sad/nasty/manipulative attempt at one. Surely no one would actually say that as a joke unless they are a massive bellend.

Tbh you lost me at this. Your poor SIL.

phoenixrosehere · 21/12/2023 13:55

Is this an issue to you because you don’t like your SIL and you have found that you two have more in common than you had thought despite you seeing her as uptight and formal?

Your focus on your SIL is odd when you’re not keen on her and the comment you made about her engagement ring was unnecessary.

If you’re going to spend the entire time worrying until your wedding and during about how similar things are to her wedding, just change things and eliminate the extra stress now while you can.

harriethoyle · 21/12/2023 13:54

You sound like a nightmare @Purplegirly01 I feel so sorry for your SIL

MargotBamborough · 21/12/2023 13:54

Does your fiancé know how you feel about the ring?

Could you talk to him and discuss exchanging it for a different ring which isn't a copy of your SIL's?

You could perhaps mention to your SIL that the ring comment was a silly joke, you didn't for one moment expect your fiancé to take it seriously and you would actually prefer not to have the same ring as her.

The dress is a tricker issue. If it's that similar then I think you might need to warn SIL in advance and explain that it was already ordered and paid for before her wedding and you obviously both just have very similar taste in dresses.

But beyond that, people don't own dress styles or colour schemes, and you shouldn't have to restrict your own choices about your own wedding just because she chose the styles and colours you happen to like for her wedding the previous year.

IdealisticCynic · 21/12/2023 13:52

SecondUsername4me · 21/12/2023 12:32

I was honestly devastated and could barely hold it together on the day

This is such an ott response.

Agreed!

BigBouncyBaubles · 21/12/2023 13:50

My SIL and I are not close at all, we are very different people and she’s not really my sort of person

Except when looking for wedding inspo

Gnomegnomegnome · 21/12/2023 13:49

Most wedding dresses look similar anyway.
Can’t you (don’t you want to) change the colour scheme so that it doesn’t look like you are basing the whole day on their wedding?

Maybe you could communicate with SIL and say your dress is really similar. Bonding and all that.

JoyeuxNarwhal · 21/12/2023 13:48

@Purplegirly01 if you're still going to wear the dress (and you should, it was presumably your favourite that you tried on etc) then I reckon telling sil beforehand is the way to go - and show her the receipt with the date you ordered it on!

piscofrisco · 21/12/2023 13:48

Change your colour scheme at least. Then speak to her about the dress to give her a heads up. And tbh I'd think the ring thing was dick behaviour in as much as I thought about it at all. What was your DP thinking? Has he no sensitivity at all? Weird and off thing to do. I get that bit wasn't your fault obvs.

NoCloudsAllowed · 21/12/2023 13:47

I couldn't bring myself to give a fuck about any of that

Thementalloadisreal · 21/12/2023 13:46

The other option is to just show SIL a photo of your dress and say hey look this is the dress I’d already paid for before, I think it’s similar to yours so I wanted you to know ahead of time that it wasn’t deliberate. She might be fine with it.

RogersOrganismicProcess · 21/12/2023 13:45

Is this really a problem? The ring and the dress are just materialistic details. What should matter most is the marriage and the life long relationships you will have with your new family members.

It sound like you are both more similar that you realise, same tastes in rings/dresses and same worries about ‘copying’.

Instead of letting this build into something it doesn’t need to be, speak with her openly and honestly about your fears and concerns. Use it as a moment to strengthen your relationship.

Emotionalsupportviper · 21/12/2023 13:44

Thementalloadisreal · 21/12/2023 12:29

Honestly, just find a different dress. The dress is for one day, she’ll be your sister in law forever.

This.

People may not notice the similarity on the day, but when they see the wedding photos they most certainly will. And as it is likely that a number of the guests will have been to both weddings and will have their own photos, it won't go unremarked.

Tooshytoshine · 21/12/2023 13:44

All rings and wedding dresses are pretty similar.

You are over thinking it. If you like it, wear it.

Charlize43 · 21/12/2023 13:44

I think your mum is right. Most people don't even notice the dress, worry that the catering and drinks are top shelf at your wedding as that's what most people remember and will comment on.