Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s going to look like I’m copying my SiL

235 replies

Purplegirly01 · 21/12/2023 12:13

I need some honest advice.

My brother & SIL got engaged a couple of years ago and married this year. I got engaged this year and my wedding is all booked and arranged for next year.

I’d jokingly said to my now fiancé that I expected a bigger engagement ring than my SIL’s - unfortunately he took it literally and got
exactly the same ring, but my centre diamond is quite visibly bigger. My DB and SIL never commented on my ring at all, however I’ve heard through mutual friends that they were both really upset by it. It was embarrassing for me having people comment on how similar they are but I didn’t want to make my fiancé feel awkward about it.

Fast forward to their wedding, and my SIL’s wedding dress is really similar to the one I had already ordered & paid for. I was honestly devastated and could barely hold it together on the day. Everyone kept asking me if I was ok but I obviously couldn’t say what the issue was.

My mum is the only person who has seen my dress and she said it’s fine, no one will remember her dress & compare but I can’t help feeling that I look like a massive copy cat especially with the rings too! I really don’t know what to do - it’s my dream dress but I’m worried I look silly with all the similarities. My SIL and I are not close at all, we are very different people and she’s not really my sort of person and I find her quite formal and uptight which is another reason why I feel so awkward about the dress being so similar.

YABU - you look like you’re copying
YANBU - no one will notice

OP posts:
MeMySonAnd1 · 21/12/2023 14:44

Computing? Competing meant to write)

MeMySonAnd1 · 21/12/2023 14:43

A friend of my sister copied my wedding to the point of stealing photos of my flowers from a family album. My sister was furious… I was flattered 😁

Engagement rings’ differences are so subtle that probably you are worrying for nothing, the only thing they may have noticed is that the stone is marginally bigger (and therefore more likely not to be a diamond) so nothing to worry about there unless…..

If your fiance created this situation by asking his brother the name and seller of the ring he got, I can see why the other couple may think you are a copy cat.

If the above is known to all the family, yes, YANBU to be worried about the dress. I would see if you can get a different one or modify the current one a bit so it doesn’t look as if you are computing with her, which I think you are as otherwise you wouldn’t have said to your fiance that you wanted a ring bigger than hers.

Raincloudsonasunnyday · 21/12/2023 14:42

I have to say, from the moment you described your 'joke' about the size of ring you 'expected' from your fiance, you haven't covered yourself in glory. Barely kept it together at their wedding; not a word about your brother in all this, only your SIL; it's all about you. I think the competition with your SIL is mainly in your head, and I don't think you like having any.

Don't know what I'd advise to someone like you: I don't think you'd take advice. I think you'd do whatever you wanted in the hopes that you'd "win", but are looking for people to tell you it's all okay and you're not doing anything wrong. Good luck with that. You started going wrong by even mentioning ring size.

EndOfMyTether11 · 21/12/2023 14:41

Nobody will give a shit, she's more likely to remember you acting weird on her wedding than anything. Time to grow up a bit!

seagull82 · 21/12/2023 14:40

Keep the dress, it's not something you should be worried about.. SIL is ridiculous if she causes drama over a dress.

clingon1012 · 21/12/2023 14:39

You are very strange and definitely unreasonable for saying you wanted a bigger ring and not being able to hold it together for your own brother's wedding (regardless of your feelings towards your SIL) over a dress. Plus the similarities with the colour scheme?? Seems like you DO want to upstage or copy your SIL no matter your excuses. Doesn't seem like the "bigger ring" comment was much of a joke if your fiancé - who should know you well enough! - took it literally.

Meadowflower2023 · 21/12/2023 14:38

You sound like hard work to me OP. Nobody will give a shit I'm sure.. but if they do, yes, it will look like you've copied her as you're always a step behind what she's doing. Agree with the PP saying it sounds like you admire SIL.

agentcooperinthewhitelodge · 21/12/2023 14:38

I was honestly devastated and could barely hold it together on the day.

Seriously this is ridiculous. If this is how you react over a dress you are going to find life very very hard in future. Bloody hell, you certainly enjoy drama don't you? you are making this into something huge and why were you "joking" about having a ring bigger than hers- what's that about? Sounds to me like you are in competition with her.

Pipsquiggle · 21/12/2023 14:37

Yes I would notice all those things - the ring and the dress. Some people won't.

Why did you keep the engagement ring? I am sure they had a returns policy if you didn't like it. You could probably ring them now and see if they will exchange it.

Your SIL's dress, sounds like you had a bit of a drama on their wedding day, which, TBH, is out of order. You said that your skirt is different, which may be its saving grace.

You do have agency to change stuff........... or not. Stop letting things happen to you.

Puddingpieplum · 21/12/2023 14:37

I think you're reaction / behaviour at her wedding was disgraceful, making such a show that people were asking if you were OK.
You will probably look like you copied her yes. I hope you've apologised to her for trying to make her day all about you.

HunterBidensLaptop · 21/12/2023 14:36

You've got plenty of time to choose any or all of these (already suggested) solutions:

A) Get the ring altered or exchanged
B) Get the dress altered or exchanged
C) Change the colour scheme

If you really don't want to do any of these, it's time to be really honest with yourself about why that is.

Mirabai · 21/12/2023 14:33

Lochness1975 · 21/12/2023 14:25

Similar engagement ring, similar dress, similar colour scheme, you must really admire your SIL!!!

It’s her partner who chose the ring, probably from laziness and lack of imagination. And the dress was ordered well before OP had even seen SIL - how is that any kind of homage?

Pigsinpainauchocolat · 21/12/2023 14:32

SecondUsername4me · 21/12/2023 12:41

So when he gave it to you and it was the same, why not arrange to return it and swap it for something else?

This was my first thought too. I'd have instantly said oh it's lovely but it's too much like SIL, I'd prefer it if we go and picked something together that's a bit different.

I don't understand why you let this happen.

And being visibly devastated over a dress is ridiculous.

piscesangel · 21/12/2023 14:31

BigBouncyBaubles · 21/12/2023 13:14

I was honestly devastated and could barely hold it together on the day. Everyone kept asking me if I was ok but I obviously couldn’t say what the issue was.

Eek. Like one of those people who posts a vague Facebook status about how 'you can't trust anyone' but refuse to elaborate in the hope of getting lots of 'u ok hunni?' style concerned replies. Yuck.

Completely agree with this - the whole ring and dress thing aside you were completely unreasonable to behave like this during someone else's wedding

Maisie2409 · 21/12/2023 14:29

If the engagement ring comment was a ‘joke’, I definitely think it had an element of truth to it!

I’ve been on the other side of this with SIL and it wasn’t even subtle. She wanted me to send pictures of my engagement ring from different angles, messaged my husband to ask the size of my diamond and then wound up with same ring with a bigger stone (albeit a fake one!). Many other instances of copying, trying to one-up me, but that one stands out the most…

Please don’t be this SIL!

dannyufcfan · 21/12/2023 14:27

Can't wait for the 'First, my SIL copied my ring and now she's copied my dress!' thread to pop up, next year.

Lochness1975 · 21/12/2023 14:25

Similar engagement ring, similar dress, similar colour scheme, you must really admire your SIL!!!

Belltentdreamer · 21/12/2023 14:22

Wowza - I couldn’t even tell you what my sister in laws wedding rings looked like

JANEY205 · 21/12/2023 14:20

GreenLight23 · 21/12/2023 14:13

There are trends in wedding dresses so maybe yours is a popular style? Are the lace sleeves ‘in?’ I’m not sure myself as when I got married everyone was wearing a strapless bodice. Unless you have both picked a very unusual style I’m not sure guests would notice. Your sil might do of course.

The ring situation is very embarrassing.

Yes there can be trends but 6 of my friends and I got married within 2 years and none of us had similar dresses! I think OP means her dress looks like her poor SILs dress! Otherwise neckline, sleeves, back of dress, cut and shape, fabric etc all vary hugely between dresses and it’s actually quite hard to get a dress that looks the same….

JANEY205 · 21/12/2023 14:18

You’d get away with the dress if your ring and colour scheme weren’t copied (because they are lol).

My friends and I all got engaged and married within 2 years of each other and none of us have rings, dresses, weddings or colour schemes that could be described as similar or even very close and that’s with sisters in the group too!

I know someone irl who did get the exact same ring but a bigger version as her sister and we all think she is an asshole. People probably have thought it if your ring is the exact same eg the same ring from Tiffany’s. I’d have swapped my ring because why would I want my ring the same ‘but bigger.’

People are going to talk if you don’t change the colour scheme at least. The ring makes you look crazy honestly and your fiancé can’t be blamed because he went off your weird comment. People will know.

notlucreziaborgia · 21/12/2023 14:18

‘My sister in law thinks I’m copying her, because I’ve been copying her. I’m just devastated that it’s now really fucking obvious to everyone, especially because now our wedding dresses and colour schemes are ‘remarkably similar’. I did think everyone was buying the ‘oh, what a coincidence/mistake!’ act, but it turns out they’re not. Of course I have time to change the dress and colour scheme, but I have no intention of doing so. Unfortunately this means it’s going to be even more awkward, and I’m sad because SIL and everyone else is well aware that I’m copying her. Is there any way I can make myself look better and make them think I’m not? Not by changing anything though, and preferably not by blinding them all as that’s a little extreme (and I’ll only do that if there’s no other option). Thanks in advance’

GreenLight23 · 21/12/2023 14:13

There are trends in wedding dresses so maybe yours is a popular style? Are the lace sleeves ‘in?’ I’m not sure myself as when I got married everyone was wearing a strapless bodice. Unless you have both picked a very unusual style I’m not sure guests would notice. Your sil might do of course.

The ring situation is very embarrassing.

Hairyfairy01 · 21/12/2023 14:12

Surely you can change the colour scheme? Are you getting married in the same place as well?

Pinko1 · 21/12/2023 14:11

Im surprised you said you want a bigger ring than your SIL - i mean you might think it but why would you say it to anyone?

spuddel · 21/12/2023 14:11

I was honestly devastated and could barely hold it together on the day. Everyone kept asking me if I was ok but I obviously couldn’t say what the issue was Drama llama and Bridezilla, great combo op!

Swipe left for the next trending thread