Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to insist DH does not give his exp this information about me?

269 replies

tikkytakk · 21/12/2023 10:37

I'll admit that I do not like DHs ex. She almost enjoys trying to make life awkward and difficult for us and acts entitled to time/money/information about us thats nothing to do with her or DC/ basically anything she wants from us whenever she clicks her fingers but they share DC so I've grinned and put up with it for their sake for coming up to 8 years now.

I have no contact with her aside from the odd hello how are you at drop off or pick up. I don't have her number, we've never had more than a two minute conversation etc.. just to give context.

Anyway, a few years ago I had a traumatic medical experience it was kept relatively on the down low and at the time the children didn't even know the real reason why I was unwell, just that I was poorly for a while. I recently received some compensation for this and also a small but not insignificant early inheritance from one of my parents and have spent it on a few things I.e. a new car for myself, a holiday for me and DH recently (which did not affect the time DSC were with us) and some other bits including a little work to the house that needed doing.

Ex has done her usual and demanded to know where DH is suddenly getting the money from and if he's come into some money he can be paying her more maintenance. He's simply replied with its not his money and she's said she doesn't believe him and asked again where it's come from. I've told him under no circumstances do I want my personal situation divulged to a woman I don't like and who's business it absolutely isn't.

Aibu to say he just needs to keep insisting it's not his and tell her it's none of her business. DH thinks if we just tell her she'll drop it. And she can make life very awkward and hard when she doesn't get her own way but I don't care, I'm tired of dancing to her tune whenever she demands it and this is my health and my business, nothing to do with the nosey so and so.

OP posts:
nonumbersinthisname · 21/12/2023 12:54

Similar situation where the exW was so convinced she was being deprived of her “rightful” money that she went to CMS and was awarded a sum that was 25% less than the private agreement. Which was satisfying in one way but ultimately not helpful as the fallout had to be dealt with. Long story short, she still receives the previous privately agreed amount but is still convinced she’s been swindled somehow. She’s a difficult character in general, telling the kids that their dad was not giving her enough money, withholding access etc.

A pp said that the more you say to people like this then the more they feel entitled to know and that is my experience too.

Andthereyougo · 21/12/2023 12:52

I had similar problems with ex-h’s ex. Be careful what the children know— we found out his ex used to sit the dc down when they went back to her and were questioned on who’d been to the house, what I’d done, where I’d been. One of the kids got upset one day and said his mum never shut up about me.
So no, she has no right to know about your money, she should wind her neck in but just be aware of little ears.

LuckySantangelo35 · 21/12/2023 12:51

WickedSerious · 21/12/2023 12:50

Nope,that's not how it works.

@Anna8089

lol the money is no matter what you say. Op can do what she likes with it. Soz hun

FeelAloneWithPeopleAroundMe · 21/12/2023 12:50

Firstly, let's have our facts right.
Is it the case that if you, his wife, come into money, it is seen as joint income and the law is that your joint income is accountable for your step DC's welfare? I'm sure I read on here step mums having to give their financial info. How is this different? Let's be clear on this first.

With the above in mind, does she see your joint income, and any windfalls and improvement in lifestyle, as fair game to her?

If it is the case that legally she is not entitled to any of your joint improvement of living standards as a result of your accident/ inheritance, then I would suggest that YOU contact her and say something like;

Dear XXXX

I hear that you are asking about the money I have recently spent on our house, holiday and in replacing my car. Just to be clear, this is my money entirely that I have come into, and it is in no way linked to the money you are due from your ex husband. I hope this is the end of the matter. Regards, YYYYY

Hellenika · 21/12/2023 12:50

irisgg7 · 21/12/2023 12:47

Child maintenance is based on earnings, not wealth. They do not even ask about savings.
Not sure why people are saying otherwise.
He could win the lottery and no, his payments wouldn't increase, even if he won 65 million.

People are saying otherwise because it is the case that other income and assets can be taken into account by applying for a variation. If he had won the lottery of £65m, then yes his payments would increase.

”Income and assets
Both the paying and receiving parent can ask for the following types of income and assets to be taken into account:

  • rental income over £2,500 a year
  • interest and dividends from savings and investments over £2,500 a year
  • gross earnings or pension of at least £100 a week - if the paying parent gets benefits and qualifies to pay the ‘flat rate’ of child maintenance
  • any income the paying parent may be diverting so that it is not included in the calculation (for example, giving it to someone else or choosing to have a company car instead of a higher salary)
  • assets like shares, stocks, gold or money worth more than £31,250“
https://www.gov.uk/how-child-maintenance-is-worked-out/ask-other-income-expenses-included

How the Child Maintenance Service works out child maintenance

See how the Child Maintenance Service works out maintenance and the rates they use

https://www.gov.uk/how-child-maintenance-is-worked-out/ask-other-income-expenses-included

LuckySantangelo35 · 21/12/2023 12:50

Ilovelurchers · 21/12/2023 11:38

You chose to marry a man who is co-parenting with another woman.

Your joint finances are always going to be her business until those kids are grown and flown.

If you don't like the heat, stay out of the kitchen.

@Ilovelurchers

its not joint finances though is it? It’s op money. - HER compensation and HER inheritance. So it is absolutely nothing to do with the ex.

WickedSerious · 21/12/2023 12:50

Anna8089 · 21/12/2023 12:38

Hes your husband which means its shared and yes maintenance should go up. Why are you even with this man . This is nasty. You choose to have a stepchild and husband but your money is yours. Can you not hear yourself.

Nope,that's not how it works.

SuspiciousSue · 21/12/2023 12:48

She won’t drop it even she knows where the money came from. She sounds exactly like my husband’s ex and this is precisely why we didn’t tell her I got made redundant earlier this year and got a payout of £60k.

LuckySantangelo35 · 21/12/2023 12:48

Surely no one could think you unreasonable op!

has anyone actually voted YABU?!

Hellenika · 21/12/2023 12:48

“Ex has done her usual and demanded to know where DH is suddenly getting the money from and if he's come into some money he can be paying her more maintenance. He's simply replied with its not his money and she's said she doesn't believe him and asked again where it's come from. I've told him under no circumstances do I want my personal situation divulged to a woman I don't like and who's business it absolutely isn't.”

Yanbu to not want your personal situation divulged to the ex, but surely there are many options between your DH “it’s not my money” and full disclosure? Would it be alright for DH to tell the ex “it’s solely my wife’s income”? The “it’s not my money” does sound like a lie, sort of like when police find cannabis in one’s car and one says “that’s not mine”.

irisgg7 · 21/12/2023 12:47

Child maintenance is based on earnings, not wealth. They do not even ask about savings.
Not sure why people are saying otherwise.
He could win the lottery and no, his payments wouldn't increase, even if he won 65 million.

Bromptotoo · 21/12/2023 12:45

As you say, if she wants more money she can take advice or go to the CMS. Otherwise she needs to mind her own business....

JFDIYOLO · 21/12/2023 12:44

Just tell her - I received this money myself for compensation over a private and personal medical matter that is not your business or DH's business and does not affect your children. Repeat. Repeat.

And maybe acknowledge that you see her point of view - if he had come into some money or a raise himself, yes he might reasonably be expected to pay more for his own children's maintenance.

The fact you understandably aren't engaging is making her sniff a rat that isn't there.

TheChristmasElfCanGoNow · 21/12/2023 12:43

NotObligedToArgueWithStrangers · 21/12/2023 11:33

"It's not my money. It's not your business. If you are unhappy with what I'm paying, feel free to take it up with CMS. I will not be discussing it with you further." Rinse and repeat.

This sounds like the only real solution. Become boring and repetitive, don't let her get a rise out of either of you. Don't give her any reason to believe she will get more info if she keeps pushing. It's not her business.

horseyhorsey17 · 21/12/2023 12:43

Personally I'd just tell her to avoid drama. 'My parents gave me some money' isn't exactly front page news-worthy stuff.

FestiveFruitloop · 21/12/2023 12:42

Anna8089 · 21/12/2023 12:38

Hes your husband which means its shared and yes maintenance should go up. Why are you even with this man . This is nasty. You choose to have a stepchild and husband but your money is yours. Can you not hear yourself.

Can you not hear yourself? Of course OP doesn't owe the ex any of this money which belongs to her personally. You sound like you have an axe to grind here.

MsCactus · 21/12/2023 12:42

Spinet · 21/12/2023 12:04

I understand why someone wouldn't want to make themselves vulnerable to their partners ex by talking about illness, but I just do not understand why people would rather keep it mysterious and dramatic just to make a point when children are involved. I have no doubt the ex is tiresome and grabby but the principle of 'she should mind her own business' should not come before keeping things as amicable as possible (even if that's not v amicable) for the kids.

I completely agree with this - and on that basis I think OP is being unreasonable.

Also, I've never been in a blended family situation so happy to be corrected - but surely the new partners wealth and earnings would be taken into account?

What if the ex wife married a billionaire? And ex H had more kids? Surely his payments would go down - in which case she is entitled to know about your financial situation too.

And my final point is that child maintenance is for the kids, not the ex. Bizarre to me that people keep making out "he's having to pay HER".

No, he's paying for his kids. As is she.

kimchio · 21/12/2023 12:41

BillionaireTea · 21/12/2023 10:48

If she feels insecure and as though her ex DH has form for trying to get away with paying the minimum, then she might be legit worried that he's had a big payrise and isn't telling her and the children might lose out.

So if he just says none of your beeswax that doesn't allay her concerns. He needs to say "my new partner has come into some money, it's not mine so I won't be discussing it, but it's absolutely not my income paying for all this."

This. He needs to say it is your money and so you won't be discussing it further.

PeopleAreWeird · 21/12/2023 12:41

I would go through CSA and be done with it

If you have the kids 3 nights a week, depending how many days you have them, she will get very little !

Go through CSA and tell her, this is what u wanted, so it will all get investigated

lechatnoir · 21/12/2023 12:40

I agree she doesn't need detail but it does sound unnecessarily obtuse to doggedly stick to "it's not my money" when he could quite reasonably say "it's @tikkytakk money from her parents so nothing to do with my earnings, maintenance or our DC"

Anna8089 · 21/12/2023 12:38

Hes your husband which means its shared and yes maintenance should go up. Why are you even with this man . This is nasty. You choose to have a stepchild and husband but your money is yours. Can you not hear yourself.

PralinesandCream · 21/12/2023 12:35

I don’t understand how sharing the source of the money helps in any way. Why would she believe that its OPs money anymore than she woudn’t believe its not OP DHs money (if that makes sense)? She just sounds like a noisy chancer. Id get OP DH to get CMS involved to draw a line under discussions.

YellowReadingLamp · 21/12/2023 12:31

OP I think you need to ask your partner to deal with this to shut it down.

I’d recommend, “I am acutely aware of my financial responsibilities to my children. If my circumstances change requiring me to give you more money I will inform you and do so. My circumstances have not changed and I’m not willing to justify myself to you. If you don’t believe me that’s your choice. I will be happy to go into detail with child maintenance. You will however be wasting their time but that’s on you.”

if anything comes up in future - rinse and repeat.

I had similar with my partners ex. She learned very quickly to get back in her box where I was concerned!

FestiveFruitloop · 21/12/2023 12:27

Ilovelurchers · 21/12/2023 11:38

You chose to marry a man who is co-parenting with another woman.

Your joint finances are always going to be her business until those kids are grown and flown.

If you don't like the heat, stay out of the kitchen.

The hell they are. Surely you're not saying you think the ex is acting reasonably in this scenario?

NorthernSpirit · 21/12/2023 12:25

Absolutely none other business and your OH does not have to explain to her where the money is from.

My now DH’s EW was as the same. They had a private arrangement for CM and he was paying her £750 per month (considerably more than the CMS recommendation). This was never enough and she was always demanding more. When I purchased a new car she demanded to know my salary details and demanded more money. Sick of the constant demands (and threats to stop contact if she didn’t get it) my DH asked the CMS to calculate maintenance and she was awarded considerably less money than she was getting. God, I wish I was a fly on the wall when the CMS calculation letter came through. He does top it up (he now pays £800 per month in total).

You need to nip these things in the bud and set boundaries. You / your OH do not have to explain anything to her. NO is a full sentence.