Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to insist DH does not give his exp this information about me?

269 replies

tikkytakk · 21/12/2023 10:37

I'll admit that I do not like DHs ex. She almost enjoys trying to make life awkward and difficult for us and acts entitled to time/money/information about us thats nothing to do with her or DC/ basically anything she wants from us whenever she clicks her fingers but they share DC so I've grinned and put up with it for their sake for coming up to 8 years now.

I have no contact with her aside from the odd hello how are you at drop off or pick up. I don't have her number, we've never had more than a two minute conversation etc.. just to give context.

Anyway, a few years ago I had a traumatic medical experience it was kept relatively on the down low and at the time the children didn't even know the real reason why I was unwell, just that I was poorly for a while. I recently received some compensation for this and also a small but not insignificant early inheritance from one of my parents and have spent it on a few things I.e. a new car for myself, a holiday for me and DH recently (which did not affect the time DSC were with us) and some other bits including a little work to the house that needed doing.

Ex has done her usual and demanded to know where DH is suddenly getting the money from and if he's come into some money he can be paying her more maintenance. He's simply replied with its not his money and she's said she doesn't believe him and asked again where it's come from. I've told him under no circumstances do I want my personal situation divulged to a woman I don't like and who's business it absolutely isn't.

Aibu to say he just needs to keep insisting it's not his and tell her it's none of her business. DH thinks if we just tell her she'll drop it. And she can make life very awkward and hard when she doesn't get her own way but I don't care, I'm tired of dancing to her tune whenever she demands it and this is my health and my business, nothing to do with the nosey so and so.

OP posts:
RobertaFirmino · 21/12/2023 14:21

queenofallqueens · 21/12/2023 14:18

You sound very worked up and wound up by very simple clarifications.

You must really hate the ExW

Is that not obvious? Goodness me, OP makes it abundantly clear she does not like this woman in her first post. With bloody good reason too.

So what?

BoredofBlonde · 21/12/2023 14:19

you obviously know the law, and what she is entitled to, so you also know YANBU.

She has SBS - sticky beak syndrome. I personally would enjoy the sport of her guessing and getting riled up with not knowing

queenofallqueens · 21/12/2023 14:18

tikkytakk · 21/12/2023 14:14

Also, I've never been in a blended family situation so happy to be corrected - but surely the new partners wealth and earnings would be taken into account?

What if the ex wife married a billionaire? And ex H had more kids? Surely his payments would go down - in which case she is entitled to know about your financial situation too.

God no. Thankfully the law disagrees with you. Why would the earnings of someone who really has no responsibility for the children you have with someone else, be taken into account when calculating maintenance? Maintenance is between the two parents of the children. The two people who created the children and are responsible for them. If I got a new job tomorrow earning 100k (I wish), it wouldn't increase DHs maintenance in the same way it wouldn't decrease his payments just because she met a millionaire. Rightfully so. You're essentially making a third party responsible for paying for children that are not theirs. I have my own DC to cover the cost of thank you. Two parents should be able to manage the cost of theirs without my money.

You sound very worked up and wound up by very simple clarifications.

You must really hate the ExW

tikkytakk · 21/12/2023 14:16

And obviously if I do one day earn 100k a year or whatever, DSC will benefit from that at our house because they live here half the week practically. I certainly wouldn't also then be sending money to their mum as well from my earnings. Pigs would sooner fly.

OP posts:
tikkytakk · 21/12/2023 14:14

Also, I've never been in a blended family situation so happy to be corrected - but surely the new partners wealth and earnings would be taken into account?

What if the ex wife married a billionaire? And ex H had more kids? Surely his payments would go down - in which case she is entitled to know about your financial situation too.

God no. Thankfully the law disagrees with you. Why would the earnings of someone who really has no responsibility for the children you have with someone else, be taken into account when calculating maintenance? Maintenance is between the two parents of the children. The two people who created the children and are responsible for them. If I got a new job tomorrow earning 100k (I wish), it wouldn't increase DHs maintenance in the same way it wouldn't decrease his payments just because she met a millionaire. Rightfully so. You're essentially making a third party responsible for paying for children that are not theirs. I have my own DC to cover the cost of thank you. Two parents should be able to manage the cost of theirs without my money.

OP posts:
LetMeOut2021 · 21/12/2023 14:09

LimeCheesecake · 21/12/2023 14:06

@HaddawayAndShite - that’s why I said up thread it would be sensible for the OPs dh to say that the money is the OPs, and it’s been spent on the house and her new car plus holiday she treated them too. A white lie like “a distant family member inheritance” would cover it.

while they are playing secrets about where the money has come from, the OP presumes because her dh has said the money isn’t his, that the ex will have worked out that means it’s hers, but that forgets there’s the option that it could be coming from his parents, or that they are racking up massive debts which could long term negatively impact the dsc.

The response would just be “but why did the DC not go on holiday”
“Does OP not see them as part of the family?”
”Does OP not want to holiday with them?”
”Theyre always left out”
better not to give details to manipulate.

LimeCheesecake · 21/12/2023 14:06

@HaddawayAndShite - that’s why I said up thread it would be sensible for the OPs dh to say that the money is the OPs, and it’s been spent on the house and her new car plus holiday she treated them too. A white lie like “a distant family member inheritance” would cover it.

while they are playing secrets about where the money has come from, the OP presumes because her dh has said the money isn’t his, that the ex will have worked out that means it’s hers, but that forgets there’s the option that it could be coming from his parents, or that they are racking up massive debts which could long term negatively impact the dsc.

Forgotmylogindetails · 21/12/2023 14:06

@LetMeOut2021

exactly right.

BasiliskStare · 21/12/2023 14:05

If it were me I would be OK with Dh saying to ex "OP was given some money by her parents " especially if he is paying above CMS already. What I would not be so happy about is medical issues being discussed. Those to me are private and not for discussion with anyone the OP doesn't choose to share them with.

Whatineed · 21/12/2023 14:05

BobLemon · 21/12/2023 11:26

I’ve got a DH with a similar ExW. I recall the time she told us that she had a right to know if we were TTC.

Luckily, my DH has zero time for her and a thick skin. He communicates with her the absolute minimum and would always preserve my privacy, no matter the level of badgering and threats. 9 years later, the energy she puts into wanting to know our business hasn’t waned. It’s like it’s an ingrained habit.

Oh I would have gone into such detail about how I was TTC 😂😂😂

LetMeOut2021 · 21/12/2023 14:01

Forgotmylogindetails · 21/12/2023 13:58

Why do people think because a women has a child with a man she has the right to his business for the rest of her life.
as long as the kids are looked after , it’s nothing to do with the ex.
im A mum and a step mum and I couldn’t give a shit about what my ex is doing because it’s not my business unless of course he’s effecting the children.

The notion is utterly baffling isn’t it? If it happened within a relationship it would be considered coercive control.

HaddawayAndShite · 21/12/2023 14:00

Do people really think this stupid cow will drop it if OPs husband said 'It's from OPs parents'. Of course she bloody won't and if you believe she will I've got a bridge to sell you. And once she knows it's OPs money, and doesn't believe an appropriate amount has been spent on HER kids, you know the claws will come out, bitchy comments, comments to the kids about evil step mummy hoarding her money and not spending it on them etc. It's textbook.

The reason CF like this exist is because of the wet blankets bending over backwards to accommodate their demands on the basis of playing happy families. Because the only person who comes out happy in this scenario is the ex.

Forgotmylogindetails · 21/12/2023 13:58

Why do people think because a women has a child with a man she has the right to his business for the rest of her life.
as long as the kids are looked after , it’s nothing to do with the ex.
im A mum and a step mum and I couldn’t give a shit about what my ex is doing because it’s not my business unless of course he’s effecting the children.

LetMeOut2021 · 21/12/2023 13:53

Avatartar · 21/12/2023 13:21

Get DH to copy a payslip to her and tell her to go to CMS if she doesn’t believe him. Perhaps consider seeing and getting a solicitor to write her a letter telling her to go to CMS and leave you alone which will probably fire her up, but also get her to stop asking.

Why would you spend money on lawyers just to prove a negative? If the ex wants clarification she can pay the £20 or whatever it is to CMS.

Emotionalsupportviper · 21/12/2023 13:53

Brightandbubly · 21/12/2023 11:16

He needs to tell her it’s not his money, it isn’t her business to know anything more than that and he won’t be discussing it any further. End of

This.

And that if she doesn't shut up about it, then HE will go to the CMS and she'll find that her maintenance entitlement is less than he is paying. (He doesn't actually have to reduce it and I'm not suggesting that he does - just warn her that he could if so inclined.)

Her children are presumably benefitting anyway from the much improved home they now live in when with the two of you.

wildwestpioneer · 21/12/2023 13:52

Your dh should send her a message that says

'OP financial position is none of your business and I won't discuss it with you any further. If you continue to have doubts about the accuracy of my maintenance payments, can I suggest we arrange the payments via the CMS. This will ensure my salary is evaluated each year and adjusted as necessary.'

AGirlWithAHandOnHerArm · 21/12/2023 13:48

Absolutely do not tell her, it’s none of her business. The more you put your boundaries in now, the better it will be in the future. She will hopefully soon get the message and leave you alone.

LifeExperience · 21/12/2023 13:47

Show DH this thread and tell him to man up. He's your problem, not the ex.

CruCru · 21/12/2023 13:47

Avatartar · 21/12/2023 13:21

Get DH to copy a payslip to her and tell her to go to CMS if she doesn’t believe him. Perhaps consider seeing and getting a solicitor to write her a letter telling her to go to CMS and leave you alone which will probably fire her up, but also get her to stop asking.

If I got a solicitor’s letter telling me not to ask any more questions, I’d be SURE something fishy was going on. Who forks out for that if they have nothing to hide?

How old are the children? If the OP has had 8 years of this sort of thing, there can’t be all that many more years of dealing with the ex left.

LetMeOut2021 · 21/12/2023 13:46

MsCactus · 21/12/2023 13:03

Hopefully there's someone legal here who can clarify - but if you're married all income is joint, so SURELY your wealth and income has an impact on your DHs child maintenance payments.

I'm not saying the ex wife isn't being unreasonable. But I don't think a step parents wealth is none of the exWife's business. All money when you're married is joint money.

And someone upthread has already explained with reference to the government website how you can apply for wealth/assets - not just income - to be taken into account when calculating maintenance payments.

A marriage is between two people.

Children are between two people.

Where those parties aren’t the same there’s no cross over inbetween.

People have a right to privacy - they don’t have to lay their private info out just because their partner has kids with someone else.

ThankYouVeryMuchGerry · 21/12/2023 13:41

Kudos to you for putting up with her shit for 8 years without telling her to do one. Your DH needs to keep repeating the message and take your side - you are his wife.

I know he shares kids with her, but he should be limiting his contact with her to messages about the kids only and telling her to bugger off about everything else.

8 years!?! The woman seriously needs to move on and get a hobby!

Littlegoth · 21/12/2023 13:40

Ilovelurchers · 21/12/2023 11:38

You chose to marry a man who is co-parenting with another woman.

Your joint finances are always going to be her business until those kids are grown and flown.

If you don't like the heat, stay out of the kitchen.

Hahaha.

Nope!

Yesiamtiredactually · 21/12/2023 13:38

tikkytakk · 21/12/2023 11:10

I don't want to tell her because it's none of her business where its come from providing it's not DHs increased earnings for CMS purposes. She's asked him and he's said it isn't. The fact she thinks he's lying is her problem, not mine. She can contact CMS and check if she wants to.

I'm sick of having to bend over whenever this woman demands it. This is something that is my business and my finances. She isn't entitled to the info and for once, I don't want to give it to her. I guess in a way just to show her that she doesn't get to have her own way all the time.

Oh 100% do not tell her. I’ve got someone similar to this in our lives and I totally empathise!
They seem to love having so much power over people and being able to use children as leverage to get what they want!
As you’ve said, the only options are; you tell her, which you do not want to do for completely reasonable reasons, or, you don’t tell her, she becomes frustrated and enquires via CMS and shoots herself in the foot.
she could attempt to punish you both by causing you grief, but let’s be honest, this would be temporary and is almost guaranteed to punish herself too by ruining any plans she’s made for her child free time!
Stand your ground!

Shelby2010 · 21/12/2023 13:37

DH needs to specifically tell her that it’s your money but no other details. If she asks for further info, he just tells her it’s your business to choose who to discuss it with, not his.

BungleandGeorge · 21/12/2023 13:35

Honestly you are just making drama for the sake of it. He just needs to say that you have inherited some money, he’s hardly divulging your innermost secrets. If you don’t like her it’s best to just rise above it. If he’d had a bonus or wage increase or taken a second job he would be liable for extra payments and so many fathers ‘forget’ this.

Swipe left for the next trending thread