Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to insist DH does not give his exp this information about me?

269 replies

tikkytakk · 21/12/2023 10:37

I'll admit that I do not like DHs ex. She almost enjoys trying to make life awkward and difficult for us and acts entitled to time/money/information about us thats nothing to do with her or DC/ basically anything she wants from us whenever she clicks her fingers but they share DC so I've grinned and put up with it for their sake for coming up to 8 years now.

I have no contact with her aside from the odd hello how are you at drop off or pick up. I don't have her number, we've never had more than a two minute conversation etc.. just to give context.

Anyway, a few years ago I had a traumatic medical experience it was kept relatively on the down low and at the time the children didn't even know the real reason why I was unwell, just that I was poorly for a while. I recently received some compensation for this and also a small but not insignificant early inheritance from one of my parents and have spent it on a few things I.e. a new car for myself, a holiday for me and DH recently (which did not affect the time DSC were with us) and some other bits including a little work to the house that needed doing.

Ex has done her usual and demanded to know where DH is suddenly getting the money from and if he's come into some money he can be paying her more maintenance. He's simply replied with its not his money and she's said she doesn't believe him and asked again where it's come from. I've told him under no circumstances do I want my personal situation divulged to a woman I don't like and who's business it absolutely isn't.

Aibu to say he just needs to keep insisting it's not his and tell her it's none of her business. DH thinks if we just tell her she'll drop it. And she can make life very awkward and hard when she doesn't get her own way but I don't care, I'm tired of dancing to her tune whenever she demands it and this is my health and my business, nothing to do with the nosey so and so.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
sashadjas · 03/03/2024 01:59

Butchyrestingface · 21/12/2023 14:55

@tikkytakk Do you think it's possible that your husband's ex posts on MN and has found this thread? Xmas Grin

Yup, and I reckon it's @queenofallqueens ...😂

funinthesun19 · 24/12/2023 16:26

Showmethesunny · 24/12/2023 11:09

Chances are the ex will be wound up whether she knows where the money is coming from or not. Once she knows about OP’s inheritance/compensation she will just try to claim it’s family money. So the mithering will just continue

tell me you don’t know anything about finances following divorce without telling me…..

family money isn’t a thing after a clean break divorce. You sound like a bitter man

I meant the ex might try to claim the inheritance is family money between OP and her husband as an argument to get his maintenance increased.

I know it’s not family money between the husband and his ex 🤦🏼‍♀️. It’s literally the opposite.

Chocolatebuttonns · 24/12/2023 11:41

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

Chocolatebuttonns · 24/12/2023 11:40

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

Showmethesunny · 24/12/2023 11:09

Chances are the ex will be wound up whether she knows where the money is coming from or not. Once she knows about OP’s inheritance/compensation she will just try to claim it’s family money. So the mithering will just continue

tell me you don’t know anything about finances following divorce without telling me…..

family money isn’t a thing after a clean break divorce. You sound like a bitter man

Showmethesunny · 24/12/2023 11:07

CMS is separate from family court decisions and any financial orders? Not everyone requires a court order for custody and CMS is applicable

I know this I am divorced. Although we do 50/50 so no CMS

I do look at the theoretical calculation on the gov website, which very much does provide a suggested payment for 50:50. No idea how often it’s applied in real life, however.

it’s not. That’s the point. From the Gov website Q: What happens if the day-to-day care of a child is equal between a paying parent and a receiving parent? A: In this situation, the paying parent does not have to pay any child maintenance for that child

someone above has said that in some situations one person still has to pay, this would only arise from an odd occasion like the child sleeps 50/50 but one parent does ALL the childcare apart from sleeping. And this would be hard to prove.

funinthesun19 · 24/12/2023 09:36

Muchof · 22/12/2023 10:47

I’m not an ex.

But my impression is also that OP is deliberately creating drama here. The ex has asked a simple question because she wants to ensure her children are not missing out. All OPs DH needs to do is say, “Tikkytak had an inheritance / received money from parents”. Instead he is being deliberately vague and no doubt winding the ex up. Which I think OP is enjoying.

Chances are the ex will be wound up whether she knows where the money is coming from or not. Once she knows about OP’s inheritance/compensation she will just try to claim it’s family money. So the mithering will just continue. AND OP’s privacy won’t have been respected either which is what this thread is all about. It will be a lose lose for everyone if the ex knows including the ex, because it will just make her bitter and jealous. She will also bring it up all the time too I bet. “ tikkytakk has got that money so you can both pay for xyz as you have more money than me.” … which would be wrong as it’s OP’s money and it shouldn’t necessarily have to go towards dsc’s costs.

Lifeasiknowitisout · 24/12/2023 07:02

Showmethesunny · 23/12/2023 23:26

I get child support for my eldest. I wouldn't ask. Nor would I want more. It's neither my concern (Id not ask)

she’s simply asking if he’s had a massive payrise which would mean more child support. It’s a right, not a beg

And she has been told he hasn’t.

If she doesn’t believe it she can go to CMS and get them to check.

She is entitled to anything else. The fact that she hasn’t suggests she knows he hasn’t had a massive pay rise. She just wants to know.

If she chooses not to believe the truth that’s her pribkem. Not the Ops or Ops dh.

Lifeasiknowitisout · 24/12/2023 07:00

Showmethesunny · 23/12/2023 23:39

@SemperIdem no, by court of law no money exchanges when it’s 50/50

That’s not actually true.

In some circumstances money can be still payable for 50:50

Toooldtoworry · 24/12/2023 06:58

Showmethesunny · 23/12/2023 23:29

Why doesn’t he do 50/50 so there’s no maintenance?

oh, because he’s a shit father you say?

sp yes, she has a right to ask his earnings. Going through CMS takes a percentage off which doesn’t benefit the kids. He just needs to show her his payslip. Simple. Dad of the fucking year

Projecting ... much!

Maybe their personal circumstances mean he can't do 50/50. We don't live in an ideal world. We have to make the most of our situation.

SemperIdem · 24/12/2023 00:00

Showmethesunny · 23/12/2023 23:39

@SemperIdem no, by court of law no money exchanges when it’s 50/50

CMS is separate from family court decisions and any financial orders? Not everyone requires a court order for custody and CMS is applicable.

I’ve never done CMS with my ex, probably should have done and would do, if I had my time again. But we’re effectively been 50:50 and when I’ve been particularly irritated, I do look at the theoretical calculation on the gov website, which very much does provide a suggested payment for 50:50. No idea how often it’s applied in real life, however.

Showmethesunny · 23/12/2023 23:39

@SemperIdem no, by court of law no money exchanges when it’s 50/50

SemperIdem · 23/12/2023 23:35

@Showmethesunny

When I have checked CMS calculations, they still give one for 50:50, is that not accurate to real life?

Showmethesunny · 23/12/2023 23:29

Why doesn’t he do 50/50 so there’s no maintenance?

oh, because he’s a shit father you say?

sp yes, she has a right to ask his earnings. Going through CMS takes a percentage off which doesn’t benefit the kids. He just needs to show her his payslip. Simple. Dad of the fucking year

SemperIdem · 23/12/2023 23:29

Showmethesunny · 23/12/2023 23:26

I get child support for my eldest. I wouldn't ask. Nor would I want more. It's neither my concern (Id not ask)

she’s simply asking if he’s had a massive payrise which would mean more child support. It’s a right, not a beg

She has been told, and won’t accept it. That is inappropriate and if she so strongly disbelieves him, she can go through CMS to challenge.

Showmethesunny · 23/12/2023 23:26

I get child support for my eldest. I wouldn't ask. Nor would I want more. It's neither my concern (Id not ask)

she’s simply asking if he’s had a massive payrise which would mean more child support. It’s a right, not a beg

DragonMama3 · 23/12/2023 17:19

She has zero righs to access any personal data.

Tell her to jog on!

DragonMama3 · 23/12/2023 17:19

I get child support for my eldest. I wouldn't ask. Nor would I want more. It's neither my concern (Id not ask).

Mittleme · 23/12/2023 16:46

Spot on .
to be quite honest I wouldn't be asking any info from someone am no longer with

Basilsage · 23/12/2023 09:06

"My wife has savings"

usernamealreadytaken · 23/12/2023 09:02

tikkytakk · 21/12/2023 14:14

Also, I've never been in a blended family situation so happy to be corrected - but surely the new partners wealth and earnings would be taken into account?

What if the ex wife married a billionaire? And ex H had more kids? Surely his payments would go down - in which case she is entitled to know about your financial situation too.

God no. Thankfully the law disagrees with you. Why would the earnings of someone who really has no responsibility for the children you have with someone else, be taken into account when calculating maintenance? Maintenance is between the two parents of the children. The two people who created the children and are responsible for them. If I got a new job tomorrow earning 100k (I wish), it wouldn't increase DHs maintenance in the same way it wouldn't decrease his payments just because she met a millionaire. Rightfully so. You're essentially making a third party responsible for paying for children that are not theirs. I have my own DC to cover the cost of thank you. Two parents should be able to manage the cost of theirs without my money.

When DH was paying CMS (around 20 years ago), it was different - my wages weren’t directly taken in to account, but because we lived together his personal allowance was effectively reduced as housing costs were shared. I can’t remember how it worked exactly, but I had to provide all my details to CMS. When we had our first DS, his CMS payments didn’t reduce, but they did slightly when we had DS2.

Sleepytiredyawn · 22/12/2023 21:57

Use his phone, say it’s you of course and just say…my financials are my business, no one else’s and certainly not yours. You’re badgering of Ex H regarding money, my money ends here!

Golden407 · 22/12/2023 21:17

XmasPartyhat · 21/12/2023 11:25

As always is the case on MN, your ex isn't actually the problem here.

The problem is that your DH has no boundaries with his ex and prioritises her over you.

Stop complaining about her and direct your anger to the source.

How does he prioritise his ex? He ensures his children are taken care of and tries to maintain peace with their mother. How is that "prioritising" the ex?

CrazyHedgehogLover · 22/12/2023 21:10

I don’t understand why your DH just doesn’t say he doesn’t want to discuss further? Nobody is holding him down to have to tell her!

have you ever thought she knew asking would piss you off, she clearly knows that your DH sings to her tune. It doesn’t take rocket science to know this will most likely cause a disagreement to you both.

he naturally wants to tell her to try and get her off his back, you understandably don’t want her to know.. it’s personal and your well within your right!

tell him to send a simple message with you sat with him saying “the money isn’t mine, I don’t want to hear anymore about this situation now please” if she mentions it again he literally just ignores her🤷‍♀️?

if she tries mentioning the child in the sentence I.e “Zack has football on Sunday he needs dropping off, btw where did you get all the money from I think I deserve more” your DH would reply “no worries, I’ll drop Zack off no problem! Thanks for letting me know”

don’t engage in it! She’s after the drama, she’s after causing problems between you both, don’t pander to it.

Macmoominmamma · 22/12/2023 20:53

I’ve been in your position for 20 odd years. At the start, DH’s ex took him to Court in her attempt to deny him access to his DC. For example, a seemingly innocuous conversation between DH and ex’s new partner about DH’s car model, resulted in his petrol usage being brought into question at Court by ex on the basis that DH’s round trip of 1000 miles to see his DC didn’t cost the amount DH said.

My point is, do not underestimate the grabby hands of some exes sense of entitlement to your partner’s money. You will know yourself there is a fine line as to what you tell, but I would say that it is best to say it’s inheritance rather than eg a pay rise as a pay rise can be used to make your DH pay more. Or say it is redundancy money as that doesn’t count either. She can go to the CSA at any point to request more if she feels there’s a shortfall. Don’t say anything about the compensation, as you say, none of her business.