Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Benefits question. One parent full time carer, can other parent work part time?

32 replies

MysticMushroom · 21/12/2023 09:52

I've posted here for traffic as I could really do with some advice from people who understand how this works.

I'm also prepared to get flamed/benefits bashed but at this point I am so desperate that I don't even care.

To give some background: I am a registered carer for my 7year old DS. He is diagnosed autistic and ADHD. Receives high rate DLA and low rate mobility.

Due to the nature of his needs and the utter failure of our education system, DS has never attended school properly. Pre-schools couldn't cope/meet needs so put him on severely reduced hours where he had very little interaction with other children.

At age 4 when due to start school I asked the LA if he could attend specialist as I didn't think he would cope in mainstream. They didn't listen and he lasted 4 weeks in mainstream before they reduced his hours to 2 hours a day for 3 days a week where he was kept in a cupboard away from the other pupils so had very limited social interaction.

This went on for 2 years while we fought to get him a specialist school place via tribunal.

(Very long story that I have posted about before under a different name) but the tribunal named a specialist school that we were led to believe would be suitable for DS but turned out to be completely unsuitable and unable to meet his needs, therefore leaving DS with no school at all as he can't attend this specialist school and can't go back to mainstream due to the tribunal now stating on his EHCP that he needs specialist provision.

Despite numerous phone calls and meetings with the LA and an urgent review of his EHCP taking place, we are still no closer to getting him into a school as the LA are frankly useless and don't respond. He's been left with nothing with the view of finding something next September.

Last February I found out I was unexpectedly pregnant. Decided to go ahead with the pregnancy as at the time the situation was more stable. DS was attending his mainstream school for 2 hours, had just been given a really good 1:1 there who was wonderful with him and also had support workers for the 3 days he attended school to give respite for a few more hours away from home.
The situation obviously wasn't perfect but wasn't as dire as it is now so chose to go ahead with the pregnancy.

However over the course of the pregnancy everything with DS's schooling fell apart leaving us where we are now, with DS at home full time. The massive changes that have happened over this last year have impacted him greatly and his behaviour is the worst its ever been. Incredibly challenging and we are doing it with 0 support as have no family to help us and all services have been exhausted.

This is where my question comes in:

We claim UC. My partner works full time, long hours. Is also away EOW as he has sees his children from a previous relationship.
I am registered as a full time carer for DS therefore do not have to seek other employment until 2029 (although I did have a part time job up until my pregnancy). Is it possible for my partner to be considered the 'main carer' of our baby and therefore only be required to work part time while I continue being the registered carer of DS?

As if this was possible then it would take so much pressure of a situation that is not working right now. It is next to impossible to meet DS's needs without any respite or support and be able to look after a 4 week old baby. Partner works long hours so out of the house most of the time.

The situation has become so impossible that I am feeling really depressed and have no hope. Might be clutching at straws with this but if DP could be home for more hours it might actually be survivable but unsure whether we can claim UC if he is in part time work only.

Looking for advice from people who know about this. Sorry the post is so long. Its such a long story and I tried my best to shorten it down.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Saracen · 22/12/2023 23:54

Yes, you can do what you are considering. So long as your DH is the one claiming Child Benefit for the baby, he would be exempt from work requirements altogether until your younger child is three, though he would have to attend some meetings with UC after the first year. After the little one is three, your DH would need to work 30 hours a week.

Have a look at a benefits calculator and get some expert advice to see how your overall financial situation would change if your DH works part-time or not at all.

Good luck with everything. It sounds really tough. I hope things will improve for your family soon.

Fidgety31 · 22/12/2023 18:14

Your husband can’t be the carer for the baby in the same sense you are carer for your child - unless the baby is disabled and receives DLA as that’s the qualifying benefit .
For him to be the main parent for UC purposes to avoid having to work full time - he would have to be the recipient of the new baby’s child benefit .

But you will not be better off financially than him working full time .

KeepGoingThomas · 22/12/2023 17:59

If you aren’t eligible for legal aid for a pre-action letter do look at SOSSEN. If you can’t afford their reasonable price you really need to consider how you will manage if DP stopped working because the difference between the money you have coming in with DP working and what you would have coming in if DP stopped work will be more than their fee each month.

BettyBakesCakes · 22/12/2023 17:53

LAs are a huge pita op. You need to go to tribunal if you think you've found a suitable school and/or get a solicitors letter if they arent providing education/contents of the EHCP. I would suggest chatting with Ipsea/sossen.

Dishwashersaurous · 22/12/2023 10:09

So sorry for this difficult situation.

Would you be able to cope financially if your partner reduced his hours, or stopped work?

Irrespective of whether he would be required to do work search you need to think really carefully about the financial position of yourself

SaySomethingMan · 22/12/2023 10:02

MysticMushroom · 22/12/2023 08:55

@SaySomethingMan I have been pushing them. But what can I do when I push and push and they still ignore me? There is no one to hold them accountable. I've tried formally complaining and still nothing changed. I've tried writing to the MP and nothing has happened.

I don't have the money for my own legal advice, unless like a PP said I can get free advice.

I absolutely cannot move to a different area. I don't have the money to move. I am in social housing so can't even move if I wanted to as there is a housing shortage and if you are considered adequately housed you can't apply to move.

We were deceived into thinking this specialist school would be the right school for DS. The mainstream school he was in just wanted to get rid of him so told us a load of lies. The specialist school was absolutely appalling with their communication so never actually communicated that the school was so unsuitable until the day of the tribunal by which point it was too late.

I am literally doing all I can.

Im sorry if i came across as accusatory. It wasn’t intentional.

Did you say you’ve been in touch with IPSEA? SOS!SEN?

There are charities that can help you get some respite too. It’s harder for you being pregnant now but you could plan a bit here and there until you’re ready to take action again.

Unfortunately, you cannot rely on anyone else to tell you which school will be suitable for your son. You have to visit, speak to the staff, research it online, etc. The number of cases assigned to case workers are so high that they have little time to work on them thoroughly.

MysticMushroom · 22/12/2023 08:55

@SaySomethingMan I have been pushing them. But what can I do when I push and push and they still ignore me? There is no one to hold them accountable. I've tried formally complaining and still nothing changed. I've tried writing to the MP and nothing has happened.

I don't have the money for my own legal advice, unless like a PP said I can get free advice.

I absolutely cannot move to a different area. I don't have the money to move. I am in social housing so can't even move if I wanted to as there is a housing shortage and if you are considered adequately housed you can't apply to move.

We were deceived into thinking this specialist school would be the right school for DS. The mainstream school he was in just wanted to get rid of him so told us a load of lies. The specialist school was absolutely appalling with their communication so never actually communicated that the school was so unsuitable until the day of the tribunal by which point it was too late.

I am literally doing all I can.

OP posts:
KeepGoingThomas · 21/12/2023 18:58

Follow the advice in my pp about threatening JR. Sometimes the threat is enough, but if it doesn’t work you need a pre-action letter. Check if you are eligible for legal aid for a pre-action letter - this will be done on your finances, but if you get to JR proceedings themselves it is in DS’s name and he can be eligible in his own right. If you aren’t eligible for legal aid, SOSSEN is reasonably priced - far cheaper than DH giving up his job.

I wouldn’t move LAs. If you move LAs the new LA will review the EHCP and can amend, reassess or even cease to maintain. Obviously you would be able to appeal, but it would be added stress.

SaySomethingMan · 21/12/2023 18:25

KeepGoingThomas · 21/12/2023 10:45

You need to push the LA to provide a suitable, full time education and the provision in F. They can do so, they need to fund more specialist staff, but they won’t do so unless you force them to.

When was the early review? The LA has deadlines they must adhere to and can be enforced.

I agree with this. You need to push them.
You need to do more research. It might mean that you need to move out of area to one with better SEN services although pretty much everywhere is dire.

How did the tribunal name an unsuitable school? Did you not request a school?

It sounds really difficult but you do need to do more because no one else will and you’re his only advocate.

Have you contacted IPSEA? Or your local charity that provides advice on SEN?

Savedpassword · 21/12/2023 18:17

What are your reasons for for refusing to consider the school the LA suggested?

MysticMushroom · 21/12/2023 18:12

@KeepGoingThomas I know they are but I don't know what I can actually do about it as wherever I turn and try to complain/force things to happen I just get fobbed off even more. Like making a formal complaint or writing to the MP. I don't have the money for any kind of legal stuff to do on my own. I dont even have the legal knowledge. Its just an impossible situation and is now even more difficult trying to battle all this and do all these people's jobs for them while also caring for a 4 week old baby.

OP posts:
KeepGoingThomas · 21/12/2023 16:31

The LA is fobbing you off. They will only comply with their legal duties if you force them to.

If the review was mid September and the LA is going to amend they should have finalised now.

BookishBabe · 21/12/2023 12:22

To answer your question, yes, one parent can be the "carer" and the other parent can be the "main parent" on the system.
Your DH wouldn't need to work until your new baby is 3.

You can change it on your universal credit page under changes to circumstances.

Good luck!

MysticMushroom · 21/12/2023 11:55

@KeepGoingThomas Thank you for this information. I'll have to have a look at all the exact dates in the time line when or if I get a minute. I think I remember the outcome of the urgent EHCP review being they agreed to amend the EHCP and have sent out his EHCP to a specialist school who have not yet replied. They also set up an EOTIS package but nothing has come of it as there are no suitable provisions who can work with my son.. or so they say.

OP posts:
MysticMushroom · 21/12/2023 11:49

@Squirrelsonthescaffolding Thank you for sharing this. It gives me a little bit of hope that things might not be so horrible forever. It's hard to stay positive at the moment though.

OP posts:
RichTea63 · 21/12/2023 11:30

I'm so sorry you're going through this OP, you've been so let down. I wonder whether homestart could advise about support and benefits. I can't work out how to post the link on here but Google Homestart in your area. As pp suggested your midwife may be able to advise.

Babyroobs · 21/12/2023 11:14

Yes it is possible but as others have said will you be able to cope on such a reduced income as UC will in no way make up for his loss of earnings. Also if he pays maintenance for his other kids I'm unsure if that amount would drop. How many other kids does he have?

MummySS22 · 21/12/2023 11:09

I'm not an expert but as a full time carer for my DS, I completely sympathize.

KeepGoingThomas · 21/12/2023 10:54

If the LA is refusing to provide a suitable full-time education and the provision in F have you contact SOSSEN for help with a pre-action letter both for failing to provide provision under s19 of the Education Act 1996 and also failure to deliver provision detailed, specified and quantified in F of the EHCP under s42 CAFA 2014?

The LA must inform you whether they are going to amend or not within 4 weeks of the review and if they are going to amend issue the amendment notice at the same time. Have they done this? If they are going to amend they must then finalise within a further 8 weeks. Have they done this? If the LA have not complied with the timescales you can enforce them, via JR if necessary.

Squirrelsonthescaffolding · 21/12/2023 10:51

PS my friend also similarly had no respite because they said they couldn’t cope and he needed 2:1 .

Squirrelsonthescaffolding · 21/12/2023 10:49

I don’t know about benefits I’m afraid but I just wanted to say that your situation sounds so tough. Much less difficult than for you I’m sure but I remember the impossibility of caring for two young children with very different needs. There were times when there was always someone in the house crying. You’ve probably thought of this already but is there any voluntary practical support you could get eg to hold the baby while you do things with DS eg from home start or a church or other community group? Or are there any teenage/student family members who could come and stay in the holidays to be an extra pair of hands for a few days. if you have any space? This really helped me but I know it would only be a drop in the ocean.

Also wanted to say that while every child is different my friend was in a very similar situation to you, first child diagnosed autistic very young, high needs, smearing, impossible to safely leave the house with both DC , partner working full time, no family support. I think she got funded specialist childminder, then special school. He’s now an adult with friends and a part time job. I know this isn’t always the outcome but I just wanted to say things can get much better than might be imagined. I really hope you get a suitable school for him.

MysticMushroom · 21/12/2023 10:49

The early review was mid September. I have tried pushing the LA time and time again. I've made a formal complaint about their lack of response and blatant ignoring of our situation for it to be investigated and the solution to be placing a job ad for more staff. I've written to my MP detailing the whole situation for him to write to the LA and receive a response from them telling him they are in contact with me when they are not! But that was enough for him to drop us.

I don't know what else I can do! I am on the phone in the queue for up to an hour every single day trying to be able to speak to them to be told "I can't help you with this, so and so will call you back" and she never does. Or will send an email at 6pm before she leaves work and then not respond to my replies.

No one will help us and I feel like I am drowning.

OP posts:
KeepGoingThomas · 21/12/2023 10:45

You need to push the LA to provide a suitable, full time education and the provision in F. They can do so, they need to fund more specialist staff, but they won’t do so unless you force them to.

When was the early review? The LA has deadlines they must adhere to and can be enforced.

MysticMushroom · 21/12/2023 10:40

In 2029 my son will be reassessed for DLA so potentially I may have to look for work then if he no longer gets medium or high rate, although unlikely he wouldn't as his needs are severe.

DS already has an EOTIS package funded by the LA but when I say they are useless I mean it. All the providers they have contacted to provide support workers for DS have failed. They've turned up for one session and said basically 'nope, can't do this, he is top high needs'. One woman turned up and took one look at him and left straight away! Absolutely heartbreaking for DS.

As for the poster who told me to take the lead on finding a school for my son... I have done. I've researched independent specialist schools, contacted them, visited, found the ones I think could be suitable, placed them before the LA (it has to go through then, I can't do it myself because they control the funding) and they have said "No. We don't think that'll be suitable. We'll send his EHCP to this school"... and sent it to a school that I didn't want or think would be appropriate. The schools deadline to respond was last month and they haven't responded and no amount of chasing the LA to get this response will make them do anything. So can't even move forward until they get their act together.

Meanwhile DS is having meltdowns daily, he is becoming increasingly defiant. He has PDA profile which makes things even harder to manage. I am functioning on 1 or 2 hours broken sleep a night. Trying to look after a baby and provide full time care to DS.

Would give anything just to have a few hours respite a day but it's all been taken away with no hope of it coming back as there just isn't anything out there.

OP posts:
KeepGoingThomas · 21/12/2023 10:35

Very rarely there is discretion for a second carer of a disabled child to have reduced or no work related conditions, but you wouldn’t get a second carer element. Only one person in a couple can be considered the nominated registered carer of dependent children. The other parent can still be considered as a carer for a disabled person.

The LA has a duty to ensure DS receives a suitable, full-time education and anything detailed specified and quantified in F. If this isn’t happening email the Director of Children’s Services requesting provision under s19 of the Education Act 1996 and reminding them of their duty under s42 CAFA 2014. If they refuse, delay or ignore email again threatening judicial review. Then, if that fails, contact SOSSEN for help with a pre-action letter.

Have you appealed the EHCP following the early review?

Have you had social care assessments? A carer’s assessment for you and an assessment via the disabled children’s team for DS.