Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think lack of routine and structure is to blame?

38 replies

Grilly · 21/12/2023 09:04

My friend has a four year old. He can’t sit still, can’t pay attention and is often in trouble at school for being disobedient and being rough with other kids.

Friend and her husband split before the boy was one and I don’t know the ins and outs but they were both living with new partners within a few months. Her son spends alternate weekends and holidays with his dad and stepmum, weekdays with his mum and stepdad, and alternate weekends and some evenings and midweek overnights with his mum’s parents or other family and babysitters. He’s been in full time childcare since he was a baby.

I’ve babysat a lot over the years and he’s a lovely boy but needs a lot of redirection, exercise and expectation setting. He and my daughter get on great and he really takes pride in crafts or whatever we do. He doesn’t get read to at home or have much if any individual attention (they have older kids). She does her best but she’s got four kids to look after now including a baby and is always busy. My friend is now talking about pursuing various SEN diagnoses and medication to calm him down.

AIBU to think he’d be doing much better if he had some routine and structure and attention paid to him?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ActDottie · 21/12/2023 10:38

It may be true but you don’t know the full ins and outs of his life so I don’t think you’re qualified to make this judgment.

Ace56 · 21/12/2023 10:10

I also think YANBU. As pp have said, even if he does have SEN it’s definitely not being helped atm by his lack of attention and structure in his life.

This isn’t necessarily his parents’ fault, but if this was my child I’d be having a long hard look at my parenting and at what’s happening in my child’s life before jumping on the medication/assessment bandwagon.

Grilly · 21/12/2023 10:10

People have asked how I am offering support. I’ve thought about suggesting that we have him a set night or two every week. But I’m worried that adding in another setting with different expectations would make it worse. He cries a lot when he has to go home after a sleepover here.

Friend’s ex has asked to swap around the contact pattern (they can’t do 50/50 due to distance), and to be honest I think it’d be better for him, but Friend immediately shuts down the idea and I don’t think the ex would be successful at court as Friend’s always been the primary carer.

OP posts:
zingally · 21/12/2023 10:05

As a primary school teacher, I'd say you were probably right OP.

But that being said, it's not really your business, or your problem.

Mabelface · 21/12/2023 10:00

It doesn't matter what or if diagnoses he's being assessed for, what matters is that he has unmet needs and your friend is looking into this so the appropriate support can be put in place. She's absolutely doing the right thing. Leave her be.

Notthatcatagain · 21/12/2023 09:55

Poor little lad. He's pretty much homeless, of course he will have problems

PepperIsHere · 21/12/2023 09:53

All kids would do better with more attention, and structure us a great start for family life.

Whatever the case, the little vot is not having his needs met. It may be because his needs have not been identified ie neurodiversity.

Or it may just be that he needs a lot more exercise. A child cannot sit and concentrate until they can run, and they need to run and climb a lot.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 21/12/2023 09:39

PastTheGin · 21/12/2023 09:13

I think you are probably right, OP, but this will not be a popular opinion.

I agree. But ops friend will totally fall out with her if she says it.

Spendonsend · 21/12/2023 09:38

If you have a safeguarding concern about him being bedraggled, dirty and neglected then you should ring the NSPCC about the best way to express that concern.

(It wont be speculating on mumsnet)

Brandyginger · 21/12/2023 09:38

@namechange1986 where I live in London, and the kids I know at private schools, parents go privately and can go from not wanting to engage with their challenging child to holding a script for meds in a few months. There are private waiting lists for assessment but it’s more a matter of weeks rather than years.

As I said I have a child with SEN and I am in a lot of support groups and have seen a lot over 14 years. my own mother told me it was my poor parenting why I had a child with ASD and numerous other diagnoses so I do know what it’s like to be blamed for SEN.

But in my personal opinion a lot of structure and careful parenting can help and some behaviour is pathologised as SEN and medicated when it really isn’t needed. Particularly if parents are paying thousands of pounds. Just my lived experience.

WhichOneGoes · 21/12/2023 09:37

Mariannas · 21/12/2023 09:06

In what way are you qualified to make this judgement?

Presumably the same way that dozens and dozens of posters on Mumsnet think they are qualified to diagnose autism and ADHD among others from the shortest of OPs

OP, you just can't tell but surely a hectic, disorganised household where the parents flit from one thing to another are more likely to have kids who are all over the place too.

TheSnowyOwl · 21/12/2023 09:35

It’s difficult because both a lack of attention and sen could easily be the cause. Being bedraggled and dirty is often a cause of not being washed or changing clothes frequently enough but that can also be sensory issues with a sen child that as a parent you don’t push, because you are aware you are already asking too much of them and they can’t cope.

Two of my children are autistic and it can take several hours to do a bath and hair wash. Those hours consist of a child screaming, lashing out, and being disruptive to the rest of the household. Sometimes for everyone’s sake, washing is done on a less regular basis than it would be for a neurotypical child.

Also, my sen children wouldn’t cope with full time childcare and many other autistic or adhd children wouldn’t either. As a result, the home time comes across to an outsider as a dysregulated mess but really it’s just a sen child having a meltdown because they can’t cope.

CandyLeBonBon · 21/12/2023 09:34

Op my eldest was like this and was indeed diagnosed with adhd and we decided medication was appropriate at 6. HOWEVER none of that happened BEFORE extensive work was done to ensure it wasn't environmental factors (eg parenting/routine) at play. We had to exhaust all possibilities, attend parenting classes, be observed by professionals etc etc and only once that was done and they were convinced it wasn't my parenting/routine/diet/lifestyle that was the issue, did they move on to adhd/asd assessments and subsequent diagnosis. My son is nearly 22 now and I don't know how much has changed but I'm pretty sure it's still not a question of popping to the GP and coming out with a prescription for Ritalin.

Dweetfidilove · 21/12/2023 09:33

He may or may not have SEN, but I agree with you. His little life sounds awfully chaotic, so SEN or not, he could do with some structure and attention.

BogRollBOGOF · 21/12/2023 09:32

It could be lifestyle. It could be SEN. It could be both. If SENs are involved that can often make it harder to be consistent about routines. If a child has SENs, there's a higher chance that their parents do too and that will make consistent parenting harder.

Different people have different ideas about what a routine is. We did have a light bedtime routine of book and bed around a certain time, but because it wasn't done in a fixed way by 7pm, DM has always considered that we don't have a bedtime routine. Never mind that I wasn't tired by 7pm, inevitably dragged it out as late as I could, got told off, then lay in bed for two hours and got told off for damaging my eyesight if I tried to read by the streetlamps to try and pass the time. The 7pm bit was the part that defined the routine in her eyes 🙄 "Routine" can be a subjective concept.

Spendonsend · 21/12/2023 09:31

The assessment process should take into account background. I know it seems to vary from area to area, but a lot of areas the first stage is asking lots of questions about the set up at home - 'the parental interview'. The second stage in a lot of areas is a long parenting course (which actually is quite good apart from the awkward timings). Then there is the multidisciplinary bit before diagnosis where lots of professionals observd the child. Then you are on a wait list for assessment for medication but thats not automatic. At the moment no new adhd people are getting medication as there is a shortage and they are prioritising existing prescriptions. And most adhders are not medicated anyway.

Of course you are right that a chaotic homelife can result in behaviours that mimic some adhd/asd. Its also true that someone can have a choatic home and adhd. That's why is better trained professionals assess not friends.

ElevenSeven · 21/12/2023 09:29

PastTheGin · 21/12/2023 09:13

I think you are probably right, OP, but this will not be a popular opinion.

I agree.

Grilly · 21/12/2023 09:27

I have known Friend for a very long time and can accept maybe I’m not being a good friend to her. To be honest though, I am starting to feel she’s not being a very good mum to her son. He often looks a bit bedraggled and dirty and it’s sad to see how excited he is to read or play with me and my daughter.

She and her ex also have two older girls but they’re quite self-sufficient. Her partner values family time with just her and the new baby so her son seems a bit displaced. She is often exasperated with her son but tends to ignore him as his behaviour escalates then tell him off and he doesn’t seem to listen to her. I do think the friendship is waning because of this.

I agree he may have SEN but I also think having lived between so many homes (both parents have moved several times) and his lack of attention and routine is playing a big part in his behaviour.

OP posts:
NoCloudsAllowed · 21/12/2023 09:27

It's not really either/or though, is it? That doesn't sound like a very stable or attentive environment but he could be sen as well. People just do the best they can and it isn't always perfect.

namechange1986 · 21/12/2023 09:26

@Brandyginger rush to medication? A diagnosis tends to take years!

TheSnowyOwl · 21/12/2023 09:23

It’s impressive how you know all the detailed ins and outs of his life 24/7 to know what is missing in his life and what isn’t.

It could well be sen or it could be that he is reacting to an unsettled home life although given his age, and the fact you say he has been in full time childcare since a baby, I’m very surprised that he hasn’t had a huge amount of structure in the last four years as that’s normally guaranteed in childcare settings. Presumably he started school in September and if he does have sen, he might well be exhausted by the change so reading at home often isn’t practical.

How about you support your friend and give her some help? What experience do you have with sen? Maybe her talking to the school senco about an assessment is a good thing as that will be somebody else, who should be in a qualified position to do so, either agreeing to support an application or not - and they won’t just agree to support on her say so, not when the child is only four and been there for a term.

IWishTheBishopWell · 21/12/2023 09:23

I had a lot of structure and routine as a child and lots of attention (raised as an only child) and was read to daily.

I'm still neurodivergent (dyspraxia and dyscalculia).

This little boy may well have SEN and if he does, although he may benefit from more structure and routine, it won't remove the SEN.

JamSandle · 21/12/2023 09:22

I think this does make a BIG impact.

Shopper727 · 21/12/2023 09:21

I am consistent and impose rules on my 4 kids my youngest has asd & adhd. You are dealing with this kid 1:1 so maybe you don’t notice things, he’s happy and relaxed with you that’s not to say he copes in a classroom. Or when his baby sibling is crying or when it’s noisy/chaotic at home. A diagnosis was made for my son in various settings over a long period of time so there will be no snap diagnosis but if he’s struggling and mum is concerned then she’s entitled to be heard. That may lead to assessment it may not, it took over 3 years for my sons diagnosis x2.

you could try being supportive to your friend and kind, she’s likely quite worried about him .

GreenwichOrTwicks · 21/12/2023 09:17

Poor little boy. I wonder if he feels that he doesn’t actually belong anywhere a bit like those Jane Austen maiden aunts who were always staying in other people’s houses but knowing they were tolerated and not actually wanted? He seems like no-one’s priority 😔😔And the Mum’s response is to tout for a label and medication?????