Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teacher gift collection

163 replies

Purpleturtle45 · 21/12/2023 06:36

Every year I organise a collection at Christmas and Summer for my kids teachers and usually buy vouchers for somewhere nice. I always make it very clear that any amount is welcome and of course only donate if you want to. Some parents might want to do their own thing, or nothing which is their decision.

Most parents are very grateful for this as it gives them one less thing to do and they probably get away with donating less for a joint present than they would trying buy something themselves for £5-£10.

It has come to my attention though that some local authorities are banning this due to cost of living and parents potentially feeling under pressure do donate. Wondering people's thoughts on this? I think people should be allowed to make their own choices on this and think a ban would be very unreasonable.

YANBU- Collections are fine as long as there is no pressure/set amount

YABU- Collections should be banned

OP posts:
bravefox · 21/12/2023 15:51

If it's a conflict of interest then surely group present is better as the teacher doesn't know who has contributed what

Hotchocolateand5marshmellows · 21/12/2023 15:46

I think it's much nicer to gift individual cards and little chocolates and things, because then the children can give their teachers these things themselves and wish them a merry Christmas and have the teacher say thankyou/merry Christmas back individually. You bypass that child/teacher moment by just handing over a fiver to someone on the pta.

Having said that I don't agree with an actual ban on a collective gift.

TeacherCollection · 21/12/2023 15:45

Name changed for this as outing. This year at DS’s school a new parent organised the gift and basically put that she wanted £100 per parent. Whilst this is a private school it is also a school with very high numbers of bursary awards and military children. Collection was for 2 teachers so each got £1500. It was genuinely sickening. DS is there on a 100% bursary and we didn’t contribute because we literally didn’t have £100 to give to it.

StripeyDeckchair · 21/12/2023 15:37

The Department for Education mandated that all schools keep a register of gifts to staff & schools will be questioned during their annual audit about it & specifically about any large gifts.

I suspect that the large teacher class gifts are more private school where there are less constraints and more money.

TBH I think most staff would happily accept a ban on student/parent gifts as we'd rather the money went on yhe children - a card, letter or picture is fine.

Callyem · 21/12/2023 15:32

I always preferred to stick a tenner in a collection and not have to concern myself with additional gift buying, gift bags, cards etc.

I think the arguments against collections mostly stem from how they are done rather than their existence altogether.

Tessasanderson · 21/12/2023 15:28

Wouldyouguess · 21/12/2023 15:15

Conflict of interest? I have seen it all.
I have not met a single teacher who would favourable treat a student who offered them chocolates over someone who didnt, how does favourable treatment work anyways in your case? Exams are externally marked, we see kids twice a week. Would you mark a book better? Or smile more often? What a ridiculous idea.

Edited

Are you suggesting that any teacher would openly admit to favouring a child because their mummy gave them a gift. That would be an extremely stupid teacher. Doesnt mean it doesnt happen and is fundamentally the basis of BRIBERY LAW. You dont even have to have the intentions to be guilty of bribery.

Its been the case for decades that there are kids who are popular, invested in everything, able to attend everything because their parents can afford all the school trips, outside activities, usually quite clever because, surprise surprise their parents can help more, parents help out with school activities too because they have spare time etc etc etc. This is just an extension of that and another case of the have nots being put in their little box to keep quiet, tick the boxes and made to fight the system.

As i say, support the teachers next time they strike.

Wouldyouguess · 21/12/2023 15:15

RatatouillePie · 21/12/2023 12:52

That "personal gesture" could be seen as a conflict of interest though.

In a state school you have students from both wealthy and poor backgrounds. If a wealthy student started buying expensive gifts for their teacher, particularly GCSE and A Level, it may be seen that the teacher would think more favourably of them and spend more time helping that child consciously or subconsciously.

Pupils can become 'favourites' often without a teacher really realising.

It's funny how a gift can change an opinion.

I teach in a secondary school and I got the most wonderful gift this Christmas. It was a Christmas card from someone who I taught for GCSE last year who was a pain in the bottom! The card acknowledged how challenging their behaviour was, and thanked me for never giving up on them. It made me think quite differently about them (they don't take my subject for A Level so no conflict of interest here!).

Conflict of interest? I have seen it all.
I have not met a single teacher who would favourable treat a student who offered them chocolates over someone who didnt, how does favourable treatment work anyways in your case? Exams are externally marked, we see kids twice a week. Would you mark a book better? Or smile more often? What a ridiculous idea.

redalex261 · 21/12/2023 15:00

I really wish the school or LA would ban this. Even when it starts with the best of intentions (no pressure, any amount acceptable, whole class on card etc.) it often ends up hijacked by the power mummy with the list; keeping track of all and chasing up via message and turns into a shit show.

Primary school teachers in the main are great, they do a tough job. However I don’t see them as more deserving of a gift than any other public servant role. Secondary teachers get nothing, neither do GPs, health & safety inspectors, traffic wardens (!), community police, planning officers - none of them.

Most roles have to report gifts to avoid allegations of taking a backhander. By all means get the child to give a card to a great teacher but please pack in this biannual farce at Christmas and end of academic year. I’ve no idea how it got so big, but really wish it hadn’t.

FloweryName · 21/12/2023 14:32

RatatouillePie · 21/12/2023 12:52

That "personal gesture" could be seen as a conflict of interest though.

In a state school you have students from both wealthy and poor backgrounds. If a wealthy student started buying expensive gifts for their teacher, particularly GCSE and A Level, it may be seen that the teacher would think more favourably of them and spend more time helping that child consciously or subconsciously.

Pupils can become 'favourites' often without a teacher really realising.

It's funny how a gift can change an opinion.

I teach in a secondary school and I got the most wonderful gift this Christmas. It was a Christmas card from someone who I taught for GCSE last year who was a pain in the bottom! The card acknowledged how challenging their behaviour was, and thanked me for never giving up on them. It made me think quite differently about them (they don't take my subject for A Level so no conflict of interest here!).

You have a point about teachers possibly subconsciously putting in more effort for children who have appreciative parents, but I think a parent’s attitude throughout the year is more likely to have an effect on that in primary schools where gift giving is much more prevalent and parents and teachers have much more contact. Primary and secondary are very different so the considerations are not the same. Primary is when parents need most support from teachers themselves so they may have genuine reason to be personally thankful, and it when parents should be teaching their children to appreciate the people that care for and educate them.

If anything, class collections would go some way towards preventing favouritism that could come from gifts because almost everyone has given the same or the staff are unaware if it if they haven’t. I have enough faith in teachers that I don’t believe a couple of gifts are going to make a difference to how they do their jobs.

IgnoranceNotOk · 21/12/2023 14:01

As a parent I think the collections are brilliant. We usually put in £5 for the teacher and TA (this year £6 so it was easier to split between a job share). If they didn’t do it I’d be buying each of them wine/flowers/chocolates and it would be much more expensive!
Our WhatsApp doesn’t put any pressure on and people don’t know who has contributed or who hasn’t and I’m just gratefully to the person sorting it!
My only disappointment with it is I’d like DS to be giving someone so he can see the value of it but he has made them pictures so hopefully that’s covered.

As a teacher, I never expect anything but some of my pupils love to give gifts so they do that and there’s a collection which some do. I’ve had children make me things and others tell me they don’t give gifts and I tell them that I am grateful to have all of them in my class and seeing them trying so hard and making our classroom a lovely place is what I really want!
A couple of years ago I received a card from someone’s grandma which was the loveliest thing I’ve ever read just thanking me so much and saying how her GC loves my lessons; it made me cry!

It’s so amazing that so many parents appreciate teachers and want to share that in some way. Just supporting us through the year is all we need but it’s also lovely that children want to give and show thanks - I’ve had lots of drawings and cards made this year too.

Tessasanderson · 21/12/2023 14:00

YABU. I absolutely hate the underlying thought process that a parent should purchase anything for a teacher for doing their job. At its most basic it is purchasing favour with a teacher and i do not believe any child/parent should be made to feel that they have to 'cough up'.

It stinks of haves and have nots, bribery and favouritism. If they need gifts/presents/rewards then join them on the picket line when they strike.

RandomButtons · 21/12/2023 13:29

Mumoftwoboysaged4and5 · 21/12/2023 11:35

We do collections and it’s so much easier. We each put in £10 per teacher and then get them a lovely Fortnum and Mason hamper. Considering a bottle of wine and a box of chocolates would be more than a tenner, it’s a much cheaper and easier way of doing things.

I do understand there is a cost of living crisis but teachers work incredibly hard for very little pay and a small gesture of appreciation goes a long way.

I’m not disagreeing that teachers work very hard and deserve to be paid better.

however, starting salaries for qualified teachers is £30k. Bang on average income. Therefore I think we can expect that the average classroom contains 50% of kids whose parents are on the same or less income than teachers.

If you have a large income and want to give great gifts - awesome. But £10 x 3 per child (to cover teacher and TA’s) is a hell of a lot of money. You get that there are people who can’t afford food or gifts for their own family right?

RudolfsLeftToe · 21/12/2023 13:15

I’m that parent this year, mainly because no one else wanted to do it but still wanted a collection to be organised and it’s always been easier for me to just throw in.
I didn’t give an amount or keep an eye on who’d donated because it was late in the day and I’m just not really arsed. Now I’ve thought about it I think for those who can’t afford to give anything it’s actually better this way than all the kids taking something in and giving to the teacher individually and them not having anything to give iykwim. I’m signing the card from the whole class so the teachers / kids don’t have a clue who’s put in or hasn’t and the teachers get a decent gift and not 30 mugs.

RedToothBrush · 21/12/2023 13:06

Purpleturtle45 · 21/12/2023 06:42

Local authority/school policy can ban teachers from accepting gifts over a certain value.

That's always been the case. Many get gifts over the stated value but no one enforced the rule.

I do think group collections are problematic for lots of reasons.

One is the risk of a parent being dishonest. Another is parents having pressure put on them by other parents to contribute.
Another is fallings out over what has been bought.

Then the school end up having to deal with the fall out.

And this is without the legal taxation ramifications (technically you should declare large gifts to HMRC)

But I do know they are popular because it means people don't have to worry about the effort themselves and the teachers potentially get 'nicer gifts'.

I think it depends on whether it's felt to be causing too many problems though.

cardibach · 21/12/2023 13:05

Workworkandmoreworknow · 21/12/2023 08:46

Teachers have always had to declare gifts over a certain amount? At least as long as I’ve been in a classroom (last 12 years).:

35 years for me, private and state, two different countries of the U.K. and I’ve never had to. Are you in an Academy Trust? They may have rules. It’s not standard though.
Like a PPit’s a bit academic as I rarely get anything (secondary)

Thementalloadisreal · 21/12/2023 13:03

Greycottage · 21/12/2023 11:46

Perhaps it’s a disparity between schools in high income vs low income and normal areas.

A malteasers sharing box or a tub of celebrations is £3. It’s certainly not cheaper or easier to give £10, especially since some families have 3/4 children - £30/£40 right before Christmas? No.

In my case one of our classes has shared 3 teachers and 2 TAs, so actually £10 into a pot is much cheaper than buying 5 presents. They are all getting very generous gifts as a result of the collection.

Thementalloadisreal · 21/12/2023 13:00

I don’t think they should be banned at all! I think collections are so much easier and straightforward for parents - so long as everyone involved is aware that participation is optional and you can put in what you can afford.

It’s easier to contribute just a few quid to a pot and be included if that’s all you can afford than to try to get a card and present together for the same few quid. And then potentially feel self conscious as it would be more obvious to a teacher if they got lots of gifts of wildly differing value (not that I think the teachers would care or judge for one moment but just that it would be obvious to them if you’re struggling to afford a gift)

In addition, it’s much more environmentally friendly to give one big present than end up with 30+ boxes of chocolates and worlds best teacher mugs.

Mairzydotes · 21/12/2023 12:55

They say ' thanks for organising the collection ' like having to keep an extra tenner for yourself is and they've done you a favour

RatatouillePie · 21/12/2023 12:52

FloweryName · 21/12/2023 11:05

I don’t like the idea of state interference in something that I see as a personal gesture between families and individuals at their schools. Legislation banning parents from thanking teachers with vouchers is completely inconsistent in a society where people are expected to tip waiters, hairdressers etc for two hours of service. If school staff can’t be thanked for going above and beyond then school management, government and parents need to stop expecting them to go above and beyond as standard.

All that said though, my school doesn’t allow staff to accept cash or anything with a value above £20 and there is still plenty of opportunity for for parents to show appreciation if they want to.

That "personal gesture" could be seen as a conflict of interest though.

In a state school you have students from both wealthy and poor backgrounds. If a wealthy student started buying expensive gifts for their teacher, particularly GCSE and A Level, it may be seen that the teacher would think more favourably of them and spend more time helping that child consciously or subconsciously.

Pupils can become 'favourites' often without a teacher really realising.

It's funny how a gift can change an opinion.

I teach in a secondary school and I got the most wonderful gift this Christmas. It was a Christmas card from someone who I taught for GCSE last year who was a pain in the bottom! The card acknowledged how challenging their behaviour was, and thanked me for never giving up on them. It made me think quite differently about them (they don't take my subject for A Level so no conflict of interest here!).

WashItTomorrow · 21/12/2023 12:42

Mumoftwoboysaged4and5 · 21/12/2023 11:35

We do collections and it’s so much easier. We each put in £10 per teacher and then get them a lovely Fortnum and Mason hamper. Considering a bottle of wine and a box of chocolates would be more than a tenner, it’s a much cheaper and easier way of doing things.

I do understand there is a cost of living crisis but teachers work incredibly hard for very little pay and a small gesture of appreciation goes a long way.

Well, clearly you don’t understand there’s a cost of living crisis. £10 is a lot of money for many people. It’s more than I would spend on a present to a family member. Teachers do work hard but not for “very little pay”. All teachers I know earn a lot more than I do and considerably more than the national average.

Babybearissleeping · 21/12/2023 12:18

Our school policy is staff can't accept gifts over £100 from an individual and can't accept cash which I think is reasonable.

Quite often collections go over £100 but as that's from multiple people it's allowed

Shinyandnew1 · 21/12/2023 12:15

It has come to my attention though that some local authorities are banning this

Can you link to anywhere suggesting this, other than the Daily Mail?

I find this very difficult to believe. Local Authorities only have any sort of control over LA schools, so academies and free schools could do what they wanted. As could private schools, whose teachers often get given very expensive presents!

CaramelMac · 21/12/2023 12:09

I never give to them, if my kids want to give a gift I help them choose something appropriate and wrap it and write a nice message in a card, usually biscuits or sweets they can leave in the staff room/donate to the food bank if they don’t want them. I think it’s a bit pointless if the kids don’t have anything to do with the actual gift.

Greycottage · 21/12/2023 11:46

Mumoftwoboysaged4and5 · 21/12/2023 11:35

We do collections and it’s so much easier. We each put in £10 per teacher and then get them a lovely Fortnum and Mason hamper. Considering a bottle of wine and a box of chocolates would be more than a tenner, it’s a much cheaper and easier way of doing things.

I do understand there is a cost of living crisis but teachers work incredibly hard for very little pay and a small gesture of appreciation goes a long way.

Perhaps it’s a disparity between schools in high income vs low income and normal areas.

A malteasers sharing box or a tub of celebrations is £3. It’s certainly not cheaper or easier to give £10, especially since some families have 3/4 children - £30/£40 right before Christmas? No.

IndecentFeminist · 21/12/2023 11:42

This isn't new surely? Lots of professions have to disclose gifts etc or cannot accept them.

Swipe left for the next trending thread