Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teacher gift collection

163 replies

Purpleturtle45 · 21/12/2023 06:36

Every year I organise a collection at Christmas and Summer for my kids teachers and usually buy vouchers for somewhere nice. I always make it very clear that any amount is welcome and of course only donate if you want to. Some parents might want to do their own thing, or nothing which is their decision.

Most parents are very grateful for this as it gives them one less thing to do and they probably get away with donating less for a joint present than they would trying buy something themselves for £5-£10.

It has come to my attention though that some local authorities are banning this due to cost of living and parents potentially feeling under pressure do donate. Wondering people's thoughts on this? I think people should be allowed to make their own choices on this and think a ban would be very unreasonable.

YANBU- Collections are fine as long as there is no pressure/set amount

YABU- Collections should be banned

OP posts:
waterrat · 21/12/2023 17:37

Op how do you think it feels for a parent on low income to see a collection they cant affird to contribute to...? It feels horrible and i hate the idea of a present from two thirds of the kids with the poorer ones left out

I loathe the whole thing

Ive seen collections thst ended with teachers getting 100 quid or more in vouchers. Thst is just so wrong in my view when parents would often be nowhere near getting thst level and would never have thst sort of gift themselves

Thementalloadisreal · 21/12/2023 17:27

kimchio · 21/12/2023 17:26

Yeah maybe pro rata it?

😂 get them a box of 12 beers to share but take out 3

kimchio · 21/12/2023 17:26

Thementalloadisreal · 21/12/2023 17:21

That’s up to you but they still took your refuse the other 9 months and will continue to do so.
Strike action is taken against the employer not the end user.

Yeah maybe pro rata it?

Thementalloadisreal · 21/12/2023 17:21

RedToothBrush · 21/12/2023 17:16

You don't live somewhere which has had a three month bin strike do you?

I don't think they'll be getting much of a tip there...

That’s up to you but they still took your refuse the other 9 months and will continue to do so.
Strike action is taken against the employer not the end user.

Timeforanewnam · 21/12/2023 17:19

As a teacher, we don’t expect gifts

however, my class has often done a group voucher for us .

I actually thought the other day that potentially it would be a really cheap way to give , for example if everyone put in £1 for the teacher and £1 for the ta , they would have a lovely £30 gift card, and very cheap for the parents

I understand that in reality it doesn’t work out like that , people doing their own thing ect .

personally I would be very surprised if the la got involved, mainly due to their inability to organise a piss up in a brewery.

kimchio · 21/12/2023 17:16

Give it to the food bank

RedToothBrush · 21/12/2023 17:16

Thementalloadisreal · 21/12/2023 17:14

I think most people do tip the refuse collectors nowadays too, actually.

A gift for a teacher isn’t mandatory. I fail to see how it can be “galling” to be asked if you’d like to participate or not.

A box of pencils is worse, surely , as the Govt should be paying for provisions not parents!

Edited

You don't live somewhere which has had a three month bin strike do you?

I don't think they'll be getting much of a tip there...

Thementalloadisreal · 21/12/2023 17:14

HarryOHayandBettyOBarley · 21/12/2023 16:45

Christ that’s a bit miserable. Why buy anyone a present then?! Why buy your mum a present, isn’t it just her job to be your mum?
Teachers care for your children 6 hours a day 5 days a week and you begrudge them a box of chocs

Mums don’t get paid. Surely teachers aren't comparable to the children’s mothers? That’s like saying that your road should do a whip around for the binmen?

We’ve had some really bad teachers. It is galling to be asked to effectively tip them. A nice homemade personal card should be sufficient to say thank you to teachers who go above and beyond.

It should be written into all school’s policies that personal gifts are not allowed. Contribute a box of pencils or books to the school library if you really feel the need to send something into school.

I think most people do tip the refuse collectors nowadays too, actually.

A gift for a teacher isn’t mandatory. I fail to see how it can be “galling” to be asked if you’d like to participate or not.

A box of pencils is worse, surely , as the Govt should be paying for provisions not parents!

Thementalloadisreal · 21/12/2023 17:12

forgivingfiggy · 21/12/2023 16:43

I stopped donating to the group presents after I heard how much was collected (I also didn't like the way it was split between the teacher and TAs). It was such a huge pot of money, it suddenly seemed a bit tasteless. I get that it saves the hassle of buying individually, but I'd rather my kids pick something small and take pride in giving it to their own teacher, than some voucher for an eye-watering amount being presented. It kind of misses the whole point.

I’m not sure the teacher would agree though. Surely a good amount on a voucher would be more use than lots of little trinkets. Not sure why “the point” of gift giving should be something meaningful but ultimately useless.
Children can still write a heartfelt card.

Frankly your attitude to the amount raised makes you sound a bit petty and jealous.

Shinyandnew1 · 21/12/2023 17:12

SatanClaws · 21/12/2023 17:09

£5 x multiple children adds up to a fair sum of money for a family.

Then they don’t have to do it, that is perfectly fine.

SatanClaws · 21/12/2023 17:09

£5 x multiple children adds up to a fair sum of money for a family.

Shinyandnew1 · 21/12/2023 17:07

Crazycrazylady · 21/12/2023 16:57

In our school no one organises a group gift.
I really wish they would. It would be a job off my list . I probably always end up spending more than a tenner by the time I've wrapped and bagged the thing.
I'm a bit shocked at the amount of people who think teachers shouldn't be allowed accept anything. Seems so mean spirited. Give one if you want or don't buy it's not fair to dictate to others what to do .

Absolutely. I’m more than happy to tip other people at Christmas who regularly go above and beyond doing their job-window cleaner, postman, hairdresser etc, are we going to ban that as well?!

I doubt private schools will ever ban gift giving, so don’t think any other schools should either.

Crazycrazylady · 21/12/2023 16:57

In our school no one organises a group gift.
I really wish they would. It would be a job off my list . I probably always end up spending more than a tenner by the time I've wrapped and bagged the thing.
I'm a bit shocked at the amount of people who think teachers shouldn't be allowed accept anything. Seems so mean spirited. Give one if you want or don't buy it's not fair to dictate to others what to do .

Shinyandnew1 · 21/12/2023 16:52

I’ve always been happy to buy for my children’s teachers-I enjoy giving something towards them having something nice. If I didn’t want to, I wouldn’t do it.

Sometimes I’ve paid into a class collection, other times we’ve got them wine. Plenty of people over the years have bought gifts some years, or not at all-that’s their choice, but I wouldn’t want the option removed.

Lizzieregina · 21/12/2023 16:51

When my kids were little, we always did a teacher collection. It was not obligatory and the suggested donation was $5 or less (which is very reasonable). There were usually about 25 kids per class, so allowing for a couple of people who did their own thing or nothing, we’d usually have about $100. I actually had one teacher tell me ahead of time to just give her the money! I got a chuckle out of that and was happy to do so as it saved me the bother of trying to figure out what she might like. Also, teachers don’t tend to be rolling in dough, so she probably could use the extra.

HarryOHayandBettyOBarley · 21/12/2023 16:45

Christ that’s a bit miserable. Why buy anyone a present then?! Why buy your mum a present, isn’t it just her job to be your mum?
Teachers care for your children 6 hours a day 5 days a week and you begrudge them a box of chocs

Mums don’t get paid. Surely teachers aren't comparable to the children’s mothers? That’s like saying that your road should do a whip around for the binmen?

We’ve had some really bad teachers. It is galling to be asked to effectively tip them. A nice homemade personal card should be sufficient to say thank you to teachers who go above and beyond.

It should be written into all school’s policies that personal gifts are not allowed. Contribute a box of pencils or books to the school library if you really feel the need to send something into school.

flowerchild2000 · 21/12/2023 16:44

RandomButtons · 21/12/2023 08:27

It’s not an abuse of power, rules on gifts have been in place in the corporate world for at least the last 20 years. in my previous job we had to declare anything worth more than £10.

Teachers aren't corporate employees.

Littlecaf · 21/12/2023 16:43

I’ve organised it a few times - I’ve never known who has put in what and just do it from the whole class. I’ve learnt over the years not to over think it! If someone want to do their own thing that’s fine too.

forgivingfiggy · 21/12/2023 16:43

I stopped donating to the group presents after I heard how much was collected (I also didn't like the way it was split between the teacher and TAs). It was such a huge pot of money, it suddenly seemed a bit tasteless. I get that it saves the hassle of buying individually, but I'd rather my kids pick something small and take pride in giving it to their own teacher, than some voucher for an eye-watering amount being presented. It kind of misses the whole point.

lovelygreenglasses · 21/12/2023 16:35

A wonderful mum does ours.

A fiver each or whatever you can afford.

Occasionally a few parents say (or don't say)That they'll do their own thing, I have once. Absolutely no pressure.

Result: teachers and TAs over the years have received vouchers/ favourite chocolates or a bottle of something /one special mug etc.

It's sooo much more affordable than buying bits of this and that from each family, and a daresay nicer for the staff, and less wasteful.

Some people can really suck the joy out of things!

Awumminnscotland · 21/12/2023 16:28

As far as I understand there is at least one local authority in scotland that does this and another that considered it and yes it was in a paper daily mail headline style if I remember correctly.
No school boards here for state schools, all schools run by local authority.

Thementalloadisreal · 21/12/2023 16:28

peakygold · 21/12/2023 16:25

YABU. Why on earth should teachers receive any kind of gift from parents? They are doing their job when they aren't on leave, strike, INSET days, Occasional days, broken boiler days. Do you have a whip round for the caretaker/cleaners/lunch staff too?

Christ that’s a bit miserable. Why buy anyone a present then?! Why buy your mum a present, isn’t it just her job to be your mum?
Teachers care for your children 6 hours a day 5 days a week and you begrudge them a box of chocs at Xmas?

peakygold · 21/12/2023 16:25

YABU. Why on earth should teachers receive any kind of gift from parents? They are doing their job when they aren't on leave, strike, INSET days, Occasional days, broken boiler days. Do you have a whip round for the caretaker/cleaners/lunch staff too?

Thementalloadisreal · 21/12/2023 16:19

redalex261 · 21/12/2023 15:00

I really wish the school or LA would ban this. Even when it starts with the best of intentions (no pressure, any amount acceptable, whole class on card etc.) it often ends up hijacked by the power mummy with the list; keeping track of all and chasing up via message and turns into a shit show.

Primary school teachers in the main are great, they do a tough job. However I don’t see them as more deserving of a gift than any other public servant role. Secondary teachers get nothing, neither do GPs, health & safety inspectors, traffic wardens (!), community police, planning officers - none of them.

Most roles have to report gifts to avoid allegations of taking a backhander. By all means get the child to give a card to a great teacher but please pack in this biannual farce at Christmas and end of academic year. I’ve no idea how it got so big, but really wish it hadn’t.

There’s nothing stopping you from giving a card or small gesture to any other role you see fit, unless it’s illegal for any reason in their particular job. I have a friend in hospital this week and I’ll be taking in chocolates and biscuits for the nurses. I also tip the postman, milkman, window cleaner, if we saw the same GP more than once or had a local police presence I’d certainly give him/her a Christmas card and box of chocs.

That said, as much as traffic wardens and planning inspectors etc are valuable, they don’t care for people’s 5 year olds on a daily basis! You can’t compare.

Wouldyouguess · 21/12/2023 16:05

Tessasanderson · 21/12/2023 15:28

Are you suggesting that any teacher would openly admit to favouring a child because their mummy gave them a gift. That would be an extremely stupid teacher. Doesnt mean it doesnt happen and is fundamentally the basis of BRIBERY LAW. You dont even have to have the intentions to be guilty of bribery.

Its been the case for decades that there are kids who are popular, invested in everything, able to attend everything because their parents can afford all the school trips, outside activities, usually quite clever because, surprise surprise their parents can help more, parents help out with school activities too because they have spare time etc etc etc. This is just an extension of that and another case of the have nots being put in their little box to keep quiet, tick the boxes and made to fight the system.

As i say, support the teachers next time they strike.

I worked in secondary for 10 years. Across 4 schools, if there was any favouritism, it had nothing to do with getting a mug someone may or may not have got for Xmas. I kid you not. Still would love to see how favouritism in Maths, Geography or Science lesson would look like, have not seen many examples.
I also saw hoardes of kids from very deprived backgrounds doing amazing, getting main roles in school plays, winning competitions and whatnot. The fact a minority of teachers in some schools (private I presume?) favour kids whose parents help out does not mean it's the 'norm'. It's such a petty view that all teachers do it I am still laughing reading those posts. Except it's really not funny.
It's just sad that even at this time of the year teachers are being bashed because a few parents feel a bit sour.
Are you feeling inadequate as a parent? Do you have inferiority complex?
If the answer to both is no, it should not matter to you that some teacher out there will feel appreciated while enjoying. a box of Maltesers given to them by a student.
If yes, then dont project your feelings onto others.