Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teacher gift collection

163 replies

Purpleturtle45 · 21/12/2023 06:36

Every year I organise a collection at Christmas and Summer for my kids teachers and usually buy vouchers for somewhere nice. I always make it very clear that any amount is welcome and of course only donate if you want to. Some parents might want to do their own thing, or nothing which is their decision.

Most parents are very grateful for this as it gives them one less thing to do and they probably get away with donating less for a joint present than they would trying buy something themselves for £5-£10.

It has come to my attention though that some local authorities are banning this due to cost of living and parents potentially feeling under pressure do donate. Wondering people's thoughts on this? I think people should be allowed to make their own choices on this and think a ban would be very unreasonable.

YANBU- Collections are fine as long as there is no pressure/set amount

YABU- Collections should be banned

OP posts:
HarryOHayandBettyOBarley · 22/12/2023 16:45

Wouldyouguess · 22/12/2023 16:43

"Many are doing the bare minimum. That was very plain to see during covid."

Please join our profession ans show us how it's done maestro! No? I didnt think so 😂

Leave if you don’t like it. Simple. Think you’d miss the annual leave though!

Wouldyouguess · 22/12/2023 16:43

HarryOHayandBettyOBarley · 22/12/2023 14:21

(if you’re doing the job well).

Many are doing the bare minimum. That was very plain to see during covid.

And degrees aren’t the exclusive passport they were twenty years ago either. There are many degree holders doing quite low income roles. I doubt they get tipped though.

I kniw many teaching assistants who have degrees. Why aren’t we talking about their salaries and tipping them?

Edited

"Many are doing the bare minimum. That was very plain to see during covid."

Please join our profession ans show us how it's done maestro! No? I didnt think so 😂

Wouldyouguess · 22/12/2023 16:42

KnowWhatIMean · 22/12/2023 13:36

I saw Martin Lewis had weighed in on this, saying that nobody should feel pressure to contribute (I agree) and the person organising the gift should put every child’s name on the gift, regardless of if their parents had contributed or not, because the teacher might treat the children who hadn’t contributed differently. As a TA in a primary school I found this extremely insulting and patronising. We are in the position to know already which children are less likely to contribute because of their background, we know and understand this, and never ever treat the children differently. To suggest that we would is just staggering.

This is what I fiund laughable (and insulting)- that people make up this whole theory teachers treat kids differently based if they give a gift or not. it's so incredibly patronising, and the fact that Martin Lewis even felt to make a post about it. It's just another argument to use to bash teachers and b*tch about the same "they do nothing anyways so why would we even consider gifting anything at all".

HarryOHayandBettyOBarley · 22/12/2023 14:21

(if you’re doing the job well).

Many are doing the bare minimum. That was very plain to see during covid.

And degrees aren’t the exclusive passport they were twenty years ago either. There are many degree holders doing quite low income roles. I doubt they get tipped though.

I kniw many teaching assistants who have degrees. Why aren’t we talking about their salaries and tipping them?

SatanClaws · 22/12/2023 13:42

IgnoranceNotOk · 22/12/2023 13:02

I think what people tend to mean is that for a degree level job the pay is low.

This is why teacher retention is in crisis now as teachers know the pay isn’t terrible and they have extended holidays but now the workload is so bad and conditions and funding in schools is so poor that it’s a very challenging job and then you’re working at least 60 hour weeks and still working some of the holidays too (if you’re doing the job well).

But it's really not low at all.

KnowWhatIMean · 22/12/2023 13:36

I saw Martin Lewis had weighed in on this, saying that nobody should feel pressure to contribute (I agree) and the person organising the gift should put every child’s name on the gift, regardless of if their parents had contributed or not, because the teacher might treat the children who hadn’t contributed differently. As a TA in a primary school I found this extremely insulting and patronising. We are in the position to know already which children are less likely to contribute because of their background, we know and understand this, and never ever treat the children differently. To suggest that we would is just staggering.

WashItTomorrow · 22/12/2023 13:17

IgnoranceNotOk · 22/12/2023 13:02

I think what people tend to mean is that for a degree level job the pay is low.

This is why teacher retention is in crisis now as teachers know the pay isn’t terrible and they have extended holidays but now the workload is so bad and conditions and funding in schools is so poor that it’s a very challenging job and then you’re working at least 60 hour weeks and still working some of the holidays too (if you’re doing the job well).

No, the pay isn’t low for a degree-level job. It’s actually pretty good. People seem to have very distorted ideas about the pay in degree-level jobs.

IgnoranceNotOk · 22/12/2023 13:02

TeacherCollection · 22/12/2023 09:46

@Happilyobtuse are they on a low income though? Starting salary is 30k and they do also get all the extra holiday so if they have their own children they won’t need to pay for childcare in those times?

I think what people tend to mean is that for a degree level job the pay is low.

This is why teacher retention is in crisis now as teachers know the pay isn’t terrible and they have extended holidays but now the workload is so bad and conditions and funding in schools is so poor that it’s a very challenging job and then you’re working at least 60 hour weeks and still working some of the holidays too (if you’re doing the job well).

TeacherCollection · 22/12/2023 09:46

@Happilyobtuse are they on a low income though? Starting salary is 30k and they do also get all the extra holiday so if they have their own children they won’t need to pay for childcare in those times?

IgnoranceNotOk · 21/12/2023 23:46

forgivingfiggy · 21/12/2023 16:43

I stopped donating to the group presents after I heard how much was collected (I also didn't like the way it was split between the teacher and TAs). It was such a huge pot of money, it suddenly seemed a bit tasteless. I get that it saves the hassle of buying individually, but I'd rather my kids pick something small and take pride in giving it to their own teacher, than some voucher for an eye-watering amount being presented. It kind of misses the whole point.

I’m scared to ask, but what was wrong with the way it was split between teacher and TA??

Happilyobtuse · 21/12/2023 23:27

waterrat · 21/12/2023 17:37

Op how do you think it feels for a parent on low income to see a collection they cant affird to contribute to...? It feels horrible and i hate the idea of a present from two thirds of the kids with the poorer ones left out

I loathe the whole thing

Ive seen collections thst ended with teachers getting 100 quid or more in vouchers. Thst is just so wrong in my view when parents would often be nowhere near getting thst level and would never have thst sort of gift themselves

Everyone has the option to contribute or not contribute. People will anyway be giving gifts even if there was no collection. So you can be part of it or not depending on your circumstances. Also begrudging the teacher a nice present just because you won’t get such a big present really seems petty. I doubt anyone is going to buy me a present for £120 this Christmas. But that is what my child’s teacher got in JL vouchers and I am very happy for her. Shouldn’t we be glad that teachers who are generally on quite low income are atleast getting something back for their hard work?!

Happilyobtuse · 21/12/2023 23:16

We have class collections in our school and it is a blessing when as a parent you are stretched for time. It also works out a hell of a lot cheaper than trying to buy individual presents! I have one child in school, it cost me £10 for the class present. I have one child in nursery I ended up spending £50 on gifts for all the nursery staff. I then had to find time to wrap the gifts and drop it off etc. Much rather pay £10 and forget about it. Also the main teacher gets a voucher for JL for about £120, some wine and chocolate and a card. The other teachers get similar with smaller gift card value. Honestly I think this is great for teachers and parents!

cardibach · 21/12/2023 23:03

Thementalloadisreal · 21/12/2023 16:28

Christ that’s a bit miserable. Why buy anyone a present then?! Why buy your mum a present, isn’t it just her job to be your mum?
Teachers care for your children 6 hours a day 5 days a week and you begrudge them a box of chocs at Xmas?

I agree. I’m also wondering a bit about ‘leave’ -what’s that?
Also whenever I’ve worked in a school that has a heating fail teachers have been expected in even if pupils aren’t and then worked in one room with electric heaters plugged in.
Occasional days will be part of the standard holidays, as are inset days. No pupil gets fewer days at school because of them.
So that leaves strikes. I’ve been teaching for 35 years and have been on strike on exactly 3 occasions (plus one I missed because I was working in a private school at the time). Not massive really, is it?

mollyfolk · 21/12/2023 22:58

i think they should be banned. My children go to a school with lots of parents who earn decent incomes but a significant amount are low income parents. I think it can put pressure on families who don’t have it to give towards the collection. I’ve always worked for government bodies or non profits and it has never been allowed for staff to receive presents from clients or suppliers.

Ohmylovejune · 21/12/2023 22:54

The only reason I can think of it being reasonable to not allow gifts over a certain level is where there could be bribery.

I'd think it's less likely to fall into that description if it's a group gift and it's lovely for a teacher to get something useful rather than lots of small and probably very similar items.

I can see this system occasionally getting out of hand but the nature of schools means that will pass. Next year there will be a new set of children and a new set of parents.

ichifanny · 21/12/2023 22:52

We aren’t allowed to accept monetary gifts in the nhs so why would it be allowed in other caring or public sector jobs . I understand why it’s to stop bribery or special treatment .

Amana · 21/12/2023 22:48

redalex261 · 21/12/2023 15:00

I really wish the school or LA would ban this. Even when it starts with the best of intentions (no pressure, any amount acceptable, whole class on card etc.) it often ends up hijacked by the power mummy with the list; keeping track of all and chasing up via message and turns into a shit show.

Primary school teachers in the main are great, they do a tough job. However I don’t see them as more deserving of a gift than any other public servant role. Secondary teachers get nothing, neither do GPs, health & safety inspectors, traffic wardens (!), community police, planning officers - none of them.

Most roles have to report gifts to avoid allegations of taking a backhander. By all means get the child to give a card to a great teacher but please pack in this biannual farce at Christmas and end of academic year. I’ve no idea how it got so big, but really wish it hadn’t.

LA’s don’t have any control over academy trusts.

lovelygreenglasses · 21/12/2023 20:14

My DM taught for 40 years.

She used to love presents from her class and she'd always save them under the Christmas tree and let me open them on Boxing Day.

She never worked in an affluent area but received all manner of things... mainly matchmakers, Maltesers and cheap wine, occasionally a nice candle or scarf. This was well before class WhatsApp groups and joint presents.

But imagine if every child, every Christmas and summer, had given her some sort of trinket. That'd be 2,400 wax melt burners/mugs/jewellery stands/cute wall hangings over the course of a career!

She maintains that the most meaningful things were nice notes and cards from the children or parents.

But the class collection, especially when done openly and sympathetically is a godsend!

Unic0rn · 21/12/2023 20:05

This

WillowCraft · 21/12/2023 19:52

I think class collections are a bit rubbish, partly because they don't involve the child, partly because of the pressure to contribute via the WhatsApp group messages, partly because the resulting voucher can't be shared amongst all staff.
For those saying they just put "from all children in year x" well what's the point of a gift if you don't know who it's from ?
Seems better for me to get the child to either make or write a card, or choose a small present, something small and cheap is fine, a £2 choc bar or pack of biscuits etc. It's more personal and those types of gifts are easy to share with the cleaners etc if need be or pass onto food bank.

Not a teacher but I'm in another role where people give gifts at Christmas. I've been given all sorts over the years from leather handbags and huge bouquets to individual serving wine bottles and cheap bath bubbles. (Mostly boxes of biscuits and chocolates though!) It really is the thought that counts. Someone who is very poor who has gone to the trouble to buy a £2 gift has given proportionately much more than someone rich who chucks £20 into a collection organised by someone else. A handwritten card is the best reward of all.

HarryOHayandBettyOBarley · 21/12/2023 19:44

A box of pencils is worse, surely , as the Govt should be paying for provisions not parents!

There are loads of teachers on MN who post about how they use their own money to fund additional classroom supplies.

Contributing to the classroom is far more sensible.

There is no need to tip teachers. It is ludicrous. They get paid like every other state employee and they are pad as much if not more than many.

I cannot fathom why this is even a thing.

Tip the cleaner or the teaching assistants if you feel the need to tip.

Purpleturtle45 · 21/12/2023 19:42

waterrat · 21/12/2023 17:37

Op how do you think it feels for a parent on low income to see a collection they cant affird to contribute to...? It feels horrible and i hate the idea of a present from two thirds of the kids with the poorer ones left out

I loathe the whole thing

Ive seen collections thst ended with teachers getting 100 quid or more in vouchers. Thst is just so wrong in my view when parents would often be nowhere near getting thst level and would never have thst sort of gift themselves

I don't think that necessarily means that you shouldn't do it though. I am not a high earner and there are lots of things I would like to be able to do/buy for my kids and myself but just have to accept that it's not within my budget and get on with it!

OP posts:
Moreorlessmentallystable · 21/12/2023 19:04

I have 2 kids and the parent on one of the groups are well organised and do a collection at end of the year. Both times contributes £10 which is fine, collection went to around £250 as I cluded a combined group and they got vouchers and flowers. For Christmas we normally bring a basket of pastries for the staff room, this year we just did sweets as both my kids have 2-3 teachers, the day we made the sweetie jars a parent asked if we wanted to contribute to the collection for the 2 teachers. I was. ABIT embarrassed to say no, we went other way but genuinely didn't know they were doing this for Christmas as it was left to the last few days....I mean if it's a tenner per teacher that tunes I to £40 Christmas and £40 end of year...we already have a huge family and have to buy far too many presents. Nothing against teachers, I think they deserve it but shouldn't be expected. In my line of work (private sector) we are not allowed any gifts from customers ( even when we don't really have any input on decision making )...

girlfriend44 · 21/12/2023 17:40

Purpleturtle45 · 21/12/2023 06:36

Every year I organise a collection at Christmas and Summer for my kids teachers and usually buy vouchers for somewhere nice. I always make it very clear that any amount is welcome and of course only donate if you want to. Some parents might want to do their own thing, or nothing which is their decision.

Most parents are very grateful for this as it gives them one less thing to do and they probably get away with donating less for a joint present than they would trying buy something themselves for £5-£10.

It has come to my attention though that some local authorities are banning this due to cost of living and parents potentially feeling under pressure do donate. Wondering people's thoughts on this? I think people should be allowed to make their own choices on this and think a ban would be very unreasonable.

YANBU- Collections are fine as long as there is no pressure/set amount

YABU- Collections should be banned

Thankfully, someone has seen sense. It divides people and causes stress.
What's wrong with a card of thanks, simple just send a card if you want.

waterrat · 21/12/2023 17:38

The fact you think it is ok to give a gift just leaving out any poor children whose parents cant afford to chip in shows you dont get it