Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DP believes some psychics are real, I think he's lost it

319 replies

Dpi8 · 21/12/2023 00:09

A discussion about a documentary I watched last night descended into an argument today when chatting over dinner. It was about Derren Brown and how he tests so called psychic mediums in an attempt to prove that it's a load of old rubbish - which I agree with him on.

He got majorly arsey with me when I told him about cold reading and the other techniques they use, such as using vague statements that could apply to most people in the sitters demographic. IE, telling an elderly lady that they have a parent in the spirit world who had a dodgy knee.

I asked him for some examples from which he reached his conclusion that some are genuine but he wasn't forthcoming with anything of any substance, simply mentioning some bloke from the Ghost Adventures series who wanders around buildings 'debunking' certain things for plausible deniabily then making up shite of his own to 'prove' the contact.

This is a hill I'm prepared to die on as I will not accept that such tosh is in any way genuine.

AIBU to say that absolutely all psychics are full of shit?

OP posts:
WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 21/12/2023 13:04

Jacfrost · 21/12/2023 12:47

Could you please offer a rational explanation for something I've seen. A hairbrush slide off a table by itself, quite slowly and deliberately, when it was several inches from the edge.

I wasn't drunk / on drugs / suffering any mental health problems/ carbon monoxide poisoning/sleep deprived.

The table was level, no earthquake. It just slid off for no reason and I saw it.

Yeah, you’ve got me there. It was the ghost of Vidal Sassoon, defo.

MasterBeth · 21/12/2023 13:00

Jacfrost · 21/12/2023 12:47

Could you please offer a rational explanation for something I've seen. A hairbrush slide off a table by itself, quite slowly and deliberately, when it was several inches from the edge.

I wasn't drunk / on drugs / suffering any mental health problems/ carbon monoxide poisoning/sleep deprived.

The table was level, no earthquake. It just slid off for no reason and I saw it.

There are two possible rational explanations:

  1. You were mistaken in some way about about what you saw.

  2. Everything we know about the physical nature of the Universe is wrong.

I know which one seems most likely to me.

Have you read this book? http://www.theinvisiblegorilla.com/overview.html

You should.

The Invisible Gorilla: And Other Ways Our Intuitions Deceive Us

http://www.theinvisiblegorilla.com/overview.html

NonPlayerCharacter · 21/12/2023 12:50

Jacfrost · 21/12/2023 12:47

Could you please offer a rational explanation for something I've seen. A hairbrush slide off a table by itself, quite slowly and deliberately, when it was several inches from the edge.

I wasn't drunk / on drugs / suffering any mental health problems/ carbon monoxide poisoning/sleep deprived.

The table was level, no earthquake. It just slid off for no reason and I saw it.

Everything we suggest you will insist is impossible, but draughts, slippery surfaces, slight inclines or someone making stuff up on the Internet are all far more plausible than a spirit without enough imagination to do anything cooler.

ETA: I'd like to know how many times you've told this story, too. A few weeks ago on a woo thread, someone told the story of how she got lost on the way back while on holiday and had definitely entered a time slip, no other explanation. In the first post she was clear she'd done the journey at least once (so might have been only once). In the second retelling, she had been doing it all week and it was physically impossible to take a wrong turn and the local who helped her could not understand where she'd gone wrong. She had been looking for a pond as a landmark and saw a frog. This was, apparently, clear evidence of a time slip (frog, but no water) rather than evidence that she was in fact closer to water than she thought.

The story was embellished with each retelling (what is it now, I wonder) and evidence that she was actually not as far from her desired place as she thought was seen instead as evidence that she had time travelled.

Jacfrost · 21/12/2023 12:47

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 21/12/2023 12:18

Quite.

I’m also amazed, and dismayed, at the number of MNers who believe in ghosts, poltergeists and the ‘paranormal’. Absolutely incredible in this day and age.

Could you please offer a rational explanation for something I've seen. A hairbrush slide off a table by itself, quite slowly and deliberately, when it was several inches from the edge.

I wasn't drunk / on drugs / suffering any mental health problems/ carbon monoxide poisoning/sleep deprived.

The table was level, no earthquake. It just slid off for no reason and I saw it.

ScarlettSunset · 21/12/2023 12:37

I don't have a doorbell! It didn't occur to me that perhaps I'm psychic, just that people knock... but I shall test my psychic ability by playing the euro millions this week. I shall report back if I win the jackpot!

Sadandhurt23 · 21/12/2023 12:32

I remember when a researcher on Most Haunted set Derek Accora up , and he fell for it. The guy was a complete fraud, as are many others. That said, my step dad was in an audience with Colin Fry, my SD is a total sceptic, however the stuff CF threw out to the audience couldn't have been more apt for my SD. He kept quiet but it made him cry.

Ortila · 21/12/2023 12:30

Elphame · 21/12/2023 11:37

You are clearly one of the sham ones then as a couple of them don't!

🤦‍♀️

divinededacende · 21/12/2023 12:24

I don't actively believe in psychics, ghosts and the like and I don't believe in god but I would definitely label myself as Agnostic. I do believe that the vast majority of people who "practice" in these areas are using mind games and trickery but I don't let that take away from the fact that I do keep a small part of myself open to the possibility that there are things beyond what we understand.

I think the society we live in makes it seem like we know everything about how the world and the universe works but the truth is, we don't. We don't even fully understand how the human mind works - not in a complete way.

I wouldn't judge people who do believe. For now, I'll make my life choices based on fact, what I can quantify and the best information available to me. As long as you're not trying to make me override those choices because of some mystical force, we're fine and I'm happy to hear about your beliefs.

It wouldn't be the hill I would die on with someone. His belief, however flawed, isn't harming anyone. And I doubt it's something that has a particularly big impact. If he's suggesting he bring his physic round to consult on your finances, then you can fight your battle but his ain't it.

On a side note; a psychic told my mum that it would end in tragedy if I ever got on a motorbike so I never got near my uncles bike. Even the kid-friendly ones some folk on the estate had were a no-go. I hated that bitch 🤣.

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 21/12/2023 12:18

BeardOToots · 21/12/2023 12:02

Am absolutely flabbergasted at the sheer number of people who believe in this utter, utter nonsense.
Marks to be exploited by charlatans who prey upon people’s misery.
I’m entirely with you OP.

Quite.

I’m also amazed, and dismayed, at the number of MNers who believe in ghosts, poltergeists and the ‘paranormal’. Absolutely incredible in this day and age.

Frabbits · 21/12/2023 12:12

Jacfrost · 21/12/2023 09:51

It's a belief that there's no god. Again, none of us actually know either way, so both positions are beliefs.

The only sensible position is agnosticism.

Atheism is a lack of belief. Athiests don't go around believing there is no God. It's a perfectly logical position to take.

You don't actively go around not believing in a lot of things without the need to call it a system, do you.

Firefly2009 · 21/12/2023 12:11

MasterBeth · 21/12/2023 12:07

Ha ha. He's an idiot.

This is my favourite reply

Lol.

Yes.

MasterBeth · 21/12/2023 12:07

Ha ha. He's an idiot.

Clawdy · 21/12/2023 12:03

Years ago, my sister had a phone call from her friend, saying half-jokingly "Are you alright? Amy (her three year old daughter) just told me you've fallen down the stairs!" Bizarrely, my sister had indeed tripped and fallen down the stairs a few minutes earlier. We never forgot that strange moment, so weird.

BeardOToots · 21/12/2023 12:02

Am absolutely flabbergasted at the sheer number of people who believe in this utter, utter nonsense.
Marks to be exploited by charlatans who prey upon people’s misery.
I’m entirely with you OP.

Frabbits · 21/12/2023 11:53

No psychic has ever, ever proved that they can do anything other than easily replicated magic tricks.

As such, until proved otherwise the only logical conclusion to reach is that they are full of shit - either they are so deluded as to actually think they are psychic or, as is the case 99.999% of the time, they know they aren't psychic but are just complete and utter frauds.

MahShinyShoes · 21/12/2023 11:50

How often does this come up in conversation that it matters?

Personally, I think the absolute conviction that there is nothing bigger than us, or outside of our comprehension and those who are open to the possibility, are somehow mentally lacking, is very arrogant.

How can you discount entirely that there could be something you can't conceptualise? It's impossible to prove either way, so in itself is nothing more than an equally strong belief on the opposite side of the coin.

But yeah, those psychics who charge old ladies to speak to Brian are full of shit.

NonPlayerCharacter · 21/12/2023 11:49

Elphame · 21/12/2023 11:37

You are clearly one of the sham ones then as a couple of them don't!

A couple of psychics don't have doorbells, says Elphame on Mumsnet? And people say there's no proof!

(Are you sure they're not just Mumsnetters who don't answer the door?)

randomuser2020 · 21/12/2023 11:47

This reply has been withdrawn

Removed at poster's request due to privacy concerns.

Elphame · 21/12/2023 11:37

NonPlayerCharacter · 21/12/2023 11:04

Because I'm psychic, obviously. How sceptical of you.

You are clearly one of the sham ones then as a couple of them don't!

DamnUserName21 · 21/12/2023 11:25

Ortila · 21/12/2023 10:49

Judgmental, much?!

Damn right.

Haha. 😍

Undineimmor · 21/12/2023 11:12

What if your husband was a committed Christian, believed water was turned to wine, and that a God he could neither see ir hear was giving him directions and forgiving him. Would that be a hill you would be prepared to die on ZOP.

Realistically, nobody knows definitely. People who hold extremely strong views based on nothing, or the opinions of Derren Brown, who has made a good living saying this kind of thing, are being closed minded.

ElsieMc · 21/12/2023 11:12

I posted on a similar thread a few weeks ago giving vague details on accuracies when I had a reading. I am a sceptic I must say but I found it particularly chilling. What I didn't say, for self preservation reasons, was she actually named my brother, why he left and asked how I felt about being adopted and so forth.

I received a lot of scorn over the use of "you turn the key at number 3..." because it is a renowned generic response and yes, perhaps I am very stupid and gullible here - as is the man in uniform response. But one particular poster responded with such scorn, contempt and nastiness I was compelled to respond strongly whereupon they backed down somewhat. I think it brings strong feelings to the surface and if it brings you some peace for whatever reason, then so be it.

henrysugar12 · 21/12/2023 11:07

I am sceptical, I have been to some psychic shows and had a couple of readings where it's easy to see that they have "plants" in the audience or are cold reading. But I've also visited one who has told me stuff that is impossible for her to know about. She's given me names of people that aren't the common Mary, John etc... none of which I'm linked to on social media and I gave her a different name anyway so she couldn't have researched first.

And I think as long as someone is getting comfort from what they are being told and aren't told anything bad, then what's the harm?

StaunchMomma · 21/12/2023 11:05

This is a hill I'm prepared to die on

Aaaaaand the most pointless Hill to Die On of the year award goes to.......

Seriously, OP - let the man have his own opinions and accept they don't have to match yours.

DamnUserName21 · 21/12/2023 11:05

NonPlayerCharacter · 21/12/2023 10:48

It's an inoffensive opinion that harms no one

Some would argue that fake psychics do do harm by preying on the vulnerable and grieving.

I was referring to the partner's opinion, not the actions of psychics, real or otherwise.