Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DP believes some psychics are real, I think he's lost it

319 replies

Dpi8 · 21/12/2023 00:09

A discussion about a documentary I watched last night descended into an argument today when chatting over dinner. It was about Derren Brown and how he tests so called psychic mediums in an attempt to prove that it's a load of old rubbish - which I agree with him on.

He got majorly arsey with me when I told him about cold reading and the other techniques they use, such as using vague statements that could apply to most people in the sitters demographic. IE, telling an elderly lady that they have a parent in the spirit world who had a dodgy knee.

I asked him for some examples from which he reached his conclusion that some are genuine but he wasn't forthcoming with anything of any substance, simply mentioning some bloke from the Ghost Adventures series who wanders around buildings 'debunking' certain things for plausible deniabily then making up shite of his own to 'prove' the contact.

This is a hill I'm prepared to die on as I will not accept that such tosh is in any way genuine.

AIBU to say that absolutely all psychics are full of shit?

OP posts:
Frabbits · 21/12/2023 15:58

pponk · 21/12/2023 14:13

@NonPlayerCharacter and @Frabbits the opposite isn't to believe in something but simply to say "who knows, it might happen" .

There is a limit, though. I mean, you don't go around saying "who knows, it might happen" to any old shit, do you? Otherwise how would you get anything done.

Besides, we know how psychics can give the impression they can know things about people. It's not more woo than a magician sawing a woman in half.

Dpi8 · 21/12/2023 15:39

Rainbowhairanddontcare · 21/12/2023 15:29

I disagree. Many years ago myself and my now husband saw a highly recommended psychic. It's that long ago I can't remember everything but she knew so many things she couldn't have found out. No social media then or anything. At the time my boyfriend had a very distinctive classic car (we went in mine) she described it exactly. She described exactly how we got together and what happened leading up to it. She told me all about my job and what I was going to do next. Wish I could remember more but it was the car description that got me. She couldn't have known it.

Reccomended by who? Is it beyond the realms of possibility to suggest that she got the information from the person/people who reccomended her to you?

OP posts:
Rainbowhairanddontcare · 21/12/2023 15:29

I disagree. Many years ago myself and my now husband saw a highly recommended psychic. It's that long ago I can't remember everything but she knew so many things she couldn't have found out. No social media then or anything. At the time my boyfriend had a very distinctive classic car (we went in mine) she described it exactly. She described exactly how we got together and what happened leading up to it. She told me all about my job and what I was going to do next. Wish I could remember more but it was the car description that got me. She couldn't have known it.

Dpi8 · 21/12/2023 15:21

I think some people are misunderstanding me.

I haven't said nor do I think that I or we as humans know and understand everything. It is psychic mediums in particular we were discussing.

As for 'woo' in general - I myself have had several experiences that aren't easy to explain off the bat (and would probably make me look bonkers if I were to talk about them, so I don't tend to, but there's always a logical explanation)

The poster upthread who thought she was seeing a ghost, then realised that it was her mind playing tricks on her during a period of extreme stress, rings a bell with me.

I've had untold instances of somebody popping into my mind out of the blue and then 10 minutes later bumping into them, or they contact me, throughout my life. It's just coincidence. Less skeptical people would see that as having some foresight ability. In fact I've heard somebody use exactly that type of 'foresight' as evidence of how psychic they are.

I once had a dream that my now ex cheated and got somebody pregnant, low and behold a month later I was contacted and told exactly that (and it was true). Psychic? Nope, I just knew he was disloyal and untrustworthy and that influenced my dreams.

People who claim to be able to talk to the dead though, I just don't buy it and never will until the unlikely day that one of them are able to prove it.

OP posts:
Missmarplesknittingbuddy · 21/12/2023 15:20

Personally, I don't believe in psychic ability but I do believe that some people a are much more perceptive than others. I also believe ,in time , science will explain some/ many of the things we think are supernatural and in several hundred years people will look back and at us in the way we look back at those who attributed certain things to witchcraft etc .

BeardOToots · 21/12/2023 15:09

Ghosts then I guess.

NonPlayerCharacter · 21/12/2023 14:51

I need more learned experience because my gut is a fucking idiot.

bruffin · 21/12/2023 14:46

OracleofWurms1 · 21/12/2023 00:54

Uri Geller

Cia Project : Star Gate Project

If extra abilities are not possible, then how do we expain gut feelings ?

although i dont believe in psychics that talking to spirits

Edited

Gut feelings are actually learned experience. They have trained soldiers to have gut feeling/ intuition by repeatedly taking them through experiences using VR sets etc

Also the Star Gate Project has been debunked. They did not put any strategies in place to stop the use of stage magic tricks. The researchers were very gullible . Watch the Honest Liar on Netflix or Prime and it explains why the research was so bad.
When Geller appeared on the Carson show, the show took advice from Randi on how to stop him using magic tricks and he couldn't perform at all.

AwfullyWeeBillyBigchin · 21/12/2023 14:21

IncompleteSenten · 21/12/2023 14:04

Anything is possible but there is absolutely no scientific evidence that psychics are genuine.
None of them have ever been willing or able to demonstrate their skills in a controlled environment.

Someone saying they saw a psychic and they believe the psychic was genuine is not evidence. Too much trust and faith is required. First of all you'd have to believe the person is telling what they believe to be the truth. Then you'd have to ignore the fact that test after test after test has shown how easily people are fooled and how selective memory is.

I'll believe psychics are real when they can demonstrate their skills to scientists consistently in tests carried out under strictly controlled conditions.

Edited

Actually, some have, but with laughably predictable results 😂

AwfullyWeeBillyBigchin · 21/12/2023 14:19

@NonPlayerCharacter If it could be demonstrated, but the mechanism remain unknown, it would be even more interesting for scientists. They love that sort of challenge. As you say, though, it's never been demonstrated to be genuine.

AwfullyWeeBillyBigchin · 21/12/2023 14:17

Not one so called psychic has passed a test of their own design. That should tell you all you need to know on the matter 👍🏻

NonPlayerCharacter · 21/12/2023 14:15

pponk · 21/12/2023 14:13

@NonPlayerCharacter and @Frabbits the opposite isn't to believe in something but simply to say "who knows, it might happen" .

It never has happened.

I don't think some people realise how much scientists would actually love for this to be proven under lab conditions. It would be Nobel prizes all round and fame forever. We're talking an entirely new discipline, like finding alien life.

pponk · 21/12/2023 14:13

@NonPlayerCharacter and @Frabbits the opposite isn't to believe in something but simply to say "who knows, it might happen" .

1967Kitherly · 21/12/2023 14:09

I can’t say I believe or don’t believe Psychics, it really does fascinate me! Not so much going to see Psychics all though I have at charity events etc (only one of which actually said anything true about me) I just enjoy hearing people stories of what they have been told if it’s been accurate etc. I don’t take it too seriously I think its just fun, although I do know some people can take it so seriously and there are some scam artists out there.
However as a PP said, i think it brings some people comfort, seeing a robin or a feather and thinking its a loved one checking in. If its brings people comfort than harmless things like that are fine.

NonPlayerCharacter · 21/12/2023 14:05

pponk · 21/12/2023 13:51

i think you'd have to be psychologically unsound to have such a level of unwavering arrogance to believe you categorically know everything about the the universe, to be so sure that psychic abilities don't exist.

It's psychologically unsound not to believe in something for which there is absolutely no reliable evidence, has never been seen under lab conditions and which has countless proven frauds?

IncompleteSenten · 21/12/2023 14:04

Anything is possible but there is absolutely no scientific evidence that psychics are genuine.
None of them have ever been willing or able to demonstrate their skills in a controlled environment.

Someone saying they saw a psychic and they believe the psychic was genuine is not evidence. Too much trust and faith is required. First of all you'd have to believe the person is telling what they believe to be the truth. Then you'd have to ignore the fact that test after test after test has shown how easily people are fooled and how selective memory is.

I'll believe psychics are real when they can demonstrate their skills to scientists consistently in tests carried out under strictly controlled conditions.

Frabbits · 21/12/2023 14:03

pponk · 21/12/2023 13:51

i think you'd have to be psychologically unsound to have such a level of unwavering arrogance to believe you categorically know everything about the the universe, to be so sure that psychic abilities don't exist.

Equally, when faced with something for which there is no credible evidence whatsoever, why would you believe in it?

CreationNat1on · 21/12/2023 13:54

Hairbrush..... Static energy from hair strands.

If your fob car key ever loses battery, you can recharge it by sticking it in your hair (bun) for a few minutes.

pponk · 21/12/2023 13:51

i think you'd have to be psychologically unsound to have such a level of unwavering arrogance to believe you categorically know everything about the the universe, to be so sure that psychic abilities don't exist.

Jacfrost · 21/12/2023 13:41

MasterBeth · 21/12/2023 13:00

There are two possible rational explanations:

  1. You were mistaken in some way about about what you saw.

  2. Everything we know about the physical nature of the Universe is wrong.

I know which one seems most likely to me.

Have you read this book? http://www.theinvisiblegorilla.com/overview.html

You should.

I wasn't mistaken about what I saw, I just can't explain it.

That book sounds interesting!

Jacfrost · 21/12/2023 13:40

NonPlayerCharacter · 21/12/2023 12:50

Everything we suggest you will insist is impossible, but draughts, slippery surfaces, slight inclines or someone making stuff up on the Internet are all far more plausible than a spirit without enough imagination to do anything cooler.

ETA: I'd like to know how many times you've told this story, too. A few weeks ago on a woo thread, someone told the story of how she got lost on the way back while on holiday and had definitely entered a time slip, no other explanation. In the first post she was clear she'd done the journey at least once (so might have been only once). In the second retelling, she had been doing it all week and it was physically impossible to take a wrong turn and the local who helped her could not understand where she'd gone wrong. She had been looking for a pond as a landmark and saw a frog. This was, apparently, clear evidence of a time slip (frog, but no water) rather than evidence that she was in fact closer to water than she thought.

The story was embellished with each retelling (what is it now, I wonder) and evidence that she was actually not as far from her desired place as she thought was seen instead as evidence that she had time travelled.

Edited

On the contrary I wouldn't insist anything is impossible, I'd love a rational explanation but I've been thinking about this for the past 30 odd years and can't come up with one.

OopsOutnumbered123 · 21/12/2023 13:26

Singasongofsixpence24 · 21/12/2023 00:51

I've namchanged to say I am psychic and it's mostly awful. I don't practice professionally and have lost many 'friends' because all they want is card readings/ healings and what do you think will happen/ any weird feelings etc. Because I'm accurate its quite addictive for them. When I put up boundaries they soon stop calling. It's very hard to know a person's loved one is going to die and not be able to tell them or worse again know when and where and how my own mother would die. Sadly I often really hope I'm wrong or some details are wrong but too often they're not. It's really very painful and can be nightmareish at times. I don't tell new acquaintances that I can do anything like that anymore.

It sounds fascinating but I understand why it could also be a curse having the ability to see things. I’d love to read an AMA thread on psychic abilities if you ever have a quiet evening 😂

Calypso89 · 21/12/2023 13:11

84% of the population of the world identify with a religion. That means the majority of people believe in a spiritual realm as well as a material one. As a religious person, I do believe that psychics are harmful. But I think YABU to be shocked that people believe in such things, as those who believe only in the material are in the minority globally.

NonPlayerCharacter · 21/12/2023 13:05

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 21/12/2023 13:04

Yeah, you’ve got me there. It was the ghost of Vidal Sassoon, defo.

I saw that ghost. Gave me a right shock. That's why my hair looks like this.

Swipe left for the next trending thread