Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DP believes some psychics are real, I think he's lost it

319 replies

Dpi8 · 21/12/2023 00:09

A discussion about a documentary I watched last night descended into an argument today when chatting over dinner. It was about Derren Brown and how he tests so called psychic mediums in an attempt to prove that it's a load of old rubbish - which I agree with him on.

He got majorly arsey with me when I told him about cold reading and the other techniques they use, such as using vague statements that could apply to most people in the sitters demographic. IE, telling an elderly lady that they have a parent in the spirit world who had a dodgy knee.

I asked him for some examples from which he reached his conclusion that some are genuine but he wasn't forthcoming with anything of any substance, simply mentioning some bloke from the Ghost Adventures series who wanders around buildings 'debunking' certain things for plausible deniabily then making up shite of his own to 'prove' the contact.

This is a hill I'm prepared to die on as I will not accept that such tosh is in any way genuine.

AIBU to say that absolutely all psychics are full of shit?

OP posts:
IncompleteSenten · 01/01/2024 07:02

🤣 well I'm convinced.
It's not like people lie on the internet or that we're able to independently verify that claim.

KnittedPond · 31/12/2023 19:56

Dpi8 · 31/12/2023 19:43

Apparently the police do use them, according to a 'psychic' that posted above. They said they worked on a well known case that was all over the papers.

But they’ve signed the Official Secrets Act or are kept mysteriously quiet by police forces reluctant to admit they solved cases not because of good detective work but because Madame Doris from down the road got a funny feeling about the apparently grieving husband of the murder victim?

Shucks, it’s like all those paranormal feats not working under test conditions, or psychics being too unworldly and unwilling to profit from their powers to have claimed the James Randi prize.

Dpi8 · 31/12/2023 19:43

JennyMatrix · 31/12/2023 19:23

Why don't physics work for the police and solve all crime? Because they're too busy winning the lottery!

Apparently the police do use them, according to a 'psychic' that posted above. They said they worked on a well known case that was all over the papers.

OP posts:
JennyMatrix · 31/12/2023 19:23

Why don't physics work for the police and solve all crime? Because they're too busy winning the lottery!

Ortila · 31/12/2023 18:59

Yeah we do. Religion is just people making stuff up.

Jacfrost · 31/12/2023 18:10

Grimpo · 31/12/2023 14:35

The difference is that no-one has to prove a negative. If I asserted that there was a species of big purple and green striped squirrels living in trees all over the world and you said there wasn't, it would be up to me to prove what I am saying; no-one would expect you to produce evidence that no purple and green squirrels exist, because you don't need to and it would be impossible anyway.

It's up to people who assert that a god exists and that it is their god rather than that of any other religion to prove their case, atheists don't have to prove non-existence. They can however reasonably point to the singular lack of evidence for the existence of a god, despite the lapse of thousands of years, as strongly suggesting that they are correct.

I didn't say atheists have to prove non existence. I just said nobody actually knows either way

QueenOfHiraeth · 31/12/2023 17:55

It always amuses me when people use science as the fount of all knowledge to deny other possibilities. Science changes as new evidence becomes known and proven and often that new evidence arises from people questioning the current wisdom
I tend to think most psychics are not genuine but I struggle to explain the one who spoke to a friend, in my presence, with no prior knowledge of her, and said "One of your children is ill, it isn't just a virus, it's a long term thing but don't worry, she will be fine". Friend's youngest was ill and, at that point, the GP thought it was lingering effects of a virus. The following week she was diagnosed with T1 diabetes. She is now grown up and leading a happy healthy life.
It is arrogant in the extreme to claim either side of this argument is completely right and insult others who think differently. The best any of us can say is we find one side far more probable than the other based on our own knowledge and beliefs so most sensible people are somewhere between the two and would not choose to die on either hill

DinoDays · 31/12/2023 15:08

Digestivechocolatebiscuit · 21/12/2023 08:47

I'm one of those psychics.. l have actually worked with my local police force in the past..( yes they use us).. l can't go into detail but it was to their benefit and all over the local news .. but they never say they used me or other psychics.

Edited

Did ya? Aye!

KnittedPond · 31/12/2023 15:00

Montegufoni2017 · 31/12/2023 14:58

YABU because you’re just being narrow minded. You don’t have to believe or have faith in anything if that’s how you feel but to dismiss DH’s faith is unfair.
Why can’t you just have different opinions on it?

Because his ‘opinion’ is baseless, credulous and suggestive of chronic underthinking? All opinions are not equal. His basis for his belief in psychics appears to be something he saw on a TV programme.

Montegufoni2017 · 31/12/2023 14:58

YABU because you’re just being narrow minded. You don’t have to believe or have faith in anything if that’s how you feel but to dismiss DH’s faith is unfair.
Why can’t you just have different opinions on it?

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 31/12/2023 14:46

Grimpo · 31/12/2023 14:35

The difference is that no-one has to prove a negative. If I asserted that there was a species of big purple and green striped squirrels living in trees all over the world and you said there wasn't, it would be up to me to prove what I am saying; no-one would expect you to produce evidence that no purple and green squirrels exist, because you don't need to and it would be impossible anyway.

It's up to people who assert that a god exists and that it is their god rather than that of any other religion to prove their case, atheists don't have to prove non-existence. They can however reasonably point to the singular lack of evidence for the existence of a god, despite the lapse of thousands of years, as strongly suggesting that they are correct.

There is a difference between faith and claims though. If a religious person says “I believe in my god(s) and holy texts and that’s how I live my life”, they operate within a belief system. It’s not susceptible to evidence.

If they say “come to my church and we’ll heal your cancer”, that’s different. That needs evidence (and is illegal and immoral).

All psychics make claims, otherwise there’s no point in them, and they all need evidence. For which - faith healers and psychics - there is not a scrap.

Dpi8 · 31/12/2023 14:43

Abbyant · 31/12/2023 14:27

I used to watch a show about ghost hunters and they were plumbers so they’d check the plumbing and electrical wiring in the haunted homes and debunked a lot of things as they plumbing noises or feeling weird because of the emf reading by electrical equipment, but there was stuff they couldn’t explain.

That's the show DP is using as evidence lol

OP posts:
KnittedPond · 31/12/2023 14:35

Dpi8 · 31/12/2023 13:58

It's a bit cruel this god guy isn't he? I mean I don't particularly like or agree with self professed psychics, obviously, but I wouldn't wish death and burning on them..

The demons and burning are as fictitious as the ‘psychics’.

It’s like saying the Easter Bunny is going to take down Santa Claus.

Grimpo · 31/12/2023 14:35

Jacfrost · 21/12/2023 09:33

The irony though is that being an atheist is like a belief system in itself. You strongly believe there is no higher power.

But the thing is, you don't know that, any more than somebody who strongly believes in a god. None of us have any proof or knowledge either way do we

The difference is that no-one has to prove a negative. If I asserted that there was a species of big purple and green striped squirrels living in trees all over the world and you said there wasn't, it would be up to me to prove what I am saying; no-one would expect you to produce evidence that no purple and green squirrels exist, because you don't need to and it would be impossible anyway.

It's up to people who assert that a god exists and that it is their god rather than that of any other religion to prove their case, atheists don't have to prove non-existence. They can however reasonably point to the singular lack of evidence for the existence of a god, despite the lapse of thousands of years, as strongly suggesting that they are correct.

Sjh15 · 31/12/2023 14:27

I went to one a year or so ago that asked me directly
‘who is’
’who is’
’who is…. Passed from pneumonia’
the first name was my mum. Second name was my dad. Third name was my MILs partner. She gave me their first names directly. Difficult to ignore that….

Abbyant · 31/12/2023 14:27

I used to watch a show about ghost hunters and they were plumbers so they’d check the plumbing and electrical wiring in the haunted homes and debunked a lot of things as they plumbing noises or feeling weird because of the emf reading by electrical equipment, but there was stuff they couldn’t explain.

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 31/12/2023 14:17

KnittedPond · 31/12/2023 13:05

I would say that discovering your husband is a credulous, superstitious underthinker might well be a ‘hill you wanted to die on’.

Yeah, any psychic belief nonsense and it’s matrimonial lawyer time.

Dpi8 · 31/12/2023 13:58

porridgeisbae · 24/12/2023 10:29

I used to be involved in the scene and I think a very few people can genuinely do it (not me) but it's very rare.

Also if they do get right answers by psychic or cold reading means, it's from demons anyway.

Tell him everyone should seek guidance only from the Bible/Jesus.

Psychics etc are an abomination to God and will burn, sadly.

It's a bit cruel this god guy isn't he? I mean I don't particularly like or agree with self professed psychics, obviously, but I wouldn't wish death and burning on them..

OP posts:
KnittedPond · 31/12/2023 13:05

zeibesaffron · 31/12/2023 12:57

You are totally unreasonable he can believe what he wants too. Is this really the hill you want to die on - give over!!

I would say that discovering your husband is a credulous, superstitious underthinker might well be a ‘hill you wanted to die on’.

zeibesaffron · 31/12/2023 12:57

You are totally unreasonable he can believe what he wants too. Is this really the hill you want to die on - give over!!

BettyUnderswoob · 24/12/2023 14:58

Indeed @WhatsTheUseOfWorrying , it's sad that things (be they beliefs, customs, ethics, morals...) don't really progress and improve with further enlightenment and scientific discovery; they merely change.
People always have and always will believe in all sorts of counter-intuitive crap for which there is no proof, nor even any evidence. 🤷‍♀️

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 24/12/2023 14:08

Oh for Pete’s sake. Of 416 voters 45% think you’re being unreasonable to say that psychics are full of shit.

I know this isn’t statistically reliable as a survey, but it’s so depressing.

How did centuries of science, logic and the enlightenment not drive out belief in this utter garbage?

bruffin · 24/12/2023 11:22

Seaglass7 · 24/12/2023 11:09

You could have written this about me (apart from the psychic stuff, I’m a none believer.

My DF (now departed) was an alcoholic and I had to be hyper vigilante around him. Facial expressions, the tone of the room, when it was better to go off to your bedroom to stay out of the way, before things actually happened and the arguments started between him and DM. I went through these huge emotions all throughout my childhood and they absolutely have made me hyper aware of changes within people, even subtle changes, where I know they have shifted somewhat in their mannerisms, that they might have something they need to talk to me about.

Even now, when I feel that shift in a person my stomach lurches and I feel uneasy, just how I felt when I was a child.

Derren Brown is the one who really made me a firm nonbeliever.

I agree DH has MH problems and i pick up on his tone from just a word if he is feeling depressed.
I had a friend who told me here friend who was a psychic and picked up that another friend was paranoid about BO but never told anyone until psychic mentioned it, so she must be genuine. To me someone who is paranoid about BO would be constantly checking themselves and it would be really obvious from body language.

Seaglass7 · 24/12/2023 11:09

CreationNat1on · 21/12/2023 10:11

Many people who think they are empath, are in fact hypervigilent, usually triggered by some type of trauma. For example the child of an alcoholic who is put in charge of the parent, or who has to manage the parents moods. They watch for microfacial expressions and they pick up on extremely subtle indicators. They don't even realise they do this, if they sense something earlier than other people then they may identify or be identified as having certain psychic abilities.

Some people have honed their perceptive skills to athlete levels, usually as a coping mechanism.

You could have written this about me (apart from the psychic stuff, I’m a none believer.

My DF (now departed) was an alcoholic and I had to be hyper vigilante around him. Facial expressions, the tone of the room, when it was better to go off to your bedroom to stay out of the way, before things actually happened and the arguments started between him and DM. I went through these huge emotions all throughout my childhood and they absolutely have made me hyper aware of changes within people, even subtle changes, where I know they have shifted somewhat in their mannerisms, that they might have something they need to talk to me about.

Even now, when I feel that shift in a person my stomach lurches and I feel uneasy, just how I felt when I was a child.

Derren Brown is the one who really made me a firm nonbeliever.

KnittedPond · 24/12/2023 10:43

porridgeisbae · 24/12/2023 10:29

I used to be involved in the scene and I think a very few people can genuinely do it (not me) but it's very rare.

Also if they do get right answers by psychic or cold reading means, it's from demons anyway.

Tell him everyone should seek guidance only from the Bible/Jesus.

Psychics etc are an abomination to God and will burn, sadly.

Why would ‘demons’ need to be involved in cold-reading? It’s a set of techniques used to make the subject think the ‘psychic’ mysteriously knows things about them. It doesn’t require any supernatural intervention whatsoever.