Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DP believes some psychics are real, I think he's lost it

319 replies

Dpi8 · 21/12/2023 00:09

A discussion about a documentary I watched last night descended into an argument today when chatting over dinner. It was about Derren Brown and how he tests so called psychic mediums in an attempt to prove that it's a load of old rubbish - which I agree with him on.

He got majorly arsey with me when I told him about cold reading and the other techniques they use, such as using vague statements that could apply to most people in the sitters demographic. IE, telling an elderly lady that they have a parent in the spirit world who had a dodgy knee.

I asked him for some examples from which he reached his conclusion that some are genuine but he wasn't forthcoming with anything of any substance, simply mentioning some bloke from the Ghost Adventures series who wanders around buildings 'debunking' certain things for plausible deniabily then making up shite of his own to 'prove' the contact.

This is a hill I'm prepared to die on as I will not accept that such tosh is in any way genuine.

AIBU to say that absolutely all psychics are full of shit?

OP posts:
Bobbotgegrinch · 21/12/2023 10:33

EmmaEmerald · 21/12/2023 10:14

so, you're joking about the ghost?

No, I'm not joking.

I spent better part of two years catching sight of a human shaped figure out of the corner of my eye at home. He wouldn't be there when I looked properly. He often made me jump out of my skin, standing at the top of the stairs was a favourite trick of his. He also spent one night lobbing a spoon around my kitchen.

But noone else ever saw him, and him turning up coincided with the shittest period of my life, where my mental health was in the toilet. I was in an absolutely horrendous job, and my Mum was dying. I was under huge amounts of stress. When the stress started to vanish so did he.

So I'll happily admit that I've been haunted, but it was by my own brain rather than a ghost.

CostelloJones · 21/12/2023 10:32

FWIW I love a bit of Derren Brown.

I agree with PPs that undoubtedly there are many who claim to be psychics and just take advantage of people.

However I have experienced some unexplainable things and would have called BS if someone had told me it had happened to them. I don’t think you can completely disregard the possibility.

YABU to be so angry about it - what a weird battle to pick

Ortila · 21/12/2023 10:31

jennytheonionslayer · 21/12/2023 10:23

The burden of proof is on those making the claim, so until I see peer reviewed empirical evidence to support it then is a real as god, Father Christmas, the tooth fairy and indeed any form of superstition.

Agreed.

There's loads of opportunity to prove it but thus far nobody has. That foundation in the USA had a million quid hanging around all ready to go to anyone who could demonstrate something paranormal. It hung around for half a century which is surely enough time for even the tardiest of ghosts to get their act together. However not one person did.

jennytheonionslayer · 21/12/2023 10:31

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

NonPlayerCharacter · 21/12/2023 10:30

jennytheonionslayer · 21/12/2023 10:29

42?😜

No, but I know why you chose that one. It's mostly harmless.

jennytheonionslayer · 21/12/2023 10:29

NonPlayerCharacter · 21/12/2023 10:28

You don’t have proof that psychic ability does not exist.

There's tons of evidence it doesn't exist and no reliable evidence that it does. What number am I thinking of?

42?😜

CostelloJones · 21/12/2023 10:28

Hipnotised · 21/12/2023 01:12

@Dpi8 look on the bright side, if you were to die on this hill he could keep in touch 😂

😂😂😂😂👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻

NonPlayerCharacter · 21/12/2023 10:28

You don’t have proof that psychic ability does not exist.

There's tons of evidence it doesn't exist and no reliable evidence that it does. What number am I thinking of?

Possiblynotever · 21/12/2023 10:27

I do not know if this helps. When my DC was almost 3, we took a rather long car trip, just the two of us.
At some point, out of the blue, she remarked: " Mummy, the car is hungry". I then checked, and, to my shock, I was running out of fuel.
The petrol station sign was fast approaching, and I pulled over.
I then realised that the next station was 50 miles away, and I would have had to stop way before reaching it.
My daughter did not know anything about cars, and, more importantly, from her position, she could not see the fuel level.
Did she have 🔮 powers? Did she simply want to stop? Did she just decide that the car needed food because she wanted food?(I do not think so, as she refused to eat).
I have always wondered...

jennytheonionslayer · 21/12/2023 10:23

The burden of proof is on those making the claim, so until I see peer reviewed empirical evidence to support it then is a real as god, Father Christmas, the tooth fairy and indeed any form of superstition.

Lighrbulbmo · 21/12/2023 10:19

You don’t have proof that psychic ability does not exist. I mean .. wow you saw a programme about Darren Brown.. I mean that is hardly evidential to your argument.
You both have equal quality evidence to back up your argument. That amounts to fuck all evidence. Therefore agree to disagree and peace be with you both on the matter.

Ortila · 21/12/2023 10:19

This would niggle at me too OP. It's not a question of having different opinions - some opinions are wrong. This is one of them. It's entirely irrational and I'd question the judgement of anyone who fell for this nonsense. Eg if a person is this credulous, they're probably be more prone to making poor financial/life decisions. It's not a good thing.

Wtfammaduck · 21/12/2023 10:18

OP I think it’s daft to argue/fall out over this. Is it really any different from someone believing in an invisible sky fairy? Cos billions do that and billions don’t.

I’m a hypocritical sceptic.

My rational mind wants to say this doesn’t exist but I have experienced way too many odd things ghosts and premonitions and god it seems odd typing it out but I’ve had messages from dead people I don’t know for people I do. I assess whether it’s worth saying anything. I never do it on demand (I can’t) and sometimes I think maybe I’m going mad but the things I’ve said have been true or come true. There’s nothing creepier than seeing someone in your bedroom you don’t know trying to tell you something. I wish it was my loved ones coming to me but that rarely is the case (usually if someone is dying) which means I tend to know before I’m told. I don’t enjoy it, I don’t want it, it’s just there and it shouldn’t come true but it does.

NonPlayerCharacter · 21/12/2023 10:17

CreationNat1on · 21/12/2023 10:11

Many people who think they are empath, are in fact hypervigilent, usually triggered by some type of trauma. For example the child of an alcoholic who is put in charge of the parent, or who has to manage the parents moods. They watch for microfacial expressions and they pick up on extremely subtle indicators. They don't even realise they do this, if they sense something earlier than other people then they may identify or be identified as having certain psychic abilities.

Some people have honed their perceptive skills to athlete levels, usually as a coping mechanism.

Most of the self described empaths I've seen on here have been pretty unpleasant and think they have deeper feelings than other people. They also think that anyone who doesn’t dramatically show emotion can't be feeling it, which is just about the most unempathetic thing imaginable.

One got so angry at being told she wasn't some special higher being that she started abusing someone and told her she had obviously never experienced trauma. The poster was a bereaved parent with many posts on the relevant boards (even a psychic could have looked it up). The empath was told this and continued to abuse the parent before thinking to offer any condolences. A particularly egregious example, but pretty much in line with most of them.

EmmaEmerald · 21/12/2023 10:14

Bobbotgegrinch · 21/12/2023 09:42

I'm a massive skeptic about pretty much everything supernatural, to the extent that I don't believe in ghosts despite having "seen" one repeatedly over a two year period.

DP on the other hand happily believes in all manner of spooks, psychics and other woo stuff. Yes we might occasionally take the piss out of each other about our views, but only lightly, why on earth would you get into an argument over something so small?

so, you're joking about the ghost?

Jacfrost · 21/12/2023 10:13

KnittedPond · 21/12/2023 09:52

Don’t make me quote Bertrand Russell on the teapot again.

Its really not that difficult.

I wasn't talking about who should prove or disprove anything.

CreationNat1on · 21/12/2023 10:11

Many people who think they are empath, are in fact hypervigilent, usually triggered by some type of trauma. For example the child of an alcoholic who is put in charge of the parent, or who has to manage the parents moods. They watch for microfacial expressions and they pick up on extremely subtle indicators. They don't even realise they do this, if they sense something earlier than other people then they may identify or be identified as having certain psychic abilities.

Some people have honed their perceptive skills to athlete levels, usually as a coping mechanism.

EmmaEmerald · 21/12/2023 10:11

OP I see you've had a bad experience

I would imagine 99.9% are frauds. I've never seen anyone about contacting the dead.

But I have come across people with bizarrely accurate knowledge and specific predictions. Mostly fortune telling, not stuff you could cold read.

wudubelieveit · 21/12/2023 10:04

i come from a family where a number of us have seen/ felt spirits....theres absolutely no financial gain for any of us ,its not something that is "performed" for anyone else. You are entitled to believe what you want ....however would you post about or argue likewise if your husband was a Christian or anyone who practises any sort of religion?

TheShellBeach · 21/12/2023 10:02

Dpi8 · 21/12/2023 10:01

All of that could apply to most people though surely?

Edited to say I just re read your post as I missed it the first time 😂😂😂

Edited

Exactly. That was the point of that post.
They were being sarcastic and showing how charlatans work.

Dpi8 · 21/12/2023 10:01

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 21/12/2023 09:56

I definitely believe in psychic powers.

A few years ago I went with a friend to a seer. She knew I was getting married, that I’d been on holiday recently, that I’m shortsighted and that we’d driven to see her.

It was shockingly accurate.

When I had to rush back to get my car keys I’d left on the table - by the crystal ball - she even told me (for free) that I’d travel over water.

It was a lovely day. On the way back my friend complimented me on my engagement ring, my new glasses and my tan. And we drove on a bridge over a river!

All of that could apply to most people though surely?

Edited to say I just re read your post as I missed it the first time 😂😂😂

OP posts:
Castlerock44 · 21/12/2023 10:00

I agree with him. For all the charlatans out there, there are genuinely psychic people. How could there not be.

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 21/12/2023 09:56

I definitely believe in psychic powers.

A few years ago I went with a friend to a seer. She knew I was getting married, that I’d been on holiday recently, that I’m shortsighted and that we’d driven to see her.

It was shockingly accurate.

When I had to rush back to get my car keys I’d left on the table - by the crystal ball - she even told me (for free) that I’d travel over water.

It was a lovely day. On the way back my friend complimented me on my engagement ring, my new glasses and my tan. And we drove on a bridge over a river!

TheShellBeach · 21/12/2023 09:56

ValerieMoore · 21/12/2023 00:50

Holly Wells’ father wrote that he talked to a psychic in the days after her disappearance. The psychic told him that she was gone and that her body was located to the east of Soham and that she was in shallow water. This was true. He said the murderer had a red car and described the view from his house (there was something like a windmill in the background). These suggestions were also true.

He said the letters C an O were in the address of the property she died in (College Close, where Huntley’s house was) and that Kevin Wells had walked past this house during his search (Kevin met Huntley outside the house and spoke to him within hours of the girls’ disappearance).

He described Maxine Carr as “mousy” looking and Ian Huntley as mid- thirties with dark hair, and that they were not from the area and have northern accents (Huntley is from Grimsby, not sure about the accent).

That was just guesswork. Red was a very popular car colour at the time. It was obvious that the girls had been murdered, right from the beginning, so the shallow grave thing was hardly inspired. Kevin Wells walked past every house in Soham when he searched for his child.

Come on, you can see where the charlatan got all this from.

KnittedPond · 21/12/2023 09:52

Jacfrost · 21/12/2023 09:51

It's a belief that there's no god. Again, none of us actually know either way, so both positions are beliefs.

The only sensible position is agnosticism.

Don’t make me quote Bertrand Russell on the teapot again.

Its really not that difficult.

Swipe left for the next trending thread