Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Death by road accident, would you want to know what happened

142 replies

hollyivy123 · 20/12/2023 21:56

NC for this. I witnessed an accident in the summer of a motorcyclist v. car. It happened right in front of me and my son when we were driving back from a break in the UK. We were one car behind the car which was impacted so were very nearly involved in it. After the initial shock of witnessing the motorcyclist who was on the wrong side of the road crash into the car we sat stunned for about a minute then I got out and went to help the motorcyclist who needed CPR. Unfortunately he didn't make it. It was all very traumatic for us and totally for the partner who has been left behind. Through social media I have worked out who she is as she posted on the local police page about the accident, though she has no idea who I am and that I helped her partner in his last moments. I wonder if it would bring any comfort to her to know who I am, or whether it's best she never knows. The police apparently told her that he was given CPR by the side of the road as she's said it on facebook that she's grateful for whoever did it. What would you want if it was your partner? Would you want to know who that person was? I wouldn't want to trigger her, but yet on the other side I think her knowing i'm also a HCP it might bring her comfort somehow? Or would I be disrupting her grieving process to contact her a few months after the event and particularly at christmas. I'm not planning to without putting serious thought into it, but I was interested in what other people's thoughts were thanks. I've put the voting very simply, don't read too much into that, just vote as you think.
YABU - Don't contact her
YANBU- Contact her

OP posts:
givethedoggerbone · 20/12/2023 23:45

Sorry to hear you went through this, op, and you did an incredible thing for someone in their last moments.

In answer to your question - objectively, I'd look at this almost in the same way as protocols for people seeking information about adoption (in the past, moreso than today where life story work is considered so much more fundamental).

So in the same way that a parent who had given up a child could make Social Services aware that they were receptive to contact, but would not make contact themselves.

Thus leaving the adopted child free to make those enquiries themselves, without any timescale forced by the other party.

The reason I say this is - I think if the bereaved partner right now wanted to reach out to you, she could probably have already made those enquiries with the police. And it seems she hasn't.

If she wants contact with you it needs to be on her own terms. So I would say make the police know that you are happy to be contacted and leave it at that.

Also, I know that you are an HCP but in my experience traumatic things that we can cope very well with at work can be a very different experience indeed when we experience them in our personal lives (and I noted that your son was with you, so you would have had to manage his own reactions as well as yours). So please do seek counselling support if you feel you need it, I'd imagine there's an EAP where you work that can refer you.

I think you did an incredible thing and I hope you have a happy christmas.

time4aNC · 20/12/2023 23:44

100% contact her.

My father collapsed at work (he owned a store) whilst serving a customer when I was a child. If the customer wasn’t there he would’ve probably been found dead. He had a major stroke and was in hospital for 2 years before dying. I’m so grateful for that customer for at least giving him a chance. I would kill to meet that person and just say thank you.

porridgeisbae · 20/12/2023 23:44

@hollyivy123 I think it might come across as you want praise from her.

It's also best not to mention it to her as it might disrupt her process of dealing with things if you bring it up all over again.

Lemonfoxtrot · 20/12/2023 23:44

Please don’t feel you are being selfish.

it’s quite clear from your post that this isn’t about you, and your motives are to help.

I think you should reach out to the police liaison and say you’d be happy to meet / discuss what happened. Maybe include the fact that you are a health professional and you know that for some people, it can be helpful to talk to someone who was there.
leave the door open for her, but no need for a response.

it may not be the right time for her, but she may want to meet you a few months down the line. I’m sure she’ll be touched that you care.

user1492757084 · 20/12/2023 23:43

Your attention to the crash victim was amazing and your concern for his family is very kind.

I wouldn't want her to know my address and vice versa etc and I would not want to contact her without Police advice. Because anonymity, long term, could be healthy for you both.
I would not contact via message as it is too impersonal.

If I were to contact I would want to speak directly or meet in person in a public place. They could find it a comfort if you had information about their loved one's few minutes of pain, last words or look of serenity; otherwise they could just want to express thanks.

An appropriate time would have been right after the event - there and then, roadside; or at the end of an inquest (should you both be there). If she approaches the Police and tries to speak to you, you could register your permission and approval to speak on the phone or exchange anonymous letter etc. (whatever is comfortable to you)

It is my gut reaction to not make contact, to leave it all sit and to be able to bump into each other and not know.
It is never a mistake to focus on treasued memories of a deceaced loved one and if seeing you (in a shop or driving your car etc) triggers thoughts of the actual death,it might not be the best.

Salome61 · 20/12/2023 23:40

I am so sorry, this is so traumatic for you.

A motorcyclist crashed immediately in front of my friend many years ago, and she helped him. He died whilst they were waiting for the ambulance. My friend did allow the police to give her details to the family and she met his wife, who wanted to know what he had said before he died. He hadn't said anything, but the wife contacted my friend a few times afterwards to see 'if she'd remembered' anything. Tragic for everyone.

CleansUpButWouldPreferNotTo · 20/12/2023 23:30

hollyivy123 · 20/12/2023 23:15

So it's been suggested that I would be being 'selfish' in wanting closure to the event and that i'm being unreasonable. What are everyone's thought's on this? It's sad that people think i'm being selfish. You know what? I'm anything but. I have a son with special needs who witnessed the whole event and I had to consider his emotions before I even exited the car to go and do CPR. He's a teenager who I worried about leaving alone in my car while I gave CPR to the victim. I spent my time doing CPR and looking back to him to make sure he wasn't having some sort of meltdown in my car. Thankfully he was giving me the thumbs up but not really realising the seriousness of what was going on. I have had to consider his emotions after the event and we've talked extensively about it to make sure he's okay. I'm far from selfish. I'm sorry if this sounds like a dripfeed but I didn't think it would be necessary for the debate. I have a whole load of other things to think about. I want the person who is grieving for this chap to feel better somehow if she can, if I can help great, but if not i'll stand back for sure.

I do not think you're being selfish. You have very personal information about their loved one's last moments which may or may not bring them comfort.

Personally, I would want to know as much as possible and would want to 'meet' with you, not necessarily in person. Perhaps you could contact police liaison and make the offer, then leave it up to the poor chap's partner.

You were amazing - you did a good deed that day, not many would have been able to unfreeze and try to assist. Well done you.

Selenitetower · 20/12/2023 23:30

Oh absolutely and it was very much the same for this family, his sister was just looking out for him and just couldn’t believe he would act so recklessly. But it can be an incredibly hard pill to swallow that someone you love and care for has acted in a way that has impacted their life so drastically and for your case resulted in his death. If you could contact her anonymously at all I would do that and try to conceal your identity.

Americano75 · 20/12/2023 23:27

I lost my brother in an RTA, it was a busy road and I know there were many people who tried to help. I would love to have heard from any one of them. Sometimes the thought of his last moments torment me.

I once witnessed a young man literally drop dead in front of me, he was running in a half marathon and it turned out the poor boy had an undiagnosed heart condition. I wrote to his father via his work, because I wanted him to know his son did not suffer, and died surrounded by people who did their best to save him.

northernlasses · 20/12/2023 23:27

I'd ask the police to pass on your details and to let her know that she can contact you if she wants to.

TequilaNights · 20/12/2023 23:24

@hollyivy123 you did an amazing thing, but you also witnessed something so horrific and it will have a huge emotional impact on you, please give yourself time to process what happened, your concern you are showing your son should extend to you too, be kind and don't take anything anyone says to heart.

Mornusting · 20/12/2023 23:24

What do you know about the event that would help her in any way? Other than putting a face to a person. Are you able to answer questions from her eg did he suffer?

Avatartar · 20/12/2023 23:23

OP I don’t think people
think you are being selfish. Trauma and grief are extremely complicated things. Talk to police liaison so they can manage the
passing of information from you to the bereaved. They also know how the legal system and processes work. It was a shocking thing for you to
experience and flight may have caused some witnesses to freeze or do nothing. You helped the man. I think posters are wondering if you would find talking the event through with a counsellor
helpful in the first instance

hollyivy123 · 20/12/2023 23:23

Selenitetower · 20/12/2023 23:16

I wouldn’t do it just because she could be in denial over her partner being at fault of the accident.

We witnessed an incident where the motorcyclist ran a red light and was hit and thrown from his bike it was awful. It was then posted in the local fb group and I commented that I was first on the scene and offered first aid to him and stayed with him until the ambulance arrived and his sister commented wanting to know what happened so I told her and she abused me for saying he ran the red light and was essentially the cause of his own incident. He didn’t die but we did have to give statements to the police and we said what happened and because she knew who we were she was contacting us telling us to change our story because he couldn’t be at fault it was awful.

Edited

I can see this point of view. He was at fault as he was overtaking when he shouldn't be. It's difficult. He was a person who was clearly loved by his partner and he lost his life. It's a really difficult one to call, I know people make mistakes and misjudgements. That day wasn't his day poor fella

OP posts:
Zoomie1 · 20/12/2023 23:22

'if you were not in the crash yourself, you may or may not want to know the details of how a loved one died. You may want to know about medical treatment given at the roadside or in a hospital, and whether a loved one said anything or was unconscious during this time.
Sometimes it is possible to meet and talk to people who provided help at the crash site, such as a paramedic or a fire officer, or members of the public who provided first aid. If you want to do this, your police contact will be able to find out if this is possible. Alternatively, your police contact may be able to ask these people questions on your behalf.' Section 1: What happens now? | England & Wales | Brake

Section 1: What happens now?

Section 1: What happens now? | England & Wales | Brake

Information and advice about the first few days after a road death in England and Wales

https://www.brake.org.uk/how-we-help/get-help-if-a-crash-victim/information-and-advice-after-road-death-or-serious-injury/procedures-following-death-on-the-road-england-and-wales/section-1-what-happens-now#what-happened-in-the-crash

Japanesejazz · 20/12/2023 23:18

Leave it alone
my husband died in a motorcycle accident
it was an accident but so many of his relatives just felt the need to sue anyone who was there

Rattenbury · 20/12/2023 23:18

Don't put her in a position to feel like she needs to perform gratitude or discuss the event with a stranger.

this.

Selenitetower · 20/12/2023 23:16

I wouldn’t do it just because she could be in denial over her partner being at fault of the accident.

We witnessed an incident where the motorcyclist ran a red light and was hit and thrown from his bike it was awful. It was then posted in the local fb group and I commented that I was first on the scene and offered first aid to him and stayed with him until the ambulance arrived and his sister commented wanting to know what happened so I told her and she abused me for saying he ran the red light and was essentially the cause of his own incident. He didn’t die but we did have to give statements to the police and we said what happened and because she knew who we were she was contacting us telling us to change our story because he couldn’t be at fault it was awful.

hollyivy123 · 20/12/2023 23:15

So it's been suggested that I would be being 'selfish' in wanting closure to the event and that i'm being unreasonable. What are everyone's thought's on this? It's sad that people think i'm being selfish. You know what? I'm anything but. I have a son with special needs who witnessed the whole event and I had to consider his emotions before I even exited the car to go and do CPR. He's a teenager who I worried about leaving alone in my car while I gave CPR to the victim. I spent my time doing CPR and looking back to him to make sure he wasn't having some sort of meltdown in my car. Thankfully he was giving me the thumbs up but not really realising the seriousness of what was going on. I have had to consider his emotions after the event and we've talked extensively about it to make sure he's okay. I'm far from selfish. I'm sorry if this sounds like a dripfeed but I didn't think it would be necessary for the debate. I have a whole load of other things to think about. I want the person who is grieving for this chap to feel better somehow if she can, if I can help great, but if not i'll stand back for sure.

OP posts:
yarnwitch · 20/12/2023 23:15

I have seen people respond to friends/family members comments on social media posts about fatal accidents, for example 'I was there and comforted them, just to let you know they weren't alone'
I think I would do that rather than send a message which may be too intrusive. You could always add that they are welcome to message you.

tachetastic · 20/12/2023 23:15

hollyivy123 · 20/12/2023 21:56

NC for this. I witnessed an accident in the summer of a motorcyclist v. car. It happened right in front of me and my son when we were driving back from a break in the UK. We were one car behind the car which was impacted so were very nearly involved in it. After the initial shock of witnessing the motorcyclist who was on the wrong side of the road crash into the car we sat stunned for about a minute then I got out and went to help the motorcyclist who needed CPR. Unfortunately he didn't make it. It was all very traumatic for us and totally for the partner who has been left behind. Through social media I have worked out who she is as she posted on the local police page about the accident, though she has no idea who I am and that I helped her partner in his last moments. I wonder if it would bring any comfort to her to know who I am, or whether it's best she never knows. The police apparently told her that he was given CPR by the side of the road as she's said it on facebook that she's grateful for whoever did it. What would you want if it was your partner? Would you want to know who that person was? I wouldn't want to trigger her, but yet on the other side I think her knowing i'm also a HCP it might bring her comfort somehow? Or would I be disrupting her grieving process to contact her a few months after the event and particularly at christmas. I'm not planning to without putting serious thought into it, but I was interested in what other people's thoughts were thanks. I've put the voting very simply, don't read too much into that, just vote as you think.
YABU - Don't contact her
YANBU- Contact her

I think you did a wonderful thing that day, and I trust that you are looking to do another wonderful thing now.

But grief is complex. I agree with others that say reach out to the police and explain to them that you would be willing to speak with the family if that would help. Then leave it there.

Under no circumstances reach out via social media. There are better channels when things are this delicate.

TequilaNights · 20/12/2023 23:13

I have been in her position, almost identical, there will be a coroners inquest where she will get to sit and listen to witnesses and see how it has torn their lives apart, it was really horrific, if I had known what I do now, I would not have gone.

Do not contact her directly, use the proper channels when you are called upon and use all resources available to you and your son.

I will edit to say this is just my views, I just think you need to be very careful, the partner will be very delicate, but reading some other replies it brought them great comfort.

Whatever you decide, thank you for trying to help him, and do take care of yourself.

AnotherSaturdayNight · 20/12/2023 23:10

My dad died in a car accident many years ago. I was told a nurse stopped to try to help. I would like to thank her for stopping to help. It gave me comfort to know he wasn’t left alone in the road.

AndOnAndOn1000 · 20/12/2023 23:04

I would definitely want to know.

SequentialAnalyst · 20/12/2023 23:03

Many years ago a close friend died in a RTA. Her sister and I did want to know the details, up to a point, because in the absence of such details we each imagined the worst possible scenarioSad We did find out enough to know that it was not quite as bad as we imagined, though sadly fairly bad.

I think I woúld reach out, as gently and tentatively as is feasible.

Swipe left for the next trending thread