Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Death by road accident, would you want to know what happened

142 replies

hollyivy123 · 20/12/2023 21:56

NC for this. I witnessed an accident in the summer of a motorcyclist v. car. It happened right in front of me and my son when we were driving back from a break in the UK. We were one car behind the car which was impacted so were very nearly involved in it. After the initial shock of witnessing the motorcyclist who was on the wrong side of the road crash into the car we sat stunned for about a minute then I got out and went to help the motorcyclist who needed CPR. Unfortunately he didn't make it. It was all very traumatic for us and totally for the partner who has been left behind. Through social media I have worked out who she is as she posted on the local police page about the accident, though she has no idea who I am and that I helped her partner in his last moments. I wonder if it would bring any comfort to her to know who I am, or whether it's best she never knows. The police apparently told her that he was given CPR by the side of the road as she's said it on facebook that she's grateful for whoever did it. What would you want if it was your partner? Would you want to know who that person was? I wouldn't want to trigger her, but yet on the other side I think her knowing i'm also a HCP it might bring her comfort somehow? Or would I be disrupting her grieving process to contact her a few months after the event and particularly at christmas. I'm not planning to without putting serious thought into it, but I was interested in what other people's thoughts were thanks. I've put the voting very simply, don't read too much into that, just vote as you think.
YABU - Don't contact her
YANBU- Contact her

OP posts:
kimchio · 21/12/2023 07:07

Dontgivemeplants · 21/12/2023 00:27

Of course I'd like to know. It would be a treasured conversation for the rest of my life. Meet her for a coffee. Jeeezus, why wouldn't you

Or it might fill her with anger and rage. Or she might not want to know the details. It's personal.

kimchio · 21/12/2023 07:04

DGHZ · 21/12/2023 00:56

What about sending her a little plant or something with a note saying you’re so sorry for her loss and say you’re the HCP who was with her partner at the end. Just don’t give away any info she doesn’t already know in the brief note. Leave it open ended and if she wants to contact you she’ll message you for more information. I think most people probably would want to know, sometimes it is better just being swamped with it at all at the time, even if it is traumatic. At least that way you’re not partially trying to get your life back together then finding out another little piece of information and having it floor you again ☹️ I think it will be of comfort though

Don't do that! OP needs to keep distance between them. Go through the police. Keep that barrier. Otherwise she risks inserting herself into the bereaved grief.

Sodndashitall · 21/12/2023 06:51

auburnglow788 · 20/12/2023 22:09

She knows that her partner received CPR and she is now approximately 4 months into the grieving process - I cannot see any benefit of her knowing who gave him the CPR.

I think the benefit is knowing that it was a HCP who administered the CPR so I guess from that perspective she would know that nothing more could have been done

Saggypants · 21/12/2023 02:21

Argh I don't know.

As a pp said, knowing that he received the best possible first aid from an HCP might help with any worries that more could have been done to save him.

Did he suffer? You don't have to tell us of course, but if you spoke to her she may ask... in which case are you prepared to answer that question honestly? I don't think I could make contact if there was a chance I'd be adding to her trauma with new and awful details.

Whichwhatnow · 21/12/2023 02:12

hollyivy123 · 21/12/2023 00:21

Thanks for all your responses it's a difficult but interesting debate and obviously personalised to the person who has lost so there's no easy answer, but it helped to post it anonymously anyway thankyou

My parents were in almost exactly the same situation. A teenage motorcyclist came off his bike outside their house, my dad gave him CPR and my mum held his hand as he passed away. They've had several of his friends come to knock on their door to thank them for looking after him. I would contact her OP, if I were her I'd want to know that he was cared for.

MadinMarch · 21/12/2023 02:10

Yes, I'd want to know. But I wouldn't want to know 4 days before Christmas.

This

Itwasafterallallaboutme · 21/12/2023 01:47

35965a · 20/12/2023 22:01

Maybe you could contact the police and ask their liaison to pass on your details if she wants them? I’m not sure I would contact her directly.

This ^^

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 21/12/2023 01:27

If I were you, I wouldn't do this unless you are prepared to lie, like a "he wasn't in pain" kind of lie.

DeeLusional · 21/12/2023 01:21

You have had a very traumatic experience and I think this desire to get in touch is more about you than it is about the bereaved, perhaps to try to make sense of it by knowing more about the deceased with whom you shared a very intense intimate experience. You have already seen his partner's social media - don't you think if she wanted contact with you, she would have made it known there? I think you need counselling to help you deal with this. Good luck x

Grumpyat40 · 21/12/2023 01:11

My partner was a motorcyclist involved in a serious accident last year. Luckily he survived, despite his serious injuries because of the people who were first on the scene who helped him. An othopaedic surgeon, an anaesthetist and nurse. The orthopaedic surgeon called the ICU of the hospital he was taken to and I was able to speak to him, thank him profusely and update him on my partners condition. I asked for their contact details and my partner was able to contact them himself several months later.

We have never been able to find the nurse. The Police did not have her details or any note of her. It was her who called me from his phone. Despite the fact I now have serious anxiety when my phone rings, and NZ accents can trigger me (the nurse had a strong NZ accent) I would still like to hear from her so we can thank her. Knowing my partner wasn't alone, and was in safe hands is comforting.

Obviously the outcome was very different in your scenario, but I think their partner would want to hear from the person who tried to help them - although I'd avoid the details.

DGHZ · 21/12/2023 00:56

What about sending her a little plant or something with a note saying you’re so sorry for her loss and say you’re the HCP who was with her partner at the end. Just don’t give away any info she doesn’t already know in the brief note. Leave it open ended and if she wants to contact you she’ll message you for more information. I think most people probably would want to know, sometimes it is better just being swamped with it at all at the time, even if it is traumatic. At least that way you’re not partially trying to get your life back together then finding out another little piece of information and having it floor you again ☹️ I think it will be of comfort though

Wordsareimportant · 21/12/2023 00:50

My dad was hit by a van when on his motorcycle. Thankfully he is still alive but suffered a life changing stroke and is now paralysed and lost his speech.

1 person came forward with a statement (he saw the ‘after’ but not what happened) - the incident was on a roundabout during rush hour so there I’m 99% sure other people saw. No one else said anything at all.

i was so grateful to the man that contacted us to say he helped. It was lovely to know that in my dad’s time of need, there was a friendly caring person there to help.

if I were you, I’d message. even if it is for a ‘selfish’ reason - you might get closure from it and that’s not selfish in my opinion.

theduchessofspork · 21/12/2023 00:40

I don’t think you should contact her

I’m very grateful to the person who helped my sibling in a similar circumstance but ultimately there’s no insight you can give her and it would be intrusive.

What you could do is let the police know that you’d be happy to be contacted by her if she wishes.

This has naturally weighed on you OP, but I think it would be better to work on leaving it behind (with some professional help if necessary) rather than seek to involve yourself in it further.

Strawberryjams · 21/12/2023 00:31

I’m so sorry that you and your son had to witness something like this. It must be extremely difficult for you too especially as you did everything you could. I agree with the suggestions of doing so via the police. That way if she declines that’s fine, you tried. A message popping up can’t be unseen and may upset her. I think I would want to know because a HCP giving CPR means they had the best person available not someone who had no knowledge. I think that would give me some peace but as I haven’t been through it I can’t say for certain.

Dontgivemeplants · 21/12/2023 00:27

Of course I'd like to know. It would be a treasured conversation for the rest of my life. Meet her for a coffee. Jeeezus, why wouldn't you

hollyivy123 · 21/12/2023 00:21

Thanks for all your responses it's a difficult but interesting debate and obviously personalised to the person who has lost so there's no easy answer, but it helped to post it anonymously anyway thankyou

OP posts:
HerMammy · 21/12/2023 00:09

My DP was in your position and the police asked him afterwards if they could give his details to the family , he said yes and received a card thanking him for his efforts and it meant a lot to know he wasn't alone.
I really wouldn't contact her direct, it's not appropriate, she knows people tried to help and if she wanted your details she could ask the police.

Algorhythum · 21/12/2023 00:06

I think knowing it was an HCP who gave cpr would stop the ‘what if’s’ in my brain if it were me. By that I mean that knowing you were trained rather than someone who was just trying but didnt know what they were doing would comfort me, as I would know that you had given him the best chance possible.

I’d contact her, but maybe wait until after Christmas?

Pushmepullu · 21/12/2023 00:02

Something similar happened to us last year and we gave cpr and held the victim’s hand as he died. We found out who he was, he lived in the next village to us and I would like to have told his widow that he didn’t die alone but at a follow up interview with the police, without me saying anything, I was told that we should not contact the family. Apparently some ghoul had read about the accident and contacted the family but gave some incorrect details and had greatly upset the family.
As much as I would want to know should this happen to my loved one, you should speak to the police liaison officer first as they deem it inappropriate.

BorderlineBagpuss · 20/12/2023 23:59

I think the choice should be hers not yours, so write her a message of condolences and enclose your name and number.

AuntPru · 20/12/2023 23:57

Hi OP. I haven't read all responses, just your posts. I am sorry you experienced this and you should be proud of what you did to help this poor man.

I agree with the advice re police liaison, inquests and union advice. I mean this very gently, but I think you need to carefully consider why you are thinking about contacting the widow. I think you should only do it because you believe you've got information that will help her. It would be very understandable if you are traumatised and want to be in closer contact to help with this, but please don't get in touch for that reason. I really hope you understand what I mean and I wish you and your son strength to get through this xxx

Pluvia · 20/12/2023 23:52

LongtimeLurker123 · 20/12/2023 22:02

My husband was killed in a road accident a couple of years ago. I was told at the time that someone passing stopped and gave him CPR. It was kind of them to try, but it did not work. The person never contacted me and to be honest, although I am grateful to them, I am not sure I would want to be contacted. I definitely would not want to be told any more details about the accident. This is just me, of course, other people might want to know.

Something similar happened to me many years ago. I felt no desire to speak to the man who found my partner and called the police. It was clear from the inquest how he died and I was in no fit state to risk asking questions and learning things that might make it all worse. I wrote the man who helped a note thanking him for all he'd done, hoping he wasn't too distressed by what he'd witnessed and wishing him well. I think the police support officer passed it on to him and she relayed a message from him saying that he understood and if there came a time when I felt I would like to talk to him he would be happy to do so. I never really felt the urge, but I'm not the kind of person who needs to know every last detail of anything.

In your shoes, OP, I'd think hard about it and if you do decide to offer to speak to her I'd go through the police and certainly not directly. If she does want to speak to you, I would keep your account very simple and factual and leave out distressing detail. You sound sensitive and thoughtful, but I can imagine a situation where some people might want to make it all about them — which is obviously a no-no. He's dead, nothing can comfort her but there is a possibility of unintentionally making things worse for both of you not just by what you say but how you say it. When people are overwhelmed by grief they're not rational (I know I wasn't, anyway) and sometimes it's easy to take things the wrong way.

It must have been really hard for you and your son to do what you did. I salute you for stopping in such dreadful circumstances. I hope you've had some support to deal with the experience. I wonder whether perhaps you're thinking that talking to her may help you? Not sure that's the best way to go about things. Perhaps speak to a counsellor? Good luck.

Wetblanket78 · 20/12/2023 23:51

I would want to know but wait until after the inquest. My ex was with a friend at our local pub when his friend had a heart attack. He gave CPR while someone rang an ambulance. He unfortunately didn't make it. His niece got his number and she rang the next morning wanting to speak with him.

flibbertigiblets · 20/12/2023 23:50

@hollyivy123 I know exactly where you are coming from. The legal process is so f*cking clinical. I would have valued having someone like you, although I can only imagine how hard it must have been for you at the time and since. Clearly not everyone who has been in this position feels like I do though so I guess think on it and do what you feel may be best.

NOTANUM · 20/12/2023 23:50

I have been in a similar situation. Someone close to me tried to give CPR after ann accident and sadly wasn’t successful.

The police told us the family were very grateful someone (anonymous to them) tried to help and we left it there. In the times of social media, maybe we would have taken a different path but I doubt it would have been a happier outcome for the family. They are suffering and a name won’t help them.

Celebrate the fact you helped and leave it there. You did a good deed that day.