Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the people have a romanticised view of the last few generations?

212 replies

safari111 · 20/12/2023 21:19

Whenever I bring up my mental health with my dad or husband, especially since having kids, instead of support or understanding I receive a speech on how my grandma or my husband's grandma "coped with so much, had so little, and were SO HAPPY. Everyone was happy, blah blah blah" that's all I get. That no one had the mental health issues and neurological problems that people have today and all of that. It enrages me that 1. My mental health is invalidated. 2. Everyone else's mental health problems are invalidated and 3. Everyone romanticises the fact that people were absolutely happier a generation or 2 ago, despite poverty, war, poor health etc.

What are your thoughts on this? Have you experienced similar?

OP posts:
Dacadactyl · 20/12/2023 22:29

I also think that in the past, religion helped people cope, whereas now a lot fewer people believe.

5128gap · 20/12/2023 22:28

When I grew up in the 70s, no one had 'mental health issues' but a few women, my mum included had 'bad nerves' which typically seemed to involve a prescription for valium and a great deal of discretion as it was embarrassing. I didn't know of a single child or young person who was considered mentally unwell. I remember times in my teens when I was deeply unhappy and anxious, but I put that down to situational things, friendship issues, exam nerves. It wouldn't have entered my head to think of this in terms of mental health. So, I don't know if people were actually happier, or whether if not they would have just put it down to life problems rather than pathologising it. I also don't think we had as much sense that we were entitled to be happy then either so expectations were lower.

Naptrappedmummy · 20/12/2023 22:28

Agree with PPs, it’s a mix of the two, of course people had MH issues or were unhappy but there was less navel gazing and for the most part getting on with it was a healthy distraction and meant their issue didn’t take over their lives. We are encouraged to overthink everything now, diagnose ourselves, obsess over every injustice and measure our lives against ‘perfection’. Whereas I think in the past people didn’t expect life to be fair or perfect, were much better at taking the rough with the smooth and knowing one sad incident didn’t stop the world from spinning.

Bbq1 · 20/12/2023 22:27

gemloving · 20/12/2023 22:22

@Bbq1 I'm so glad things have changed. They put us in to a butterfly suite, baby was with us and we had time to grieve. You'll never forget your baby but even 2 days ago in A&E, I was reminded that I'm still young and I can have more children. I didn't say that this will never replace him or remove my grief but I just didn't think it was a kind thing to say.

I'm so sorry for your loss but I hope you found some comfort in being able to grieve your baby. I'm very glad to hear that things have moved on so much but find it hard to understand why drs still act as if children are almost interchangeable. Especially in this day and age.

PermanentTemporary · 20/12/2023 22:26

Just to mention that suicide rates are MUCH lower now than they used to be. In the UK peak male suicide rates were in 1905 and 1934.

My great grandmother went into a mental health institution in 1922 and died 30 years later still there. One of her children was institutionalised as a boy after attacking another child, and never came out either.

I would rather live now, with everything that's difficult in modern life, by about a thousand per cent.

Disturbia81 · 20/12/2023 22:26

I never understand the life was happier thing.
There are so many things about the past that are terrible.

Riverlee · 20/12/2023 22:26

Mental illness was a taboo subject in the past. People didn’t speak about it.

Today, it’s good that mental illness is more recognised, but at the same time people have become less resilient. As someone above said, there’s a lot more overthinking.

Runaway1 · 20/12/2023 22:23

Family on both sides were working class and very, very poor.

1 grandfather was in WW1 and suffered PTSD his whole life, medicating with alcohol. His wife depressed. 3 of 4 kids’ mental health blighted, with one now psychotic, two have had lifelong major depression.

Other grandfather couldn’t serve. Had depression to the extent of being unable to work for periods. The church fed and clothed the kids during this time. One of his kids developed schizophrenia, another had severe social anxiety. This was termed being ‘funny buggers’.

So yeah, things were shit and people suffered. There just wasn’t any help.

TwinklingLightsEverywhere · 20/12/2023 22:23

I think these days we expect others to care more about our MH, or at least pretend to. Lots of people just don't know how to deal with it, they can't think of anything practical to do so resort to 'others have it worse' or advise you to forget about it and get on with life.

There's no reason why others should act as your counselor and validate your problems, they have their own problems and often just can't see what they can do. If you think they'd like to help you tell them what you want :
To just listen to you?
To agree with you?
To challenge you?
To give advice?
There are genuinely people who value all these approaches, it sounds like you need someone in the one of the first two categories.

I do also think in general people are less resilient, which isn't 'keep calm and carry on' it is that you have developed the tools during your life to allow you to cope in a lot of situations.

I also wonder whether some people are very keen to show how sympathetic and compassionate they are as publicly as possible - usually all over SM, so when you aren't treated the same in real life you feel hard done by.

gemloving · 20/12/2023 22:22

@Bbq1 I'm so glad things have changed. They put us in to a butterfly suite, baby was with us and we had time to grieve. You'll never forget your baby but even 2 days ago in A&E, I was reminded that I'm still young and I can have more children. I didn't say that this will never replace him or remove my grief but I just didn't think it was a kind thing to say.

Dacadactyl · 20/12/2023 22:22

I think a lot of it is that people didn't have time to think about these things in the past.

They had more children, more money worries etc.

But their lives were smaller and everyone around them was the same as them. They probably weren't aware they had it bad iyswim which made it easier to cope with maybe?

Tacotortoise · 20/12/2023 22:17

Oh God yes. People do it to themselves though. To listen to my MiL talk the second world war was just an endless round of pulling together, people supporting each other and drinking cocoa and singing in the Anderson shelter waiting for bombs that never came. My FiL, who grew up in London, who's dad went off to fight and whose grandparents did not own a grocers shop has a slightly different take on it.

CurlyhairedAssassin · 20/12/2023 22:16

The widespread availability of highly visual news footage surely must add to people's "worry load" for want of a better term. It's a bit different seeing really disturbing footage very regularly of global suffering etc than reading a written report in a newspaper or even listening to a voice on the radio. I'm not sure what that is doing to our brains and stress levels. We must be absorbing and retaining those traumatic images in some way.

Singleandproud · 20/12/2023 22:14

DD is diagnosed with autism she manages at school with various coping strategies.
My Dbro has lots of autistic traits had an awful time at school and was a school refuser.
My DDad has lots of autistic traits had a bad time at school, easily influenced into undesirable behaviour left school at 15 no qualifications, has worked isolated jobs as an adult or cared for DBro when a school refuser and DGP when they had cancer has been out of the work place supported by my mum for 20 years.
My DGDad had autistic traits left school at 12 as was normal in rura Ireland in the 40s, worked the family farm before moving to the UK and doing a physical and repetitive job.

Life was harder in the past but also less demanding and less navel gazing, people at least the poor were kept physically busy this would have benefited some people's MH or kept their mind busy. Modern living is too stimulating for most people and we don't even know it and far too much comparison available instead of just comparing your life with the same people you lived near which was similar ,we are ofcourse animals and we are so far removed from the lives that we should naturally lead that it's no wonder MH issues are increasing

Grapewrath · 20/12/2023 22:13

It’s a combination of denial of MH problems and rose tinted glasses. I read one of the SM posts the other day about ‘if yiu grew up in the 80s’ and how amazing it was.
I remember a lot of poverty and people being deeply unhappy- things like DA and addiction were hidden behind closed doors and everyone pretended everything was fine when it really wasn’t

merryhouse · 20/12/2023 22:12

I remember reading magazines in the seventies - Punch (it had cartoons), Woman's Weekly and so on, as well as Reader's Digest - and one of the things I quite clearly remember is the number of adverts for Sanatogen Tonic.

I got the distinct impression that this was something vast swathes of the housekeeping population were chugging daily.

As this sign shows, the recommendation was three glasses a day...

Vintage Sanatogen Tonic Wine Shop Advertising Sign With Tin Front & Card Stand | eBay

Find many great new & used options and get the best deals for Vintage Sanatogen Tonic Wine Shop Advertising Sign With Tin Front & Card Stand at the best online prices at eBay! Free delivery for many products.

https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/295896495379?_trkparms=ispr%3D1&amdata=enc%3A1gOoJ4zQpSDeHYSTlPzXGiQ63&campid=5338268676&customid=CjwKCAiAvoqsBhB9EiwA9XTWGSsGhvopNb0uQWbLcW4hZhXYG0iYrQ3csHvU2U5s4o_-PJHM6WHASRoC_8cQAvD_BwE&mkcid=1&mkevt=1&mkrid=710-53481-19255-0&toolid=10044&var=0

Lalalanding · 20/12/2023 22:09

I think you just were not in the circles. 2 in my father’s family at least were alcoholics. My mother worked in a voluntary service for children with disabilities.

The children, a lot of them, were hidden out at home or institutionalised and if at home mothers were just to get on with it, absolutely zero education.

People carpet swept and denied significant issues.

pinkstripeycat · 20/12/2023 22:07

My great grandad was depressed and shot himself. Of course poor mental heath (and PTSD) were a thing years ago but people were often too busy trying to survive (my Nan would go hungry to feed her family) to give their mental health much consideration. Also other folk would just shrug and keep going, stiff upper lip and all that. I don’t think they were any happier than people are now.

Their struggles were different to ours

XmasPartyhat · 20/12/2023 22:00

I have an autistic child. My own mother made comments about there being a lot of autism about these days (like it was the cold) and that people didn't have it in her day. When my child was diagnosed she told me that was a shame.

My mum has never been diagnosed with anything. But she has glaringly obvious traits of autism and OCD. Anxiety and trying to control situations. Meltdowns when she doesn't get her way or things don't go as she expected. Ritualistic hand washing, locking and unlocking doors and flicking light switches. The empathy and emotional intelligence of a shoe.

People might not have been diagnosed in her day. But she is still probably autistic.

TimeFlysWhenYoureHavingRum · 20/12/2023 21:55

Yanbu. Aparrently they all worked so much harder and never committed any crimes either.

Teddleshon · 20/12/2023 21:54

I don’t believe that people were necessarily happy but they certainly seemed to be better at coping with bad things happening in their lives.

mantyzer · 20/12/2023 21:54

So my mother was born during the war. That generation were told to be grateful for enough food and peace in their country. Expectations were much lower.

mantyzer · 20/12/2023 21:52

People were not happier, but they did not expect to be. Contentment was the goal.
There did seem to be less major mental health problems e.g. school avoidance, unable to work due to depression and anxiety. Some people did have this, but it seems far less than now.

NoraLuka · 20/12/2023 21:49

I’m sure people felt bad about some things just as much as we do, but they just didn’t talk about it as much. My granddad died when my dad was a teenager, DGM had to support her kids on her own in the days before there were benefits etc. This must have been difficult for them all but Dad has spoken to me about it precisely once!

DGM used to tell a story about her own grandmother who lost a daughter as a toddler. She was elderly by the time DGM knew her, but she’d kept the girl’s little dress in the back of her wardrobe and would sometimes get it out to look at, about 50 years later. There must be millions of stories like that which never get recorded but surely not everyone was happy all the time.

Maybe there was less fear of missing out because people didn’t know as much about what was happening outside their own area. Obviously they had the news etc but not wall to wall influencers and celebrities etc.

Bbq1 · 20/12/2023 21:47

gemloving · 20/12/2023 21:24

I never thought people were happier but people were expected to just get on with it and not talk about their problems. It seems as though because life was a lot harder, there was less sympathy but I might be wrong. I never lived then.

After my baby died, I learned that my own grandmother lost a baby and doctors said to her: just get pregnant again and forget about him at the time and she told me that she'd never forgotten about him. This was 60 years ago but she's also never talked about it as it was just expected to get on with it.

My mum has her first baby stillborn when she was just 21. The dr said "you have got lots of time to have as many babies as you like". Even worse, afterwards they put her on the maternity ward surrounded by new mums and babies. She never even got to see him and has never forgotten. Such cruel, uncaring attitudes back then but I guess they actually thought it was the right thing to do.

Swipe left for the next trending thread