Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the people have a romanticised view of the last few generations?

212 replies

safari111 · 20/12/2023 21:19

Whenever I bring up my mental health with my dad or husband, especially since having kids, instead of support or understanding I receive a speech on how my grandma or my husband's grandma "coped with so much, had so little, and were SO HAPPY. Everyone was happy, blah blah blah" that's all I get. That no one had the mental health issues and neurological problems that people have today and all of that. It enrages me that 1. My mental health is invalidated. 2. Everyone else's mental health problems are invalidated and 3. Everyone romanticises the fact that people were absolutely happier a generation or 2 ago, despite poverty, war, poor health etc.

What are your thoughts on this? Have you experienced similar?

OP posts:
ShippingNews · 21/12/2023 04:29

mantyzer · 20/12/2023 21:52

People were not happier, but they did not expect to be. Contentment was the goal.
There did seem to be less major mental health problems e.g. school avoidance, unable to work due to depression and anxiety. Some people did have this, but it seems far less than now.

This is true. I grew up in the 60's - my parents lived through the Blitz in London and had to go and identify neighbors who had been killed in their houses overnight. Mum said they really didn't expect to survive - every day was a blessing . They didn't have time to feel sorry for themselves.

Mum had a stillborn baby during the War, and like other comments here, she was told she had time to have more babies and she should just move on. Which she did - she only told me about it once when I was pregnant.

Something I notice now which was unknown when I was growing up , was "school avoidance" . We went to school and that was that - big classes, my school photos show about 40 kids in a class. I never knew of kids getting to avoid school or be home schooled, even though everyone's mother was at home . It just didn't happen. You were expected to get on with it .

I don't think we have rose coloured glasses on about the past - it wasn't all sweetness and light - but people really were expected to get on with life.

Flufferblub · 21/12/2023 04:24

My dgm suffered with depression her whole life. Her mother died when she was young, and she had to work and raise her younger siblings. She married my dgf, fell pregnant and he went off to war. She wouldn't hear from him for weeks/months at a time, and didn't know if he was coming back. She raised her child alone for the first few years. After the war, luckily my dgf came home. They had a total of 5 children. It's no wonder she had problems after all the trauma she'd been through, but was expected to just crack on. When she did go for treatment, it was things like electric shock therapy. People had mental health problems, it just wasn't understood or supported like it is now.

MrsHughesPinny · 21/12/2023 04:16

Similarly to others, there’s a lot of tragedy in my family including DV, institutionalisation, alcoholism and extreme poverty. My great grandmother and her sister were forced into prostitution just to feed themselves and their younger siblings in the 1890s after their father left the family with another woman after their mother died. There was no government help, just bits from the church or the community so people didn’t have a choice but to get on and do what they had to do.

Trauma existed so MH issues existed, of course they did. They just weren’t spoken about. People had an ‘eccentric aunt’ or a cousin who was ‘just a bit of an oddbod’ and that’s all that was said. People went into institutions never to be heard of again. The shame and stigma was enough for families to just pretend they were dead.

Life was harder, people were harder and they didn’t expect as much out of life as we do now. We have it way better. Thankfully psychology, sociology and science has also moved on and we can understand, diagnose and appropriately treat MH struggles now.

mantyzer · 21/12/2023 03:13

"My mother had a friend who spent a lot of time in psychiatric hospitals but I think the idea of mental health diagnosis was for those suffering in much more profound ways than is recognised now. There's more support at lower levels of distress than there was in the past."

I agree with this. People with lower levels of distress may have talked to the Vicar or his wife, but most just got on with it. What other choice did they have?
People who received treatment were mainly quite seriously ill - although there were also those young women committed for having abortions or being a lesbian.

SequentialAnalyst · 21/12/2023 01:55

Of course, I have many other ancestors who did not have MH issues, or none that are recorded or remembered. I expect everyone has a similar mix in their past.

SequentialAnalyst · 21/12/2023 01:54

Looking at my family history:
Great great grandfather committed suicide 1860s
At the inquest it was said his sister had problems
His wife's youngest brother was a paranoid schizophrenic and spent years in an asylum. In better conditions than being an inpatient these days. Other folk in the record book of the asylum seem to have been admitted with mania, and left again after 6 weeks. This is about the same as these days, but with no medication.
A female relative the 1950s was hospitalised with what now seems to have been post-partum depression coupled with grief at the loss of her DF. She was treated with insulin therapy - basically being put in a coma for a week. Some who remember her think she became more "docile" after this.
A great uncle by marriage had a lobotomy for severe depression, possibly brought on by his wife's repeated miscarriages. They never had children in the end, and she had to be the breadwinner. I met him a few times - something seemed to have been lost. 1960s.
Another great grandfather drowned himself in the Thames, 1910s.
A friend of a family member killed herself with an overdose, 1970s.

Stigma used to be reserved for those with TB, cancer, or MH issues. Now, it seems to be applied mainly to MH issues, and is still real, despite all the anti-stigma stuff that's been going round the last couple of decades.

Human nature doesn't change that much over time.

caringcarer · 21/12/2023 01:54

My Gran had a baby that weighed only 2lb exactly. The doctor delivered him at home and told her he's a runt, put him at the bottom of the bed and I'll come around to you tomorrow. Gran fed him every 2-3 hours and cuddled him in bed with her. The doctor called the next lunch time and saw Gran feeding him and told her she was making life hard for herself because he was a runt and too small to survive and She shouldn't feed him. This was said in front of my Auntie who was 8. Gran ignored the doctor and that baby grew up to be my Dad. He had 5 Dad's. He served in the war and lived until he was 74. Expectations were very different then.

Panastasia · 21/12/2023 01:46

I also agree with your points, OP.

My gma, born 1920s, always maintained a stiff upper lip. But I know she’d had a terribly hard life. She had a stillborn baby boy, then lost a second son to meningitis. There was no therapy, support groups, and I expect she did just press on with other children to look after. But she told me she lost all her hair, and wore a wig for a decade following her losses. Holding it in like she was expected to took a terrible toll.

Riversofthesea · 21/12/2023 01:36

Sorry OP I didn’t answer your question. Yes, your 3 points are correct imo.

My mother was much like your dad in her attitude. She also had extraordinary robust and physical health until she hit her 80s and health issues and an anxiety/panic disorder caught up with her. She told me she didn’t realise how hard it could be to have a chronic physical health illness and/or mental health issues - despite having a son with both who ended his own life. That’s how nutty and batshit it all was. Still is, in many ways.

endlessdarkness · 21/12/2023 01:14

Lovepeaceunderstanding · 21/12/2023 00:33

@safari111 , I’m pretty sure I will be shot down in flames for this but you asked for views. Here is mine:
I am 60, I have a pretty decent understanding back to my grandparent’s generation. My maternal grandmother was Victorian.
There has, I believe been a quite significant shift in people’s expectations. Nowadays people seem to expect so much more for themselves, their joy appears to me to be much more self centred. I also and importantly believe that now many people are horribly fixated by the negatives of their existence and compounded by increasing numbers of people who feel that responsibility for their feeling happy lies outside themselves.
I should make it abundantly clear that there are and always have been people who genuinely suffer mental health issues but I consider that to be separate from those who suffer from ‘Oh woah is me, I abdicate responsibility for myself; someone else must do everything because I’m too damaged’ issues.
Obviously I have no idea which camp you fall into OP. In years gone by most people, myself included had our fair share of crap, we had lows, we had troubles. We understood that that’s life and did the best with what life gave us but we also felt grateful for each good thing however small. Our expectations were much lower too at the same time we accepted responsibility for ourselves and our families both young and old.
Make of my honest response what you will but my final word is this:
Past generations had a better attitude to life and consequently a better experience of it despite often being every bit as challenged as we are now, if not more.

I agree with this. We just 'got on with it' and found ways to cope because we had no other option. Considering the crap life has thrown my way, I think I've benefited from the capacity to just 'get on with it'. I enjoy the simple things in life.

On the other hand, I think my degree of ability to 'get on with it' and deal with myself is probably unnatural. Definitely learned from the school of hard knocks and knowing that no-one was there for me anyway, so I just had to cope however I could.

I was talking to my older children about this and asked them if they thought that all the emotions and feelings support they got when they were younger was helpful or actually not helpful, in terms of whether it interfered with them building resilience. They all think that it was actually helpful to have had that support and understanding of their feelings, unlike what I got when I was just told to stop being silly if I was upset. They think it contributed to their own resilience.

So I don't know what the answer is. Probably the validation is better overall.

My mother had a friend who spent a lot of time in psychiatric hospitals but I think the idea of mental health diagnosis was for those suffering in much more profound ways than is recognised now. There's more support at lower levels of distress than there was in the past.

One thing I do think is that young adults seem to be much less friendly and kind to each other now. Maybe social media has a role in that. Maybe I'm wrong, but it's what I am observing.

OracleofWurms1 · 21/12/2023 01:11

@safari111 if everyone wrote in a dairy about how they felt etc it would be a mix of perspectives

Riversofthesea · 21/12/2023 01:00

God, the shame of having a mental health problem back then! Not only would people not talk about their own mental health illnesses, they’d look at anyone who admitted to being mentally unwell like they’d suddenly sprouted 2 heads - which is why people didn’t talk about their own mental health challenges.

I don’t believe people lack resilience these days. I think we are about as resilient as we’ve ever been. Saying people lack resilience these days is just blaming them for not being able to meet all the challenges of living in this current time - there are many.

I pinched this from Twitter. Re resilience:

“'Resilience' is a sneaky neoliberal trope. It frames, as a psychological virtue, painful endurance of circumstances from which others benefit at your expense.”

Gritting your teeth and enduring while other, luckier, people live better - resilience. Finding a way to pull your self up by your bootstraps - literally impossible - resilience. Being told all it takes is to apply yourself more and work harder (while you are working as hard as you can) - resilience.

Who does our ‘resilience’ benefit exactly?

ToWhitToWhoo · 21/12/2023 00:56

My grandmother on my father's side, and my great-grandmother on my mother's side, had serious bouts of depression. Two of my mum's cousins took their own lives; that was in the 50s. I know several people who may not have 'navel-gazed' in response to the stress and deprivations of their 1930s and 40s childhoods: they only became alcoholics, neglectful of their own children, and/or pathological hoarders.

WingingItSince1973 · 21/12/2023 00:53

I am so so glad things have changed for mental health. It's not perfect but I dread how my 17 year old dd or my 8 year old dgs would have been treated even when I was at school in the 70s and 80s. Or my friends son with crippling bipolar when medication wasn't available. These kids would have been classed as 'slow' or 'aggressive'. Even in my senior school in the middle 80s there was a special place in the school called the 'remedial block'!!! I do sincerely apologise for using that term. But it was a stigma to be in there and how those poor kids just have felt being ostracised and not in any beneficial therapeutic way. My dgs school has a sensory room, quiet areas and other adaptions for children who can't cope in a noisy environment and any other Sen. I just hope those kids from my day have the help they do now. My eldest has just been diagnosed adhd as an adult. When we tried to get her help as a teen we were laughed at. She has struggled all her life and has attempted suicide twice. Now thankfully she has been diagnosed and is on the right pathway.

Lovelymoon · 21/12/2023 00:40

I really agree with everything you’re saying here OP

Lovepeaceunderstanding · 21/12/2023 00:33

@safari111 , I’m pretty sure I will be shot down in flames for this but you asked for views. Here is mine:
I am 60, I have a pretty decent understanding back to my grandparent’s generation. My maternal grandmother was Victorian.
There has, I believe been a quite significant shift in people’s expectations. Nowadays people seem to expect so much more for themselves, their joy appears to me to be much more self centred. I also and importantly believe that now many people are horribly fixated by the negatives of their existence and compounded by increasing numbers of people who feel that responsibility for their feeling happy lies outside themselves.
I should make it abundantly clear that there are and always have been people who genuinely suffer mental health issues but I consider that to be separate from those who suffer from ‘Oh woah is me, I abdicate responsibility for myself; someone else must do everything because I’m too damaged’ issues.
Obviously I have no idea which camp you fall into OP. In years gone by most people, myself included had our fair share of crap, we had lows, we had troubles. We understood that that’s life and did the best with what life gave us but we also felt grateful for each good thing however small. Our expectations were much lower too at the same time we accepted responsibility for ourselves and our families both young and old.
Make of my honest response what you will but my final word is this:
Past generations had a better attitude to life and consequently a better experience of it despite often being every bit as challenged as we are now, if not more.

overwhelmed2023 · 21/12/2023 00:12

I think what people mean is they were expected to be more independent tougher and resilient. Sometimes that resulted in serious problems not being addressed or bad things happening ( seeing lots of flashers etc etc) or sometimes it meant but sometimes the freer more simple life with lots of tone spent together playing out, living close together etc meant you had that safety and security and felt really happy, despite having much less belongings etc.

pretzelbreath · 21/12/2023 00:09

It's a classic case of rose tinted glasses. They used to lock people up in asylums for 'lunacy', 'melancholy' and 'mania'. Mental health problems very much existed, patients were treated like prisoners, tested on, lobotomised and neglected.

ToWhitToWhoo · 21/12/2023 00:05

Our fathers of old were robust, stout, and strong,
And kept open house, with good cheer all day long,
Which made their plump tenants rejoice in this song—
Oh! The Roast Beef of old England,
And old English Roast Beef!

But now we are dwindled to, what shall I name?
A sneaking poor race, half-begotten and tame,
Who sully the honours that once shone in fame.
Oh! the Roast Beef of Old England,
And old English Roast Beef!

(From a song by Henry Fielding, 1731)

As I always say: Things ain't what they used to be- and they never were!

Lemonfoxtrot · 21/12/2023 00:04

People talked about it less, but I reckon people’s mental health was worse- not better. it was just normalised.

You only have to hear stories of the way some older people were brought up to realise there were some pretty messed up people around 100 years ago!

People suppressing their sexuality.
people being beaten for expressing any sexuality
pregnancy outside marriage considered shameful.

Then look at the trauma from WW2 - my mum remembers a neighbour getting drunk and crying in the street regularly due to what he experienced …he was lucky in that his family cared for him.

ToWhitToWhoo · 20/12/2023 23:59

Yes, many people definitely romanticize the past!

E.g.

In my day, children of fourteen and fifteen didn't dress in the height of the fashion; go to parties, as nearly like those of grown people as it's possible to make them; lead idle, giddy, unhealthy lives, and get blase at twenty. We were little folks till eighteen or so; worked and studied, dressed and played, like children; honored our parents; and our days were much longer in the land than now, it seems to, me.

Spoken by a 70-year-old grandmother in Louisa Alcott's 'An Old-Fashioned Girl' (1869).

Incidentally, this book includes the attempted suicide of a 17-year-old girl.

Beesandhoney123 · 20/12/2023 23:54

People pick and choose their memories, we as individuals question more, example doctors, but we don't seem to learn new things, just re hash old things.

Women can vote, we can get divorced and not be ostracised from society. Men can prefer openly not to spend time in pubs but with their family

People can't look forward and foresee change to their situation as it is too disruptive to face perhaps, so they look back and mould history as its based on facts and some artistic licence. One can't go back in time. To look forward means change and people generally don't like change on a personal disruptive scale

Boomboom22 · 20/12/2023 23:50

I think it's just arrogance. The human experience hasn't really changed that much. I think even in medieval times people had the same worries. We are more child centred but have less kids and tech to help so still busy. We still have sexual and platonic relationships. It's just victorian times that were uptight not most of history. Being a serf or servant wasn't better than being poor now.

APurpleSquirrel · 20/12/2023 23:49

My grandmother definitely had mental health problems. She lost her brother in WWII. & her middle daughter died at 18months old from pneumonia. my grandmother became so depressed she underwent electric shock therapy! I've no idea if it was voluntary or not.
But it wasn't talked about.

Dixiechickonhols · 20/12/2023 23:45

They sound uneducated. I live near a former large asylum, there was an exhibition of photos and records at a local community hall. I’d be very tempted to take them to something like that.

Swipe left for the next trending thread