Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the people have a romanticised view of the last few generations?

212 replies

safari111 · 20/12/2023 21:19

Whenever I bring up my mental health with my dad or husband, especially since having kids, instead of support or understanding I receive a speech on how my grandma or my husband's grandma "coped with so much, had so little, and were SO HAPPY. Everyone was happy, blah blah blah" that's all I get. That no one had the mental health issues and neurological problems that people have today and all of that. It enrages me that 1. My mental health is invalidated. 2. Everyone else's mental health problems are invalidated and 3. Everyone romanticises the fact that people were absolutely happier a generation or 2 ago, despite poverty, war, poor health etc.

What are your thoughts on this? Have you experienced similar?

OP posts:
Lovepeaceunderstanding · 21/12/2023 09:15

@endlessdarkness , your username struck me. 😔
My mother also had a friend who suffered with her mental health, her best friend and a lovely soul. She used to have electro convulsive therapy, I truly hope they don’t do that to people anymore.
I was in no way mollycoddled by my parents and to be honest I often used their parenting style to help form my own style of parenting in so far as I made sure I was quite different. I fear that things may have swung too far in the other direction now and that we have a lot of people who lack resilience.
Merry Christmas. X

the80sweregreat · 21/12/2023 08:42

Loath those QR codes ! We were second hand car looking the other week and they just have the codes in the car's window now to scan , not easy when the windscreen was wet and the phone didn't register it properly
I sniffed a bit of a cover up ( especially as one car was listed cheaper online too )
Sorry to derail, but they are everywhere now
I'd rather see figures on the car telling me exactly what it's selling for

Createausername1970 · 21/12/2023 08:37

I think there was mental health issues in previous generations, but not the recognition or the help, so it generally went unnoticed.

Agree with other posters that as a generalisation, people lived in closer proximity to their families, so day to day contact and support was on tap, without anyone actually seeing it as "support".

I think life is more complicated nowadays. Technology make things possible, doesn't necessarily make them easier or enjoyable and if you are struggling, there is more stuff nowadays to struggle with.

For example. I had a packet of royal icing sugar. I wanted to know approx how much water to add. You would have thought it would be on the box. Oh no it wasn't. I had to scan the code thing to be taken to the Silver Spoon website, and I had to scroll down to find it. FFS. If I was already feeling low about something else, this unnecessary faff to just do something simple would make me feel worse. In fact I didn't even realise I had to scan the code, I was getting all f'ing in the kitchen about not being able to find what I was looking for on the box. It was DH who sussed it out.

The "big" things like death etc., happen across the generations, but I think we have much more other stuff to deal with on a daily basis that can tip the balance.

DonnaHadDee · 21/12/2023 08:31

I think there is a tendancy for people to look back fondly at the past, remember the good parts and forget about the bad parts. And then might often on share the good parts? My father was in the army and served in Cyprus and Kenya, and had wonderful photos, often spoke about those times, had lifelong friends he kept in touch with. He only ever spoke about the good things. It seemed like a huge adventure. The "private" stories he had in his journals was very very different. What he saw, what he had to do, what he felt, the mental and physical stress, he was seriously ill in hospital for 3 months with appendix and almost died.

My DF was also a very religious man, and that is something he never spoke to us much about either. So perhaps another factor is that some people are more inclined to share more of their private self externally?

Look after yourself OP, be your own priority.

ruby1957 · 21/12/2023 07:38

mantyzer · 20/12/2023 21:54

So my mother was born during the war. That generation were told to be grateful for enough food and peace in their country. Expectations were much lower.

Absolutely this.
I was born just after the war - some rationing was still around and the War had had an effect on people's health, both mental and physical.
Life was much tougher than it is now - but the expectations were never that you would be pretty, or wealthy. or have a dazzling career etc.

With lower expectations our joy in life came from family, friends and community. There was no-one to feel envious of or be compared against - most of us lived the same kind of life.

CrunchyCarrot · 21/12/2023 07:33

I'm fast approaching 70 and there's no way I'd say people were happier in any past decades I've lived in. More problems were swept under the carpet though, things weren't talked about. I lived in a small town and people knew each other (and gossiped!) about what was going on.

From what I heard from my grandmother, she did not have an easy life, in fact was abandoned by her father and ended up in a very strict convent school and was miserable! Life was not 'easy' at all. Similarly for her own mother. Different times, different challenges.

Lalalanding · 21/12/2023 07:25

Here is another one for the rose tinted amongst us. I was at an exhibition last week from the late 1800s/early 1900s where they had photographs of children, the youngest was a 4 year old girl, who were imprisoned for various crimes, hers was vagrancy, in adult prisons. I’m thinking mental health, no one gave a shit.

Shoppingfiend · 21/12/2023 07:25

TimeFlysWhenYoureHavingRum · 20/12/2023 21:55

Yanbu. Aparrently they all worked so much harder and never committed any crimes either.

I livedin the countryside and not many people had cars. So had someone stolen something where would they go, how would they hide. Few Cars meant they would have stood out like a sore thumb even if they had one - people knew the people in their vicinity. And cars went at lower speeds. The police could phone ahead to watch out for them. Now people can walk out of supermarkets with stuff in a balaclava.

JustlikeElllie · 21/12/2023 07:13

I'm 39 and I definitely don't think people were happier in previous generations. A lot of my older relatives had very bad mental health problems in the 50s. Most of them turned to alcohol.

There was also a lot of severe poverty, child abuse was rife. It might have been a happy time if you were reasonably well off or from a loving family but for those that weren't it was a horrendous time.

Of course things aren't perfect now either but there are a lot of improvements to living conditions, the way the vulnerable are treated.

People will always have rose tinted specs because that's nostalgia. I grew up in the 80s and 90s and remember how lovely everything was but I don't think it's all reality I think I was just young .

safari111 · 21/12/2023 06:51

Wow, I'm amazed at how many replies I've woken up to..I'll read these throughout the day and try to reply to some! Really interesting to see the perspective from different age groups. Thanks everyone for the replies so far!

OP posts:
RedToothBrush · 21/12/2023 05:40

Point 3: Communities. People were generally in communities in a way we don't see in the same way. Everyone knew everyone else. Thus social isolation was different. People didn't lock themselves away from the world because that was harder to do. They had to mix and get out of an echo chamber just repeating negative affirmations. Online communities are self selecting and narrow in focus. And if someone doesn't turn up as expected on a given day, they are less likely to be missed.

RedToothBrush · 21/12/2023 05:33

Two conflicting things are possible.

One: people with significant mental health problems were not supported and helped in the past. This made their lives considerably worse

Two: lack of resilience due to over protection is leading to more people struggling to cope and having more minor issues. The current trend for validation rather than resilience building might be adding to the problem by encouraging avoidant type behaviour rather than coping strategies which in the long term makes the issue worse.

I don't think it is an either or thing.

Riversofthesea · 21/12/2023 05:31

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 21/12/2023 05:26

There's definitely two extremes - rose tinted glasses, but also there's those who like to remind us how they walked 12 miles, barefoot, in a blizzard, to school every day.

And ate coal for breakfast….

endlessdarkness · 21/12/2023 05:30

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 21/12/2023 05:26

There's definitely two extremes - rose tinted glasses, but also there's those who like to remind us how they walked 12 miles, barefoot, in a blizzard, to school every day.

I think a lot more was expected of children, much less emotional support. There were definitely elements that were much harder and like walking 12 miles in snow to school. My husband used to walk an hour to school a long a busy main road when he was six. Then home again. That was okay then. These days you'd probably get a knock on the door from social services if you allowed that.

But things were easier in some ways too. We could get away from school, bullies couldn't follow us home via technology. Life was simpler in many ways, which meant there was more quiet in life.

I'm actually glad I had my childhood before screens and the internet.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 21/12/2023 05:26

There's definitely two extremes - rose tinted glasses, but also there's those who like to remind us how they walked 12 miles, barefoot, in a blizzard, to school every day.

Heatherbell1978 · 21/12/2023 05:24

Interesting thread. I think it revolves a lot around what we expect in order to be happy these days. People are dissatisfied because they don't have a certain 'thing' or feel they should be living the same life as someone else. We're a society surrounded by marketing, social media and a general message that validation comes from owning x and y. In the past I'm not sure that existed to the same extent. It's something I'm actively trying to 'opt out' of ie being happy with what I have, not unhappy with what I don't have.

autienotnaughty · 21/12/2023 05:24

I think technology has brought new/different stresses to life that people struggle to switch off from. Social media has created a new way to bully/taunt/bragg that lasts 24 hours a day. Throw in higher expectations within society re achievements, rising living costs,so many rules and regulations around how everyone lives their lives. I'd say life is pretty stressful for most people.

I grew up in the 80/90's not that long ago but it was much slower paced I think people were happier or didn't know better

Tattingersbubbles · 21/12/2023 05:17

My Nan was my role model. Poor as a church mouse. Never complained, found joy in small things. Loved a competition in later life and won some pretty random shit. But she had plenty she could’ve been melancholy about, but just kept buggering on. My GF deserted her after the war (not that he served) and left her with 5 kids under 7. There was no social security at that time. No family to support her. Lovely woman, always put the thoughts of others above herself. Raised all kids single handedly and worked her fingers to the bone. Ride a bike everywhere. My dad inherited her cheerful, kind upbringing even though he was shipped off to boarding school because of the above but contented to have a nice house, new cars, steady job and a family. My mother was an awful woman but he would never leave because of the experience of his own single parent household, plus he probably couldn’t afford to.

My own mother had a pretty unfortunate upbringing, also ended up at boarding school but ended up with a chip on her shoulder and was a massive narcissist. Instead of concentrating on her luck at having a lovely husband, well behaved kids (we were too scared to be anything else) never had to work, never lifted a finger around the house, always complaining, dissatisfied with her lot all of the time.

I think happiness/contentment is partly innate and partly resilience to life’s challenges. So no, I don’t think previous generations were happier, but they certainly had more to worry about.

endlessdarkness · 21/12/2023 05:16

ShippingNews · 21/12/2023 04:29

This is true. I grew up in the 60's - my parents lived through the Blitz in London and had to go and identify neighbors who had been killed in their houses overnight. Mum said they really didn't expect to survive - every day was a blessing . They didn't have time to feel sorry for themselves.

Mum had a stillborn baby during the War, and like other comments here, she was told she had time to have more babies and she should just move on. Which she did - she only told me about it once when I was pregnant.

Something I notice now which was unknown when I was growing up , was "school avoidance" . We went to school and that was that - big classes, my school photos show about 40 kids in a class. I never knew of kids getting to avoid school or be home schooled, even though everyone's mother was at home . It just didn't happen. You were expected to get on with it .

I don't think we have rose coloured glasses on about the past - it wasn't all sweetness and light - but people really were expected to get on with life.

I'm younger than you but yes, school avoidance just wasn't a thing. You went to school whether you wanted to or not and there was no discussion. I'd probably have been a school avoider if I could have got away with it.

There were a few home schoolers but it was so much less common then.

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 21/12/2023 05:13

LoreleiG · 20/12/2023 23:44

I don’t agree that people were happier with less choice, it’s just another rose-tinted thing we say now. My grandparents left school at 14 because they had to but they didn’t want to. Just because there was no choice doesn’t mean people were happy about it.

As always one example doesn't necessarily apply to all. My father left school at 14 because the schools were closed due to polio and he thought he might as well be earning money instead of sitting at home. I left school at 16 (just) because I was sick of it and wanted to be earning money. Others in my class left at 15 because they wanted to be earning money. Young people in those days were not babied as much as many are now, they were ready to be independent and live their own lives.

Mumof2teens79 · 21/12/2023 05:05

I think people were less unhappy because their expectations were lower. They were happy with their lot.
People now expect perfection, compare themselves and their lives to others and also expect to be happy. A lot of people expect everything to be fixable and that life must be fair.

There's a lot to be said for acceptance and realising what you have.

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 21/12/2023 05:05

Naptrappedmummy · 20/12/2023 22:55

I don’t think everyone was fine but I think they were more resilient to minor/moderate MH issues.

Of course they were. And for your information @pinguins I, and all of my family, and all of my friends are not at all "mentally fragile", we all deal with reality - and some have had a lot to deal with, and are still dealing with it, and I imagine all of us would say that the majority of people were fine back then (when exactly is "back then" btw?). We just happen to come from a generation which doesn't spend every waking hour obsessing over every thing in life which doesn't go according to plan, and are mature enough to know that no-one is entitled to a life free of problems.

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 21/12/2023 04:56

Naptrappedmummy · 20/12/2023 22:28

Agree with PPs, it’s a mix of the two, of course people had MH issues or were unhappy but there was less navel gazing and for the most part getting on with it was a healthy distraction and meant their issue didn’t take over their lives. We are encouraged to overthink everything now, diagnose ourselves, obsess over every injustice and measure our lives against ‘perfection’. Whereas I think in the past people didn’t expect life to be fair or perfect, were much better at taking the rough with the smooth and knowing one sad incident didn’t stop the world from spinning.

This is exactly it. People accepted that life didn't always go according to plan, and didn't constantly look at others and wish they had their lives/money/luck whatever. Everything is such a drama these days, whereas people used to just get on with their lives. I see it in a lot of threads on MN, people who can't seem to work out how to deal with the most simple issue.

Benibidibici · 21/12/2023 04:46

"My mother had a friend who spent a lot of time in psychiatric hospitals but I think the idea of mental health diagnosis was for those suffering in much more profound ways than is recognised now. There's more support at lower levels of distress than there was in the past."

This. Our family doctor tried to suggest my grandparent was "depressed" a month following death of spouse they had been with since teenage years, its not depression to grieve.

I know i'll get slaughtered for saying this but I also think there's more support & acknowledgement (in life & education settings) for less profound degrees of neurodiversity. The changes to diagnostic criteria after DSM 3, including those to ICD 10, massively increased the scope of what was classified as a clinicial condition. A lot of people diagnosed now simply didnt meet diagnostic criteria in the 80s and were left to get on with life. There were a bucket of people who didn't love school, so they left it at 16 and went into work or college.

Benibidibici · 21/12/2023 04:37

I think people these days spend too much time overthinking and over complicating every aspect of everything, not sure it is any better these days

This. I also think people accepted some things like illness & the death of the elderly as part of life.

A lot of people i know nowadays seem to dissolve into an extended state of utterly broken bereavement after their frail parent aged 90+ dies. It is of course very sad but people seem to expect we can live forever and avoid ever getting bugs & viruses.

Children/teens seem to have far poorer mental health in particular. All this anxiety just would have been ignored. I sometimes wonder if by overacknowledging it we affirm it unhelpfully and also send an unconscious message to young people that we agree that a) there is a reason to be anxious and b) we don't trust/believe they can cope.