Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the people have a romanticised view of the last few generations?

212 replies

safari111 · 20/12/2023 21:19

Whenever I bring up my mental health with my dad or husband, especially since having kids, instead of support or understanding I receive a speech on how my grandma or my husband's grandma "coped with so much, had so little, and were SO HAPPY. Everyone was happy, blah blah blah" that's all I get. That no one had the mental health issues and neurological problems that people have today and all of that. It enrages me that 1. My mental health is invalidated. 2. Everyone else's mental health problems are invalidated and 3. Everyone romanticises the fact that people were absolutely happier a generation or 2 ago, despite poverty, war, poor health etc.

What are your thoughts on this? Have you experienced similar?

OP posts:
safari111 · 21/12/2023 15:53

@NeverDropYourMooncup I hadn't heard about that but will definitely look into that history now!

OP posts:
NeverDropYourMooncup · 21/12/2023 15:40

Don't forget about Barnados - plenty of children, particularly boys, would be given to them around the ages of 3-5 and sometimes brought back after another baby had come, sometimes only when an older sibling got a job/married and took them on, if at all. Two exes' fathers, completely different location, completely different lives socially, both dropped them off one day and effectively ran away whilst they were distracted with a toy. One went on to do exactly the same to their son who had undiagnosed ADHD, only with boarding school instead. Another ex's mother put her son into boarding school at six and didn't have him back until he left at 16 when her inheritance from his father ran out, but as she was very wealthy, that was seen as OK.

Then there were far more adoptions and children unofficially adopted or fostered by relatives, not necessarily even knowing what had happened or why - being told 'they're dead' was common if they knew the person they were with wasn't their mother or father. Often this was when they weren't, they were living a few miles away.

Ahwhatthehell · 21/12/2023 14:50

Different times, different pressures.
It’s not any easier now than it was back then. Just different.

LonelynSad · 21/12/2023 14:28

XmasPartyhat · 20/12/2023 22:00

I have an autistic child. My own mother made comments about there being a lot of autism about these days (like it was the cold) and that people didn't have it in her day. When my child was diagnosed she told me that was a shame.

My mum has never been diagnosed with anything. But she has glaringly obvious traits of autism and OCD. Anxiety and trying to control situations. Meltdowns when she doesn't get her way or things don't go as she expected. Ritualistic hand washing, locking and unlocking doors and flicking light switches. The empathy and emotional intelligence of a shoe.

People might not have been diagnosed in her day. But she is still probably autistic.

Yep they most definitely had it, they were just labelled the naughty kid or the weird one

SequentialAnalyst · 21/12/2023 14:10

Surely there was a lot of school avoidance? It was probably quite easy to set off to school, even register, but then bunk off?

Charlingspont · 21/12/2023 12:43

You're right @XmasPartyhat and @Lalalanding - I do think that for some children, making them remain in some form of education till they're 18 now (and thus allowing the government to 'massage'the unemployment figures of course) is very detrimental to some children, not just those who don't cope with an educational environment. There are those who really need to be able to leave home but can't because they don't have a job that could support them so they have to stay in (at the very least) unpleasant situations at home.

Lalalanding · 21/12/2023 12:12

stepintochristmas1 · 21/12/2023 11:36

I really don't think society is more tolerant of mental illness nowadays . Seen it so much on here .People can't get away fast enough from friends/family with mental illness . Society wouldn't care that much if we brought asylums back .

People do run a mile from other people’s problems. I think some people are busy dealing with their own though. Life is rarely easy for anyone and when it is difficult times are always possible.

CoffeeCantata · 21/12/2023 11:42

I don't think anyone sees the past as 'rose-tinted', do they, unless they know absolutely nothing of history? Even in almost living memory there has been a world war, and at least 4 genocides (that we know about) etc???

But whether people were tougher, more resilient, less whiney...that's an interesting question. Of course their expectations of life were generally much lower than ours - they were contented with smaller, simpler things, I think - a healthy attitude and one which isn't doomed to lead to disappointment.

I'm as anti-war as any sensible person but I did think, when I saw the young Ukrainian men rushing to enlist and defend their country - how many of the UK population would do that now? I just couldn't imagine it. Of course it's utterly horrible - but I think it's something that marks the current generation from past ones - for better or worse*. I hate to think of what happened to those brave young people.

I think many of us are spoiled now and behave like children. The number of threads on MN with people wailing that they haven't got the present they wanted, that someone has 'offended' them, that they can't deal with envy of others who have more holidays/better car/bigger house. That really depresses me - for God's sake, people gave their lives 2 or 3 generations ago - sometimes we need to get a grip.

*I'm not talking about aggression here - I'm talking about a situation where your country is under an existential threat, as in Ukraine.

stepintochristmas1 · 21/12/2023 11:36

I really don't think society is more tolerant of mental illness nowadays . Seen it so much on here .People can't get away fast enough from friends/family with mental illness . Society wouldn't care that much if we brought asylums back .

Partypop · 21/12/2023 11:28

I definitely think that the past wasn’t as rose tinted as people think, and agree that people still suffered with mental illness but just didn’t talk about it. However, I think it’s more the narrative that’s forced down our throat about how we are so lucky as we now have all this technology, we are so liberal, everyone has all these rights, medical advance, we have so much stuff, religion is on its way out, etc etc…we are expected to believe that all this means life nowadays is GREAT and so much better than the old days. This simply isn’t true…life is as shit for most people, maybe even worse, than before 🤷‍♀️

CherryBlossom321 · 21/12/2023 11:25

They weren’t happier, they were repressed. Children were invalidated and shamed for showing emotion, and “discipline” came in the form of physical violence.

Lalalanding · 21/12/2023 11:22

Charlingspont · 21/12/2023 11:02

I think the reason there wasn't so much school avoidance was because children were frightened of their parents. I look back, and again, my mother was at home, but there is no way I'd have been able to not go to school. She's have hit me, for a start, so it's just a very different way now.

Most kids in my parents generation never went to secondary school at all. School refusal wasn’t a thing because school wasn’t a thing.

XmasPartyhat · 21/12/2023 11:19

Charlingspont · 21/12/2023 11:02

I think the reason there wasn't so much school avoidance was because children were frightened of their parents. I look back, and again, my mother was at home, but there is no way I'd have been able to not go to school. She's have hit me, for a start, so it's just a very different way now.

Children also weren't forced to go to school like they are now! Compulsory school age was 16 when I was in school. In my parents day it was 14.

School was also different in my parents age. My dad went to a grammar school which was more like what school is now. My mum went to a comprehensive which basically taught the boys vocational skills for trades while the girls learned how to type and stuff like sewing etc. Children who weren't academically inclined weren't forced into sitting in maths and English classes. There is no place nowadays for children or adults who don't fall nicely into academic boxes like there was a generation or two a go. There are less well paid manual jobs for those who don't have academic qualifications.

Charlingspont · 21/12/2023 11:02

ShippingNews · 21/12/2023 04:29

This is true. I grew up in the 60's - my parents lived through the Blitz in London and had to go and identify neighbors who had been killed in their houses overnight. Mum said they really didn't expect to survive - every day was a blessing . They didn't have time to feel sorry for themselves.

Mum had a stillborn baby during the War, and like other comments here, she was told she had time to have more babies and she should just move on. Which she did - she only told me about it once when I was pregnant.

Something I notice now which was unknown when I was growing up , was "school avoidance" . We went to school and that was that - big classes, my school photos show about 40 kids in a class. I never knew of kids getting to avoid school or be home schooled, even though everyone's mother was at home . It just didn't happen. You were expected to get on with it .

I don't think we have rose coloured glasses on about the past - it wasn't all sweetness and light - but people really were expected to get on with life.

I think the reason there wasn't so much school avoidance was because children were frightened of their parents. I look back, and again, my mother was at home, but there is no way I'd have been able to not go to school. She's have hit me, for a start, so it's just a very different way now.

Tatumm · 21/12/2023 10:29

Every era has its challenges and rewards. Life is not static - attitudes change.

Echobelly · 21/12/2023 10:28

It's complicated really. In some ways I think society worked better when there was someone at home, more sense of community, someone to look after people who were sick or discharged from hospital, even if they were a neighbour and not family. However, that burden fell entirely on women and if that wasn't the life a woman wanted it would have been miserable and frustrating and all that was on offer. But maybe we could have that again if there were some kind of basic income so people, male or female, could stay home if they needed to.

There are benefits to the 'stiff upper lip' but also costs in the longer run.

Ohnonoohoh · 21/12/2023 10:24

My sister works in a care home and talks about this sort of thing and it really winds me up

"Bill and Dorris have been together for 60 years and their such an inspiration"

No their not, Dorris came from a time where divorce was a scandal, she came from a time where she had to put up and shut up. I bet she was miserable most of the time

MistyMountainTops · 21/12/2023 10:21

Regarding young people the world has changed so much though with the introduction of technology.
I was raised in a completely different age to how my own children are being raised, it makes a massive difference. You can't really compare as every generation faces it's own challenges, maybe if we had been brought up now our MH would be different. We are now living in such a totally unnatural and artificial way, miles away from our natural state it's no wonder our younger generation are struggling. We shouldn't be shaming them or viewing them as non resilient when effectively we have created many of the problems they face.

safari111 · 21/12/2023 10:19

@endlessdarkness Definitely agree with your points, and I do think that you hit the nail on the head with things finally catching up with me. I found it very difficult to make the appointment, which I've been waiting a month for, and after a heated discussion with my husband last night* I very nearly canceled my appointment and thought I am clearly not very resilient and need to keep chugging along. But actually, no. Not this time. It's affecting my parenting now, and I need to be a stable mum to give my kids the best chance in life.

*We have since made up.

OP posts:
endlessdarkness · 21/12/2023 10:10

safari111 · 21/12/2023 09:57

Firstly, thank you all for your responses. I'm sorry to hear of all the tragic stories that people have brought up.

From what I gather, the summary of thoughts are:

  1. MH issues were not talked about/swept under the rug. Absolutely can see the truth in this as even in this day and age I find it hard to talk about. I've also seen it in my own family.
  2. Community/religion played a part in keeping peoples' spirits up. And we have definitely drifted away from this nowadays.
  3. People were less idle, so physical activity and being outdoors helped. The recommendation to exercise and spend time in nature for good health remains relevant.
  4. Expectations were lower. I do think social media and capitalism have a role in this. How can you miss what you never had and don't know about either?

There are a lot of great points. In my personal circumstance, the 2 major life-changing events in my life were my mum suddenly dying the week I turned 18, and my first pregnancy ending in miscarriage.

I remember the night she died, my dad was in complete shock, and asked me if I was going to school the next day. Multiple times he threatened to jump off the roof. But there was no talking about our loss, good memories, or shared grief. We all isolated ourselves in our own method of grieving and somehow came out the other side.

There are many other painful things that happened in my life, but I have to say that I cracked on with things. I sat my A-levels, went to university, and achieved a lot. However, with 2 small children, a lack of sleep, a lack of support, I finally am at a point where I genuinely worry I might snap. I no longer feel like I can keep going without addressing past trauma. It feels like my body is stopping me from functioning normally. So, personally, I do feel that after 13 years I do need to talk to a GP in the hope I can reset. Lest I buy a bigger rug.....

It would not be unusual for it to catch up with you later if you haven't had the chance to process it properly before. Talking to your GP and getting some counselling might be really helpful. I think having our own children can often bring these things to the fore too.

Community was a mixed thing. There were good people, bullies, toxic people, all manner of people in the community. As far as family, there was more sense of duty, people were less likely to stand up against interfering parents, going NC was less likely. These may be good or bad things, depending on your point of view. But people were less isolated. If you were home with young children probably others in your immediate area were too. Communities of mothers have become more fragmented in that way.

safari111 · 21/12/2023 10:02

@Riversofthesea @Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter this made me laugh. Have you seen the Monty Python sketch which says something similar? It's worth a watch, in fact I think everyone on this thread should watch it 😆 I'll try to link it.

Four Yorkshiremen- Monty Python

Four Yorkshiremen discuss "the bad old days" and how young people don't properly appreciate what their elders had to go through. Hilarious.

https://youtu.be/ue7wM0QC5LE?feature=shared

OP posts:
zingally · 21/12/2023 10:01

People were just expected to put up or shut up. Those that couldn't, quickly got put into asylums or workhouses.

But there was also more of a sense of community back then. People helped each other with everyday life, more than they do now, and perhaps there was more of a sense of "we'll get through it together."

safari111 · 21/12/2023 09:57

Firstly, thank you all for your responses. I'm sorry to hear of all the tragic stories that people have brought up.

From what I gather, the summary of thoughts are:

  1. MH issues were not talked about/swept under the rug. Absolutely can see the truth in this as even in this day and age I find it hard to talk about. I've also seen it in my own family.
  2. Community/religion played a part in keeping peoples' spirits up. And we have definitely drifted away from this nowadays.
  3. People were less idle, so physical activity and being outdoors helped. The recommendation to exercise and spend time in nature for good health remains relevant.
  4. Expectations were lower. I do think social media and capitalism have a role in this. How can you miss what you never had and don't know about either?

There are a lot of great points. In my personal circumstance, the 2 major life-changing events in my life were my mum suddenly dying the week I turned 18, and my first pregnancy ending in miscarriage.

I remember the night she died, my dad was in complete shock, and asked me if I was going to school the next day. Multiple times he threatened to jump off the roof. But there was no talking about our loss, good memories, or shared grief. We all isolated ourselves in our own method of grieving and somehow came out the other side.

There are many other painful things that happened in my life, but I have to say that I cracked on with things. I sat my A-levels, went to university, and achieved a lot. However, with 2 small children, a lack of sleep, a lack of support, I finally am at a point where I genuinely worry I might snap. I no longer feel like I can keep going without addressing past trauma. It feels like my body is stopping me from functioning normally. So, personally, I do feel that after 13 years I do need to talk to a GP in the hope I can reset. Lest I buy a bigger rug.....

OP posts:
endlessdarkness · 21/12/2023 09:35

Lovepeaceunderstanding · 21/12/2023 09:15

@endlessdarkness , your username struck me. 😔
My mother also had a friend who suffered with her mental health, her best friend and a lovely soul. She used to have electro convulsive therapy, I truly hope they don’t do that to people anymore.
I was in no way mollycoddled by my parents and to be honest I often used their parenting style to help form my own style of parenting in so far as I made sure I was quite different. I fear that things may have swung too far in the other direction now and that we have a lot of people who lack resilience.
Merry Christmas. X

I hear you about deliberately choosing to parent very differently. I do think it might have swung a bit far in the opposite direction now as sometimes having to handle things (when appropriate, of course) builds confidence and so resilience. But maybe this is a reaction to the tough parenting of the past and it will balance out more in future?

They do still use ECT but not as often. It does have a place but should definitely be a last resort, in my opinion.

I should probably change my username, it's not meant to be depressing. :-)

threecupsofteaminimum · 21/12/2023 09:27

Brilliant thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread