Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the people have a romanticised view of the last few generations?

212 replies

safari111 · 20/12/2023 21:19

Whenever I bring up my mental health with my dad or husband, especially since having kids, instead of support or understanding I receive a speech on how my grandma or my husband's grandma "coped with so much, had so little, and were SO HAPPY. Everyone was happy, blah blah blah" that's all I get. That no one had the mental health issues and neurological problems that people have today and all of that. It enrages me that 1. My mental health is invalidated. 2. Everyone else's mental health problems are invalidated and 3. Everyone romanticises the fact that people were absolutely happier a generation or 2 ago, despite poverty, war, poor health etc.

What are your thoughts on this? Have you experienced similar?

OP posts:
NeverDropYourMooncup · 30/12/2023 11:02

Tacotortoise · 30/12/2023 10:49

People having multiple children with multiple partners is as old as time. Today we have divorce, previously parents died. This was not less stressful.

Or just walked away to marry somebody else without bothering with that tricky divorce part. Paper records weren't easily linked up, so if a man decided to walk out on wife and children, move a few miles away and marry somebody else, not even bothering to have a false name, there was no way of finding them unless a relative actually spotted them, found out where they were living and who they were with and reported a bigamous marriage.

My half siblings were contacted by their father's 'first' (ie, only legal) wife a couple of years ago. Their mother not only has no idea that she was never legally married, she had been receiving pension/benefits based upon his contributions as a widow since the 70s - so even the State didn't have a clue.

Naptrappedmummy · 30/12/2023 10:53

Lalalanding · 21/12/2023 11:22

Most kids in my parents generation never went to secondary school at all. School refusal wasn’t a thing because school wasn’t a thing.

They finished school at 10/11 did they? Funny because compulsory leaving age in 1947 was 15.

Savedpassword · 30/12/2023 10:53

Tacotortoise · 30/12/2023 10:49

People having multiple children with multiple partners is as old as time. Today we have divorce, previously parents died. This was not less stressful.

I’d argue that it’s MUCH more of an issue now than it was 30 years ago. Even within my own extended family, there are multiple children with multiple half siblings from both parents. Complex, acrimonious relationships with damaged, insecure kids caught in the middle.

Tacotortoise · 30/12/2023 10:49

People having multiple children with multiple partners is as old as time. Today we have divorce, previously parents died. This was not less stressful.

SunnieShine · 30/12/2023 10:47

WandaWonder · 20/12/2023 21:30

I think people these days spend too much time overthinking and over complicating every aspect of everything, not sure it is any better these days

Spot on.

Savedpassword · 30/12/2023 10:41

Lack of resilience, social media pressures, ‘being triggered’, extreme reactions to ‘normal’ day to day inconveniences, the rush to medicalise ‘normal’ emotions and behaviours,significant lack of family and social support when raising children, people having multiple children with multiple partners leading to children with attachment issues.
These are ‘modern’ issues. If stating that they didn’t have the same impact on society 20 or 30 years ago means I have a ‘romanticised view’ then guilty as charged.

CeciledeVolangesdeNouveau · 30/12/2023 10:35

It’s possible that there are similar levels of stress generation to generation and actually culture to culture. The Japanese language has a word for working yourself to death, for example. We find different ways of sorting it out and some are more sustainable than others. For every stiff-upper-lipped Blitz baby there was someone locked up in an asylum for thirty years or having their brain bisected with an ice pick.

Tacotortoise · 30/12/2023 10:29

Anybody who has read Jane Austen knows how much pressure there was on girls to maximise their looks and catch a husband so as not to be left "on the shelf" - which was actually a grim prospect for a woman unless she was independently wealthy.

Riverlee · 30/12/2023 10:10

“There was no pressure to look like a supermodel. You weren’t expected to be a ‘better’ version of yourself like young girls are now. You accepted yourself and your flaws. You weren’t expected to have a bigger house or car or holidays. Now there’s so much pressure to achieve more.”

Not exactly true. “Death of a Salesman” written by Arthur Miller in 1949 is basically about ‘The American Dream’ and having the best things.

Tacotortoise · 30/12/2023 09:58

Menomeno · 30/12/2023 08:47

I don't think that young people ‘lack resilience’ as such, I believe that they’re actually mega-overwhelmed and it’s easy to see why.

Back in the day, people had no choices. They’d leave school and boys would follow their Dads down the pit, into the shipyard or whatever. Girls would go into service until they became housewives. Everyone knew their role from day dot, and there was no pressure to achieve any more than that. There was an acceptance that that was your ‘station’ in life.

Now we have far more choices on every front, and although having choices and agency is a good thing, there is a price to be paid for it. Even something as simple as shopping can be overwhelming. In the old days if you needed to buy something, there was only one type of it in the shop. Now we’re there for ages comparing price per 100g/salt content/expiry dates etc. The choice is overwhelming at times and it can be really stressful.

There was no pressure to look like a supermodel. You weren’t expected to be a ‘better’ version of yourself like young girls are now. You accepted yourself and your flaws. You weren’t expected to have a bigger house or car or holidays. Now there’s so much pressure to achieve more.

Young people are constantly stimulated and self-medicate with dopamine hits from constant scrolling,watching videos, posting on SM, checking messages, rolling news… I suspect most of them don’t know how to just “be”, which is utterly detrimental to MH.

I’ve waffled a bit but my point is that having choices can come at a massive price and I’m very grateful that I grew up before the internet existed.

I think you are grossly misunderstanding the era if you think these sorts of life were stress free or less stressful.

endlessdarkness · 30/12/2023 09:53

Menomeno · 30/12/2023 08:47

I don't think that young people ‘lack resilience’ as such, I believe that they’re actually mega-overwhelmed and it’s easy to see why.

Back in the day, people had no choices. They’d leave school and boys would follow their Dads down the pit, into the shipyard or whatever. Girls would go into service until they became housewives. Everyone knew their role from day dot, and there was no pressure to achieve any more than that. There was an acceptance that that was your ‘station’ in life.

Now we have far more choices on every front, and although having choices and agency is a good thing, there is a price to be paid for it. Even something as simple as shopping can be overwhelming. In the old days if you needed to buy something, there was only one type of it in the shop. Now we’re there for ages comparing price per 100g/salt content/expiry dates etc. The choice is overwhelming at times and it can be really stressful.

There was no pressure to look like a supermodel. You weren’t expected to be a ‘better’ version of yourself like young girls are now. You accepted yourself and your flaws. You weren’t expected to have a bigger house or car or holidays. Now there’s so much pressure to achieve more.

Young people are constantly stimulated and self-medicate with dopamine hits from constant scrolling,watching videos, posting on SM, checking messages, rolling news… I suspect most of them don’t know how to just “be”, which is utterly detrimental to MH.

I’ve waffled a bit but my point is that having choices can come at a massive price and I’m very grateful that I grew up before the internet existed.

What, 150 years ago?

Tumbleweed101 · 30/12/2023 09:08

I think the media push is for people to expect to be happy all the time and be constantly analysing why they might not be happy rather than just accepting that life can be boring and hard work at times and have traumatic phases. When bad things happen they analyse rather than move on, keeping them stuck going over and over it.

As a society we are exposed to a lot more information though the internet and see much more other other people’s lives meaning we compare ourselves against unrealistic benchmarks. The likely hood of me ever owning a home and earning over £30k is low and yet I’m wanting home makeovers and villas abroad because that’s what others have. Therefore I couldn’t possibly be happy (for example).

Menomeno · 30/12/2023 08:47

I don't think that young people ‘lack resilience’ as such, I believe that they’re actually mega-overwhelmed and it’s easy to see why.

Back in the day, people had no choices. They’d leave school and boys would follow their Dads down the pit, into the shipyard or whatever. Girls would go into service until they became housewives. Everyone knew their role from day dot, and there was no pressure to achieve any more than that. There was an acceptance that that was your ‘station’ in life.

Now we have far more choices on every front, and although having choices and agency is a good thing, there is a price to be paid for it. Even something as simple as shopping can be overwhelming. In the old days if you needed to buy something, there was only one type of it in the shop. Now we’re there for ages comparing price per 100g/salt content/expiry dates etc. The choice is overwhelming at times and it can be really stressful.

There was no pressure to look like a supermodel. You weren’t expected to be a ‘better’ version of yourself like young girls are now. You accepted yourself and your flaws. You weren’t expected to have a bigger house or car or holidays. Now there’s so much pressure to achieve more.

Young people are constantly stimulated and self-medicate with dopamine hits from constant scrolling,watching videos, posting on SM, checking messages, rolling news… I suspect most of them don’t know how to just “be”, which is utterly detrimental to MH.

I’ve waffled a bit but my point is that having choices can come at a massive price and I’m very grateful that I grew up before the internet existed.

SheerLucks · 23/12/2023 06:34

shearwater2 · 23/12/2023 05:39

YANBU. There is so much generational trauma, grief and sadness from wars, poverty, lack of/missed opportunity, issues created by socisl conservatism, sexism, homophobia etc in the 20th century and people not dealing with things at the time. There were so many secrets, lies, and things brushed under the carpet in the past. Lots of writers have made their careers writing novels about it! I think my generation (X) used/s drink, drugs, smoking, and comfort eating to get over a lot of things rather than confront their feelings. I hope younger generations can be more emotionally aware and in tune with their minds and bodies and that society continues to be more open minded and tolerant.

I agree with this.

shearwater2 · 23/12/2023 05:39

YANBU. There is so much generational trauma, grief and sadness from wars, poverty, lack of/missed opportunity, issues created by socisl conservatism, sexism, homophobia etc in the 20th century and people not dealing with things at the time. There were so many secrets, lies, and things brushed under the carpet in the past. Lots of writers have made their careers writing novels about it! I think my generation (X) used/s drink, drugs, smoking, and comfort eating to get over a lot of things rather than confront their feelings. I hope younger generations can be more emotionally aware and in tune with their minds and bodies and that society continues to be more open minded and tolerant.

CasperGutman · 23/12/2023 05:28

I haven't come across the idea that everyone was happier, no. That life was tough and they got little help but what they could give each other, yes.

But if we're talking war, grinding poverty etc. then that's not the generation above mine, that's my grandparents (sealed below decks on the Arctic convoys) or, to a greater extent, my great grandparents (one with health never right after the 'Spanish' flu but with no NHS and no money for doctors; one taking his own life ten years after returning from the trenches, unable to cope with the memories of what he'd seen).

mantyzer · 23/12/2023 03:25

Its interesting that everyone talks about the past as pushing down feelings. But I think in the modern world the acceptable range of behaviour is now much narrower than in the past. There used to be more freedom to be a bit odd.

Its also interesting people talking about community in the past as a support. This could be true. But there was also a lot of gossip and judgement. So you might have neighbours willing to babysit for free, but they would also judge your mothering and tell you if they thought you were doing something wrong.

SequentialAnalyst · 23/12/2023 02:06

@endlessdarkness
Because of the system of state schools that segregated state pupils by "intelligence" i.e. how they did in the 11+ , and taught them according to how they were expected to fit in in the future. Once in a Secondary Modern you had little chance to shine academically. The girls did typing as one of their courses - fair enough, but I can imagine many pupils were disenchanted with their lot. But it's mainly speculation, I admit.

Then the comprehensive model came in, and various schools were amalgamated, often operating on more than one site, unsurprisingly. But by then I was in Higher Education.

My point was not about public schools vs state schools, but about Grammar schools vs Secondary Mods. I spoke about myself to indicate that I was selected out of the state system, at the expense of the Local Authority, and therefore had no direct experience of being in state school at secondary level.

Riversofthesea · 22/12/2023 22:39

safari111 · 22/12/2023 13:56

@alwaysmovingforwards I think this is an interesting point. You also sometimes hear of people who come from privileged backgrounds feel almost resentful to have life handed to them on a silver platter. You can lose touch with reality when you can't understand the true value of things. I think that sometimes a bit of suffering and hard work makes you feel greater satisfaction in what you achieve and the relationships that you have.

I think hard work results in satisfaction (as long as people are paid correctly) but suffering never leads to satisfaction in my opinion. At best it can lead to relief once suffering has past.

Too much suffering and too much hard work people, not makes people.

endlessdarkness · 22/12/2023 20:58

SequentialAnalyst · 22/12/2023 12:59

Well, I commuted to school in the 1960s by train - won a scholarship through 11+. But loads of people went to their local Secondary Modern School, having failed to make the 11+ grade for a local Grammar. I can imagine many of them being less than keen on school, and bunking off, but perhaps I am wrong?

I'm not sure what your point is? I don't see why private or public schooling makes people more or less likely to like school or bunk off? Bunking off was uncommon and you'd probably get caught from what I know. You're either inclined to do it or not.

safari111 · 22/12/2023 14:00

@Partypop I see.. so perhaps not the idea of suffering itself, but the faith that there is something bigger and better waiting ?
I think religion can have a big part in being part of a community - which I think is important to survive and thrive. Nowadays, as many have mentioned, we live lives which are a lot more scattered, isolated or online.

OP posts:
safari111 · 22/12/2023 13:56

@alwaysmovingforwards I think this is an interesting point. You also sometimes hear of people who come from privileged backgrounds feel almost resentful to have life handed to them on a silver platter. You can lose touch with reality when you can't understand the true value of things. I think that sometimes a bit of suffering and hard work makes you feel greater satisfaction in what you achieve and the relationships that you have.

OP posts:
SequentialAnalyst · 22/12/2023 12:59

endlessdarkness · 21/12/2023 21:54

Not really. You might have a day or two bunking off in your high school days (few did) but your parents would get a call because every class had a book that went around. My brother was caught out because they noticed the names that were absent were part of the same friendship group.

Well, I commuted to school in the 1960s by train - won a scholarship through 11+. But loads of people went to their local Secondary Modern School, having failed to make the 11+ grade for a local Grammar. I can imagine many of them being less than keen on school, and bunking off, but perhaps I am wrong?

alwaysmovingforwards · 22/12/2023 10:09

WandaWonder · 20/12/2023 21:30

I think people these days spend too much time overthinking and over complicating every aspect of everything, not sure it is any better these days

I agree.
Also, I think a lot of it is the start point.
If you consider at the start that life is hard and will be tough, you'll cherish and appreciate the small wins and progress you make.

If you start from a vision of perfection / entitlement, then most days won't live up to your expectations and people then get negative and disappointed over time. Which I think is the era we're living in now.

Partypop · 22/12/2023 09:28

@safari111 that’s interesting about faith…I alluded to it in my post, that in modern times there is the narrative that we are all ‘enlightened’ and the world is a better place with the decline of religion (in the west anyway), but I don’t think that’s true. I’m Christian and most don’t believe that we will get ‘rewarded’ for suffering, as it’s random…but I think faith must have helped in the past (and still helps me now) as you are aware that life on earth is only fleeting and there is better to come. Also suffering gives you the opportunity to help others, also God suffered on tje cross, so to some suffering somehow makes us feel closer to Him. So I think in the past, more people of genuine faith probably did equal a generally happier society…

Swipe left for the next trending thread