Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the people have a romanticised view of the last few generations?

212 replies

safari111 · 20/12/2023 21:19

Whenever I bring up my mental health with my dad or husband, especially since having kids, instead of support or understanding I receive a speech on how my grandma or my husband's grandma "coped with so much, had so little, and were SO HAPPY. Everyone was happy, blah blah blah" that's all I get. That no one had the mental health issues and neurological problems that people have today and all of that. It enrages me that 1. My mental health is invalidated. 2. Everyone else's mental health problems are invalidated and 3. Everyone romanticises the fact that people were absolutely happier a generation or 2 ago, despite poverty, war, poor health etc.

What are your thoughts on this? Have you experienced similar?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ToWhitToWhoo · 01/01/2024 16:36

mantyzer · 01/01/2024 13:27

@ToWhitToWhoo so when children were still working in factories and sleeping on the streets.
The quote is obviously taken out of context.

The book, and the quotes, were about schoolchildren (education was then compulsory until the age of 12), not teenagers, who were indeed mostly already working; and were about children living with their parents, not homeless orphans or workhouse children. It is unlikely that the comments about children being given 'the feeling that everything must be arranged for their enjoyment' or parents allowing them to live 'in complete disregard of the claims of others and to consider themselves of paramount importance' referred to homeless street children or even to 13-year-old factory workers and farm labourers.

But yes, whatever the problems of modern life, things are much better now for most children than they were in 1908- not to mention that many of the boys were soon to be cannon fodder.

zigggyzaggy · 01/01/2024 13:39

Well, one thing that never changes is how money makes all the difference.

My parents are in their 90s. Listening to my mum, you would think that life was so much better then but she lived in a big house with several acres, horses, staff etc. Whereas my dad had 5 siblings in a 2 bed terrace and an out of work dad because he had emphysema from working in a factory.

mantyzer · 01/01/2024 13:27

@ToWhitToWhoo so when children were still working in factories and sleeping on the streets.
The quote is obviously taken out of context.

ToWhitToWhoo · 31/12/2023 15:36

The harmful effects of the hurry and strain of modern life'; 'The present tendency to give children the feeling that everything must be arranged for their enjoyment'; 'Many parents...allow them to live in complete disregard of the claims of others and to consider themselves of paramount importance'; 'There is far too much sentimentality...as regards corporal punishment. The consequence is the hooliganism and bad behaviour so frequently seen'. Tut, tut, tut, the youth of today! ...By the way, all these quotations come from M.E. Sadler: 'Moral Instruction and Training in Schools: Report of an International Inquiry'. Publication date: 1908.

ToWhitToWhoo · 31/12/2023 14:15

Doone22 · 30/12/2023 22:14

Latest science supports putting a brave face on it/stiff upper lip as actually being better for your mental health after all.

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/health/mental-health-depression-negative-thoughts-b2415200.html

So maybe they're right.

The study is about techniques for suppressing anxious thoughts about possible bad things that could happen, not about putting a 'brave face' on painful experiences that are already happening.

In any case, the real point of what's been said on the thread is not so much about whether people are helped more by talking about their traumas or by avoiding talking about them, but about whether we have a misleading idea that older generations didn't have the traumas because they didn't talk about them. Often they did, and showed the effects in other ways than verbally.

2024name · 31/12/2023 11:43

@Menomeno I agree with you. However, it seems like there a NO services, not even bad ones, available for some mental illnesses today.

Menomeno · 31/12/2023 09:30

2024name · 31/12/2023 08:01

I think there was more help for MH difficulties forty or fifty years ago than there is now. It was not better help, and hospitalisation was used too frequently, but there was more likelihood of some intervention at that time. Now, although people understand more about mental illness, services are so stretched and underfunded that there is little professional help available when it is needed.

I disagree. My DM spent half my childhood in psychiatric units. Apart from being chemically coshed and electrocuted she received no treatment, certainly no form of talking therapy. People were terrified to admit to having MH problems because this was the type of barbarism that was called ‘treatment’. People talk about there having been a stigma in the old days, but it went far beyond stigma. Women with post natal illness could be locked up for life. It’s easy to see why the majority of people would keep their mouths shut and suffer in silence.

2024name · 31/12/2023 08:01

I think there was more help for MH difficulties forty or fifty years ago than there is now. It was not better help, and hospitalisation was used too frequently, but there was more likelihood of some intervention at that time. Now, although people understand more about mental illness, services are so stretched and underfunded that there is little professional help available when it is needed.

NorthernLights5 · 31/12/2023 07:04

I think older generations had to deal with a lot more as society has changed so much. People expect a lot more now I guess. I do think people look at life previously with rose tinted glasses. I'm just a carer and looked after a lovely lady. She told me about meeting a man at a dance..."he danced into my life and danced right back out". She had (and breastfed) the baby for 6 months but her father had left. So there was only her and her mother to make ends meet. She had to give her baby up. I think people now don't appreciate how lucky they are for the most part.

BertieBotts · 31/12/2023 06:23

One study does not "the latest science" make, but also, that study is referring specifically to anxious thoughts about things that might never happen, not traumatic events which have happened. It also only looked at effects over 3 months. It probably is useful for thoughts triggered by anxiety, but more research would be needed on the technique.

LoreleiG · 30/12/2023 13:36

My grandparents left school by 14 at the very latest and went to work in a factory or in service. My mum is only 75. That is not really ‘attending secondary school’ in my book. My Gran was raised a son who became a professor, but had to herself work in a cotton mill, the lack of choice about which must by anyone’s standards have been a bit crap.

CeciledeVolangesdeNouveau · 30/12/2023 13:31

Monty Python?

malificent7 · 30/12/2023 13:12

This thread reminds me of that comedy sketch...who was it? Harry Enfield?

" stale bread for breakfast?! You were lucky ....In my day we only ate once a year on Christmas day and then it was a lump of coal. "

Naptrappedmummy · 30/12/2023 12:56

daliesque · 30/12/2023 12:53

That’s Ireland which I expect had different rules. I’m just pointing out the majority of children did not leave school by 10 or 11 a few generations ago in the U.K.

I think they did/do. I wasn't arguing, just throwing in an anecdote about my Irish grandfather. My Italian grandfather probably left school at a similar age, but I never really knew him as he died when I was young.

The compulsory leaving age in the U.K. in 1947 was 15. Therefore most children at this time, did not leave school at 10 or 11, in the U.K.

daliesque · 30/12/2023 12:53

That’s Ireland which I expect had different rules. I’m just pointing out the majority of children did not leave school by 10 or 11 a few generations ago in the U.K.

I think they did/do. I wasn't arguing, just throwing in an anecdote about my Irish grandfather. My Italian grandfather probably left school at a similar age, but I never really knew him as he died when I was young.

Naptrappedmummy · 30/12/2023 12:41

Menomeno · 30/12/2023 12:22

Eh? I never once said life then was stress free back then??? Of course it was stressful, monotonous, hard work, miserable, depressing; not to mention more risky to health! But there wasn’t the added pressure to do anything more than just exist. There was less to stimulate then, and less to overwhelm even though life would have been more difficult overall. My point was that while people accuse today’s youngsters of being snowflakes and lacking resilience, I can understand why so many suffer with MH problems. 🤷🏻‍♀️

I agree. I think our efforts to mitigate every risk in life for young people and convince them they’re owed a life full of excitement and fulfilment has massively backfired. I’m continually astonished at the level of involvement posters have in the lives of their older children. Benign neglect was fantastic - it gave older children and young people a chance to push boundaries, learn lessons, and gain independence. Continually micromanaging children, entertaining their childish tantrums and telling them there is danger round every corner has given them all anxiety complexes. Let them be.

Menomeno · 30/12/2023 12:22

Tacotortoise · 30/12/2023 09:58

I think you are grossly misunderstanding the era if you think these sorts of life were stress free or less stressful.

Eh? I never once said life then was stress free back then??? Of course it was stressful, monotonous, hard work, miserable, depressing; not to mention more risky to health! But there wasn’t the added pressure to do anything more than just exist. There was less to stimulate then, and less to overwhelm even though life would have been more difficult overall. My point was that while people accuse today’s youngsters of being snowflakes and lacking resilience, I can understand why so many suffer with MH problems. 🤷🏻‍♀️

Naptrappedmummy · 30/12/2023 12:13

In fact older than 105 - more like 115 if they left school at 10 by 1918 at the latest. So Pp would likely be 90 plus. Odds of that?

Naptrappedmummy · 30/12/2023 12:09

NeverDropYourMooncup · 30/12/2023 11:03

Depends upon that PP's parents' age. It was 12 (and not exactly enforced) until 1918.

Unless they are or would be 105 by now it’s unlikely they and everyone they knew left school at 10 or 11. Bit of convenient fiction going on there I think.

Naptrappedmummy · 30/12/2023 12:08

daliesque · 30/12/2023 11:58

They finished school at 10/11 did they? Funny because compulsory leaving age in 1947 was 15

My Irish grandfather left school at 12, worked on the family farm for a year, hated it and then left home on his 14th birthday, came to England joined the army by lying about his age. By the time he was "legal" to leave school he had transferred to the RAF and was shipped out to fight the Germans.

That’s Ireland which I expect had different rules. I’m just pointing out the majority of children did not leave school by 10 or 11 a few generations ago in the U.K.

daliesque · 30/12/2023 11:58

They finished school at 10/11 did they? Funny because compulsory leaving age in 1947 was 15

My Irish grandfather left school at 12, worked on the family farm for a year, hated it and then left home on his 14th birthday, came to England joined the army by lying about his age. By the time he was "legal" to leave school he had transferred to the RAF and was shipped out to fight the Germans.

daliesque · 30/12/2023 11:44

The 80s were very different if you grew up in a mining town (or Scotland or a northern city) than if you were in the south east making 'loadsamoney'.

The 80s were extremely grim for large parts of the UK. They're grim now but long term Tory rule will do that. We love our Tories in this country.

This. I grew up,in Scotland and it was a different world to London and the South East. The damage that fucking woman caused will last for generations in many of our mining communities.

Not all,of us have parents who bought a house for tuppance that is now worth millions. Many people in the 80's never managed to buy a house at all and many who did, who took advantage of the right to buy council houses, ended up losing them less than a decade later when the interest rates went up to 15% overnight. These were working class, low earners so no parents or savings to bail them out.

The 80's were fucking grim for a lot of us who lived it. My dad had to work three jobs just to pay the rent and my mother refused to work (she just kept having children as an avoidance technique). We were mostly fed on chips and fried egg. Occasionally we'd have a Chinese takeaway as a treat on dads payday. Or if our paternal grandmother decided she wanted mother to cook her a roast, she'd provide the meat and the veg.

School was our way out of the shithole in which we lived, so bunking off was never an option for a lot of us bright kids, even though every lesson was disrupted by the kids who weren't bright and didn't want to learn. We had some good teachers though who offered extra lessons for some of us who wanted to get to college and university.

It was a shit childhood. We had no holidays, no trips out, no nice clothes and a diet that would bring horror to the mummy's on here who only feed their kids unicorn dust. The only point to childhood in those times and where I grew up was to get through it and get the hell away. I look at my nieces and nephews now - all late teens and young adults - still in the place where we grew up, and they seem so passive and accepting of the crap hand that they have been dealt. Their parents had no ambition and the kids are the same. My nephew can't work because of anxiety...bollocks he has anxiety. He's just a lazy shit who can't be arsed to get out of bed in the morning and get himself out to work. No SEN, no depression or mental health problems, no neurodiversity....just self diagnosed anxiety. He lives at home and mum and dad provide everything he needs so he just doesn't see the need to work himself - at the age of 22. And there are many, many like him where I grew up. At least in my generation the young people had no choice but to get out and work or go to college.

And the thing I hate most is that it brings out a latent Norman Tebbit in me that makes a lifelong labour supporter like me all.....anxious 🤣🤣🤣

Tacotortoise · 30/12/2023 11:09

NeverDropYourMooncup · 30/12/2023 11:02

Or just walked away to marry somebody else without bothering with that tricky divorce part. Paper records weren't easily linked up, so if a man decided to walk out on wife and children, move a few miles away and marry somebody else, not even bothering to have a false name, there was no way of finding them unless a relative actually spotted them, found out where they were living and who they were with and reported a bigamous marriage.

My half siblings were contacted by their father's 'first' (ie, only legal) wife a couple of years ago. Their mother not only has no idea that she was never legally married, she had been receiving pension/benefits based upon his contributions as a widow since the 70s - so even the State didn't have a clue.

Yes FiL and his sister were actually illegitimate for the first few years of their lives as their father was already married - not that they or the neighbours knew, their parents just presented as a married couple. Luckily the first wife did eventually seek a divorce so their parents could then marry.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 30/12/2023 11:03

Naptrappedmummy · 30/12/2023 10:53

They finished school at 10/11 did they? Funny because compulsory leaving age in 1947 was 15.

Depends upon that PP's parents' age. It was 12 (and not exactly enforced) until 1918.

Swipe left for the next trending thread