Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I’ve started throwing out whatever DH leaves on the floor

235 replies

Lollibert · 20/12/2023 21:11

I’m at my wits end I don’t know how else to get through to My DH he leaves dirty socks on the floor, his dirty clothes, his leaves dirty dishes on the table leaves empty packets of his snacks everywhere now in the beginning I didn’t mind my DH works and I keep the home, I cook and clean and that was fine until I became a mum, and found out very quickly that cooking and cleaning childless vs cooking and cleaning when u have a child are too very different things, this all I ask of him,
one: put your dirty dishes in the sink you don’t have to wash it just please put it in the sink and pour a little water over the top until I can get to it (as I hate when he leaves it out and the food on the plate drys and becomes hard to get off)

two: put your dirty laundry in the washing basket

three: put your empty packets in the bin

four: take off your shoes at the door (he tracks mud in)

is that seriously too hard of a thing? We’ve had arguments where he said he works all day and I know he does he has a very physically demanding job and we ended up having so many arguments about it that he said fine he will do what I ask to save the arguments, that’s great except he still doesn’t do it says he forgot, if I remind him before he gets the chance to forget he says I nag him, so I think I had a mental break down tonight and threw out the dishes he left out on the table threw out the clothes he left on the floor threw out his muddy shoes that he was kind enough to take off IN THE LIVING ROOM after getting a trail of mud on the living room carpet which left me cleaning up a trail of mud and I swore to him from now on this is how it’s going to be I will throw out whatever he leaves out and I really don’t want to but I’m serious I can’t be the one in the wrong for this am I living in an alternate universe I don’t know how to get through to this man and he is so good in every other way except this I just can’t understand it

OP posts:
SouthLondonMum22 · 21/12/2023 09:25

Abracadabra12345 · 21/12/2023 09:17

How old is your baby?

I like the replies which suggest strategies. Less so the ones that urge you to leave which is the default position on MN. Isn't there a thread somewhere talking of the reality and colossal expense of breaking up with a young child?

Plus - in every other way, he's a good partner and you love him. I like blocking his entrance until he takes his boots off and work on one thing at a time

99% of the strategies involve treating a grown man like a child. Not very attractive.

If OP wants to continue with the marriage, of course that's up to her. It isn't something I'd be willing to do because being disrespectful doesn't make someone a good partner and ultimately, the resentment of cleaning up after a man child would bubble over.

Abracadabra12345 · 21/12/2023 09:17

How old is your baby?

I like the replies which suggest strategies. Less so the ones that urge you to leave which is the default position on MN. Isn't there a thread somewhere talking of the reality and colossal expense of breaking up with a young child?

Plus - in every other way, he's a good partner and you love him. I like blocking his entrance until he takes his boots off and work on one thing at a time

getfreddynow · 21/12/2023 08:38

must be so frustrating because you can’t get why he doesn’t do simple things. And you want the relationship to work not leave him.

odd he can’t get it. And sounds like he has no answer.

you said he works 5-5 x6 days a week in.a physical job. That is a brutal schedule. Does he enjoy it?

Does he follow instructions all day or have to think for himself on his job? Can he drop a day?

not as excuse for not doing basic things but is work a contributing factor? Is he also more burnt out since baby came , he has stopped functioning properly? Easy way to know is he any different on Sundays or during time off?

I think I’d stand by the door when he came in and say boots off or put baby gate blocking hall with sign on it tk take boots off so he can’t get past.
because you said you don’t want to leave him, you need to change 1 behaviour at a time to avoid being stuck and frustration turning to hatred. Boots week 1 or till he does it .

Summonedbybees · 21/12/2023 08:17

If you split up, you will be expected to get a job. You either tolerate his mess and look on it as a trade off for not working and contributing to household finances, or you find a job. Having a job gives you proper options.
You are making yourself so vulnerable. You cannot depend on someone else to provide for you financially forever. Take a proper look at what you want your future to look like and work towards achieving this goal.

maltichi · 21/12/2023 08:06

I know someone who did this with her husband's pants. Threw them in the bin every time, it did work apparently but it was just the pants.

In all seriousness though if he still can't/won't change his habits can he entertain the baby/do bedtime every evening whilst you clean up? Or can he pay for a cleaner? I do think he should be tidying up after himself but sometimes a compromise is just easier.

LadyEloise1 · 21/12/2023 08:03

taylorswift1989 · 20/12/2023 21:21

YANBU. Throw everything out. He sounds like a fucking dick.

I mean, it might be easier to just throw him out.

I agree. Smile

DonnaBanana · 21/12/2023 08:02

This is no way to treat an adult in their own home who, I assume, pays at least half the mortgage too. You are treating him more like a child which will have a bad effect on your adult relationship eventually. However, it cuts both ways and you aren’t responsible for cleaning up his mess, he is.

bonzaitree · 21/12/2023 07:59

I think you should get back to work OP. This relationship doesn’t seem to be working out and you don’t want to be trapped. I’d get back to work and try and save a cushion of money whilst in the relationship. Start operating like a single parent and see what it’s like and whether it’s something that you’d like.

I would stop doing his washing, ironing and cooking him meals. Stop doing anything that’s just for him. De-centre him from your life and focus on you and your baby. Get your career started. Get your child their free hours in childcare.

He is likely to sense your change in attitude. Be careful if he has been violent or abusive in the past as things could escalate.

Elmeux · 21/12/2023 07:58

Hi OP.

This was me too. My husband is incapable of putting anything in the bin - the plastic pull off tops off a milk carton, the ring pulls from 'his' flavoured milk, empty packets/packaging/envelopes/carrier bags, he'd just leave them all on the side. He never did any washing and left dirty clothes on the floor. He'd empty the dishwasher but leave it all in the counter top. I used to put in all either in his work bag, his coat pocket or his shoes. He still didn't do anything about it. Then I collected all the bits of shit up in a show box and wrap it for his birthday or Christmas. He got arsey about it naturally. I've tried everything. Don't get me wrong, I can be a bit untidy when things are busy, but will always have a blitz every couple of days, but things aren't dirty. No matter how much I asked nicely, pleaded, or lost my rag - NOTHING CHANGED. He won't change. He doesn't respect you or see your relationship as a partnership. If you are unhappy you need to make a step to make you happy. I now sleep in the spare bedroom, I don't do his washing and I don't cook for him. I can't see it improving, but can't leave/end things right now.

LadyBird1973 · 21/12/2023 07:54

To the posters who say that mud tracked all over the house etc is a 'minor inconvenience', that is only true if you aren't the one constantly cleaning it up!
It's soul destroying to have to keep repeatedly clearing up after another adult. He is perfectly capable of putting a dish in the sink or removing his shoes, he just doesn't care enough to make it a priority!
The OP shouldn't have to live in someone else's dirt! I bet at work he doesn't just leave his shit all over the place, because there would be consequences!

I think that not all couples are meant to live together. If he's unwilling to change, you might want to consider separate houses. You shouldn't have to treat your husband like a baby or a dog you are trying your train - that would kill any attraction for me, having to teach my grown arse husband how to behave like an adult. But I would be tempted to leave a big laminated sign on the front door telling him to remove his boots. If he's tracking in mud, eventually he'll track in dog poo!

Summonedbybees · 21/12/2023 07:49

@Lollibert
Your child will go to nursery and school. You either set yourself up for a life that is straight out of the post war period or you recover some self respect and find a job. The threads you read on here from female posters who somehow have ended up with husbands and partners who don't work, shows how women dislike cock lodgers. Everyone needs a job and to be contributing to a pension. It is part of being a grown up. Many men find it hard to be the sole breadwinner.
Having a job gives you so many more options. It is good for you self respect and mental health.
Vow to yourself that 2924 is going to be the year you either find a job or retrain. You may find it does wonders for your marriage and hopefully it will teach your husband to treat you with more respect and to pull his weight.

wildwestpioneer · 21/12/2023 07:48

I think there's a big difference to general household mess to clean as a sahp, and someone who just leaves stuff everywhere because they know they don't have to be tidy or clean. There's no excuse for an adult not to remember to take off muddy shoes before walking on a carpet.

I'd always tidy the house before the cleaner came, not because I didn't want her thinking we were a scruffy bunch, because it's not her job to put away our shit. It's to clean.

I would find your dh behaviour disrespectful, it's almost like saying FU, I'm not listening to you and carrying on as I please, with no regards to what you've asked me previously.

I'd definite just bag up his stuff and chuck outside, not sore I'd consider as to chick plates out tho Grin

LlynTegid · 21/12/2023 07:35

If you say to him that is what you will do, you must go through with it.

Lollibert · 21/12/2023 07:33

@DinkyDonkey2018 thats what I mean in other ways he’s great and a great dad just terrible when it comes to the household

OP posts:
Lollibert · 21/12/2023 07:30

@Picklewicklepickle he has a very messy job, it’s why he comes home muddy a lot of the time

OP posts:
DinkyDonkey2018 · 21/12/2023 07:22

I have one a bit like this. The most amazing partner and father but SO fucking messy! I didn't have the balls to throw his stuff in the bin, but I did gather everything up and shove it at the back of his wardrobe in a big pile. He didn't notice until he realised he'd run out of clean work clothes and couldn't find his keys and wallet. I told him where everything was, and he's been much better, even hoovering up the mud from.his work boots whilst I sit and enjoy my coffee. Lovely.

Picklewicklepickle · 21/12/2023 07:12

Lollibert · 20/12/2023 22:32

@Mumof2NDers tbh I think people are getting the wrong idea of him on here he’s not controlling etc in every other way he’s amazing but he’s just the messiest man to ever Grace this earth and looks genuinely confused when I argue about it like he can’t see the problem no matter how much I argue, but that’s only when it comes to mess he listens when it comes to anything else I just understand why this is the one thing I can’t get through to him on. And it’s also the one thing I refuse to accept. It drives me mad But I wouldn’t leave him over as people are suggesting.

I would bet a million pounds he’s not messy at work, it’s a choice

thecatwiththesilveryfur · 21/12/2023 07:11

Lovelyjubbbly · 20/12/2023 22:05

OMG!!!!!! This is my house I’m in the same position I just read this out to my DH

his reply

‘ well there should be a threat for us men about this try leaving the washing basket in the same place every day we work every day and don’t want to come home to be doing duties that’s your job we provide and cleaning is ur duty ‘

😂😂😂😂

I'm sorry you're married to a disgusting pig who has no respect for you. Would you like our help to leave?

Resilience · 21/12/2023 07:08

You need to think about where your line in the sand is with this one. I would - and have - end a relationship over this. No self-respecting, fully abled adult should expect another human being to pick up after them unless they are being paid for professional services. Household division of labour (e.g. doing all the laundry by agreement) is completely different to picking up after someone. It is beyond disrespectful IMO. It's also a massive passion killer. No one feels turned on by picking up skiddy underpants, wiping up piss off the toilet seat/bathroom floor, or vacuuming the tracked in mud. They feel like a maid and full of resentment. Studies have shown that men who contribute more equally around the house have more sex.

Personally, I think this story still fails to really grasp the point, but it's a good introduction to how actions like this kill relationships: https://www.huffpost.com/entry/she-divorced-me-i-left-dishes-by-the-sinkbb_9055288/amp

I saw one poster who tackled this effectively by leaving stick it notes on everything her DH left lying around for her to sort. She wrote "Fuck <her name>" on them to make the point that this was what she felt her DH was saying to her every time he did this.

Ultimately though, will you leave if he doesn't change? It's worth thinking about now. I've seen so many women think "I can't break up the family over something as petty as housework". Most of them find that the disrespect underlying it becomes worse as the pattern becomes more entrenched, which ends up killing the relationship anyway. Sometimes they muddle on in an unequal unfulfilling relationship, sometimes they split up just later.

I say this as someone who has a muddly DH who leaves his stuff everywhere. What he doesn't do though is leave me dirty clothes/plates to clear up or actively generate mess for me to deal with. I tolerate his muddliness because it's his home too and we share housework 50/50 (he may actually do more than me tbh).

Good luck!

Goldcrestonabranch · 21/12/2023 07:07

Why on earth did you give up work?

ObsidianGrape · 21/12/2023 07:03

Does he forget to do things asked of him at work? Or does he manage to follow simple instructions? If the answer is yes, then he's capable of it, but he doesn't respect you enough to do it. After being told so many times to do these simple things, I find it hard to believe that he continues to 'forget' to do them. He obviously chooses not to do them. I bet he doesn't leave wrappers, dirty cups, plates on his desk at work....

Don't feel guilty and remove his stuff from the bin. In future double lock the door when he comes in from work and make him take his shoes off before letting him in. Stop doing his laundry. Don't buy food with wrappers for him. Give him disposable plates and cutlery like someone else said. Actually maybe don't even cook for him anymore either. If he asks why tell him you forgot. Hopefully he will realise you are serious soon enough and start acting like an adult

amberisola · 21/12/2023 06:56

As it's got so bad, I can understand why you did that. In fact yesterday I gathered up all the bits of clutter DH had left scattered around the house for days/weeks and put them in a bag, which went in his car.

Leaving dirty stuff like plates and clothes lying around though to me would mean reconsidering my living situation. It's unhygienic and depressing to live around that. And any attraction would be gone!

It sounds like he has no respect for you or himself, and I agree with PP that this sort of behaviour is often passive aggressive.

I would stop wasting energy asking him to do basic life tasks (he knows to do them, it's a choice not to) but also stop doing anything for him at all, put his dirty stuff in a bag and leave him to sort it out.

Goodlard · 21/12/2023 06:43

WandaWonder · 20/12/2023 21:34

Imangine

wife posting on here 'I came home from work and found out my husband threw away my things''

'omg that is a red flag, you need to kick him out, he is gaslighting you'
'you must leave'

Howis it gaslighting?

Goodlard · 21/12/2023 06:42

Honestly, this is nothing to do with other bing in a mess and everything to do with him deciding you're his dogsbody and maid.

I'd seriously be repulsed by a man that wanted to treat me like that!

SouthLondonMum22 · 21/12/2023 06:33

Lollibert · 21/12/2023 00:10

@Calliopespa he is respectful in other contexts BUT I am entitled to be upset about the mess he makes anytime he’s ever spent a few days away for work the entire house stays exactly the way I left it, he is respectful in ways where he won’t do anything without asking if mind or without asking me how I feel about it that’s why it baffles me so much that he won’t listen it comes to mess and I do feel justified in my anger because I don’t ask him to do the washing I don’t ask him to do the dishes Because I know he works very hard for us, he works from 5 till 5 six days a week Sundays off, but I feel like I’ve been as understanding as I can be in this situation and now he should be understanding that I’m only asking him very simple things like put his dish in the sink put his clothes in the basket take his shoes off he says he genuinely forgot but u can’t forget nearly every time

Does he have any issues with not 'seeing' mess at work? I'm assuming not because he knows his boss wouldn't put up with it. If he can manage to clean up after himself at work then he can surely manage it at home too.

Maybe it is time he starts doing more around the house and he'll start appreciating and respecting you more in the long run. Sit down with him at a time where he hasn't just left mud on the floor and tell him how disrespected and taken for granted you feel and that you want him to do more around the house.

He finishes work at 5. Many, many working people do housework as well as working full time. He needs to start seeing it as his responsibility too because that's part of the problem.

Swipe left for the next trending thread