Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people without kids have more money?

306 replies

Zoomzoomzoomzoom0 · 20/12/2023 20:46

Than people with kids I mean. Twice this week I've had single child free friends tell me how
" lucky" I am that I have my husbands pension to " fall back on". I don't even know what that actually means, he has his pension, I have mine, we both work, 1 pension per person. Neither of us will be able to retire early. We have 2 kids. Kids cost a bloody fortune.
I sort of let it wash over me the first time, but the second remark ( different person) bugged me.
She said " Well I don't have my husbands pension to fall back on" so I said " You also don't have kids costing you a bloody fortune"
I don't care about other people's life choices, or how they spend their time or money, I honestly barely think about other people! Except today obviously 🤣
Both of these women obviously think I am financially better off than them. I've never thought about it, but how could I be??? ( we all work in the same industry btw, on similar wages)

OP posts:
KimberleyClark · 23/12/2023 07:54

KimberleyClark · 23/12/2023 07:51

Yes, I’ll get 50% of my DH’s pension if he dies first, he’ll get half of mine if I die first.

Talking about occupational pension here, not state.

KimberleyClark · 23/12/2023 07:51

converseandjeans · 23/12/2023 07:49

@coffeeaddict77

It doesn't work like that

I'm pretty sure 50% of my teachers pension will go to DH if anything happens to me first. I had to nominate him.

Yes, I’ll get 50% of my DH’s pension if he dies first, he’ll get half of mine if I die first.

converseandjeans · 23/12/2023 07:49

@coffeeaddict77

It doesn't work like that

I'm pretty sure 50% of my teachers pension will go to DH if anything happens to me first. I had to nominate him.

KimberleyClark · 23/12/2023 07:33

Another example: fresh food. Many items cost substantially more if buying in small quantities.

This is true, it’s getting more and more difficult to buy,for example, milk in pints or two pint containers. Even just as a couple we have little chance of getting through a 4 Pinter before it goes off.

Anahenzaris · 23/12/2023 06:53

YABU. Financially, single women are the most vulnerable. There is no reason to expect that you must be in a more difficult financial position than your solo friends because you have children. Naturally, some single women and men are wealthy, some couples are in extreme poverty. But as you are all earning similar wages, and it sounds like not in poverty - yes your dual income status puts you at a huge advantage over a single income.

Now, you may choose to spend very large amounts of money on your kids, even to the point of financial harm. But often there’s options to reduce spending if needed.

A few things to think about

  • solo people have no backup. If they lose their income they have nothing. A couple both with the ability to work can more easily get one into basic employment and had openings for both to take on basic jobs (supermarket, fast food etc) to keep their head above water. A solo person instantly had half the income potential (once children are in school rather than private care - both parents working is an option without high fees).
  • solo people are at the bottom of the list for govt support eg housing (people with kids are much higher) - when this go wrong there’s limited charity or welfare directed towards single childless people (unless they are old enough)
  • many expenses come with couple and family discounts. This can be everything from health care, insurances and govt fees and taxes through to luxuries like holidays, entrance fees etc
  • As households increase in size the per person cost decreases (until you pass a threshold) there are many things where multiple users have a negligible increase in cost or a comparatively much smaller one. Eg a family car. A family can access 1 car for almost the same cost as 1 person. It might not be convenient to share a car between a couple, but it is possible. Another example: fresh food. Many items cost substantially more if buying in small quantities. You pay almost as much rent to house a single person with the same luxuries as a family (having a kitchen, laundry, lounge room etc). If you doubled my rent you have a massive increase in luxury that goes beyond extra space for a couple kids (this is no longer true if you have 10 kids, but for a small number of kids it is still true)
  • solo people often have to pay for things society supports for couples / things couples can do for cheaper. Eg couples often can access paid leave not available to a solo person for care. A solo person may need to hire a carer while a couple person can use paid carers leave to receive the same care. Even things as simple as being able to be dropped off or picked up rather than needing to pay for Ubers. Even things as simple as getting something upstairs can require hiring a worker rather than doing it together.
  • Retirement planning often needs to start young. People with children are more likely to have someone to help them in their retirement - be that providing care or financially. Solo people need to plan to have to purchase that assistance, won’t have 2 pensions, and won’t have any discounts from being a couple. Simple things like picking up the shopping or changing a light bulb can get expensive. Until very recently, it was illegal for you to live as an older person in a granny flat if you didn’t have an approved relationship with the owners - kids were approved relationships (friends definitely were not)
  • it is harder to get a mortgage as single income than doubled (each adult on same decent income) with a small number of children - which limits property investment, pathways into secure housing etc (where I live rentals are not long term, and even with a lease you can loose the place no fault of the owner wants it back for themselves).
  • even small savings while young can hand huge impacts on long term financial position. If my household savings had been able to go up even 10% above what I managed solo I’d have been in the property market years earlier - my mortgage would likely be half (for both of us) we’d be paying down faster. When I compare myself to those around me (couples) with kids - I’m not even close to catching up to those on comparable incomes to me.

this list isn’t even exhaustive. The data I’ve seen suggests it costs about 1.5x what it does for a solo rather than small family day to day. When kids are pre-school aged couples with kids can struggle more - but over the long term they are in markedly stronger financial positions (just don’t get divorced!). Getting ahead while working has a huge impact on financial security in retirement. Even if 100% of the second went to essentials for the whole family (so no additional savings, no additional investment in a mortgage etc) you would still have the compulsory retirement savings of a second person - so double the forced savings for your retirement, so conservatively 25% more each than your single mate (and that’s with no help from your kids for anything)

Now that doesn’t mean kids aren’t expensive. It also doesn’t mean that you shouldn’t be able to complain about the cost of kids.

But you do need to understand that financially it can be very risky if you are solo. And it’s also ok for your friends to feel frustrated that there’s a lot of costs to being solo that aren’t often thought of. Too many people think solo=rich. Political narrative is often around helping families, lowering costs for families. It can be frustrating when people don’t even acknowledge that being solo has a financial cost that can really impact quality of life.

I’m using solo to mean not coupled not with children as opposed to single, where there can also be children. The above is also assuming all the adults have approximately equal income, and there’s no major costs hitting one group not the other (a complex disability in either group is just not an equal comparison any more)

coffeeaddict77 · 22/12/2023 22:26

Teder · 22/12/2023 17:31

No. People like you (and I) chose to have multiple children. Single people don’t often (sometimes they do) choose to be alone and in a financially precarious position. I don’t undertand what you don’t understand. 🤷🏻‍♀️ I don’t whine that it’s expensive to house my children and tell single people they should share with strangers. It is expensive to house my children but I’m very grateful and fortunate I’m not forced to share with strangers when I don’t want to but I have no financial choice!!

How is whether I chose to have children relevant to the question of whether I would have been better off financially if I hadn't🤔

coffeeaddict77 · 22/12/2023 22:19

CleverLilViper · 22/12/2023 17:45

Maybe people shouldn't have multiple children if they can't afford to house them and don't want them to share a room? 🙄

That is not relevant.

coffeeaddict77 · 22/12/2023 22:17

CagneyAndLazy · 22/12/2023 20:18

We chose to pay for child care and I chose to continue working full time.

I don't get your point. You chose to do what you did.

My point is, many, many people have 1 or 2 children (or more) while working in low-paid, if not minimum wage jobs. To say that having a child means you can't have a Porsche when you otherwise could have done is, frankly, bollocks. If it were true, childless people would all be loaded but, clearly, they're not.

You can't choose not to pay for chidcare if you both work unless you think babies and young children can look after themselves.
If you hadn't paid for childcare one parent would have had to give up their job so they could look after the children and then live on one salary. How would three or four people living on one salary be better off than a single person living on the same salary.

coffeeaddict77 · 22/12/2023 22:04

converseandjeans · 22/12/2023 20:46

I think if you get husband to sign something you would be eligible for 50% of his pension once he passes away.

It doesn't work like that.

converseandjeans · 22/12/2023 20:46

I think if you get husband to sign something you would be eligible for 50% of his pension once he passes away.

CagneyAndLazy · 22/12/2023 20:18

coffeeaddict77 · 22/12/2023 13:29

Presumably you didn't pay for childcare or take drop in salary from working part time to look after them then. My children easily cost more than 15k a year once that is taken into account.

We chose to pay for child care and I chose to continue working full time.

I don't get your point. You chose to do what you did.

My point is, many, many people have 1 or 2 children (or more) while working in low-paid, if not minimum wage jobs. To say that having a child means you can't have a Porsche when you otherwise could have done is, frankly, bollocks. If it were true, childless people would all be loaded but, clearly, they're not.

CleverLilViper · 22/12/2023 17:45

coffeeaddict77 · 22/12/2023 14:52

So you are arguing that it would be a terrible hardship for single adults to house share even though they would have their own room and space but fine for three teenagers to share a room.🤔

Maybe people shouldn't have multiple children if they can't afford to house them and don't want them to share a room? 🙄

CleverLilViper · 22/12/2023 17:43

YABU for this generalisation.

Yes, kids are expensive but you also chose to have them knowing that.

However, just because someone doesn't have children, doesn't mean that that automatically means they have more money than someone who does have kids.

You could have a dual-income family with kids who are making a lot more than someone who is living on a single income with no kids and vice versa.

It's not remotely as straightforward as "kids=poor" "no kids=rich."

Wealth can sometimes depend on if someone is single or married/in a couple. Often, if someone is with someone, they will have more money than someone who is single as a household.

I live alone and live on one income-with no kids, my brother and his wife live together with one child.

By and large, I'd say they have more disposable income than I do per month despite having a child due to their incomes being joint.

Just because someone doesn't have kids also doesn't mean that they don't have other financial burdens, too. Many choose to not have children due to the financial implications and their inability to meet it.

FuckinghellthatsUnbelievable · 22/12/2023 17:41

I think it’s fairly obvious a couple will be better off than a singleton in retirement. Kids do cost a fortune so you’re average family is generally poorer than a couple. Single people without kids can struggle all the way through as rent / life is so expensive for one.

Teder · 22/12/2023 17:31

coffeeaddict77 · 22/12/2023 14:52

So you are arguing that it would be a terrible hardship for single adults to house share even though they would have their own room and space but fine for three teenagers to share a room.🤔

No. People like you (and I) chose to have multiple children. Single people don’t often (sometimes they do) choose to be alone and in a financially precarious position. I don’t undertand what you don’t understand. 🤷🏻‍♀️ I don’t whine that it’s expensive to house my children and tell single people they should share with strangers. It is expensive to house my children but I’m very grateful and fortunate I’m not forced to share with strangers when I don’t want to but I have no financial choice!!

CostedStrikeRate · 22/12/2023 17:27

Life is all about tradeoffs

Verv · 22/12/2023 17:02

coffeeaddict77 · 22/12/2023 16:16

I don't think it does even out. While being in a couple does cost a less than being single, the lower cost is far outweighed by children. They cost a fortune not just in terms of feeding and clothing but also childcare (or lower wages if you don't use it).

Okay. I dont have them so no idea of the costs of childcare etc.

coffeeaddict77 · 22/12/2023 16:16

Verv · 22/12/2023 14:56

It's just different I think.
Being single is in some respects more expensive as we dont split mortgages, rent, utilities, food, holiday bills, etc etc.
But by the same token, we arent feeding additional young people with voracious appetites because they are growing.
Probably evens out in the end, somewhere.

I don't think it does even out. While being in a couple does cost a less than being single, the lower cost is far outweighed by children. They cost a fortune not just in terms of feeding and clothing but also childcare (or lower wages if you don't use it).

Verv · 22/12/2023 14:56

It's just different I think.
Being single is in some respects more expensive as we dont split mortgages, rent, utilities, food, holiday bills, etc etc.
But by the same token, we arent feeding additional young people with voracious appetites because they are growing.
Probably evens out in the end, somewhere.

coffeeaddict77 · 22/12/2023 14:52

Teder · 22/12/2023 13:31

How many people here bend over backwards to make sure their children have their own space? You could easily room share with a child or put 3 children in one room or in a lounge and it’s much cheaper. So, for the parents saying it’s expensive to house a family… yes, of course but many choose to have a bigger home.

So you are arguing that it would be a terrible hardship for single adults to house share even though they would have their own room and space but fine for three teenagers to share a room.🤔

fitzwilliamdarcy · 22/12/2023 13:33

Lincslady53 · 22/12/2023 11:20

A few years ago we took our kids to a show with a couple of gay friends who had a similar business to ours. We had a Nissan Bluebird at the time. They pulled uo in their Porsche. 'How come you have a Nissan and they have a Porsche?' asked DD. 'How many children do they have?' I replied. Argument over.

Wow you have just proved every person without kids is richer than every person with them, thread is OVER! 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

(My parents had a Porsche when I was young and my childless self can’t afford to run a car. Anecdotes are fun!)

Teder · 22/12/2023 13:31

coffeeaddict77 · 22/12/2023 13:08

We are talking about the financial side of things so I'm not sure of your point. I actually wasn't "financially stretched" when I chose to live with lodgers in my early thirties although the rent they paid was obviously useful for paying the mortgage off.

How many people here bend over backwards to make sure their children have their own space? You could easily room share with a child or put 3 children in one room or in a lounge and it’s much cheaper. So, for the parents saying it’s expensive to house a family… yes, of course but many choose to have a bigger home.

coffeeaddict77 · 22/12/2023 13:29

CagneyAndLazy · 22/12/2023 13:03

I've heard cliches/anecdotes like this before but really struggle to reconcile the idea that having a child makes the difference between being loaded and being poor or, in this case, between running an old banger or a Porsche.

I'm sure that - ignoring school fees - DD didn't cost us anything like an additional £15k+ per year, which is realistically what DH's Porsche cost per year a few years back (with depreciation) when he had that.

Presumably you didn't pay for childcare or take drop in salary from working part time to look after them then. My children easily cost more than 15k a year once that is taken into account.

coffeeaddict77 · 22/12/2023 13:13

I think people are confusing which situation is financially easier and which situation they would prefer emotionally. I know I would have been much better financially if I had remained single and had not got married and had children. Perhaps it is different if you don't have a professional job or qualifications and marry someone who does though.

coffeeaddict77 · 22/12/2023 13:08

Teder · 22/12/2023 12:45

Comparing living with the man you love and the children you choose is absolutely not the same as being financially stretched to the point where you choose 🙄🙄🙄 to live with strangers. I cannot believe this needs pointing out. I say this as someone with a husband and children btw.

We are talking about the financial side of things so I'm not sure of your point. I actually wasn't "financially stretched" when I chose to live with lodgers in my early thirties although the rent they paid was obviously useful for paying the mortgage off.

Swipe left for the next trending thread