Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people without kids have more money?

306 replies

Zoomzoomzoomzoom0 · 20/12/2023 20:46

Than people with kids I mean. Twice this week I've had single child free friends tell me how
" lucky" I am that I have my husbands pension to " fall back on". I don't even know what that actually means, he has his pension, I have mine, we both work, 1 pension per person. Neither of us will be able to retire early. We have 2 kids. Kids cost a bloody fortune.
I sort of let it wash over me the first time, but the second remark ( different person) bugged me.
She said " Well I don't have my husbands pension to fall back on" so I said " You also don't have kids costing you a bloody fortune"
I don't care about other people's life choices, or how they spend their time or money, I honestly barely think about other people! Except today obviously 🤣
Both of these women obviously think I am financially better off than them. I've never thought about it, but how could I be??? ( we all work in the same industry btw, on similar wages)

OP posts:
coffeeaddict77 · 23/12/2023 19:40

Livelifelaughter · 23/12/2023 18:32

But that's my point, if you're single you have just your own salary, so lose your job and that's it.

If the breadwinner of a family loses their job they are probably in a worse position. The other adult will often only have a much lower paid part time job and there will be children to support as well as both adults. I was much more worried about job loss when I had children than before.

Livelifelaughter · 23/12/2023 18:32

But that's my point, if you're single you have just your own salary, so lose your job and that's it.

GetWhatYouWant · 23/12/2023 18:31

Livelifelaughter · 23/12/2023 17:00

That's not correct, say the figure of £223 k is correct, and it can't really be as most people don't have that amount of spare tax free income. But evenso it doesn't mean a solo person is SAVING 223k because it's expensive to be single, base costs of housing, a car are the same and the other factors mentioned in posts...

The figure came from the Times, I googled it. As I said it's an average i.e. some people will spend more and some people will spend less.
I also made no comment about whether people were single or not, when trying to compare one variable you have to make other things equal i.e. if a couple with no children had similar salaries and outgoings to a couple with children clearly the childless couple would be hugely better off. But as I said all that doesn't take into account differences in incomes and personal circumstances. But the fact remains if you want your child to have an enriching childhood with opportunities provided for the best outcomes going into adulthood it is costly.

coffeeaddict77 · 23/12/2023 17:21

Livelifelaughter · 23/12/2023 16:51

@coffeeaddict77 I get your point. But I suppose what I am saying is that in my friendship group, people who earn around the same as me, notwithstanding having children, they all live in houses and have the mortgage paid for in full. This isn't the case for friends who are single on the same wage. Obviously this doesn't apply to all income groups. But if for example I went part time I couldn't actually pay the bills and mortgage for my flat, whereas my colleagues can and do go part time and have two children. The big difference seems to be those who have privately educated children which does make a massive difference. But those with children in state education, no I don't think it's more expensive because your lifestyle is different. Seriously, I go out a lot more because I would go nuts otherwise...

You don't know their joint income though. Maybe they have had help from parents or perhaps they have just married people on high salaries.

Livelifelaughter · 23/12/2023 17:00

GetWhatYouWant · 23/12/2023 12:18

The latest estimate is that it costs on average £223k to bring up a child from 0 to 18. Therefore on similar salaries people without children will be hugely financially better off, it stands to reason.
Of course because of income disparities you can't say that people without children are always better off.

That's not correct, say the figure of £223 k is correct, and it can't really be as most people don't have that amount of spare tax free income. But evenso it doesn't mean a solo person is SAVING 223k because it's expensive to be single, base costs of housing, a car are the same and the other factors mentioned in posts...

Livelifelaughter · 23/12/2023 16:51

@coffeeaddict77 I get your point. But I suppose what I am saying is that in my friendship group, people who earn around the same as me, notwithstanding having children, they all live in houses and have the mortgage paid for in full. This isn't the case for friends who are single on the same wage. Obviously this doesn't apply to all income groups. But if for example I went part time I couldn't actually pay the bills and mortgage for my flat, whereas my colleagues can and do go part time and have two children. The big difference seems to be those who have privately educated children which does make a massive difference. But those with children in state education, no I don't think it's more expensive because your lifestyle is different. Seriously, I go out a lot more because I would go nuts otherwise...

coffeeaddict77 · 23/12/2023 16:48

LumiB · 23/12/2023 13:16

It doesn't matter how much if costs to bring up a kid it doesn't make a solo person more richer. As its been said time and again, if the disposable income left over is the same then its your choices that determine how its spent. You choose to have children so your disposable money goes on thag another chooses not to and spend it holidays, clothes etc.

They don't magically have more money. Its the same amount of money just spent differently

And if you resent the cost of raising children dont have them.

Why would someone without children resent the cost of having them? Or do you mean that someone who does have children but resents the cost should go back in time and not have them?

coffeeaddict77 · 23/12/2023 16:40

Livelifelaughter · 23/12/2023 14:10

So I am single and it's very expensive. In my friendship circle everyone married lives in a house and those who are single don't.
Also you tend to go out more to socially connect rather than sit on your own at home, it's not unusual for my single friends to go out 3 times a week when I was in a relationship a lot more time was spent cooking together at home.
At the end of the day you have two incomes even if you treat your finances separately; if one of you lost your job and couldn't afford to pay their share of the bills well the other isn't going to let you starve.
I find it quite annoying when people with two incomes with children think they are worse off than a single person, you spend a lot as a single person, and don't start me on holidays...

The two incomes is spent on more than two people and often it is more like one and a half incomes at best if one person is working part time so they can look after the children.

coffeeaddict77 · 23/12/2023 16:35

whimsicalmoon · 23/12/2023 14:14

No, it's not a choice. I'm nearly 40, and I have disabilities and chronic health issues, and now increasingly bad mental health as a result of the things I've mentioned. I don't want to flat share like a student. I would love to have a normal life and a "DH" but I don't. I'm making the best of what I have and trying to survive. I would not be able to live with random people. It's not at all the same being married and choosing to go away with friends as having nobody to go with.

Your lack of empathy is disgusting.

Don't be ridiculous. I haven't given an opinion on whether you should or shouldn't live by yourself. I have said it is a choice which is something you have said yourself given that you live by yourself because you don't want to share.

Teder · 23/12/2023 15:27

whimsicalmoon · 23/12/2023 14:14

No, it's not a choice. I'm nearly 40, and I have disabilities and chronic health issues, and now increasingly bad mental health as a result of the things I've mentioned. I don't want to flat share like a student. I would love to have a normal life and a "DH" but I don't. I'm making the best of what I have and trying to survive. I would not be able to live with random people. It's not at all the same being married and choosing to go away with friends as having nobody to go with.

Your lack of empathy is disgusting.

It reminds me of those threads where people say they’re lonely as they have no Christmas plans and you get a bunch of sanctimonious twats say “oh I’m cooking for 15 people and I’d love to be alone”.

It’s easy to say you’d flat share if you’re single when you’re not bloody single!!

ChocolateTVandbaby · 23/12/2023 14:24

There are so many variables

it's not just kids he no kids

and even if it were, most people would and do choose to have the kids

whimsicalmoon · 23/12/2023 14:14

coffeeaddict77 · 22/12/2023 00:33

I'm not sure how old you are and I don't see what it has to do with age anyway. I sometimes go away for a few days with friends rather than DH and we usually share rooms to keep costs down. We're in our 50s. I lived in shared houses in my early 30s and would probably do so again if I was single. I get that you don't want to but it is a choice.

No, it's not a choice. I'm nearly 40, and I have disabilities and chronic health issues, and now increasingly bad mental health as a result of the things I've mentioned. I don't want to flat share like a student. I would love to have a normal life and a "DH" but I don't. I'm making the best of what I have and trying to survive. I would not be able to live with random people. It's not at all the same being married and choosing to go away with friends as having nobody to go with.

Your lack of empathy is disgusting.

Beezknees · 23/12/2023 14:12

CagneyAndLazy · 23/12/2023 14:11

That's £12.5k PER YEAR, PER CHILD.

There are hundreds of thousands, if not millions, of 2-child families where the parents would not have anywhere near £25k NET per year spare before having children. Many wouldn't have 10% of that completely spare.

How on earth do even 2 average earners both working full time (let alone those on low pay) have over £2k spare per month over and above all other living costs?

It's just total and utter nonsense.

UNLESS... the average parent is receiving so much in in-work benefits that it covers the huge gulf between salaries and that ridiculous £12.5k per year? In which case it's completely irrelevant for a comparison with how much better off childless people are, because those people are not receiving the benefits.

I definitely do not spend £2k a month on DS. That's my entire month wages including benefits and I'm a lone parent

CagneyAndLazy · 23/12/2023 14:11

GetWhatYouWant · 23/12/2023 12:18

The latest estimate is that it costs on average £223k to bring up a child from 0 to 18. Therefore on similar salaries people without children will be hugely financially better off, it stands to reason.
Of course because of income disparities you can't say that people without children are always better off.

That's £12.5k PER YEAR, PER CHILD.

There are hundreds of thousands, if not millions, of 2-child families where the parents would not have anywhere near £25k NET per year spare before having children. Many wouldn't have 10% of that completely spare.

How on earth do even 2 average earners both working full time (let alone those on low pay) have over £2k spare per month over and above all other living costs?

It's just total and utter nonsense.

UNLESS... the average parent is receiving so much in in-work benefits that it covers the huge gulf between salaries and that ridiculous £12.5k per year? In which case it's completely irrelevant for a comparison with how much better off childless people are, because those people are not receiving the benefits.

Livelifelaughter · 23/12/2023 14:10

So I am single and it's very expensive. In my friendship circle everyone married lives in a house and those who are single don't.
Also you tend to go out more to socially connect rather than sit on your own at home, it's not unusual for my single friends to go out 3 times a week when I was in a relationship a lot more time was spent cooking together at home.
At the end of the day you have two incomes even if you treat your finances separately; if one of you lost your job and couldn't afford to pay their share of the bills well the other isn't going to let you starve.
I find it quite annoying when people with two incomes with children think they are worse off than a single person, you spend a lot as a single person, and don't start me on holidays...

CagneyAndLazy · 23/12/2023 13:58

mantyzer · 23/12/2023 12:29

The cost of bringing up a child includes childcare. And most get free nursery and childcare vouchers. And that figure is hugely over inflated. Most families do not spend £48300 in their child when they are 0 to 3 years old.

Exactly this.

Some people won't have even had £48,300 in net income in 3 years.

There's so much nonsense spouted about how much children cost, with people adding on the cost of luxuries like choosing to give up work to look after them.

LumiB · 23/12/2023 13:16

It doesn't matter how much if costs to bring up a kid it doesn't make a solo person more richer. As its been said time and again, if the disposable income left over is the same then its your choices that determine how its spent. You choose to have children so your disposable money goes on thag another chooses not to and spend it holidays, clothes etc.

They don't magically have more money. Its the same amount of money just spent differently

And if you resent the cost of raising children dont have them.

coffeeaddict77 · 23/12/2023 12:55

mantyzer · 23/12/2023 12:29

The cost of bringing up a child includes childcare. And most get free nursery and childcare vouchers. And that figure is hugely over inflated. Most families do not spend £48300 in their child when they are 0 to 3 years old.

I don't know much about free childcare nowadays but it didn't exist when my children were 0-3 years. Does everyone get it now?

mantyzer · 23/12/2023 12:29

The cost of bringing up a child includes childcare. And most get free nursery and childcare vouchers. And that figure is hugely over inflated. Most families do not spend £48300 in their child when they are 0 to 3 years old.

mantyzer · 23/12/2023 12:25

But people with children often get benefits.

GetWhatYouWant · 23/12/2023 12:18

The latest estimate is that it costs on average £223k to bring up a child from 0 to 18. Therefore on similar salaries people without children will be hugely financially better off, it stands to reason.
Of course because of income disparities you can't say that people without children are always better off.

mantyzer · 23/12/2023 12:07

When I was young and single I had a job helping underprivileged families. Most seemed better off than me.
When I was single I was earning a low wage with no entitlement to benefits and no help from anyone. It was tough.

mantyzer · 23/12/2023 12:04

Some contribution based private pensions do pay out to the spouse.

coffeeaddict77 · 23/12/2023 11:45

KimberleyClark · 23/12/2023 07:51

Yes, I’ll get 50% of my DH’s pension if he dies first, he’ll get half of mine if I die first.

Yes, it does seem some older public sector pensions will pay out to the spouse (although I don't think as much as 50%). I don't think that usually applies to contribution based private sector ones usually nowadays though. Certainly mine doesn't.

coffeeaddict77 · 23/12/2023 11:24

@Anahenzaris While it is true that costs per person usually go down to some extent the more people in a household the fatal flaw in most of your argument is that the proportion of people earning money in that household also decreases greatly so the money has to be divided between a lot more people.
For example, a single person earning 50K will be able to spend the money just on themselves. In a family with two adults and two young children one adult might be earning 50K but the second adult will either be earning a lot less or most or all of their income will effectively be spent on childcare. The children won't be earning anything at all but still have to be fed and clothed.
I do agree that single people are often more vulnerable than families if they loose their job but even then it's not always the case. e.g. we were able to accommodate single BIL for a couple of months when he lost his job but wouldn't have had a room in the house for a whole extra family. Regardless, I think this is a discussion on who is better off if earning the same amount of money from a job rather than who is better off on benefits.

Swipe left for the next trending thread