Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people without kids have more money?

306 replies

Zoomzoomzoomzoom0 · 20/12/2023 20:46

Than people with kids I mean. Twice this week I've had single child free friends tell me how
" lucky" I am that I have my husbands pension to " fall back on". I don't even know what that actually means, he has his pension, I have mine, we both work, 1 pension per person. Neither of us will be able to retire early. We have 2 kids. Kids cost a bloody fortune.
I sort of let it wash over me the first time, but the second remark ( different person) bugged me.
She said " Well I don't have my husbands pension to fall back on" so I said " You also don't have kids costing you a bloody fortune"
I don't care about other people's life choices, or how they spend their time or money, I honestly barely think about other people! Except today obviously 🤣
Both of these women obviously think I am financially better off than them. I've never thought about it, but how could I be??? ( we all work in the same industry btw, on similar wages)

OP posts:
CruisingForAMusing · 21/12/2023 08:42

What I will say is not having kids certainly makes it easy to justify spending money on other interests.
Our camper van is currently in for another £1500 of welding work. That some people spend that a month on nursery fees blows my mind!

Beezknees · 21/12/2023 08:40

cakeorwine · 21/12/2023 08:39

Strange comment.

All depends on incomes, relationships, etc.

But generally, children cost money. They can affect your career. And your life choices.

But they also bring so much to your life.

But I think DS doesn't want children and would much rather have the money!

Why is it strange?

cakeorwine · 21/12/2023 08:39

Beezknees · 21/12/2023 08:33

I have one child and I have more money than my single friend who lives alone paying a mortgage.

Strange comment.

All depends on incomes, relationships, etc.

But generally, children cost money. They can affect your career. And your life choices.

But they also bring so much to your life.

But I think DS doesn't want children and would much rather have the money!

JaninaDuszejko · 21/12/2023 08:33

DH and I had more money before kids than we had after, our incomes went down due to maternity leave and working PT and our expenses went up due to childcare, needing a bigger house (we'd be mortgage free now if we hadn't had kids) with higher bills associated with it and the food bill with teenagers is horrendous. Holidays require larger properties with multiple bedrooms rather than a single hotel room, and travel for 5 people in the school holidays is much more expensive than travelling outside the school holidays.

Now you can argue that having children is a choice but so is choosing to live alone and holiday alone. When I was single I lived in shared accomodation so my housing costs were far lower than they are now (where I'm paying a far greater share of the housing costs since we have 3 members of the household who don't contribute), and I would holiday with friends at cheap times of year and split the costs so again, much cheaper.__

Beezknees · 21/12/2023 08:33

I have one child and I have more money than my single friend who lives alone paying a mortgage.

Daisies12 · 21/12/2023 08:30

YOU CHOSE TO HAVE KIDS. FFS stop complaining.

OhpoorMe · 21/12/2023 08:08

It’s so tiring when single people complain. Honestly, as parents we just get on with it.

Erm. Have you been on mumsnet before?!

AfraidToRun · 21/12/2023 07:44

You have more options but less money.

One of you loses your job, you have the other to fall back. Same with pensions. If you want a career change with temp reduction in salary, your partner can do overtime to make it up.

LumiB · 21/12/2023 07:38

End of the day if you are childfree and sine you are penalised for it your whole life and its expensive.

A simple example is council tax, lets take two households living next to each other:

House A has 2 adults both earning £35k
House B has 1 adult earning £35k
Council tax is £100 per month

House A - each adult pays £50
House B - adult pays £75 with single person discount

Both houses retire same time and require adult social care to be funded by council

Look who had paid in more..the single person yet its the 2 adult household that will require more money from the council and per person have paid in less.

This is just one example of why as a single children person you are always financially disadvantaged/ penalised for your lifestyle choice.

There has never been one single budget where a single childfree person has had a financial benefit given to them as a group, with rhe exception of the recent help we had paying our energy bill but everyone got that so it doesn't really count.

I welcome anyone to come and tell what specific help single childree get other than the disposable income we have left means we can spend it on ourselves. What advantages do we have? We don't even get 50% of council tax!!

Zoomzoomzoomzoom0 · 21/12/2023 07:32

Yes the real difference is being married or not, it was me who brought kids into it. 2 separate financial implications really as pp pointed out.
I actually think I was being unreasonable and they both had a point.
But as I said, I don't compare myself to others generally. A bit random for sure for it to come up twice in a week
We are all early 50s so perhaps all considering how much longer we will be dragging our arses into work.

OP posts:
HAF1119 · 21/12/2023 07:30

I think it's daft for either side to comment personally, therefore you're not unreasonable at finding their comments unnecessary. Possibly unreasonable thinking it's cheaper to be single than to be in a couple with children.

I guess in terms of simplicity - the pension - by the time you get it the children will be adults. So - if you were both renting a £1000 property each - single person would be paying for it with their pension alone, whilst a couple would be paying with a combined pension.

Angrycat2768 · 21/12/2023 07:21

Surely the difference in pensions is being married ir single, not kids. If they were married with no kids they would still be entitled to dome pension. Do they not have their own pensions? No one has ever said this to me. Very odd that 2 people have bemoaned this, especially as you have uour own pension and work!

Zoomzoomzoomzoom0 · 21/12/2023 07:17

Yes I can how post title was misleading, but I did mention in the op that I have a similar job/ financial set up as both women.
What we really needed was a fourth woman to join the conversation, one with a good job, pension, a husband, but no children.
I think I will revert to my original position of not comparing myself to other people at all.

OP posts:
mantyzer · 21/12/2023 03:17

Most older single people I know are not well off. Being in a couple and pooling resources makes a big difference.

WandaWonder · 21/12/2023 03:07

I would say it is the people that have less money have more kids

Catsmere · 21/12/2023 03:04

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 21/12/2023 01:05

But being child free USUALLY enables you to work and get the higher income.

The Australian carer pension is more than unemployment benefits, although still low. Way better than what you would get in the UK.

What would happen to you if you stopped getting the carer pension?

I worked for nearly forty years. None of my jobs were high income. Best I ever had was $32 000 twenty years ago. Working itself doesn't mean higher income - look at all the people stuck in minimum wage jobs. The carer pension I've been on isn't much less than what my last job paid. And getting work once you're over forty can be damn difficult.

If I'm no longer my mother's carer it will be the dole. It's seven years before I can get the age pension. The dole won't even cover the rent. I'll have to hope the Victorian government work program that targets getting particular groups into work (women over 45 in my case) will help.

sammylady37 · 21/12/2023 01:15

You’d want to be pretty stupid to not realise that it isn’t as simple as “no kids means more money”. There are individual circumstances that obviously dictate whether that’s actually the case.

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 21/12/2023 01:05

Catsmere · 20/12/2023 21:21

You're assuming childfree people are on a good wage. I'm single and childfree and now live on a carer pension (Australian). I have less money than most people I know, and they all had children.

But being child free USUALLY enables you to work and get the higher income.

The Australian carer pension is more than unemployment benefits, although still low. Way better than what you would get in the UK.

What would happen to you if you stopped getting the carer pension?

Iouis · 21/12/2023 00:55

Why on earth does anyone know about your husbands pension? Maybe it's time to change the things you're talking about with them.

Nevermind31 · 21/12/2023 00:24

i suppose out of two couples earning the same the one without kids have more disposable income. That is a fact, regardless of the couple with kids having chosen to have them.
out of a couple and a single person, of course the couple is better off as they have two incomes. And I suppose in a morbid way you could say that a widow/er is going to be better off because the surviving spouse will get the pension payout, should the spouse have a pension.
still, not really a plan for retirement… they could divorce…
in any case, a very odd comment from friends

Ktime · 21/12/2023 00:17

RendeersDancingTowardsChristmas · 20/12/2023 23:58

I don't think people without kids have more money. How can they, if they are in similar jobs earning similar wages?
What they do have is more money to spend on themselves!

A big proportion of parents disposable income is spent on their children. So, the majority of parents do have less money to spend on themselves.

I think your friends who referred to your DH pension, could invest some of their disposable income to bump up their pension!

But it’s really not single people’s problem that parents have less money to spend on themselves.

So many threads on MN where parents expect their single relatives and friends to fund their child’s Christmas, birthday, house purchase or university life.

coffeeaddict77 · 21/12/2023 00:16

Ktime · 20/12/2023 23:47

For every idiot who thinks people with kids have more money there is an idiot who thinks single people have more money.

So it evens out.

What’s indisputable is that a working couple on the same salaries as a single person will have more money than the single person.

So couples who give their single relatives one present whilst expecting two presents should cop on.

Edited

It's not indisputable as the single person without children will have been able to save more when younger (as not spending on children) and pay more into a pension. I don't think it costs that much more to live if single than a couple by pension age either if a homeowner.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 21/12/2023 00:12

Of course having kids is more expensive than not having any. I’m still surprised that many people are surprised by this! The same with Single people without partners to share expenses.

I see it every day in real life and here… people shocked that couples without children have more disposable income. I mean it really is simple math, right?

RendeersDancingTowardsChristmas · 20/12/2023 23:58

I don't think people without kids have more money. How can they, if they are in similar jobs earning similar wages?
What they do have is more money to spend on themselves!

A big proportion of parents disposable income is spent on their children. So, the majority of parents do have less money to spend on themselves.

I think your friends who referred to your DH pension, could invest some of their disposable income to bump up their pension!

Ktime · 20/12/2023 23:47

For every idiot who thinks people with kids have more money there is an idiot who thinks single people have more money.

So it evens out.

What’s indisputable is that a working couple on the same salaries as a single person will have more money than the single person.

So couples who give their single relatives one present whilst expecting two presents should cop on.