Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think this should be more than enough to live of?

155 replies

Jennyscarkey · 20/12/2023 20:20

I am feeling really shit at the moment. I never seem to have any money and I work long hours and thought I had a decent income. I’m one of the lowest paid in my team but I came from a poor background and I’m just grateful to have had the opportunity to earn more than minimum wage. Yet even though I earn more than I ever thought possible for someone like me and where I grew up, I don’t think I can manage my money at all? My take home pay is 3,600. I am a single parent and also get 300 on top of this for maintenance. My rent is 900 and my little girl goes to nursery full time and that costs 1,400 a month. I claim the tax free part. I don’t have other outgoings expect 200 a month on a loan and usual utilities. Don’t have sky or Netflix etc.

I have gone through my cards to see what I’m spending and honestly it is just food, petrol, entry to soft play or a lunch here and there. I don’t buy clothes or make up or go on holiday. I was paid again yesterday and I had 2 pounds left before the money came in. I just don’t know where I am going wrong? I will never be able to afford a mortgage at the way this is going.

OP posts:
BarbaraofSeville · 21/12/2023 08:49

Like others have said, it sounds like you're spending a fortune on food and 'bits'. A tenner a day leaking away on nothing is £300 pm.

You need to review everything as lots of little savings will add up and make a big difference

Do a money makeover and potentially save £1,000s - Money Saving Expert

For food, do you waste a lot? Eat expensive things all the time (fresh fish, imported fruit and veg etc?). Do you get toiletries and cleaning products when on offer or do you buy more expensive brands when you need them?

If you shopped more frugally, you could probably cut loads off your grocery bill without a noticeable difference in what you buy. Get whatever is on offer, or shop in Aldi/Lidl.

Set a budget for your lunches out and soft play etc. If you're doing these things regularly, the cost can really add up. You earn a decent salary, but not so much that you can spend what you like all the time without any effort to control the cost.

But there's light at the end of the tunnel. When your DC goes to school, you'll only need to pay for wraparound care, and your disposable income will increase significantly. But definitely do a benefit check today, with high rent and childcare costs, you may be entitled to some top ups and however small it is, every little helps and might entitle you to extra cost of living payments that are paid to everyone on UC.

threelittlescones · 21/12/2023 08:43

@Needsomesupport84

Everyone's circumstances are different. With UC there's no set income limit. Your research is incorrect.

Needsomesupport84 · 21/12/2023 08:21

Ooos just realised it says monthly

to think this should be more than enough to live of?
Needsomesupport84 · 21/12/2023 08:10

FlemCandango · 21/12/2023 08:03

I do benefit calculations as part of my day job. If the op is taking home £3600/m she could be entitled to claim UC. As she will have a work allowance, is paying rent and child care costs. Running those figures through a benefits calculator I can see a potential claim. The amount will depend on the exact figures.

The key is that she is paying rent so much will depend on where she lives and what proportion of her £900 rent can be included in her claim. The local housing allowance for a 2 bedroom property in her area will determine the maximum housing element under UC.

UC is replacing WTC/ CTC so working people with children and child care costs often can claim some UC, usually a relatively low amount. But it is always worth checking.

Really? Because type the info into any benefits calculator and you will be told you are not entitled to claim because your income is too high.

the government don’t pay benefits just because you’ve chosen to rent an expensive property. I would be shocked if any person on the OP’s salary would be entitled to anything at all. It’s classed as a high salary - higher than what 90% of the population earns.

FlemCandango · 21/12/2023 08:03

I do benefit calculations as part of my day job. If the op is taking home £3600/m she could be entitled to claim UC. As she will have a work allowance, is paying rent and child care costs. Running those figures through a benefits calculator I can see a potential claim. The amount will depend on the exact figures.

The key is that she is paying rent so much will depend on where she lives and what proportion of her £900 rent can be included in her claim. The local housing allowance for a 2 bedroom property in her area will determine the maximum housing element under UC.

UC is replacing WTC/ CTC so working people with children and child care costs often can claim some UC, usually a relatively low amount. But it is always worth checking.

MintJulia · 21/12/2023 08:00

3900 income
-1400 childcare
-900 rent
-200 loan and utilities
-??? council tax
-??? phone/broadband/subscriptions/tv licence
-??? insurance
-??? transport or car payments/car tax/MOT/petrol?

Those are my basics.

£150 a week supermarket shop seems very high. I feed us well (me and a teen ds who eats endlessly) on about £60 a week, including shampoo & cleaning stuff.

Needsomesupport84 · 21/12/2023 08:00

FUPAgirl · 21/12/2023 07:55

Pretty relieved here to hear that the previous poster was incorrect regarding UC!

Yeah. Not too keen on my tax payments propping up the affluent middle classes. My sister and her husband are both on around 30k, their combined income is less than the OP’s. They have checked and are entitled to nothing beyond child benefit. As if the government just doles out hundreds a month to anyone who wants it even if they take home nearly 4 k a month 😂

Augustus40 · 21/12/2023 07:58

Childcare does not magically stop once at school. Three months a year they are off school and then there are school clubs term times until secondary years!'re

Though it will cost less than now it will still be a monthly outlay.

FUPAgirl · 21/12/2023 07:55

Pretty relieved here to hear that the previous poster was incorrect regarding UC!

Needsomesupport84 · 21/12/2023 07:49

@threelittlescones

I did a search again and, no, someone of OP’s salary is not entitled to claim UC. Unsurprisingly. She is a higher rate tax payer ffs. Why would someone earning well over 60k per annum, more than three times minimum wage be entitled to claim benefits? Millions live on so so much less even when both parents are in work.

Needsomesupport84 · 21/12/2023 07:35

threelittlescones · 21/12/2023 06:52

@Needsomesupport84 @Motnight

If you're referring to me then I provided the breakdown that proves it's possible to receive UC on a high salary.

okay interesting because I remember searching and being entitled to no help with childcare costs when single and earning 30- something thousand and genuinely struggling.

ItAintGonnaGoDownEasyIfItAintCheezy · 21/12/2023 07:17

XmasPartyhat · 20/12/2023 20:38

Have you looked into applying for Universal Credit? As a single parent who is renting, you may be eligible for a proportion of your childcare costs at least.

UC? With an income of 4k a month? 😂😂😂😂

I really hope my tax pennies aren't being dished out to people taking home practically double what I am. Jesus christ.

She should well be able to live off that.

threelittlescones · 21/12/2023 06:52

@Needsomesupport84 @Motnight

If you're referring to me then I provided the breakdown that proves it's possible to receive UC on a high salary.

Motnight · 21/12/2023 06:31

Needsomesupport84 · 21/12/2023 04:46

3600 take home pay is a salary of about 65-70 grand gross a year. And someone on here suggested you should apply for universal credit 😂

I was thinking that 🤔

Pipsquiggle · 21/12/2023 06:20

Nursery years are hard. I remember virtually having no savings for several years. The nursery fees just wiped them out.

How old is your DC? Are you still buying nappies/ baby milk?

Meal planning and dot-com shopping is the way forward

Seaitoverthere · 21/12/2023 05:39

As others have said you need to get a handle on your expenditure and start a proper budget. You need to include every thing such as car tax, MOT, ar servicing, car insurance, house insurance, utilities, insurance, council tax, Christmas, birthdays, a budget for social activities , clothes, haircuts, dentistry etc. Work out the annual total and divide by 12 and this sum goes aside each month to be added to rent, childcare and loan and then you can see where you are at and then work out a sensible food budget. .There are spreadsheets available online to use.

Personally I wouldn’t go to Aldi and shops online with a weekly delivery after planning out your food for the week making sure you have covered 3 meals a day for you both.

If you can get a handle on spending now then when childcare reduces you will have money available to save in the future.

Mmmm19 · 21/12/2023 05:30

@HewasH2O its lot more than 47k gross. 60k gross if no student loan or pension, above 70k If there is loan and pension coming off. I know as recently went up from 47k to around that and was surprised by take home went up less than Half of gross

OP it does sound loads on paper but two lot lower salaries combined with less tax could have 4-5k combined which would make all the difference as only food and eating out is more as a couple the other costs would be the same. Also the cost of living crisis is a a real killer for everyone but we are lucky it’s mainly affecting luxuries rather than essentials. Budget a bit better in the shop and hang in there till nursery finished, as apps say that will be 1k more per month.

and yes another one laughing at the cluelessness of those suggesting universal credit. The OP won’t even be eligible for child benefit

PepperIsHere · 21/12/2023 05:29

Being a single parent is a hell of a lot more difficult than being in a partnership; there is literally no-one else to cook when you're sick, or anyone to care for the child when they're sick, or any number of supports that so many people take for granted.

It's v easy for people in partnerships to talk loftily of saving money by never eating out but if the OP never went out she'd never get to chat with another adult. I don't think £20 a week on an occasion that brings companionship and a break from drudgery is a waste, I'd see that as self care. Enjoy it.

The opportunities for reducing spending are probably in places like finding new providers for insurance, WiFi, phone etc

How long will it take you to pay off the loan?

I recommend opening separate accounts for each expense e.g. power, insurances, WiFi & phone, car (include all costs across the year), loan, Christmas & birthdays, and open a savings one too. My bank let's me do this at no cost.

On payday, I pay into each account accordingly. I also have the direct debits coming from the individual accounts so they sorta tick away on their own. For example, with my car costs, I only need to pay service every 6 months but the money is always there, it's never an unexpected cost. Even haircuts, shoes etc need to be accounted for. Stick £50 into the savings account and forget about it.

With regards to food shopping, could you try shopping online instead? In that way, it's easier to stick to your list. Perhaps settle on 3 regular meals that you'll eat each week and always keep the ingredients on hand. On the weekend, make twice as much as you'd eat and freeze half for a week night.

Try making one change a week, perhaps, so you don't feel overwhelmed. In about 3 months, you should notice that things are more manageable.

OMGitsnotgood · 21/12/2023 05:23

Those saying you need to cut down your lunches/ shopping bill are a little short-sighted. OK, so you could save £150-200 a month. That's about £2000-2500 a year. Yes it's a decent amount. It's not enough to get you a mortgage anytime soon, though.

So are you suggesting OP just continues spending as she is? Yes, there is no quick fix to getting on the property ladder, realistically OP unlikely to be able to afford to buy until she stops paying nursery fees. Still, it's not short sighted to encourage her to look at what seems like a ridiculously high supermarket spend for one adult who says she skips lunch and a pre-schooler who will have some meals at nursery. £2500 a year is a healthy contribution to a deposit.

autienotnaughty · 21/12/2023 05:09

Stop doing lunches then and go Aldi for your food shop. Try to do one big shop for say £80 and then milk/bread etc £20 a week. Have a set budget for petrol and outings.
Plus there will be things like Xmas . December is typically a expensive month.

Have you checked if you are entitled to universal credit? Are you getting child benefit ? that's another £85 a month. Do you pay single occupancy council tax?

Are you ok with computers? Id set a spreadsheet up write down what goes out and keep track.

You are on a good wage but you are also a single parent with high nursery fees. If your ex still lived with you and earned similar you would have more spare cash.

When you get the 30 free hours (at 2 or 3?) you will be better off for it.

GreatGateauxsby · 21/12/2023 04:49

It can be depressing. Nursery fees and the debt will stop. Eventually 😅

I took our monthly outings for everything (mortgage bills, utilities, food, petrol) if I assume half costs and inc 100% of childcare I’d be doing £4.1k. our mortgage is higher than your rent adjusting for that
I’d be at 3.9k.

we live “slightly better than average” despite our income supposedly putting us in the top 10% but... I’m pretty thrifty. Coffee is a rare treat, lunch out maybe once a month?

so you aren’t doing anything wildly “wrong”

maybe some tweaks.

Food
We spend about £120 - 140 for 2 adults a toddler and a dog.
as others said check out food budget there are gains to be made there. We do combo of Aldi and online I find this the best.
Meal planning helps.

your lunches out if you can aim for £10-15 caps on those.

your child
in terms of activities I do soft play maybe once every 3 months. Generally it’s free stuff…I have a great puddlesuit for dd, a reusable coffee cup and an encyclopaedic knowledge of local playgrounds… for summer it’s splashparks.
we basically only do paid stuff for Easter, Halloween and xmas and then I am still quite fussy/cheap 🙈

almost all DDs clothes are 2nd hand I do bundles on what’s app groups and vinted.
i resell individually anything i dislike.
then once worn I also resell everything I can before offer to friends for free /donate so that funds the next lot. I put in about £50 max for the years clothes (this is usually shoes)

Needsomesupport84 · 21/12/2023 04:46

3600 take home pay is a salary of about 65-70 grand gross a year. And someone on here suggested you should apply for universal credit 😂

banjocat · 21/12/2023 04:45

Jennyscarkey · 20/12/2023 20:42

@FaiIureToLunch if I stopped lunches that would be a saving of a around 100 a month. God it feels grim! Thought I would be free to do whatever when I got promoted and I just feel like I’m only just staying afloat

I'm sorry to hear your situation OP. So many people in their 30's and 40's at the moment simply can't get on the housing ladder through no fault of their own.

Those saying you need to cut down your lunches/ shopping bill are a little short-sighted. OK, so you could save £150-200 a month. That's about £2000-2500 a year. Yes it's a decent amount. It's not enough to get you a mortgage anytime soon, though.

You'd have to live this meagre existence for at least the next 10 years to save a deposit.

It's bloody miserable.

On the plus side, the nursery fees will stop before too long and then you will free up a big chunk to save.

shivawn · 21/12/2023 04:38

It's the nursery fees that are killing your budget OP. Hopefully those will drop in the next couple years and free up more disposable income for you? Your wages are good but I completely understand that it's so difficult these days when everything is so expensive and there's always something new to pay for.

OMGitsnotgood · 21/12/2023 04:32

I have looked at all my cards and it’s supermarket costs coming out high but I’m literally buying the basics, last week it shows 140 on Tesco and 30 in Morrison’s which includes everything like shampoo, cleaning products, food etc

Take a good hard look at what you are buying. We are 4 adults, eat well and spend less all in than you are spending on 'the basics' for one adult and a preschooler, who will also be getting some meals at nursery. That includes lunches for two of us and you aren't eating lunch.