Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think this should be more than enough to live of?

155 replies

Jennyscarkey · 20/12/2023 20:20

I am feeling really shit at the moment. I never seem to have any money and I work long hours and thought I had a decent income. I’m one of the lowest paid in my team but I came from a poor background and I’m just grateful to have had the opportunity to earn more than minimum wage. Yet even though I earn more than I ever thought possible for someone like me and where I grew up, I don’t think I can manage my money at all? My take home pay is 3,600. I am a single parent and also get 300 on top of this for maintenance. My rent is 900 and my little girl goes to nursery full time and that costs 1,400 a month. I claim the tax free part. I don’t have other outgoings expect 200 a month on a loan and usual utilities. Don’t have sky or Netflix etc.

I have gone through my cards to see what I’m spending and honestly it is just food, petrol, entry to soft play or a lunch here and there. I don’t buy clothes or make up or go on holiday. I was paid again yesterday and I had 2 pounds left before the money came in. I just don’t know where I am going wrong? I will never be able to afford a mortgage at the way this is going.

OP posts:
Augustus40 · 21/12/2023 15:12

Salmon fillets is luxury food.

Jennyscarkey · 21/12/2023 15:02

My food shop is stuff like salmon fillets, mince beef, chicken, yoghurt, veg, biscuits. I don’t think it’s anything out of the ordinary but I’m very much open to suggestions

OP posts:
Pluvia · 21/12/2023 14:54

This is a single parent on £67k, so the other 36% of her salary is worth an awful lot more than most peoples'.

Jennyscarkey · 21/12/2023 14:42

pumpkinfarm · 21/12/2023 08:54

£300 maintenance?? How can these men get away with this. Surely at the very least (morally if not legally) he should be paying half of your childcare costs? Does he have joint custody?

@pumpkinfarm no he is here once a fortnight for a day. I have asked him to do more but says he can’t. I’ve also asked about nursery and he says he will try and pay 50 quid more a month next year but he’s not confirmed yet

OP posts:
IgnoranceNotOk · 21/12/2023 14:22

Could you get a soft play membership or for somewhere you could visit often. It’s expensive as a one off cost but then you have it all year.

Take more packed lunches out with you. Eating out is extortionate and as nice as it is when you have little kids it’s the first thing to go. Not many people eat out regularly,

Also what are you buying in your food shop?? Maybe go for a lower brand as this will have a bit impact and meal plan so you’re not wasting anything. We don’t spend that much as a family of 4 and we don’t have your income.

FlemCandango · 21/12/2023 14:01

I would suggest that a single parent paying 64% of monthly income in rent and childcare is likely to be struggling. But maybe that is just me. Benefits that are in recognition of housing and childcare are exactly how redistribution of tax should work. In my opinion. The attitude displayed on this thread is dismaying as there are real issues of inequality and poverty in the UK which are in no way caused by situations like the ops which will be short lived. And she will not be getting any additional support through benefits once her child is in school.

Pluvia · 21/12/2023 11:51

The op may be able to get a bit of UC but it is less than she is paying out each month in tax.

I've paid income tax every year of a 43-year-long working life and never qualified for benefits. And indeed, was never in desperate need and so wouldn't have sought them. I was only ever in a higher rate tax band for a couple of years in all that time, so I've never been what most people would consider well off — but despite that I'd guess I'm better off than 60% of the population. The idea that because I've paid in I'm entitled to benefits has never crossed my mind. Benefits are supposed to be a safety net for those struggling at the bottom, surely, not for those who are managing okay.

And OP, I echo what others have said: you're doing well and by managing your money better you can build the savings you're aiming for. Starting off with a child or a new mortgage is always going to be hard, but it will get easier. The trick is learning to manage your money more carefully. Benefits can be withdrawn or changed at any time but if you know how to budget you'll always be fine.

FlemCandango · 21/12/2023 11:27

ItAintGonnaGoDownEasyIfItAintCheezy · 21/12/2023 11:00

Yep. This is why rents are so high. In the 90s before caps came in and councils would just pay whatever, that pushed rents up because landlords took the piss, and this is why we are where we are today.

The fact that someone earning so much could be entitled to UC is fucking disgusting and anyone on that sort of money claiming it should be ashamed of themselves imo.

Totally disagree there. The "fucking disgusting" thing about benefits is how people are literally starving in the UK because they don't have enough to live on. The op may be able to get a bit of UC but it is less than she is paying out each month in tax. The only reason she will get some UC is that she is working and earning enough not to be impacted by the benefits cap. If she lives in an expensive part of the UK her LHA may be high enough to mean she gets some help.

The high costs of child care and rent in the UK are a problem will not be solved by lowered benefits rates.

ItAintGonnaGoDownEasyIfItAintCheezy · 21/12/2023 11:00

Pluvia · 21/12/2023 10:25

I'm really struggling to get my head around a benefits system that offers hundreds of pounds each month to someone on £60k+ who's spending £200pw on food and groceries for themselves and a small child...

So is this why rents are going up? Because people in rentals can always claim more on UC?

Yep. This is why rents are so high. In the 90s before caps came in and councils would just pay whatever, that pushed rents up because landlords took the piss, and this is why we are where we are today.

The fact that someone earning so much could be entitled to UC is fucking disgusting and anyone on that sort of money claiming it should be ashamed of themselves imo.

Wonderwoman333 · 21/12/2023 10:48

How do you think people on minimum wage manage to live?!

LardyCakeAgain · 21/12/2023 10:32

I think you're doing really bloody well, well done. Single parenting, working to keep you both afloat, paying all the childcare, rent and bills on your own, that's huge in such a shitty economy! You actually deserve a pat on the back, there are so many others who falter in this situation and just give up, it takes so much energy.

Just keep in mind - those higher paid folks had to start somewhere, like you're doing now. Keep your eyes open for any opportunities to climb the ladder - e.g. internal training courses to build your skills, vacancies for the next step up, either internally or elsewhere. Make sure your management team know who you are & what you do - if you can get childcare to go to a works social event and make contacts which will be useful later, take advantage.

Pluvia · 21/12/2023 10:25

I'm really struggling to get my head around a benefits system that offers hundreds of pounds each month to someone on £60k+ who's spending £200pw on food and groceries for themselves and a small child...

So is this why rents are going up? Because people in rentals can always claim more on UC?

WouldBeMrMicawber · 21/12/2023 10:05

Happierwithouthim · 20/12/2023 22:04

Are you throwing out food at end of week? This is literally money in the bin.

Do a click & collect or food delivery once a week and stay out of the shops. Milk freezes & thaws overnight. If you're not in the shop getting bread/milk you won't be spending the ten or twenty.

Do you smoke? If so cut back or cut out if possible

I wanted to be debt free, started with a spreadsheet in 2016, got YNAB the year after, achieved it in 2020. Divorced in 2021 & bought my own house following this, I did have deposit from my half of sale of family home. I wouldn't have managed it otherwise.

Childcare has reduced this year with dd being in secondary school. It's a big help.

Another recommendation for YNAB here! I started last month after reading the support thread on it in the Money Matters section on here and it has already made such a difference to my attitude to money, because it makes you not just really look at where every penny goes, but also control your financial decisions more deliberately. That disappearing money thing just stops happening. You could also do the same thing with a spreadsheet, if you prefer.

TrashedSofa · 21/12/2023 09:59

BarbaraofSeville · 21/12/2023 09:57

It certainly makes a mockery of the £50k CB rule as it's likely that the OP is entitled to UC because she's considered to need help, but at the same time won't receive CB because she earns 'too much'.

It is an utterly ridiculous situation. Not least because the CB system is bullshit. The title of that Resolution Foundation report I linked to is 'Inconsistent Incentives' which I thought was quite apt.

BarbaraofSeville · 21/12/2023 09:57

It certainly makes a mockery of the £50k CB rule as it's likely that the OP is entitled to UC because she's considered to need help, but at the same time won't receive CB because she earns 'too much'.

TrashedSofa · 21/12/2023 09:55

ladygindiva · 21/12/2023 09:52

I find that hard to believe as I'm entitled to around 900 on a 1100 per month wage . Also have used turn 2 us website many many times.

Doesn't mean anything without also factoring in rent and childcare costs. That's not the way the system works. Someone who earns more than you can be entitled to more than you.

TrashedSofa · 21/12/2023 09:52

I would be shocked if any person on the OP’s salary would be entitled to anything at all. It’s classed as a high salary - higher than what 90% of the population earns.

Prepare to be shocked, then. I don't know about OP specifically, but there are people whose salaries are so high they pay 40% tax and still get UC.

https://chasedeveremedical.co.uk/universal-credit-eligibility-expands-to-higher-rate-taxpayers/

https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/publications/inconsistent-incentives/

You do need to have high childcare and rent costs to be a high earner and still eligible, but it's most definitely a thing.

Universal Credit eligibility expands to higher rate taxpayers

https://chasedeveremedical.co.uk/universal-credit-eligibility-expands-to-higher-rate-taxpayers

ladygindiva · 21/12/2023 09:52

AllTheChaos · 21/12/2023 08:58

Well! I tried the Turn2Us website, put in the details Op has provided (so assumed a £55k income, no pension, and used my own council tax liability), and it said she’d be eligible for more than £900 a month!

I find that hard to believe as I'm entitled to around 900 on a 1100 per month wage . Also have used turn 2 us website many many times.

zendeveloper · 21/12/2023 09:51

Many people assume your childcare costs will disappear when your daughter starts school, but this is not true. You can go down from 1400 to say 600-700 for a wrap around childminder, but there's no way it goes down to zero.

Baffledandalarmed · 21/12/2023 09:35

Ultimately @Jennyscarkey it’s prioritisation. What matters more, expensive food shops and meals with friends or mortgage and a home?

I saved up enough for a deposit for my house when my full time job gave me £1,600 a month after tax. You have to make sacrifices to get on the property ladder (not saying this to beat you up, but after my rent and bills I had £1K - same as you, but I saved £800 of it). You know you’re going wrong somewhere so that’s a start.

Meal plan.
Stop the coffees.
Stop lunches.
Walk instead of drive.

It all makes a difference. I know lunches out are nice and eating good food is nice…but realistically you’re spending £200+ a week on food for you and DC. That’s bonkers. I don’t even spend that now and I buy organic, And have two large dogs to feed (they cost £130 a week!). Start by cutting down on what you’re buying food wise and the money will start adding up. :)

FlemCandango · 21/12/2023 09:01

As I said benefits knowledge is my job. Of course it is impossible to prove that in any meaningful way in an anon forum 😅

I don't use online benefits calculators I have custom software to make calculations and I know my benefits knowledge is correct. But rubbish in rubbish out so the accuracy of a projection depends on the inputs (like completely accurate info on income and location).

Op it is tough out there at the moment, get any help you can and good luck.

AllTheChaos · 21/12/2023 08:58

Well! I tried the Turn2Us website, put in the details Op has provided (so assumed a £55k income, no pension, and used my own council tax liability), and it said she’d be eligible for more than £900 a month!

Tohaveandtohold · 21/12/2023 08:55

The only thing I can see you’re spending much more on is the food shopping, you should not be spending that much in the supermarket for just an adult and a child.
If you can’t change that, you just need to wait till you’re no longer paying £1400 for nursery. That’s a killer even for a 2 income household. When you DD starts school, you’ll have at least £1000 extra that you can save for a mortgage so it’s just a matter of being patient till then and just to get some extra funds now, reduce what you spend on the food shopping.

pumpkinfarm · 21/12/2023 08:54

£300 maintenance?? How can these men get away with this. Surely at the very least (morally if not legally) he should be paying half of your childcare costs? Does he have joint custody?

BarbaraofSeville · 21/12/2023 08:52

Forgot to say, if you find 'food' a chore, Gousto/Hello Fresh might help as it will mean your main meals are taken care of. It's expensive, but not as much as popping into the supermarket for some bits and spending over £100 on things you don't need. Or try Lollipop, which is a similar experience, but your shopping comes from Sainsbury's so is normal grocery prices.