Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Police to be given right to use photos from driving license and maybe passport for facial recognition

87 replies

cakeorwine · 20/12/2023 20:08

Police to be able to run face recognition searches on 50m driving licence holders | Facial recognition | The Guardian

Interesting.
The Government has pictures of our faces for passports and driving licenses. A clause in a new criminal justice bill will allow the police to have access to these pictures for matching against facial recognition. Pick an image up with a camera and the police will be able to use these pictures to identify the person.

Assuming the facial recognition technology can be trusted.

OTOH - it's useful for catching suspects.

But OTOH, how many people will end up on a database and watch list for taking part in protests, demonstrations - and who knows where that will end.

Facial recognition is being used to scan crowds for people the police are after.

The EU had proposed similar but dropped it due it being a disproportionate breach of privacy.

I suspect that I might end up on a database because of some of my political views. Probably on it already. Heck, they probably already have my picture from the DVLA anyway.

But do we really give our photos to the Government so they can be used to catch criminals?

Police to be able to run face recognition searches on 50m driving licence holders

Exclusive: Privacy campaigners say clause in new criminal justice bill will put all UK drivers on ‘permanent police lineup’

https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2023/dec/20/police-to-be-able-to-run-face-recognition-searches-on-50m-driving-licence-holders

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
5
Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 21/12/2023 14:35

@Fieldofbrokenpromises which is why it needs oversight, checks and balances and be freely held up to scrutiny any data it gives/finds. Nothing is ever perfect.
This technology is already out there and being used, all the criminal justice act is doing is allowing police slightly quicker access than they currently already have to do what enforcement and other agencies have already been doing for decades. It’s nothing new, just a little faster to get the same result.

Fieldofbrokenpromises · 21/12/2023 14:21

auburnglow788 · 20/12/2023 22:19

People use face recognition and/or finger print to open their phones.

Which goes to the point I made earlier. The tech is much more reliably able to answer the question “is this fingerprint/face one of a small number allowed to open this phone”. It becomes much less reliable (and therefore prone to incorrect results) the larger the database of possible candidates is.

Almost everyone trotting out the trite “nothing to hide” line seems to imagine that the tech is 100% reliable 100% of the time, and it isn’t.

If people insist on treating this tech as if it was, say modern day DNA evidence*, there will be miscarriages of justice.

*there have been cases of mistaken identity using DNA evidence when it was in it’s infancy.

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 21/12/2023 09:51

Yes I am well informed. That’s not a bad thing to be. Information gathering in various forms has been around since life began. To think otherwise is incredibly blinkered. Information is everything.
Your civil liberties are not being hampered by anyone gathering information.

Again, your thinking around being arrested at a protest is wrong. What you need to change is the law which severely restricts our right to protest. The LAW not the technology. Change the law by getting into politics are make a difference. It is law that’s needs scrutinising and safeguarding not technology. Technology is just a tool that the law uses.

If you want the technology to be banned (which will be impossible to do now) think very, very, very, carefully about exactly what that world would look like and just how many civil liberties and the way people can exercise them today and take for granted and as a right to have - they will be gone.

cakeorwine · 21/12/2023 08:44

"Information is the key to prevention of harm to society and as both a means of prosecution and defence."

That sounds like a slippery slope to a proper surveillance society.

Does the prevention of harm outweigh our civil liberties ?

OP posts:
cakeorwine · 21/12/2023 08:43

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 21/12/2023 08:33

@cakeorwine no they aren’t. Politics and this technology are interlinked, but they are very different species. It is a good thing to be able to arrest someone if they are easy to identify, that is not the problem to be addressed. Nor the point of your original post.

Again, it is not the technology you should be worried about, it is already in place and has been for decades, you are never ever going to put that genie back in the bottle. it would be like attempting to rid the world of nuclear technology in all its guises.

Place the emphasis on what can be done, and that is appropriate and robust checks, balances, oversight and regulation. Also campaign for everyone, no matter what side of the law they may be on, no matter what financial situation they have, to be able to access the legal systems equally.

Information is the key to prevention of harm to society and as both a means of prosecution and defence.

if you want to change the laws - get into politics.

Edited

It is not a good thing to be able to easily identify someone at a protest or a demonstration simply by using their photo ID from a driving license.

It is linked together - all part of the surveillance society that we live in. And I have no doubt there is more that we don't know about.

You seem well informed on this subject.

OP posts:
LikeTheMorningDew · 21/12/2023 08:36

The people who say, "I don't mind because I've got nothing to hide."

Probably those who say "I don't care about freedom of speech and thought because I don't think and have fuck all to say."

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 21/12/2023 08:33

@cakeorwine no they aren’t. Politics and this technology are interlinked, but they are very different species. It is a good thing to be able to arrest someone if they are easy to identify, that is not the problem to be addressed. Nor the point of your original post.

Again, it is not the technology you should be worried about, it is already in place and has been for decades, you are never ever going to put that genie back in the bottle. it would be like attempting to rid the world of nuclear technology in all its guises.

Place the emphasis on what can be done, and that is appropriate and robust checks, balances, oversight and regulation. Also campaign for everyone, no matter what side of the law they may be on, no matter what financial situation they have, to be able to access the legal systems equally.

Information is the key to prevention of harm to society and as both a means of prosecution and defence.

if you want to change the laws - get into politics.

cakeorwine · 21/12/2023 08:26

FranticallyFrank · 21/12/2023 08:22

And you don’t even have to arrest them. Facial recognition could be used to punish in other ways. Eg, if you were at a protest you could have your ability to access public transport blocked.

It’s extremely concerning.

Just in case.......

Sorry, you can't come in here. Just in case.

OP posts:
FranticallyFrank · 21/12/2023 08:22

And you don’t even have to arrest them. Facial recognition could be used to punish in other ways. Eg, if you were at a protest you could have your ability to access public transport blocked.

It’s extremely concerning.

cakeorwine · 21/12/2023 08:19

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 20/12/2023 23:43

The laws around protesting are a political argument. The laws are in place and the police can only act in them. Get involved in politics to change them. (And no I don’t agree with this particular law)
Its a separate argument and thread from the police using facial recognition and information gathering.

All part of the same thing.

Much easier to arrest someone if you have been able to easily identify them.

OP posts:
Rummikub · 21/12/2023 00:31

⬆️Exactly.

Neitheronethingnortheother · 21/12/2023 00:30

Lynxeyes123 · 20/12/2023 21:41

At the moment people with darker skin tones are more difficult for the algorhythms to identify. So this discriminates against suspects of lighter skin tones.

No, what's more likely to happen is a non-criminal black person would be mis-identified as a criminal black person in the machine learning equivalent of "all black people look the same"

It wouldn't be "lighter skin toned" people being discriminated against

Rummikub · 21/12/2023 00:11

@OracleofWurms

i do understand that concern that said id still have the machine

its risky to trust those in power to do the right thing. And especially as there’s no guarantees that there is no bias in coding.

VeryGoodVeryNice · 20/12/2023 23:56

For all those saying they have nothing to hide and this is a good thing, remember that crime is a social construct and what is considered a crime or not a crime is a constantly changing situation.

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 20/12/2023 23:43

cakeorwine · 20/12/2023 23:29

Arresting people before they protest just in case?

How does that sound to you?

The laws around protesting are a political argument. The laws are in place and the police can only act in them. Get involved in politics to change them. (And no I don’t agree with this particular law)
Its a separate argument and thread from the police using facial recognition and information gathering.

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 20/12/2023 23:37

@cakeorwine so challenge the system and get it opened up to scrutiny and accountability, make the law and legal system and the political system available for everyone one to use, and get the technology improved etc.
It’s way too late to stop the police and other enforcement agencies from using this technology. Prevention is pointless at this point it’s been around for decades, but it’s not too late to improve regulation, system upgrades and all checks and balances that can be put into place to be done. It has a lot of potential benefits for society.
There are flaws with everything, anything can be used to benefit society just as it can be used against, but information can and should be gathered to ensure the safety of everyone.
A.I and other technological advances can be harnessed for both good and bad, they are here to stay, so campaign for greater oversight and openness around them which might just have a better chance of success, because the chance to ban them has long been lost.

cakeorwine · 20/12/2023 23:29

OracleofWurms · 20/12/2023 23:17

id trust the security services more, besides considering when protests turn to vandalism etc, surley preventing incidents before they happen would be better for society overall ?

or would you rather be reading in the papers, why didnt x do more to prevent it ?

Edited

Arresting people before they protest just in case?

How does that sound to you?

OP posts:
OracleofWurms · 20/12/2023 23:17

cakeorwine · 20/12/2023 23:10

Next time there is a protest, you could be stopped on the way to the protest and detained. To make sure you don't go to the protest.

And they know that from filming you at a protest and deciding that you shouldn't go on the next one.

Of course, the police should be trusted as they never abuse their powers, do they?

Would you trust the police to be able to identify any person they see on a video feed?

id trust the security services more, besides considering when protests turn to vandalism etc, surley preventing incidents before they happen would be better for society overall ?

or would you rather be reading in the papers, why didnt x do more to prevent it ?

FranticallyFrank · 20/12/2023 23:14

You don’t know when the government ideology will no longer align with yours. You might find you are in the wrong side of the law because of what you believe in. Feminists who don’t believe men can become women is a great example. They’re being questioned by the police for expressing a view that few people 10-15 years ago would have ever believed could be contentious never mind illegal.

This is what’s happening in China. Facial recognition is fully embedded there. You can even use it to pay for goods in shops. Scan your face and off you go. What you can’t do is publicly protest if you want to keep your job.

cakeorwine · 20/12/2023 23:10

Next time there is a protest, you could be stopped on the way to the protest and detained. To make sure you don't go to the protest.

And they know that from filming you at a protest and deciding that you shouldn't go on the next one.

Of course, the police should be trusted as they never abuse their powers, do they?

Would you trust the police to be able to identify any person they see on a video feed?

OP posts:
AndThatWasNY · 20/12/2023 23:00

gotomomo · 20/12/2023 20:29

I've got nothing to hide. If they catch the bad guys, good!

What if the people in power decide that fighting for (insert whatever it is you believe in - higher taxes/lower taxes/ more immigration/less immigration/war/no war/rights for ponies/puppies/rabbits/children/women/men etc etc) and you then end up on a database. These lot of politicians decide they are going to arrest all rabbit lovers and you happen to have gone to a protest supporting rabbits. What then? You still happy to be on file?
My grandmother was tortured because her Brother in Law was anti communist. She hadn't even gone to a meeting or demonstration at that point. she was pregnant and very nearly miscarried.
It's a very dangerous road

OracleofWurms · 20/12/2023 22:51

LikeTheMorningDew · 20/12/2023 22:31

This country is so fucked at this point

if there were no criminals then the security services etc and society would not need these tools

OracleofWurms · 20/12/2023 22:50

Rummikub · 20/12/2023 22:33

Pp referenced Person of interest. In that they showed two realities one where the AI went rogue.
I don’t want this in our reality.

i do understand that concern that said id still have the machine

DdraigGoch · 20/12/2023 22:48

cakeorwine · 20/12/2023 20:50

What is "doing anything wrong?"

The police film protests and demonstrations. Is it ok for the police to film protests and then identify people at the protests and demonstrations, just to add to their database.

If the protestors are breaking the law then of course I support anything that makes it easier to bring them to justice. Whether we're talking about Tommy Robinson's thugs or the racists who did this: www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-london-67328715

Duche Sorotzkin

Man subjected to antisemitic abuse after pro-Palestinian protest

Duche Sorotzkin says he was the victim of abuse at Trafalgar Square after Saturday's protest.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-london-67328715

Rummikub · 20/12/2023 22:33

Pp referenced Person of interest. In that they showed two realities one where the AI went rogue.
I don’t want this in our reality.