Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Brianna Ghey.

263 replies

girlfriend44 · 20/12/2023 18:18

Two teenagers found guilty today of murdering Brianna last Feb.

The murder was plotted on their phones. Discussed between them. The girl had a note in her bedroom found on the floor, of the murderous Plan.

The girl had downloaded the dark Web on her phone and was watching violence and gore and was obsessed with serial killers.

Where are the parents in all of this?
They just seemed to have no idea of what their teens are up to and what they are watching?

Parents are paying for the phone, no doubt, shouldn't they take more interest.

What started out as buying a little payg phone so you could contact your child on the way to and from school has gone way too far.

It's horrible out there what's going on?

Rip Brianna. We have a real problem that people are being evil so young,

Also shied been expelled from previous school lovely young lady.
She came to Briannas school and identified her as vulnerable, makes you wonder if there should be more safeguarding too?

If your expelled from school, why should another school want you. In this case it proved fatal.

OP posts:
crumblingschools · 20/12/2023 19:30

@teaandtoastwithmarmite weren't the James Bulger's murderers meant to have been influenced by videos they were allowed to watch by parents

Newyearnamechangehere · 20/12/2023 19:28

@BornIn78 thank you for explaining.

Elvanseshortage · 20/12/2023 19:28

Remember when you didn't step out of line because you were afraid of getting into trouble with your parents?

@girlfriend44

I do remember ‘the good old days’ as I am in my 60s. There were plenty of evil people then too, I don’t think things are worse. Yes I didn’t want to get in trouble with my parents, but my parents had no idea what I was getting up to because they saw a lot less of me than parents do nowadays. Young people, even quite young children, were out without their parents so much more than now. I walked to and from school with friends from the age of 7, played out all day in the summer and was just generally not in the house much. Not because my parents were neglectful but that’s just how it was then. It’s a total myth that parents used to have more control over their children.

The idea that children and young people have to be indoors or tracked all the time is fairly recent and it has come about because we think it is safer that way. As it’s turned out, children are not necessarily safe tucked away in their bedrooms. We have just swapped one set of dangers for another.

Grandmasswag · 20/12/2023 19:27

bellac11 · 20/12/2023 19:21

Kids are looking up disorders for all sorts of things, plus medical disorders and putting on the symptoms, often convincing MH workers at times.

It will be impossible to know if he has ASD because its not true that people with ND disorders cant have or dont have insight into the effects on them. ASD affects veryone so differently

He’s been officially diagnosed with asd, presumably through the NHS given the input he will have had after the murder. suggesting someone can lie to achieve an NHS autism diagnosis is a bit out there. I do think in some rare cases asd can lead to criminal behaviour due to obsessive behaviour. Ie stalking.

ConnectFortyFour · 20/12/2023 19:24

disturbing murders happened before the internet but I do think unfettered access to to internet was a contributing factor in this case. Future generations will judge us for not protecting young people more from it.

on a separate note, I was also was very moved by Briannas mum’s statement. She was amazing

EasternStandard · 20/12/2023 19:23

teaandtoastwithmarmite · 20/12/2023 19:12

Dark web wasn't around when James bulger was killed

Sadly true. In extreme cases there are abhorrent acts

Neriah · 20/12/2023 19:23

Things like this are always complex, and we have minimal insight.

But there's another thread, running to many pages, about how it's WRONG and possibly CRIMINAL ( in an alternative universe) to take a teenagers phone off them after TWO previous warnings, and expect the parent to turn up to school to get it back ( and presumably explain why their little darling doesn't have any rules).

We have entitled generations who think nothing applies to them. Why is anyone surprised that society is breaking down?

crumblingschools · 20/12/2023 19:21

If they were so obsessed surely the parents would have an inkling they had some pretty horrendous ideas

Naptrappedmummy · 20/12/2023 19:21

Zone2NorthLondon · 20/12/2023 19:18

The measure of a civilised society is how we many dysfunction & criminality
Disavow yourself of hang,flog,and shame offenders
We need to have a humane well run prisons and YOI. We have unfit for purpose , crowded and dilapidated, prisons and YOI we need to fix that

Would you be happy for these 2 to be rehabilitated and end up in a flat share with one of your kids?

bellac11 · 20/12/2023 19:21

SoMuchSimpler · 20/12/2023 19:17

He was diagnosed with autism some time after the murder. She was described as having 'autistic traits'.

I'm autistic (diagnosed in my 50s), my DM is autistic, both my DCs are autistic and one of my DGS is awaiting assessment.

In my opinion 'Boy Y' lied throughout his testimony and played the 'autistic card', almost as if he'd been coached on what to say. His testimony's available online and it's very clearly that of someone who knows something about autism but doesn't actually have experience of the 'symptoms' he's describing. If nothing else his apparent self-awareness and knowledge of the effects it has on him are extremely unlikely for a young teenager with autism, particularly when they've only recently been diagnosed.

He's a liar, simple as that.

Kids are looking up disorders for all sorts of things, plus medical disorders and putting on the symptoms, often convincing MH workers at times.

It will be impossible to know if he has ASD because its not true that people with ND disorders cant have or dont have insight into the effects on them. ASD affects veryone so differently

Tiredalwaystired · 20/12/2023 19:19

girlfriend44 · 20/12/2023 18:23

Parents surely need to show some interest though?

They bought the phones. It dosent look likely this would have happened if they hadn't been able to message. The whole plan was decided by message it seems.

Homework is set via app at our school. I don’t know what happens if the child doesn’t have a smart phone, but I guess it’s not common.

There are millions of children NOT murdering who have phones. There are greater issues at play here than technology.

BethDuttonsTwin · 20/12/2023 19:19

DidiAskYouThough · 20/12/2023 18:31

There’s a better thread about this: (by ‘better’ I mean intelligently written and links etc.)
https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womensrights/4967164-guilty-verdict-in-brianna-ghey-case

Edited

Yes only well educated feminists are able to express their ideas and thoughts in any meaningful and acceptable way right?

The snobbery on this website beggars belief at times.

BiscuitsandPuffin · 20/12/2023 19:19

I think YANBU to wonder how they arrived at 15 so warped and broken that they were ready to plan and execute this murder. It wasn't a spur of the moment "impulsive" thing, this was two people with an obsession with murder.
The parents shouldn't have let the children see true crime shit on the TV at such a young age.

The parents should have known where their kids were and what they were doing.

The parents should have brought their children up not to go round planning to kill people and to respect people who were different.

Because while the actions and motivations came from the children, children are a collection of the beliefs, influences and experiences that they have soaked up from everyone around them. And fundamentally, that comes from the parents and what they allow their children to be exposed to.

Parents usually know when their children have additional needs long before diagnosis, even if they don't know what specific diagnosis they'll be given. Due to the (well known) lack of support in this country for SEN children, parents have to take responsibility for actually protecting their SEN children from dangerous influences and ensuring they turn out ok. They're not in complete control of the outcome, but they have enough influence over the early years to make a big difference. Both children were described as having "autistic tendencies" and autistic children have special interests that everyone around them knows about. What did the parents do to redirect their children's macabre interests into something less detrimental from an early age? What did they do to teach them the difference between fantasy and reality, a line many ND people can't see (myself included, as a child)?

You see it all the time on here, people who wake up surprised their teenager is an awful person, and they just cannot see all the junctions before this moment when they could have averted this by parenting better.

So I think the parents did have a role to play here. But I'm not sure it was the phone use that they needed to regulate. These kids started down this path a long time before that.

bellac11 · 20/12/2023 19:18

YouStupidGirl · 20/12/2023 19:12

These teenagers are not normal.

You are putting them in the same category as normal people, with normal regard for acceptable societal behaviours and fear of repercussions.

Upbringing and surroundings is sometimes a factor, sometimes they are just born that way (psychopaths).

They have no fear of punishments/ostracisation - fulfilling their most evil inner desires is probably all they can think about.

It's very difficult to understand when you dont think like that.

Its possibly likely that their conditions led them to be completely obsessed with an idea and fascination of something, in this case, hurting and killing someone.

They werent able to switch that off. Im not sure its about not caring if they got caught, they were wrapped up in the obsession which then became a compulsion. Many ND clients have these traits, usually about very mundane and benign things.

SoMuchSimpler · 20/12/2023 19:18

I'm glad it wasn't just me who spotted his BS @BornIn78

Grandmasswag · 20/12/2023 19:18

Absolutely tragic and disturbing case. I was coincidentally watching a drama last night about Brady/ Hindley. It’s always disconcerting when there are two people involved as you tend to think some lone evil people are just born that way but it’s harder to explain when there are 2 working together. Was one influenced or coerced? Time will likely tell. A bit like the Bulger case.
, I suspect at least one of these young people should never ever be released. RIP Brianna

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 20/12/2023 19:18

YouStupidGirl · 20/12/2023 19:12

These teenagers are not normal.

You are putting them in the same category as normal people, with normal regard for acceptable societal behaviours and fear of repercussions.

Upbringing and surroundings is sometimes a factor, sometimes they are just born that way (psychopaths).

They have no fear of punishments/ostracisation - fulfilling their most evil inner desires is probably all they can think about.

It's very difficult to understand when you dont think like that.

Agree with all of this. Some people are just born bad, regardless of nurture, parents, other socio factors.

Mexicansky · 20/12/2023 19:18

what they did was so far removed from “normal behaviour” I don’t think it can be rationalised by saying weren’t they afraid what their parents would think.

Zone2NorthLondon · 20/12/2023 19:18

The measure of a civilised society is how we many dysfunction & criminality
Disavow yourself of hang,flog,and shame offenders
We need to have a humane well run prisons and YOI. We have unfit for purpose , crowded and dilapidated, prisons and YOI we need to fix that

LindorDoubleChoc · 20/12/2023 19:17

What is your "being unreasonable" question?

EveryKneeShallBow · 20/12/2023 19:17

Gnomegnomegnome · 20/12/2023 19:07

Similar happened before phones/internet.

It’s lazy and ignorant to automatically blame the parents.

Quite. I left school in 1978. While I was in my final year, two boys my age from another school, who lived in my small village committed a hideous crime and were jailed. No mobile phones, they built a den, met there, planned and executed their crime. One of their parents was a doctor, and they lived in the expensive houses on the Ridge. One of the mothers spent most of the rest of her life sedated, in and out of psychiatric care. They were just normal families just like mine before it happened.

SoMuchSimpler · 20/12/2023 19:17

DuckBee · 20/12/2023 18:45

Both had additional needs as reported on BBC news.

He was diagnosed with autism some time after the murder. She was described as having 'autistic traits'.

I'm autistic (diagnosed in my 50s), my DM is autistic, both my DCs are autistic and one of my DGS is awaiting assessment.

In my opinion 'Boy Y' lied throughout his testimony and played the 'autistic card', almost as if he'd been coached on what to say. His testimony's available online and it's very clearly that of someone who knows something about autism but doesn't actually have experience of the 'symptoms' he's describing. If nothing else his apparent self-awareness and knowledge of the effects it has on him are extremely unlikely for a young teenager with autism, particularly when they've only recently been diagnosed.

He's a liar, simple as that.

WhatsInStoreFor2024 · 20/12/2023 19:15

Doubt it will be a significant sentence

bellac11 · 20/12/2023 19:14

Its very difficult because for every situation where someone with additional needs is inappropriate or violent or harmful to others, there is another situation where (often) an adult woman will recall how she was perhaps incorrectly diagnosed with anti social PD (or borderline in the old days) when in fact she had ASD and if only the diagnoses were more accurate in her childhood, she could have had the support she needed etc etc

Yet here, people are sure that this girl, and perhaps the boy, are just plain old psychopaths. They might be.

People also baulk at discussion that their ND disorders could have played a part in why they acted in the way they did. I think thats likely, their view of the world. themselves, their impulses, their social/communication processessing challenges, everything about it

Also these kids didnt get to just be violent and murderous at 15. I think that might be what people mean when linking this to parenting. There are loving parents of kids in prison. There are also far far more feckless, absent and abusive parents of kids in prison. That is more common

Pewpewbarneymcgrew · 20/12/2023 19:13

I suspect they’ll be publicly named when sentenced, it’s not difficult to find out