Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Brianna Ghey.

263 replies

girlfriend44 · 20/12/2023 18:18

Two teenagers found guilty today of murdering Brianna last Feb.

The murder was plotted on their phones. Discussed between them. The girl had a note in her bedroom found on the floor, of the murderous Plan.

The girl had downloaded the dark Web on her phone and was watching violence and gore and was obsessed with serial killers.

Where are the parents in all of this?
They just seemed to have no idea of what their teens are up to and what they are watching?

Parents are paying for the phone, no doubt, shouldn't they take more interest.

What started out as buying a little payg phone so you could contact your child on the way to and from school has gone way too far.

It's horrible out there what's going on?

Rip Brianna. We have a real problem that people are being evil so young,

Also shied been expelled from previous school lovely young lady.
She came to Briannas school and identified her as vulnerable, makes you wonder if there should be more safeguarding too?

If your expelled from school, why should another school want you. In this case it proved fatal.

OP posts:
littlebopeepp234 · 22/12/2023 06:38

Gran0laG1rl · 22/12/2023 06:32

Okaaaay so you repeatedly post at me but are demanding no replies. Sounds reasonable.🤔

It’s you who responded to me in the first place hence why I responded to you! You have completely got the wrong end of the stick about what I was saying so if you are offended then maybe direct that at the poster who was saying that autistic people are capable of murder because they attack their parents rather than responding to my response to that poster and twisting it into something that you seem to think I was implying when I wasn’t!

Gran0laG1rl · 22/12/2023 06:32

Okaaaay so you repeatedly post at me but are demanding no replies. Sounds reasonable.🤔

littlebopeepp234 · 22/12/2023 06:24

Gran0laG1rl · 22/12/2023 06:19

I don’t care who you were replying to what you wrote was inaccurate and offensive.

Ok but don’t jump on my posts in response to another poster then! I’m not replying any further as you have twisted my words and what I was saying!! IT WAS ANOTHER POSTER WHO WAS SAYING THAT AUTISTIC KIDS ARE VIOLENT ATTACK THEIR PARENTS !! Please stop replying to me because if you do I won’t respond, you just seem to be looking for an argument just for arguments sake! Also not completely inaccurate as I have already stated my own DD with diagnosed autism sometimes attacks me!!!!

Gran0laG1rl · 22/12/2023 06:19

I don’t care who you were replying to what you wrote was inaccurate and offensive.

littlebopeepp234 · 22/12/2023 06:18

Gran0laG1rl · 22/12/2023 06:15

Maybe readback your own posts

”The difference is, children with autism and ADHD attack due to an angry outburst out of frustration and their way of dealing with it is to attack”

I was responding to a poster!!! GO FIND THE POST I WAS RESPONDING TO AND READ THAT POST and you will see exactly why I said that sentence, otherwise stop replying to me because I was definitely NOT implying what you seem to think I was!

Gran0laG1rl · 22/12/2023 06:15

Maybe readback your own posts

”The difference is, children with autism and ADHD attack due to an angry outburst out of frustration and their way of dealing with it is to attack”

littlebopeepp234 · 22/12/2023 06:00

Gran0laG1rl · 22/12/2023 05:56

I have autism as do my children. I have never attacked anybody and neither have my children. My dd and I tend to bolt when in fight flight mode, she also self harms. Wording needs to be watched as the way you write your post inferred that it’s common for people with autism to be violent. It isn’t. Up to 20% have outbursts and most aren’t going to be violent towards other people. In my experience of working with children who have autism if you cater for need and make reasonable adjustments which isn’t hard outbursts aren’t common in school settings.

I just knew when autism was mentioned in this case it would be used to demonise ND youngsters.

Just because yours don’t attack, some do. However I was responding to a poster who was saying that kids with autism are violent and attack their parents. And I WAS NOT IMPLYING ANY SUCH THING. Maybe read back at the poster I was responding to first before saying that I was implying things that I wasn’t. My response to that poster was basically that even if they do attack their parents, it’s extremely unlikely to make them a serial killer and that autistic outbursts are purely out of frustration. Some autistic kids can have some intense meltdowns as does my dd, some attack, a lot don’t, however even IF these outbursts lead to murder (which is extremely unlikely) then it wouldn’t because it had been plotted by a pair of disturbed weirdos who had a kill list and got a thrill out of violence and murder

Gran0laG1rl · 22/12/2023 05:56

I have autism as do my children. I have never attacked anybody and neither have my children. My dd and I tend to bolt when in fight flight mode, she also self harms. Wording needs to be watched as the way you write your post inferred that it’s common for people with autism to be violent. It isn’t. Up to 20% have outbursts and most aren’t going to be violent towards other people. In my experience of working with children who have autism if you cater for need and make reasonable adjustments which isn’t hard outbursts aren’t common in school settings.

I just knew when autism was mentioned in this case it would be used to demonise ND youngsters.

Sirzy · 22/12/2023 05:55

Autism or anything else isn’t to blame for what happened but that’s not to say it isn’t a factor in the bigger picture of how it got to that point.

moving away from this case in particular for a second you only have to look at the prison population to see how many people there are neurodiverse and of them how many have been diagnosed later in life. How many of them didn’t get the right support to meet their needs when younger which is how they ended up on the path they did? Again that’s not blaming the additional needs for whatever they have done but it’s accepting it’s a piece of the jigsaw. By finding those common factors it should be able to be used to help prevent others going down the same path - except we still have a system whereby early intervention and support is hard to access.

ds is 14. I am lucky that I have been able to fight to get him what support he needs, he has attended two schools which are able to cater for his needs (helped by the fight I had to get the water tight Ehcp that actually reflects him not a generic one like too many!) . As a result he is doing well and thriving now but I can see how things could have been different if we hadn’t been able to get the diagnosis and support when we did. That early intervention has hopefully set the building bricks for him moving forward whatever that may look like.

sadly the system as it is at the moment fails too many young people. It shouldn’t have to take a parent screaming from the rooftops and taking local authorities to court to get access to basics but it does. Without any blame at all on any parents many parents simply can’t navigate all of that so their children fall through the cracks.

littlebopeepp234 · 22/12/2023 05:46

Gran0laG1rl · 22/12/2023 05:19

“The difference is, children with autism and ADHD attack due to an angry outburst out of frustration and their way of dealing with it is to attack “

So, so untrue The misinformation on heard re autism is just appalling. People with autism generally dont attack even when in fight/flight mode.

Also just to add to my reply to this, I was responding to a poster who was claiming that kids with autism do attack their parents violently so basically implying that autistic people can turn into serial killers - so I was basically saying that autistic people have outbursts from knee jerk reaction due to being frustrated at that moment in time - just like my dd does! But that is unlikely to make an autistic person a serial killer. Those two teenagers had every intention to be a serial killer and didn’t just kill someone after a bout of frustration

littlebopeepp234 · 22/12/2023 05:38

Gran0laG1rl · 22/12/2023 05:19

“The difference is, children with autism and ADHD attack due to an angry outburst out of frustration and their way of dealing with it is to attack “

So, so untrue The misinformation on heard re autism is just appalling. People with autism generally dont attack even when in fight/flight mode.

My dd has autism and is quite high on the spectrum so I am not misinformed thank you very much!!!!!! Also, my dd does not have a nasty bone in her body but once she is in meltdown mode will take a swipe at my face or hair. That is purely out of frustration and upset rather than anger. What I am saying is that blaming autism for this evil murder isn’t really fair to those with autism because they would be unlikely to be the type to plot such an evil calculated murder just because they have autism alone. There is something much deeper than autism going on with those two teens who killed Brianna and I doubt it is anything much to do with autism as an autistic person has a meltdown and lashes out at that moment in time due to frustration, not because they get a kick out of hurting people and plot evil murders

Gran0laG1rl · 22/12/2023 05:19

“The difference is, children with autism and ADHD attack due to an angry outburst out of frustration and their way of dealing with it is to attack “

So, so untrue The misinformation on heard re autism is just appalling. People with autism generally dont attack even when in fight/flight mode.

Fancycheese · 22/12/2023 05:08

Depriving teenagers of privacy is awful. I can’t believe there are people on here genuinely saying that parents should read all messages their 15 year old has sent/received. If you have an open and honest relationship with your child you don’t need to become MI5. How would you have felt at that age if someone read your diary?

It’s incredibly naive and ignorant to think that parents not checking their child’s phone (or the fact that one of the kids may have SEN!) is what caused this shocking crime. It’s far more complicated and nuanced than that. Anyone on the “technology caused this murder” bandwagon is clearly of questionable cognitive function.

clingon1012 · 22/12/2023 04:38

It's an extremely sad case and I can't say whether it was preventable, but you can't blame the parents for "buying the phones and not checking what they're up to". The "kids" were 15 at the time of the murder - most parents would not be checking up on their kids when they're that age unless they have a reason to be worried which perhaps they didn't as their kids never showed anything on the exterior?

littlebopeepp234 · 22/12/2023 04:31

Boomboom22 · 21/12/2023 15:10

All the parents saying their autistic children are not violent. Ok, but many are, we hear on mn of teens attacking their parents and siblings, we all had our kids removed from classes while chairs are thrown around and ultimately as teachers we all know the rules no longer apply to violence if it is a sen child.
The right to an education has been taken to the extreme in most primary schools to the point it is detrimental to others, then in secondary most spend a lot of time out of lessons.

The difference is, children with autism and ADHD attack due to an angry outburst out of frustration and their way of dealing with it is to attack - these outbursts are usually spur of the moment knee jerk reactions to something they are not happy about. However, the teens who committed this disgusting murder took time to plot what they were going to do in a very cold, callous and calculated way with absolutely no remorse then refused to take accountability for their actions and instead each one blamed the other - that sort of plot to murder and getting a thrill out of it is the work of a psychopath not just a teen with symptoms of autism.

Generally autistic people wouldn’t plot such a cruel attack and have no remorse or guilt. I would say if an autistic person was to commit murder then it would be more to do with an angry outburst at that time rather than a cruel, twisted evil plot. Many autistic individuals do show remorse and feel bad for their actions once they have calmed down. A psychopath doesn’t. So while they may show symptoms of autism, I don’t believe their actions were brought on just because of autism and I feel there is something much more deep and disturbing going through their minds.

justteanbiscuits · 22/12/2023 00:58

@aie " So yes, there is a 99.99% chance that the parents are psychopathic themselves and tortured these children."

That is the wildest conjecture I think I've ever heard!

aie · 22/12/2023 00:53

Violence NEVER emerges out of nowhere.
The mascus, the right-wingers, etc. (in short, people who don't want to read psychology and sociology) love to support the idea that psychopaths are born that way. A nature. A gene. This allows them to NOT have to be aware of how we create a violent being, and by extension, of what they themselves suffered as children in terms of betrayal, mistreatment and emotional neglect to have become adults who praise weapons, repression, discipline, the established order, in short, everything that precisely violates us.
They become the apostles of #denial because they do not want to know what happened to them as children.

In this case, children who develop interests in death, suffering, torture, and who eventually begin to experiment with it on living beings (human or non-human) do not come out of nowhere either. go. We know thanks to psychology (trauma, children abuse, torture,...) that they certainly are children who have experienced things serious enough to be emotionally very seriously marked, to develop these obsessions and these needs to act out (with sadistic enjoyment, etc.) to finally feel like they exist, feel like they are alive.
In short, it is an emotional functioning that is built (through severe mistreatment).

=> So yes, there is a 99.99% chance that the parents are psychopathic themselves and tortured these children.
In the social goal of understanding violence and helping / neutralizing / putting away people who harm others, these should at least be analyzed during the trial, and family taboos on mistreatment are omnipresent children, revealed.

I am not for punishments because it is counterproductive but for high-performance psychological care and isolation from society for people who are locked in this dangerous emotional state.

For the record, we are all "ordinary psychopaths" (as Alice Miller spoke of) since we are against cruelty towards animals...but we eat them without scruples. And we love seeing their flesh broken down and cooked in a thousand ways... while a very small part of our mind knows that there is a problem, that there is torture behind it... but we do not listen to him. That's psychopathy.

The difference is that we are free to decide to stop harming animals overnight, whereas these children are stuck in psychopathic patterns with no possibility of getting out of them (because that would require that they expose themselves emotionally, make themselves vulnerable through compassion, altruism, which are skills that require a lot of courage - because it is stressful to open up to the suffering of others). ...And they don't have these emotional resources in them because of everything they've been through that's broken them.

zaazaazoo · 21/12/2023 22:51

girlfriend44 · 20/12/2023 18:23

Parents surely need to show some interest though?

They bought the phones. It dosent look likely this would have happened if they hadn't been able to message. The whole plan was decided by message it seems.

You do realise don't you that young people virtually live on their phones and parents really do not know what they are doing in them. I'm not sure how old your dc are but if you think you'll know what your teens are up to you are deluded

coffeandrteav · 21/12/2023 22:31

AN358 · 21/12/2023 22:03

If any of those parents had ever picked up their teenage children's phones & had a zip through it-most likely that poor child would still be alive. It was all there in black & white,especially on Girl Y's phone.
Too many parents have decided that the little gadget that can connect to everything bad in the entire world should be entirely in their children's control and they don't make it clear to their teen that at any point they may look at it-it is not for privacy. Your teen shouldn't be writing anything to anybody that you shouldn't be 'allowed' to see.
I said 'most likely' rather than definitely at the start because of course in the past teens could plan awful things face to face. But it's undeniable that this was all made so much easier with phones.
I bet the parents of X &Y would do anything if they could go back in time and be monitoring the phones.
Or if anyone had actually informed Parents X of the supposedly 'common knowledge' their daughter was obsessed with torture and had a 'kill list.' (If they knew this & did nothing,well words fail me)

But snap chat deletes messages so how could a parent read them the police got them back.

The policeman in the podcast said she didn't even speak to her boyfriend the way she spoke to Boy Y. It was well hidden.

That's not to say there isn't anything in her past where bad parenting has occurred. I don't know. But just checking her phone wouldn't have stopped this.

Lougle · 21/12/2023 22:08

The thing I can't get out of my mind was girl X's instruction to Brianna, "Buy a child single ticket to Culcheth.", and the fact that Brianna messaged her Mum to tell her she was on the bus and anxious, but her Mum encouraged her for being brave. It's chilling, given the context of the events that followed.

It's a long time for everyone to wait for the sentencing.

AN358 · 21/12/2023 22:03

If any of those parents had ever picked up their teenage children's phones & had a zip through it-most likely that poor child would still be alive. It was all there in black & white,especially on Girl Y's phone.
Too many parents have decided that the little gadget that can connect to everything bad in the entire world should be entirely in their children's control and they don't make it clear to their teen that at any point they may look at it-it is not for privacy. Your teen shouldn't be writing anything to anybody that you shouldn't be 'allowed' to see.
I said 'most likely' rather than definitely at the start because of course in the past teens could plan awful things face to face. But it's undeniable that this was all made so much easier with phones.
I bet the parents of X &Y would do anything if they could go back in time and be monitoring the phones.
Or if anyone had actually informed Parents X of the supposedly 'common knowledge' their daughter was obsessed with torture and had a 'kill list.' (If they knew this & did nothing,well words fail me)

LonelynSad · 21/12/2023 21:38

Naptrappedmummy · 20/12/2023 18:20

There have always been evil young people, sadly it’s a fringe of human behaviour that is usually only exposed when they kill somebody. Let’s not blame the parents. May Brianna rest in peace.

Of course the parents are partly responsible for how their child has turned out! Goodness me

Gran0laG1rl · 21/12/2023 21:36

Children with autism are more likely to be on the receiving end of violence and bullying.

Gran0laG1rl · 21/12/2023 21:33

Boomboom22

Your post is utter bullshit.

Newyearnamechangehere · 21/12/2023 21:11

Anne Perry had a weird early life didn't she, ill and sent away to the Bahamas with a foster family and then reunited with her family in NZ, then due to be sent away again when her parents were getting divorced. I've always been interested but there's very little recorded she ever said about there murders.

Swipe left for the next trending thread