Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we can avoid the need for full time paid childcare for a while?

130 replies

hopingforbabyy · 20/12/2023 18:12

We’re trying at the moment but just pondering our options, as I will need to return to work after 9-12 months maternity leave and people are having to put their name on waiting lists as soon as they get a BFP around here. I have worked in nurseries before and would not want to leave a young baby there, in my personal opinion.

DM is available and willing to help us out on Mondays and Tuesdays, I am hoping I can condense 5 days into 4 and have Wednesdays off, and DH can hopefully put in a flexible working request to not be rota to work Thursday or Friday.

It would leave one day not covered. We do have other family who might be willing to help such as MIL but they haven’t explicitly offered and live a bit further away for it to be practical.

DH shifts are on a rolling pattern and I’d say he would maybe do two Fridays in any normal month anyway, one of which would be a night. If he put in flexible working request to have Thurs off then even if he was working Friday night, he’d be fine to have DC until I finished work at 4pm as his work is really close by

On the one or two times a month that it is a day shift, I could book annual leave or ask another family member. I usually work from home Fridays anyway and my job is flexible so I could just book half a day of annual leave if it needed to be

As I say, I have worked with young children - I understand they need your full undivided attention and would never give them anything less than this.

AIBU to think we could get away with not having to use nurseries or a childminder until they’re a bit older in these circumstances?

OP posts:
thisbetheverse · 20/12/2023 19:06

Could you explain from your experience what’s so bad about nursery as I have anxiety around this so would be good to get an honest opinion from someone who’s worked in one. Is it as bad if they are older than say 15 months?

SleepingStandingUp · 20/12/2023 19:06

I'm always curious about people who worked in childcare who wouldn't use it. What did you do at work that would put parents off? What did you do to ensure your charges were safe and looked after across the business? It always feels a bit yeah we were crap, didn't give a shit about the kids so assume all nurseries are the same

MsCactus · 20/12/2023 19:06

My DD loves her childminder. She was off sick for a week and all the other toddlers were shouting her name when she came back - she looked so delighted. She's only one year old.

I think a small amount of structured childcare can be really good for kids. My DD often comes out holding hands with other one year olds - it's so sweet. And I feel like she has her own social life.

All that is to say, I'd recommend doing one or two days a week with a childminder. It'll be good for baby if you pick a nice setting, but also nice for you as you'll have a backup to extend hours for grandparents holidays etc etc

Amberandgrey · 20/12/2023 19:05

I’m not sure if I’ve misunderstood, but it sounds like it would be

Your mum Monday and Tuesday
You Wednesday
Your DH Thursday
Your DH most Fridays but occasionally needing to rope in another family member with you WFH.

Sounds fine to me, am I reading a different thread to everyone else?

Dacadactyl · 20/12/2023 19:04

Christmassss · 20/12/2023 19:00

Do you think having ad hoc people mind your baby would be better for him/her than going to a regular childcare setting?

Grandparents, mum and dad aren't ad hoc people!

Christmassss · 20/12/2023 19:00

Do you think having ad hoc people mind your baby would be better for him/her than going to a regular childcare setting?

theduchessofspork · 20/12/2023 19:00

Well you have to cover your days, and it sounds like there’s a day you can’t cover so use a childminder rather than a nursery. They’ll get plenty of attention.

jannier · 20/12/2023 18:58

Have you visited any childminders if not you may be surprised

Christmassss · 20/12/2023 18:57

Your plan sounds a stressful, having to look around for someone to have your baby for a whole day is not going to be easy.
How about looking for a childminder for two or three days pee week?

hopingforbabyy · 20/12/2023 18:54

spriots · 20/12/2023 18:53

I don't think your DH could do a full day of childcare and then a night shift, when would he sleep?

Four days fully compressed is hard, I would consider compressing 4.5 days into 4 instead

How confident are you that your mum would be reliable? And is she fully fit enough to run around after a toddler?

Unless you really can't afford it, I would use some paid childcare

The night before. This is what he usually does anyway, he wakes up at a normal time the day of, has a normal day off then goes to work in the evening. Comes back in the morning and goes to bed.

Yeah she’s not yet 60.

OP posts:
spriots · 20/12/2023 18:53

I don't think your DH could do a full day of childcare and then a night shift, when would he sleep?

Four days fully compressed is hard, I would consider compressing 4.5 days into 4 instead

How confident are you that your mum would be reliable? And is she fully fit enough to run around after a toddler?

Unless you really can't afford it, I would use some paid childcare

Daffodilsandbees · 20/12/2023 18:46

Just put your name on a waiting list (when pregnant!) and see what happens nearer the time. Worth a deposit for peace of mind imo

Shallana · 20/12/2023 18:43

What about occasions when either your mother or husband is ill? From a HR perspective, I come across regular issues with employees having to take frequent unpaid time off because the family member who was supposed to be caring for their child is ill/on holiday/let them down etc. What if another colleague has already booked leave on the day that you need to take off and your request is refused?

You may also struggle to work from home on a Friday if DH is also home with the baby? What if things change partway through the year and his Thursday/Friday can't be accommodated anymore, or he has to cover annual leave/sickness on these days?

The hodgepodge of childcare that you have described sounds like a recipe for stress to me, I would recommend putting the child in nursery at least a couple of days per week to give yourself some wriggle room.

Dacadactyl · 20/12/2023 18:34

Could you leave your current role and get an evening and weekend job? I was a SAHM in the main, but I had a one evening a week and one weekend day a week job for about a year when we were hoping to move house and needed a bit more cash. Husband came in the door and I went straight out.

Hunkydory99 · 20/12/2023 18:33

Could you use your annual leave that has accrued throughout your maternity to cover the Fridays you’d need childcare? I did something similar. I did have to prove to my line manager I could use it within the year as we have a no carry over rule but it worked for us. They’re now in nursery but gave us that extra wiggle room for over 6 months and saved us some cash
I would however consider some formal childcare even if it’s part time - means you can have some structure and only use family part of the week which is good if they have appointments or plans as they know there are set days you don’t need them but it’s also beneficial for child to build relationships outside the family unit.

crew2022 · 20/12/2023 18:32

I'd get two days with a childminder and so flexible working so you each have one day off. Then is ask grandparents parents for one to two days a week support. That way if dc is ill and can't go to a childminders then you can ask for extra from grandparents or if the grand parents go on holiday you can take leave or ask childminder if they can do extra (some can if a regular child is away for example).
It sounds stressful as others have said to be managing on so much goodwill

cansu · 20/12/2023 18:29

Sounds stressful. Family members will get sick or have things they need or want to do. You may not get the leave you need. Partners shifts could be changed at short notice. You need reliable childcare.

Blueroses99 · 20/12/2023 18:27

I had offer of full-time family support but chose to put DC into nursery for 2 half days a week, which proved invaluable when parents went on holiday/ had appointments/ were sick as we could choose whether to go for extra days in nursery or annual leave. It would have caused resentment if we felt they were frequently letting us down. It also got DC used to a different environment and routine which was really good for them.

Compressed hours for 4 days may be tough if it means that you don’t see your child at the beginning or end of the day.

Lizzt2007 · 20/12/2023 18:27

Speaking from experience, the Fridays when partner is expected to have bub during the day, then work a night shift is likely to be a problem. It leaves no time for him to sleep, and that's likely to have a knock on effect on the Saturday. What's your back up plan for if dm is unwell, or not available one week?. Realistically one or two days professional childcare would be more sensible.

SunSparkle · 20/12/2023 18:26

Your arrangement sounds a bit precarious and be prepared for family or friends to not be very reliable, to get poorly, to go on holiday or to get bored with it all and not want to do it.

nurseries very rarely close. Childminders also often have plans in place for if they are unwell and plan holidays in advance.

I’d say use some paid childcare for two days a week and juggle the other two. The only problem with that is they may get settled in a setting and then if you want to add on further days, they can’t accommodate them.

SouthLondonMum22 · 20/12/2023 18:26

hopingforbabyy · 20/12/2023 18:20

So many around here say minimum of 2 days. Maybe a childminder would be an option though

Most will because baby will struggle to settle with only 1 day a week.

SouthLondonMum22 · 20/12/2023 18:24

I wouldn't want to rely on family members for full time childcare personally so I'd put baby's name down for at least 2 days per week. If not nursery then childminder, though I wouldn't completely rule nurseries out either.

Just be prepared for the fact that family members may change their minds when the time comes, flexible working may be denied etc and prepare just in case.

FuckoffARFID · 20/12/2023 18:23

I think only putting a baby in childcare 1 day a week would be very difficult for the baby, especially if they are being passed around the other days. One day a week really isn’t enough time to settle / get used to the nursery. 2 half days would be far preferable x

devildeepbluesea · 20/12/2023 18:23

Sounds great in practice, I’m absolutely certain something will go wrong. Agree with PP - pay for childcare, grandparents can’t (and shouldn’t) be relied upon on an ongoing basis.

RandomQuestionOfTheDay · 20/12/2023 18:21

I found grandparent care unreliable- illness, holiday, an event to go to, a bit tired, didn’t want to catch the baby’s cold. And I was only using a grandparent one day a week. You can’t really complain when it’s free, but I don’t think the grandparent understood how it impacted on my work.

On top of this your baby picks up every bug known to mankind, but you’ll have run out if backup options if you’re already using all the possible family care and annual leave and shift juggling.

If you’re not happy with nursery then in your position I’d have a couple of days a week childminder and then family/ juggle the rest.