Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we can avoid the need for full time paid childcare for a while?

130 replies

hopingforbabyy · 20/12/2023 18:12

We’re trying at the moment but just pondering our options, as I will need to return to work after 9-12 months maternity leave and people are having to put their name on waiting lists as soon as they get a BFP around here. I have worked in nurseries before and would not want to leave a young baby there, in my personal opinion.

DM is available and willing to help us out on Mondays and Tuesdays, I am hoping I can condense 5 days into 4 and have Wednesdays off, and DH can hopefully put in a flexible working request to not be rota to work Thursday or Friday.

It would leave one day not covered. We do have other family who might be willing to help such as MIL but they haven’t explicitly offered and live a bit further away for it to be practical.

DH shifts are on a rolling pattern and I’d say he would maybe do two Fridays in any normal month anyway, one of which would be a night. If he put in flexible working request to have Thurs off then even if he was working Friday night, he’d be fine to have DC until I finished work at 4pm as his work is really close by

On the one or two times a month that it is a day shift, I could book annual leave or ask another family member. I usually work from home Fridays anyway and my job is flexible so I could just book half a day of annual leave if it needed to be

As I say, I have worked with young children - I understand they need your full undivided attention and would never give them anything less than this.

AIBU to think we could get away with not having to use nurseries or a childminder until they’re a bit older in these circumstances?

OP posts:
Caffeineislife · 20/12/2023 20:38

I'd be exploring child minder or nursery even if only 2 days a week, or a couple of morning sessions. My friend relies on grandparent and extended family childcare and it is a hell of a juggle for her - especially when illnesses/ teething for fussiness/ holiday/ nice events start cropping up.

Many grandparents offer to help but don't realise the level of committment and become flakey. That for many it is a 7.30 start until 6/7pm at night when commutes are factored in. This happened to my friend. MIL was well up for a couple of days a week until she realised it was every week of the year bar friends annual leave, set days, starting at 7.30 - 6 as friend has to commute. She did 6 weeks and backpedaled as it was too long for her. Her own DM has also cut back her offer of 3 days a week. Again the long days (especially when her DS dropped his nap and he was just full of rage from 3- bedtime) and the set pattern. Friends DM has a vibrant social life, whilst as a baby and young toddler DS was happy to sit in the pram whilst her DM socialised, he suddenly wanted to be off and out and got fussy after 30 mins in the coffee shop. All of a sudden her DM wanted to change her days to fit her social life. Her DM has changed last week as it was WI Christmas party so friend had to swap her day off last minute and cancel our meeting plans. Her SIL won't have him if he is ill or fussy and her sister only gets 1 day off a week and is very much going out with friends on that day. We had a long catch up on the phone as we couldn't meet and she's got him in at a school nursery next month. It's been a long wait and as he is nearly 3 and never been to a setting lots of child minders and day nurseries were reluctant to take him. Day nurseries because he was getting too old (i.e. he starts getting funded hours and they haven't had or will get a full 2 years out of him at full price) and childminders as they were taking on babies and didn't have time to also settle an older child.

Torganer · 20/12/2023 20:33

I asked for compressed hours and it was rejected. We had banked on it and only enrolled them for 4 days a week. We have to juggle Fridays and it’s tough. Especially the first few months when they pick up every illness and send them home. Luckily we have an amazing nursery and ours went 4 full days from 11m. They absolutely love it. They run in every morning, have to remind them to say goodbye as they are so excited! They do so much at nursery, every day they do crafts, baking, outdoor play, and the social interaction with their peers has been brilliant. It’s always ‘so and so did this, then I played with Bob, and Cate let me use her truck’. Our child is 2 now and it’s been brilliant. I would highly recommend putting them in nursery for a few longer days. They eat well, (better than at home), nap better (they don’t nap at home), yes, it’s expensive, but less expensive than one of us losing our jobs due to not meeting childcare issues.

I could not do my job whilst looking after a child. I could not properly look after my child whilst doing my job.

CremeBrunette · 20/12/2023 20:30

hopingforbabyy · 20/12/2023 19:15

Yes this is 100% what I meant! I was beginning to worry I wasn’t clear

People are understanding what you mean but just highlighting how precarious this set up is and that you have no flex at all. You have no back up option for when life happens.

Imagine baby gets ill on the Sunday, you have a sleepless night with baby. You and DH have to go to work but your mum doesn’t want baby that day because she doesn’t want to be ill or she’s got a friend going through chemo who she is seeing on Wednesday. Or baby gave her the big and she’s feeling sick. So now you have to look after baby and either make up work in the evening or you or DH has to take annual leave or unpaid leave. If you’re working compressed hours, you are now working late into the night. But baby is still grizzly and doesn’t sleep well that night. Tuesday and baby still isn’t well, your mum still can’t look after baby. DH takes annual leave or unpaid leave because you need to make up some hours. Tuesday night baby still doesn’t sleep well. Wednesday is your non working day, baby is starting to feel better and is starting to be back to normal and need entertaining. Except you’re knackered and still need to make up hours at work. The housework you would usually catch up with on Wednesday isn’t done because you need to catch up on work. Thursday you start feeling sick, you work because you’re already behind on work. Friday you either work from home and try to manage baby who is now feeling better and getting into everything. You’re feeling rough and you might just catch up on work if baby doesn’t need too much attention or has a long nap. Or DH looks after baby and then works all night, you at least get on top of work but DH sleeps all day Saturday, leaving you with baby. Except now you are feeling really rough and you’re resentful of DH, who genuinely needs sleep. You’re back to Sunday again, your DH has now caught the bug.

This isn’t just when there’s a bug though. It’s if your mum doesn’t want to commit as much as you think or she wants to go on holiday. We know someone who didn’t use childcare until 3 and they had to have a spreadsheet detailing every day, who was caring for their child that day, how much annual leave they both had and who was taking it on that day. They’ve also had to take some unpaid parental leave because parents went on holiday and they didn’t have a back up. It costs us a fortune in childcare but all we need to work out is who is doing drop off/pick up, who is covering if they are sent home from nursery.

kimchio · 20/12/2023 20:23

1 day a week is really shit for the little ones. They won't settle in as easily.

Jeannie88 · 20/12/2023 20:20

As an older Mum I didn't have the option for family to help so I went part time and paid for DC to go to nursery for those days. Having family help is a huge bonus but can't be expected to work out as planned, they have their own lives etc. Going back to full time (not wfh) was fine for a while with wraparound care but didn't work with realisation of SEN.

Raverquaver · 20/12/2023 20:18

I've always felt that where there's a will, there's a way. I couldn't get comfortable with the idea of nursery (although lots of my friends have used them and their children have turned out very nicely, it was just a personal thing). I'd grown up with my mum working night shifts then looking after us during the day so more stressful/less conventional options that allowed me to keep the children at home longer didn't put me off. I definitely think you can make your proposed arrangement work, especially if your mum isn't 60 yet. Try it out and see if you can muddle through for that first year back at work. By the time they are able to communicate with you, you may feel more comfortable putting them into a daycare setting.

spriots · 20/12/2023 20:17

Ascubudr · 20/12/2023 20:06

I did this throughtout my 30's, for one night it is not a problem, you just make sure you sleep when the baby naps.

See this depends on your child - mine were not cot nappers and dropped the nap by 2 so sleeping while they slept wouldn't have worked

Amberandgrey · 20/12/2023 20:09

I agree there are excellent options out there for childcare, but ultimately as a parent you have to do what you’re comfortable with. I am uncomfortable with a childminder so won’t use one even though I know many on here like them. It’s individual choice and that doesn’t reflect on anybody else’s.

Gazelda · 20/12/2023 20:07

I get what you're hoping to achieve. And it would be lovely for your baby to have such a network of loving people caring for him (or her). But there are lots of pitfalls here, and I think you should be open to alternative plans and have a budget that has room for paid for childcare.

What stands out to me is your DH taking care of the baby on Thursday and Friday followed by working Friday night. What if baby sleeps poorly on Weds and Thursdays isn't? Poor DH will be hugely sleep deprived by the time his Friday night work shift comes around. As well as knackered from looking after a tot for 2 days. Will he be safe to work.

Your plan sounds fine on paper. But it hangs on a knife edge.

Brandyginger · 20/12/2023 20:07

And I echo what others have said about things to watch out for with grandparent childcare. My PIL liked to go on holiday A LOT and didn’t appreciate just how much notice we needed to get our ducks in a row.

TheSnowyOwl · 20/12/2023 20:06

As long as your mum and your/DH’s work patterns are reliable, it sounds fine to me. It’s also worth considering a nanny share.

Ascubudr · 20/12/2023 20:06

spriots · 20/12/2023 18:53

I don't think your DH could do a full day of childcare and then a night shift, when would he sleep?

Four days fully compressed is hard, I would consider compressing 4.5 days into 4 instead

How confident are you that your mum would be reliable? And is she fully fit enough to run around after a toddler?

Unless you really can't afford it, I would use some paid childcare

I did this throughtout my 30's, for one night it is not a problem, you just make sure you sleep when the baby naps.

Brandyginger · 20/12/2023 20:03

I had a similar arrangement but used a nanny for one day a week. Like you I was trying to avoid nursery until older, we managed to keep it going until 18months then gradually phased in a nursery.

My aunt is a child clinical psychologist and Ed psych and was very keen to ensure I tried to avoid nursery for at least a year ideally two. According to her it helps with socialisation and development post 2 but pre two the disadvantages outweigh the positives according to peer reviewed research. The research she shared with me was pretty compelling (no I don’t have links, this was a decade ago now) but obviously most people don’t have a choice as they need to work and nursery is usually the most practical and cost effective solution.

WandaWonder · 20/12/2023 19:57

I can't see this working and sounds terrible on the children

Tinkerbyebye · 20/12/2023 19:53

I don’t think it will work. DM maybe sick, what happens if you can’t do consolidated hours? And that will mean less time with the baby some days. You also can’t assume you will get a days holiday, or even half day, as others maybe taking full weeks holidays so they cant accommodate odd days

Whatsinthebag2 · 20/12/2023 19:52

I would probably consider a day of paid childcare just so the setting is a backup for if other things don't go to plan. Eg. if your mum was ill or went on hol etc, you could always ask the setting if they could add a day.

My mum looked after my first child 2 days a week and then suddenly died, I was fortunate I could get her in full time to the nursery she was at the other days at very short notice. Not that it's likely, and it's rather morbid, but it's possible.

BarelyCoping123 · 20/12/2023 19:50

Make sure you have back-up plans for when you, DH or your mother are ill, or your mother is on holiday etc

Lolovans · 20/12/2023 19:50

My grandparent care was SUPER reliable. Until she was called for jury duty and it went on for 8 weeks. Luckily my childminder could pick up the slack but I would have been stuffed if I'd had nothing like that already in place. DM was doing 2 days and childminder 2 days.

BingoWings85 · 20/12/2023 19:48

Just a warning about childminders - there are some great ones out there but there are also childminders who do it as a second best option to being a SAHM to their own children. I used one in the latter category for a brief time for after-school care for our oldest. I was really not impressed and ended the arrangement after a few weeks. No way in hell I’d have wanted my baby there being her side hustle, getting dragged around on school runs. So I’d approach it with a bit more of an open mind that childminders = good, nurseries = bad.

Another thing is that you really can’t predict what kind of baby/toddler you’ll have until you have them and how grandparents will feel about looking after them. My parents were super keen to help with childcare when I was pregnant, to the point they actually talked about moving closer to us. I talked them out of it on the basis they should wait until the baby arrived and see how they felt then. Sure enough, when the baby arrived they realised they’d forgotten a lot about what looking after babies and toddlers entailed and they just weren’t up to it. Which was fine but I was very glad I hadn’t based my childcare plans on them!

Amana · 20/12/2023 19:47

Having worked in education and seen this from the child’s side, there are too many different people involved, which may affect your child’s emotional security and attachment.

tokesqueen · 20/12/2023 19:47

I wouldn't use GP for childcare.
You'll be so beholden.

Upsadiddles · 20/12/2023 19:45

As someone who took up the offer of family childcare for a few days a weeks and then was left in the lurch when they could no longer continue at very short notice, I really recommend at least some paid childcare. Luckily as we were already using a nursery two days a week we managed to get sorted quickly, but we’d have been stuck if DC hadn’t already had a place and we’d had to start looking from scratch.

Thehonestbadger · 20/12/2023 19:44

We were promised grandparent care, both very reliable, both had worked in childcare/education their whole lives.

It was a total shit show and I ended up having to leave work 12 weeks after I returned. They were poorly one after another, one went on holiday twice at short notice and the other suddenly developed caring responsibilities (elderly parent) elsewhere. I found that even though on paper it had looked great and I honestly thought it would be air tight the whole thing was just such a mess.

ChildrenOfTheQuorn · 20/12/2023 19:43

I use a mixture of nursery and grandparents. Grandparent 1 usually flakes out once a month; hair appointment, day trip, driving husband somewhere, not well etc. Grandparent 2 is more reliable but does like to go on holiday.
If I was to do this again, I'd put DC in nursery an extra day. Eats better (more variety, no ready meals), sleeps better (grandparent can't always get them to nap) and a wide range of activities.

I think you're a bit naive tbh.

spriots · 20/12/2023 19:40

hopingforbabyy · 20/12/2023 18:54

The night before. This is what he usually does anyway, he wakes up at a normal time the day of, has a normal day off then goes to work in the evening. Comes back in the morning and goes to bed.

Yeah she’s not yet 60.

I personally couldn't have looked after an energetic toddler all day and then worked all night. If your DH can, good for him (genuinely it's very impressive) but I think it would be wise to have a back up plan.

Does she not work if she is under 60?