Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we can avoid the need for full time paid childcare for a while?

130 replies

hopingforbabyy · 20/12/2023 18:12

We’re trying at the moment but just pondering our options, as I will need to return to work after 9-12 months maternity leave and people are having to put their name on waiting lists as soon as they get a BFP around here. I have worked in nurseries before and would not want to leave a young baby there, in my personal opinion.

DM is available and willing to help us out on Mondays and Tuesdays, I am hoping I can condense 5 days into 4 and have Wednesdays off, and DH can hopefully put in a flexible working request to not be rota to work Thursday or Friday.

It would leave one day not covered. We do have other family who might be willing to help such as MIL but they haven’t explicitly offered and live a bit further away for it to be practical.

DH shifts are on a rolling pattern and I’d say he would maybe do two Fridays in any normal month anyway, one of which would be a night. If he put in flexible working request to have Thurs off then even if he was working Friday night, he’d be fine to have DC until I finished work at 4pm as his work is really close by

On the one or two times a month that it is a day shift, I could book annual leave or ask another family member. I usually work from home Fridays anyway and my job is flexible so I could just book half a day of annual leave if it needed to be

As I say, I have worked with young children - I understand they need your full undivided attention and would never give them anything less than this.

AIBU to think we could get away with not having to use nurseries or a childminder until they’re a bit older in these circumstances?

OP posts:
Superduper02 · 20/12/2023 21:47

Glad to see PP talking sense here. No offence OP but it sounds more like you don't want to pay for childcare rather than having an issue with professional childcare settings. Your family will be stretched to the max with this arrangement and it comes across as rather naïve. Also of no benefit to your little one, not knowing whether they're coming or going. I hope you will listen to the good advice given so far. Recommend getting onto a waiting list pronto.

greenacrylicpaint · 20/12/2023 21:27

yabu
your plan sounds incredibly unsettled either for you, your parents and baby.
condensed hours and 4 days (or 3 if dh can do that as well) would be much better imo.

Isitautumnyet23 · 20/12/2023 21:21

Just to reiterate what others have said, fit healthy grandparents in our family (in their 60’s) have suddenly needed operations that have taken several months recovery. I would use nursery as you know you can rely on it and it sounds like you will have a busy schedule and wont need any added childcare stress.

trytopullyoursocksup · 20/12/2023 21:17

I think this sounds really stressful. It won't work.

Here's my experience: before you have a baby you are used to multi tasking and you know that with efficiency most things take less time than they "officially" do. So, you might be drafting an email while on hold on the phone, mentally writing a meal plan while in an undemanding meeting, and so on. You aren't aware how many little sections of time are getting double use, or even triple, so you think you have much more time than you actually do.
After you have a a baby, every single thing to do with the baby takes at the absolute very least ALL the time you think it will, but usually more.
So getting ready to go out is not something you will quickly do while checking for any any urgent messages. It is a laborious task that will take ages while your baby undoes everything you are doing and demands full emotional attention and eye contact at all times. Thus you will arrive where you are going slightly late, and not having checked for messages. Your working day will be shorter, in real terms, than you expect, and if you are attempting greater volumes of work (compressed), it will seem punishing.

The admin alone from this system sounds exhausting, and this in a world where you have no time for admin. you can't do it at work, because you've got hard start and finish times and compressed workload; and you can't do it at home because the baby won't let you. You will do it sitting on the toilet on your phone crying with fatigue at 2am.

Meanwhile every other fucker who doesn't fancy this level of intense availability will be checking out at every possible opportunity. Sorry.
All this relations - even your husband - they'll all let you down.

mindutopia · 20/12/2023 21:15

I think buying in help to have flexibility and reliability and also some respite, is money well spent. If you don’t have a baby yet, don’t underestimate how much you’re going to need a break sometimes and not just to be constantly focused on being ‘childcare.’ You/Dh will need some days home without a child in tow to re-group, to catch up on sleep after working through a week with an illness plus sleepless nights with sick baby, you’ll want to go away with friends for a few days, it will be a stag do for someone’s brother’s cousin, you’ll want to have some family days together meaning needing to juggle your days around. This will be much easier with paid childcare in place.

Also don’t underestimate how much you may feel you’re missing out on working compressed hours with a baby/young toddler. It may buy you a day off a week but it does mean if working til 6pm the other days, you’ll barely see your child 4 out of 7 days. You may actually prefer shorter days so you get a short bit of family time every day, rather than leaving at 7:30 ish right after waking and getting home at 6:30 ish and going straight to bath/bedtime.

I think it can be worth spending a bit of money to buy yourself some better quality time together when you aren’t run ragged and like ships passing in the night handing the baby off between you.

NuffSaidSam · 20/12/2023 21:14

SleepingStandingUp · 20/12/2023 19:06

I'm always curious about people who worked in childcare who wouldn't use it. What did you do at work that would put parents off? What did you do to ensure your charges were safe and looked after across the business? It always feels a bit yeah we were crap, didn't give a shit about the kids so assume all nurseries are the same

I also worked in a nursery briefly and would never use one. I did the best I could, but I was 18 and had no qualifications or experience working with children. I wasn't first aid trained or DBS checked (or CRB as it was then). I hated being cooped up for 50 hours a week in one room plus small garden. The ratios were within legal bounds but always felt too high for any child to get really good care (fine, but not great). This is basically the case in all nurseries..

Specific to the nursery I worked in; the standard of care was terrible.

I know not all nurseries are like that BUT you don't know as someone on the outside which is which. The nursery I worked in was full, parents were generally happy, the Ofsted report was good, but I wouldn't have left my goldfish with those people. What really turned me off was seeing how little the parents really knew about what went on there.

SecondUsername4me · 20/12/2023 21:11

intraining · 20/12/2023 21:10

Also.. Lots of my friends have spent countless days off work because their child has been sent home for being poorly.... (sometimes they weren't) from nursery and they still had to pay the fees. So nursery does have that disadvantage too.

These are the days you call in the Mother favours- handy for emergency ad hoc childcare of a poorly little one without the solid commitment of 2x long childcare days a week.

intraining · 20/12/2023 21:10

Also.. Lots of my friends have spent countless days off work because their child has been sent home for being poorly.... (sometimes they weren't) from nursery and they still had to pay the fees. So nursery does have that disadvantage too.

SecondUsername4me · 20/12/2023 21:09

Here's the issues (that I can see)

your mum
In 2 years time (a year or so of ttc and pregnancy and a year of mat leave) she may feel very different about her ability or willingness to help two days a week

She may try it, remeber how exhausting small dc are and pull out. She may be less reliable than you would want.

Your mum may want to take holidays or go on days out with friends on those days.

compressing your hours
4x 10 hour days are hard enough anyways, plus commuting, without then doing all the hands on baby wrangling every morning and night too. Especially if your dh is off on night shift so you are doing all of it.

Your employer may say no.

dh shiftwork
He would be mad to try and do a full day with a 1 year old then a full shift at work overnight.

Covering his every other Friday dayshift with your own annual leave would take up a large chunk.

His employer may not be able to guarantee any set days off

There are so many moving parts, plus you haven't even fallen pregnant yet, so whilst it's handy to ponder the logistics of childcare, I think your plan is far too choppy and reliant on a wide range of people agreeing to a load of stuff. It's so unlikely to all slot into place, regardless of how much you've thought it through.

MissAtomicBomb1 · 20/12/2023 21:08

AliceS1994 · 20/12/2023 21:01

Attempted something very similar, but grandparents were useless and not reliable enough often cancelling at last minute for various things, dentist appointments, seeing an old friend. As is their prerogative! But make sure your expectations of grandparents are crystal clear and you have something in place for when they book holidays, are unwell etc. I ended up reducing hours and getting a childminder, not ideal and a real squeeze financially, and then sacked it all off to be a SAHM!

We had the same issue. Grandparents were well meaning but it ended up that we were using all of our annual leave to cover hospital appointments, holidays, funerals etc etc. It ended up causing a row and bad feeling for a while. Fortunately we were already using a nursery 2 days a week so upped our hours there. There's no way I'd go back to a situation where we had to heavily rely on family. What happens when they or you are ill for example?
Personally I think that having so many changes through the week will also be unsettling. In your shoes I'd look at lining up a nursery for a day or two.

AliceS1994 · 20/12/2023 21:01

Attempted something very similar, but grandparents were useless and not reliable enough often cancelling at last minute for various things, dentist appointments, seeing an old friend. As is their prerogative! But make sure your expectations of grandparents are crystal clear and you have something in place for when they book holidays, are unwell etc. I ended up reducing hours and getting a childminder, not ideal and a real squeeze financially, and then sacked it all off to be a SAHM!

LolaSmiles · 20/12/2023 21:00

Your plan sounds too precarious to me and like the baby won't know whether they're coming or going.

You've also got very little wiggle room and need to consider that if you compress your hours you're asking family to have a very long day providing childcare.

mimiku · 20/12/2023 21:00

I saw in one of your previous posts that nurseries you felt they were better after 2, with this in mind could you drop your hours so you only work 3 days (Mon, Tues and Thurs) and then up them when DC is 2 and go for a nursery then for 3 days (Mon, Tues and Fri)? This way there’s an end in sight for your mum, as whilst she may be willing now she might not be indefinitely, knowing it’s only for a year is much less of a commitment than indefinite childcare. The 30 hours funding will be in place by then also which would help with finances.

If you could financially make that work, that’d be my solution.

SecondUsername4me · 20/12/2023 20:59

he wakes up at a normal time the day of, has a normal day off then goes to work in the evening

A day off at your own leisure is vastly different to a day off running round after a 1 year old.

Ascubudr · 20/12/2023 20:58

StardustGiraffe · 20/12/2023 20:55

It could be fine but I was planning on condensing 5 days into 4 as well as my job fits it perfectly, but my work said no, so my plans were scuppered.

I was so upset as I really wanted that day with my baby, so just came to say don't set your heart on anything until it's actually signed off.

OP isn't even pregnant yet.

Itsnotallaboutyoulikeyouthink · 20/12/2023 20:55

Your husband can’t look after child in the day and then do a night shift even if it is occasional. Complete unreasonable when there are nurseries / childminders available. What your plan hasn’t included is if anyone is sick, you don’t get that issue at nursery as more people to cover. What are you going to do on the min/ Tues if your family are sick?

StardustGiraffe · 20/12/2023 20:55

It could be fine but I was planning on condensing 5 days into 4 as well as my job fits it perfectly, but my work said no, so my plans were scuppered.

I was so upset as I really wanted that day with my baby, so just came to say don't set your heart on anything until it's actually signed off.

SecondUsername4me · 20/12/2023 20:53

Just remember that condensing your hours into 4 days means the 2x days your Dm Has the baby will be longer.

Merryoldgoat · 20/12/2023 20:53

For me that way too many moving parts.

I’ve had some arrangements similar over time and they were unbelievably stressful.

Booksbooksss · 20/12/2023 20:51

This sounds like a good plan. The norm now seems to be nursery but that doesn't mean that your plan is unreasonable - far from it.

lovelygreenglasses · 20/12/2023 20:50

What PPs have said.

Compressed hours are a LOT more difficult than they sound.

In your shoes I dropped a day completely, family kindly did two days, we used two days of nursery (which was fine).

It was a struggle financially, but manageable practically, with various flexibilities built in.

SunsetCurtain · 20/12/2023 20:48

This sounds very disruptive to the child tbh, being passed from pillar to post. Not to mention that some of those plans with definitely fall through, almost certainly last minute

intraining · 20/12/2023 20:47

I would definitely recommend using family over nursery. Especially if they're willing. I dropped 3 days after having my first. It was the best thing I did. We worked childcare between us, and grandparents. Be great if you can work from home too on those odd couple of days a month....?

EvelynBeatrice · 20/12/2023 20:46

One option for one or two day or half day care is to find a nanny who has just had their own child and isn’t working as a full time nanny - I know a couple of people who have reached a mutually happy arrangement for a couple of days or half days care with nanny who brings their own child along with them. My friend loved it when she went pack part time after nine months maternity leave. She couldn’t afford - or want - a full time nanny, but needed limited cover and knew the nanny was great from her former employer before she left to have her own baby. The nanny was happy because she got to stay with her own baby. As time went on the babies were happy to have each other’s company .

IceandIndigo · 20/12/2023 20:38

Your plan sounds very stressful to me, it seems like there’s absolutely no wiggle room if anything goes wrong. If you don’t want to put your child in nursery can’t you and/or your husband go part time? I work compressed hours and the longer days are quite tiring, I can’t see that it would be practical with a young baby. It also seems contradictory, I get not wanting to give your baby to strangers to look after but if you’re working all those extra hours you won’t be available to him/her anyway.