Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this too much food for 5 people on Xmas day?

393 replies

Hoiz · 20/12/2023 15:55

Breakfast
Pret frozen croissants
Cinnamon rolls
Coffee
Bucks Fizz

Houer D'oeuvres
Pigs in blanket (American style)
Chorizo and Scallops
Salmon and Cod Roe Blinis
Garlic Prawns
Caeser Salad skewer

Main Meal
Stuffed Chicken Joint
Roast Potatoes
Mash
Dauphinoise Potatoes
Honey Carrots
Bacon and Broccoli
Parsnips
Brussel Sprouts
Cabbage
Pigs in blanket
Stuffing balls
Yorkshire pudding
Onion Gravy
Plain Gravy

Dessert
Sticky Toffee Pudding and Ice cream
Xmas Pudding
Yule Log
Cheese Platter
Mince Pies

Dinner
Leftovers

Drinks
Champagne
Wine
Bucks Fizz
Spicy Margharitas

Someone in the group is insisting on a starter but they have agreed to taking responsibility. TBC.

This will all be homemade (apart from pastries in morning and ice cream) so it’s a lot of work - 2 main people doing it. A third person will likely pitch in a fair amount.

Is it a normal amount of food? First year hosting but any less would not be what my family is used to. But I’m doing a lot more homemade stuff whereas in previous years some of the snack stuff and desserts would be M and S.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
MistletoeandJd · 20/12/2023 18:26

Most of it can be fridge and left overed. On Christmas I would rather too much then too little !

Nanaof1 · 20/12/2023 18:25

Hoiz · 20/12/2023 18:22

We normally make a “bung it” pie with leftover veg and gravy. It is HEAVENLY. Even better than the Xmas dinner.

Your guests are going to have a great time! You must be a wonderful cook to be able to get that all put together from scratch!

I hope you have a lovely Christmas holiday time!

madeinmanc · 20/12/2023 18:23

It does sound like you're a good host, have a lovely time 😍

Hoiz · 20/12/2023 18:22

We normally make a “bung it” pie with leftover veg and gravy. It is HEAVENLY. Even better than the Xmas dinner.

OP posts:
Nanaof1 · 20/12/2023 18:19

readingismycardio · 20/12/2023 16:00

If it's too much, DH and I can definitely join! And I'm pregnant, so I can eat a lot 😂

If you don't mind, could you swing by and pick us up on the way?

Though first, I need to think about getting across the pond before Christmas. 😆

OP--that is a LOT of food! I am pretty sure you could feed a dozen people and still have leftovers. It all sounds very good, but you could drop at least one hors d'oeuvres, and at least one vegetable from dinner and still feed an army.

It really seems like a lot of pressure on you for 5 people. It's supposed to be a day for all to enjoy and not a bunch of stress. Maybe not do as much yourself, pick up a few of the things pre-made?

I grew up thinking my best friend's mother put on a large doing for Christmas, but you have knocked her out of the water by far, and they would have a lot more people!

Sugarsun · 20/12/2023 18:19

pizzaHeart · 20/12/2023 18:10

Too much. I wouldn’t survive at yours OP.
make sure you’ve got enough containers and tin foil to give away leftovers.

Why wouldn’t you survive? Lol

Most people can regulate their eating and stop when they’ve had enough.

Sugarsun · 20/12/2023 18:17

It sounds amazing!!

It is quite a lot but it’s Christmas!

And most of it can be eaten over a few days if there are leftovers, which is what I assumed most families did.

Hoiz · 20/12/2023 18:17

I wouldn’t survive at yours OP.

No one is being force fed.

OP posts:
Hoiz · 20/12/2023 18:15

I’m 30.

I cooked a roast last night for dinner with friends and it was no hassle at all (one of the best roasts I’ve ever had tbh - stuffed garlic and herb butter under the skin).

Im happy with the menu as it is now, thanks all for your input.

Merry Christmas!

OP posts:
DeeLusional · 20/12/2023 18:15

1 x starter, 1 x main, 1 x pudding (allergies excepted). You're not a bleeding restaurant,

pizzaHeart · 20/12/2023 18:10

Too much. I wouldn’t survive at yours OP.
make sure you’ve got enough containers and tin foil to give away leftovers.

madeinmanc · 20/12/2023 18:08

As per a previous poster, ditching the cabbage is a good call because you have Brussels sprouts and because no-one wants reheated cabbage.

bridgetreilly · 20/12/2023 18:07

And you have forgotten the bread sauce!

DilemmaDelilah · 20/12/2023 18:07

Yes it is much too much - and I over cater for everything! The only thing that might be lacking is the meat... One chicken joint for 5 people?

I never do starters as nobody has room to eat afterwards, but each to their own! 2 types of hors d'oeuvres should be plenty for only 5 people, we just have nibbles like nuts and fancy crisps. I don't have the time of energy to faff around with doing proper hors d'oeuvres.
No more than 2 kinds of potato are needed, and no more than 3 different veg. You don't need sprouts and cabbage. Too much fart producing brassica!
Sides look fine, I wouldn't do Yorkshire puddings especially with 3 different kinds of potato but I know other people like them. I would add cranberry sauce and bread sauce because my family like them... Not sure what kind of stuffing balls you are thinking of, especially if the chicken is already stuffed? I do turkey and do chestnut stuffing with that. Maybe a surfeit of stuffing?
Far too many pudding choices. Have one hot and one cold, with cheese and biscuits if you think it necessary. I don't think it necessary - we have cheeses etc in the evening. I always have a fruit bowl available for those who are too full for pudding but still want something sweet.

Ionlylikedityesterday · 20/12/2023 18:07

Honestly yes. If I were in your shoes I would drop the starters, one vegetable dish, only do one type of gravy and two types of potatoes. I would buy the yule log too.

bridgetreilly · 20/12/2023 18:06

You don’t have to make everyone’s favourite things. Ditch the mash and the onion gravy. Two puddings is plenty: yule log and Christmas pud. A mince pie with a cup of tea for later, maybe with cheese and biscuits then. Definitely cut down on the canape choices and put crisps/nuts put instead.

Ladyofthepond · 20/12/2023 18:06

Sounds bloody delicious and you will eat like kings with those leftovers until new years!

Personally I'd make life as simple as possible by sacking off the starter thingys (the Belinis and scallops) and have those on boxing day if you're desperate.

You are def making loads of work for yourself, as long as you're fine with that then no problem! I'd make the dauphinoise, onion gravy and red cabbage in advance so they are just heat up jobs on the day, if your sister wants mash get her to make and bring it 😂

It's just 3 of us for Xmas so we do steak and chips (although swapping for parmesan and truffle roasted potatoes this year), with a few extras.

But yeah, great menu, but a LOT of time in the kitchen over xmas with it. Again, horses for courses so if you're fine with that then crack on, and don't forget to stock up on Gaviscon!

Lovemusic82 · 20/12/2023 18:05

It sounds a lot. We only have 4 people for dinner, we will have croissant for breakfast, big roast around 3pm, maybe 3 desserts , I have ordered a Yule log and will either make a truffle or pavlova, dd1 has some cheesecake in the freezer). I would save mince pies and possibly Yule log to have in the evening with coffee?

We don’t do starters as we just can’t manage 3 courses and dessert is the most important course for me so I need space for it.

Wendysfriend · 20/12/2023 18:04

Well I think it sounds perfect.

The thing is, when there's different tastes and likes a menu can look huge when a mix of things are wrote down.

If I were to write down what I'm serving for 7 people here, it would look ridiculous, but we're not eating everything, everyone will have what they like and sure that's what Christmas is about, not forcing food down that you don't like.

I always have 3 types of potatoes because we all like different ones, there's no way I'm forcing roast potatoes down my neck when I only like garlic ones, there's no way my kids will force Brussel sprouts or parsnips or mushy peas down their neck because I like them, they prefer broccoli and carrots or garden peas and one only eats corn. So yep, our veg menu is massive but I only cook enough for the meal and next day.

The thing is, people don't have to eat everything served up, if they feel full during the day then they can skip things. Whatever you have left over you can use the next day or make up a lunch box for guests to take home, they won't have anything made at home as you're hosting. Or you might be surprised and it'll all be eaten.

There's nothing worse than running out of food, plus nothing worse than sitting down and a pile of mash put on your plate when you hate it. Happened to me at inlaws one year, dry mash potatoes, hard roast and green beans, my 3 veg I really struggle to eat, it took me forever to eat the dinner.

Bristoluser · 20/12/2023 18:04

Far too much. You'll never eat all that and most will be wasted. 3 types of hors d'oeuvres is enough (we don't have any), one type of potato, no need for sprouts and cabbage, one dessert plus mince pies is more than enough and one gravy.

We don't eat breakfast or hors d'oeuves or starters and we're all completely stuffed by the evening.

BlazingJune · 20/12/2023 18:03

Have you ever cooked a roast dinner before OP?

Because most Christmas dinners are just that, with a few extra trimmings like bread sauce, stuffing and cranberry sauce.

I meat
1 sort of spuds
3 veg
gravy

Are you very young?

Evaka · 20/12/2023 17:58

As a former chef I'd advise that's a huge amount of effort and will likely end up with a fair bit of waste.

Fluffy40 · 20/12/2023 17:57

All that food would put me in hospital. It sounds tasty but far too much food.

Rudolphtherednoseddog · 20/12/2023 17:57

Honestly OP your menu just reads as gluttonous to me. I wouldn’t do that much food for twice as many people. I think you’ve got much too hung up on everyone getting their favourite things. I watched my grandparents and then my parents cook Christmas dinner that way, with a million different dishes and options and fancy extras and swore I wouldn’t do it. They were stressed, stuck in the kitchen all day (and yes, people helped), and they wouldn’t play or join in with board games because they were either still cooking, clearing up or knackered. And then we were stuck with leftovers no one wanted or that went in the bin.

I do a selection of mini pastries for breakfast and lunch is soup, bread, cheese, pate and salad. I cook a roast dinner with one meat, one kind of potato, one kind of gravy, three veg, pigs in blankets, stuffing and some cranberry sauce. One dessert. Everyone has a lovely meal even if it’s not got their absolute favourite thing in it, and I get to have a nice day too, rather than my kids watch me martyring myself to everyone’s preferred kind of potato.

Floralnomad · 20/12/2023 17:57

If you eat at 1 I don’t know why you need anything between breakfast and dinner and I’ve no idea why anyone needs 3 different potato choices when you have loads of veg .